Skip to content

[Frontier] [BROW16-01B] Complete a protected modern website workflow #409

Open

Description

@chayapats

Parent

#397 — #397; complete S16 target #392.

Model tier

Frontier: this slice requires judgment about protected authority, lifecycle/recovery or a new cross-client/service contract; exact new APIs and migrations are not yet settled.

Context to read

AGENTS.md; CONTEXT.md; docs/agents/workflow.md; docs/specs/S16-rakazo-experience.md; docs/specs/S15-conversational-autonomy.md; ADR 0064 and ADRs 0074–0077; docs/design/S16-rakazo-experience.md; docs/design/S16-mobbin-research.md. Reuse the completed design research; do not repeat broad Mobbin discovery.

Starting implementation/contract surfaces: src/s15/browser/; src/s15/conversation/; src/s16/client/; src/s16/web/. Read their current definitions and relevant tests before selecting changes. Paths with braces denote existing module families, not settled new signatures.

Deliverable

Ship the selected browser contract as a composed client-to-site workflow, including protected login/2FA, approved team session reuse, a held external action and truthful errors.

Baseline and readiness

Audited stack head 17b814220371cd1e2126be2ec9bd9753537f69e6; main remains the pre-S16 baseline. #398/#399/#403/#404 are open drafts, not merged/live acceptance. Existing S15 services are reusable baseline, and #400/#401 supply draft text/binary custody. No new behavior is claimed here. Branches/PRs and issue ownership were inspected on 2026-11-05; this new ticket has no implementation claim. Recheck at dispatch. Preserve the primary-owned jit/402-s16-file-memory branch.

Needs triage: contract/engineering choices remain; no ready-for-agent label. Resolve named contract decisions and verify prerequisite revisions before unattended implementation. Independent audit/design work may proceed now; final acceptance needs these deliveries.

Implementation steps

  1. Recheck ownership, branches/PRs, prerequisites and exact source baseline. Compare existing implementation, pinned Rakazo reuse and a simpler alternative; record the chosen tradeoff and versioned contract before coding.
  2. Implement the reviewed mediation and engine binding from BROW16-01A using public Schway seams.
  3. Connect owner setup, browser capabilities, work operations and exact action review through current policy/disclosure.
  4. Integrate modern page observations and generation-bound controls with source lineage and finite limits.
  5. Exercise a representative public website without a custom business integration; record exact unsupported requests and recovery.
  6. Integrate the authored experience using real service facts, English/Thai dictionary keys in their designated files, accessible loading/error/empty/reconnect states and current capabilities. For non-UI evidence work, verify those states instead of inventing new UI. Record migrations, compatibility and exact build evidence.

Acceptance criteria

  • Actual controlled modern site work creates an evidenced result.
  • Login/session values never enter VM, model history, exports or logs.
  • Revoke resource/recipient during browser wait prevents dispatch/publication.
  • Approval retry/reconnect yields one effect and unknown stays reconcile-only.
  • Deliverable works end to end through its actual owning service/client; source presence, transport success and model prose alone are insufficient.
  • No S14 default, S15 opt-in, installed policy, historical private scope or owner-host configuration changes without its separate explicit transition.
  • New contracts, unresolved limits and exact revision/evidence are recorded; applicable upstream licenses, immutable provenance and modified-file notices ship.

Tests and evidence

  1. Actual controlled modern site work creates an evidenced result. Use scripted models, protocol fixtures, fake clocks and barriers for deterministic cases; assert actual resulting state/bytes/effects.
  2. Login/session values never enter VM, model history, exports or logs. Use scripted models, protocol fixtures, fake clocks and barriers for deterministic cases; assert actual resulting state/bytes/effects.
  3. Revoke resource/recipient during browser wait prevents dispatch/publication. Use scripted models, protocol fixtures, fake clocks and barriers for deterministic cases; assert actual resulting state/bytes/effects.
  4. Approval retry/reconnect yields one effect and unknown stays reconcile-only. Use scripted models, protocol fixtures, fake clocks and barriers for deterministic cases; assert actual resulting state/bytes/effects.
  5. Run relevant existing module/composed regressions plus the new scenario suite; for rendered behavior, exercise the real bundle in English/Thai, keyboard and mobile widths. Record exact test paths/commands in the PR after implementation selects them.
  6. Keep real host/account/device checks opt-in and evidence-labelled; no absent credential blocks independent deterministic work. Public evidence contains hashes/outcomes only; installation-specific details belong in ignored .local records.

Requirements

S16-AC06; FR-07, FR-17, FR-37, FR-38, FR-40, FR-41, NFR-07, NFR-10, NFR-14. Retain S15 authority decisions and FR/NFR identifiers.

Blocked by

Contracts used/delivered

Use current owning POLICY, DATA15, TEAM, MEM, WORK, CHAT and S16 client/file contracts where relevant, plus Schway's supported public host surface. Specific inputs and proposed delivery: src/s15/browser/; src/s15/conversation/; src/s16/client/; src/s16/web/. The Deliverable and ordered steps define the missing contract outcome; freeze version, schemas, migration/recovery and conformance fixtures in the implementation ADR/PR. Proposed operations are not already supported APIs. A demonstrated missing engine seam requires a bounded public-only reproduction and a linked Schway contract ticket, never an internal import or duplicate runtime.

Out of scope

Other tickets' outcomes, hosted multi-user SaaS, marketplace operation, upstream branding, silent billing, replacing Schway, general historical data conversion, and unapproved live deployment. Live credentials, real-device acceptance and owner-host cutover are separately owned by LIVE16-01/CUT16-01; deterministic implementation remains in scope.

Do not

Do not use source/model/tool output as authority; expose credentials, sensitive-site sessions or protected state to working execution (trusted-site sessions are the S16-D09 exception); remove guards before proof; auto-retry unknown effects; weaken or bypass the S16-D07 human-required list or let anything but the in-chat owner decision approve it; treat current stack limitations as scope cuts; add model attribution; use implement-parallel; alter #402 ownership; self-merge or deploy. No placeholder controls or fabricated success.

Definition of done

Run bun install --frozen-lockfile, bun run typecheck, bun test --timeout 30000 for affected deterministic suites, and git diff --check; record exact selected suite commands and results. Add real-browser tests for rendered paths and package checks for shipped artifacts. Pure feasibility documentation runs link/coverage checks and git diff --check; a prototype must run its conformance cases. PR body includes Closes #409 and Refs #392, contract versions, tested head and honest pending evidence. No self-merge; parent #392 remains open until full accepted outcomes.

Requirement-specific acceptance and evidence

FR-41 baseline reuse: preserve anonymous/free-first Parallel research under current policy and bounded query/URL audit. Verify actual source freshness/coverage and untrusted-content handling when combining research with browser evidence. Failure cannot switch vendor/account/billing or disclose private data without its proper owner boundary.

Owner revision 2026-11-06

Grok-style autonomy (S16-D06–D11, ADR 0084) and Telegram removal (ADR 0085) apply. Only the S16-D07 human-required list waits for the owner, approved by a one-press in-chat card; GitHub push/PR/review replies/merge after required checks are the product default; trusted sites may keep sessions in the working VM browser while sensitive sites stay in the protected browser. Jit has no messaging channel; notifications use Web Push (#441). Policy/approval changes belong to #442.

The representative workflow should cover one trusted site run in the working VM browser and one sensitive-site gated action through the protected browser.

Activity

  1. chayapats commented on Nov 5, 2026

    @chayapats
    OwnerAuthor

    Candidate prerequisite evidence is in #436 / ADR 0079 / docs/contracts/s16-modern-browser-v1.md, head 1ad223c7a4d1931681c22dbcfed688bbdfc28c72. It demonstrates a real authenticated JS task with fetch/XHR reads and exact native-form effects, and fixes explicit-navigation readiness without changing defaults or policy. #408 remains open for review/physical proof.

    The conformance probe identifies the precise remaining contract: non-document fetch/XHR mutation has no supported native input binding and is denied, even when endpoint semantics are known. A timing window, copied CDP tool, page/model-issued permit or unknown-payload approval cannot resolve this. The proposed extension needs protected intent → exact actual request/recipient/source ceiling → one-use current dispatch, plus verified outcome/reconciliation. This remains required delivery, not a scope cut. Raw/session/guest-root and physical crash proof remain separate activation gates. Reuse the existing authored S16/Mobbin handoff; no new UI design was introduced in this probe.

  2. self-assigned this
    on Nov 18, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

needs-triageMaintainer needs to evaluate this issue.

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions