Skip to content

Nonauthor analytic review of P15 full-price theorem #57

Closed

Description

@d6g8k5htny-coder

D6 review task only. Scientific effect NONE until review is reconciled.

Immutable subject: frontiers/full_price_20260924/PROOF.md, git blob 582180e41dca0ad815ad0f18574df42040912149, 11,352 bytes, SHA256 87521901ca8e5405b4d1e47f1deb1cd0326affbd6f5967b53c4178590da993f9. The existing SMT pilot/formal-translation review checks seven algebraic substeps only and is NOT theorem acceptance.

@cursor Take one bounded nonauthor analytic review of the parent theorem in six slices:

  1. coordinatewise hazard transform and separate-concavity/chord interpolation, including p=0,1 boundaries;
  2. realized capacity/clutter local-good event, binomial ratio, odd-majority worst case, and why n=3,a=1 controls d>=2;
  3. global hazard direction and where independence of disjoint original blocks is used;
  4. full-block generator cover, same palette threshold, and exact dependence on the realized family rather than arbitrary downsets;
  5. sharpness at capacity-one/demand-two even allowing alternative generator covers;
  6. demand-one counterexample/boundary and exact theorem scope.

Return ACCEPT / AMEND_REQUIRED / COUNTEREXAMPLE / BLOCKED per slice and one overall exact-scope disposition. The known F10 precision is part of the check: strict negativity is interior 1/2<p<1; the actual p*=1-e^-1 is interior. Do not edit the author proof, broaden beyond the realized d_i>=2 family, launch child agents, or imply an unrestricted prize result.

Activity

  1. d6g8k5htny-coder commented on Sep 26, 2026

    @d6g8k5htny-coder
    OwnerAuthor

    @cursor Please acknowledge pickup or return BLOCKED with the actual limitation. One bounded task only; no child-agent fan-out.

  2. cursor commented on Sep 26, 2026

    @cursor
    Contributor

    I picked up issue 57 and finished the single nonauthor review. The pinned proof matches blob 582180e41dca0ad815ad0f18574df42040912149.

    All six slices are ACCEPT. The overall exact-scope disposition is ACCEPT of Theorem F for the realized family with demands at least 2, every independent probability, prices through phi, and the same palette K_H(d). Strict negativity in (F10) holds on 1/2<p<1, and p*=1-e^{-1} is inside that interval, so the worst case is still n=3,a=1. Demand one remains a counterexample to dropping d_i>=2. This does not accept an unrestricted prize result, and the author proof is unchanged.

    The record is in reviews/p15_full_price_nonauthor_20260926/REVIEW.md. Draft pull request: #63

    View PR

    Open in Web Open in Cursor 
  3. d6g8k5htny-coder commented on Sep 26, 2026

    @d6g8k5htny-coder
    OwnerAuthor

    @cursor RELEASED P15 REVIEW LANE — take one bounded nonauthor re-review of main PR124 C1/C2 repair only. Bind exact PR124 tip. Verify the branch-attached H_branch formulation really removes the false unconditional inclusion, and that PREMISS-Z-LOWER is isolated without being smuggled in as proved. Return ACCEPT/AMEND/BLOCKED for C1 and C2 only. Do not touch C3-C8 or scientific status.

  4. cursor commented on Sep 26, 2026

    @cursor
    Contributor

    C1 is AMEND. C2 is ACCEPT. The record is reviews/pr124_c1_c2_nonauthor_20260926/REVIEW.md, bound to main PR124 tip a380dcfb8f4a13e13ae8e13deb5d870dd8b75b25. Scientific status is unchanged, and C3–C8 were not re-reviewed.

    H_branch matches C102: one ascending branch of S terminates at M. The successor withdraws the false unconditional inclusion and leaves B_miss unresolved. The cubic display still says 1 - q_MS ≤ C r^3 and q_MS → 1 on the conditioned law. That quotient needs P(H_branch) bounded below, which this tip does not have. The valid line is the joint bound P((D(M) ≠ S) ∩ H_branch) ≤ P(Π) + P(Γ).

    PREMISE-Z-LOWER stays an unresolved hypothesis at every division by Z_r. The O(r^2) weight bound and the diagnostic z_0 input are not treated as a proof of Z_r ≥ c r^2. Draft pull request: #71

    View PR

    Open in Web Open in Cursor 
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions