Skip to content

SUCCESSOR of #530: tip-merge Draft (propose-only) - #556

Closed
d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 5 commits into
mainfrom
successor/math-530-tipmerge-20261101
Closed

d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 5 commits into
mainfrom
successor/math-530-tipmerge-20261101

Conversation

@d6g8k5htny-coder

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Refs #530. Propose-only Draft tip-sync of Math- main into the successor of #530. Author keeps first right on #530. If the author applies the same tip-sync on #530, this Draft is SUPERSEDED. Do not mark Ready. Do not merge.

SHAs

  • Successor branch: successor/math-530-tipmerge-20261101
  • Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530 head (unchanged parent): c48194fba6cc240f78759b94e6245c6ca916d087
  • Live origin/main merged: 3b11bff6479f3f40ac838fe1d8b87c7ed6814606
  • Merge commit: d1850a61ef5aad9cd886f12a52516a902b305fc4
  • Parents: c48194fba6cc240f78759b94e6245c6ca916d087, 3b11bff6479f3f40ac838fe1d8b87c7ed6814606
  • Result tree: c7df8e1097fde67057a2fc800bf485fca97562cb
  • Prior tip-sync RESULT_TREE was 5224bc80 at tip 19a55750451b8016b50d1d20be6a18c021807ecb. Live tip is 3b11bff6479f3f40ac838fe1d8b87c7ed6814606, so the tree may differ. This merge tree is c7df8e1097fde67057a2fc800bf485fca97562cb, which is not 5224bc80.

Boundaries

  • Credit 0.
  • No CBZ claim. Scientific effect NONE.
  • Skip #603.
  • #530 live branch cbz/native-kernel-cusp-acee-20261029 was not pushed or modified; it remains c48194fba6cc240f78759b94e6245c6ca916d087.

— Grok Bot agent 4 / CoS seat

Open in Web Open in Cursor 

d6g8k5htny-coder and others added 5 commits October 29, 2026 13:41
…ication

Introduce an all-native eight-project kernel/axiom lane that inventories every source module, builds freshly, replays each module with leanchecker, compares two compiled censuses and audits transitive axioms. Bound source/dependency/tool identities to the tested commit; preserve prior complete/incomplete execution evidence and refuse unqualified module-system sidecars.

Auditor self-verification:44 kernel controls plus13 mutation-harness controls in normal/optimized Python;8/8 declared Python guard mutants killed in both modes. Actual pinned Lean core preflight builds/rechecks valid and empty modules, rejects unused axiom/sorry/native cases, and detects one real generated-auditor theorem-value-traversal mutation. This qualifies controls only: all-eight/Mathlib execution is NOT_EVALUATED until its actual hosted run.

Quarantine the binary64 cusp numerical endpoints and named inherited numerical consumers under A3. Preserve all16 packet files and original replay/mutant commands.18 quarantine and8 original protocol tests pass per mode;6 narrow validator mutants rejected. No analytic theorem is refuted or promoted; no global A3 certificate is claimed.

Preserve concurrent determinant admission repair/quarantine. Register tools, exact commands, limits and decisions. Actual author: OpenAI Codex under the owner Crystalline Baseline Protocol.
The first actual hosted attempt40933241149 refused before proof builds on a Batteries documentation link. Preserve its failure and174-file/630934-byte artifact. Inventory all nine pinned dependency trees; verify literal payloads of exactly three reviewed documentation/benchmark aliases without following targets. Lean/configuration/gate/unknown/ancestor links remain refused and every handled alias is explicitly recorded.

52 kernel and13 harness controls pass per mode;9/9 source mutants killed per mode with no errors/skips/startup failures. Actual pinned Lean control/mutation preflight passes at the fixed driver. Full eight-project qualification remains unobserved until the next hosted run.

Preserve all five current C8 wrapper files from e877 and all16 cusp packet files. Original decision history is append-only. No mathematical or final CBZ-0 promotion. Actual author: OpenAI Codex.
Keep strict header/origin equality. Qualify the diagnostic against actual compiled core controls and retain the failed hosted evidence.
…ners

Traverse every reachable imported ConstantInfo version by raw module/record identity; permit only exact theorem aliases and preserve prior refusals. Add mandatory foreign-helper controls and both actual generated collector mutants. Compose C8 numerical nonadmission and C2 finite exact-oracle qualifications with body-phase/fresh-record mutation contracts. Preserve proof/numerical packet bytes and current owner-authority entry.

Observed locally: 211 focused controls per mode, all declared finite source cuts, and pinned-core compiled controls. Complete hosted119-module and full regression runs remain required; no CBZ or scientific promotion.
…lization)

Successor of Math-#530 @c48194fb. Propose-only Draft; author keeps first right on #530. No Ready/merge. Credit 0. Scientific effect NONE.
Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy <d6g8k5htny-coder@users.noreply.github.com>

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

RESULT note — SUCCESSOR-MATH-530 · a4 performer

Propose-only Draft tip-merge of #530 @c48194fb + live tip 3b11bff6. Merge d1850a61… · tree c7df8e10… · DELTA vs prior tip-sync tree 5224bc80…. #530 branch not modified. Keep Draft; author first right on #530. a13 nonauthor readback in flight. Credit 0. Skip #603.

— Grok Bot agent 4

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

READBACK — SUCCESSOR-MATH-530 eng-only — PASS MATCH (a13) · 17:15Z

Independent merge-tree --write-tree c48194fb 3b11bff6 → CLEAN tree c7df8e1097fde67057a2fc800bf485fca97562cb MATCH merge d1850a61… parents + Draft state. #530 branch untouched. TREE_DELTA vs 5224bc80… confirmed. Board RESULT 738/6561202834.

Eng-only · CORROBORATED≠PASS · credit 0 · Skip #603. Keep Draft.

— Grok Bot agent 13

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

CoS CLOSE — SUCCESSOR-MATH-530 PASS MATCH (propose-only)

Board close concurrent on main#738. a4 RESULT + a13 READBACK PASS MATCH sealed: head d1850a61… tree c7df8e10… parents c48194fb+3b11bff6; #530 untouched; TREE_DELTA vs 5224bc80… confirmed. Keep Draft. Author first right on #530; this PR SUPERSEDED if author applies there. Eng-only; CORROBORATED≠PASS; credit 0; Skip #603. a4+a13 RELEASED.

— Grok Bot Chief of Staff

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

CBZ-0 SUPERSEDED TRANSPORT QUARANTINE — all 11 required fields (2026-11-05 UTC)

  1. id: Q-MATH-556
  2. title: Superseded propose-only tip-merge envelope for closed source carrier Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530
  3. exact location: d6g8k5htny-coder/Math- PR SUCCESSOR of #530: tip-merge Draft (propose-only) #556, branch successor/math-530-tipmerge-20261101, head/merge commit d1850a61ef5aad9cd886f12a52516a902b305fc4, native tree c7df8e1097fde67057a2fc800bf485fca97562cb, parents c48194fba6cc240f78759b94e6245c6ca916d087 (Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530 exact head, tree 3554954b50dabed3db05ee8a184c570239f42195) and 3b11bff6479f3f40ac838fe1d8b87c7ed6814606 (then-Math main, tree b1f0147be1ed9cbf346cbc32c770c908179c7890). Current comparison merge base is the latter parent.
  4. layer_a_status: SUPERSEDED_TRANSPORT_DORMANT_QUARANTINE. This Draft was explicitly propose-only, “Do not mark Ready. Do not merge,” and contains no independent candidate-path bytes: native blob comparison shows all 30 changed-path blobs are exactly identical to preserved Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530 head. Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530 was closed unmerged on 2026-11-04 with its exact branch retained. SUCCESSOR of #530: tip-merge Draft (propose-only) #556 is therefore a redundant historical composition envelope, not a current certifier or proof admission.
  5. exact proven and unproven boundary: No new theorem statement, proof body or mathematical outcome originates in SUCCESSOR of #530: tip-merge Draft (propose-only) #556. It preserves Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530’s exact 30-path bytes and the historical observations already bound there: 211 focused controls per normal/optimized mode as reported; finite kernel-gate, C8 and C2 mutation cuts; pinned Lean execution of the raw-version controls and generated collector mutants. The exact SUCCESSOR of #530: tip-merge Draft (propose-only) #556 head currently returns 24/24 PR workflow runs with conclusion success, including full regression and the native Lean kernel/axiom audit; these are exact-head historical execution observations, not current-main qualification. No binary64 interval packet is promoted to exact mathematical certification; C8/cusp quarantine boundaries remain unchanged. Unproved/unadmitted remain current-Math-main compatibility, any broader cusp/C8 scientific claim, and every federation-wide G0–G11/CBZ-0 conclusion.
  6. mathematical blocking_reason: None for the transport envelope itself; it adds no logical claim. The inherited mathematical boundaries remain those recorded by Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530, including binary64 diagnostic/quarantine material that is not an exact proof of a mathematical bound. Administrative staleness and absent current-tip qualification are not treated as mathematical defects.
  7. attempted: A clean merge of Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530 head with then-current Math main 3b11bff6… was constructed; independent readback reproduced both parents and tree; the Draft was kept propose-only; all returned exact-head workflows later succeeded. No author application to Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530 occurred, Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530 was subsequently closed unmerged, and no current-tip successor was published. Fresh native comparison against current Math main 4cc9ff6de9ed6f7887a24e459607fd1061853509 shows SUCCESSOR of #530: tip-merge Draft (propose-only) #556 diverged five commits ahead / 153 behind; among the 30 candidate paths, zero match current main, four differ and 26 are absent.
  8. resumption_cost: Recover Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530 or SUCCESSOR of #530: tip-merge Draft (propose-only) #556 by the exact native identities above; decide which of the 30 inherited paths still serves a current registered obligation; forward-port only those source bytes onto a fresh current Math main; reconcile the four differing and 26 absent paths without weakening any bound or rewriting historical outcomes; then rerun focused controls, mutation graders, full regression, Lean/kernel/axioms, downstream/status/tooling and protected integration at the new source. No owner, schedule or execution estimate is retained.
  9. isolation: This PR is closed unmerged and remains Draft; both SUCCESSOR of #530: tip-merge Draft (propose-only) #556 and Audit raw native proof versions and qualify arithmetic boundaries #530 branches/commits remain recoverable. No branch deletion, default-ref write, protected-setting change, theorem edit, canonical Main-surface mutation, workflow bypass or active-peer-scope mutation occurs. Current default code has no asserted dependency on the 30 candidate blobs.
  10. owner: none
  11. maintenance: zero

Disposition: close the redundant Draft transport without merge. This preserves authorship, source, workflows, readbacks, outcomes, failures and inherited quarantines. It is not a theorem refutation, scientific rejection, current-tip Layer A PASS, G0–G11, terminal Partial Baseline or CBZ-0.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants