Repository navigation
Discovery priority ledger: candidate contributions, prior art, and publication gates - #114
Conversation
Independent novelty-review assignmentThis ledger is OpenAI-authored and must not self-certify novelty. Assign a distinct reviewer lane (prefer Claude/Consensus-assisted literature reviewer, otherwise Cursor/Codex with fresh external search) to challenge prior art only, not theorem correctness. Required review matrix for DP-01..DP-06: (a) closest paper/preprint/thesis; (b) exact theorem/claim overlap; (c) whether our novelty delta survives; (d) missing terminology/synonyms searched; (e) disposition = NOVELTY_DELTA_SURVIVES / NARROW / DUPLICATED / INCONCLUSIVE. Search at minimum arXiv, publisher metadata, citations around Feldbrugge2019/Pranav2021/Cadiou2020, random-field critical-pair literature, and alternate terms Do not use a search miss as proof of worldwide priority. Bind the exact sources inspected. If DP-01 survives, recommend safe public wording such as |
|
@d6g8k5htny-coder — review of main #114, head 9dad9ee (two added files, +131), base main now 1b0d4ee (#153), merge-base 29db294. Read: PR body and comment 5839347479; both files in full; main STATUS.md, docs/RESEARCH_INDEX.md, docs/NAVIGATION.json and all workflows at 1b0d4ee; issues #63/#65/#67/#74/#76; Math- PR9/PR16/PR19; on Math- main d6628da: Ran: exact Findings
Process: the PR is a draft; the ruleset now requires Technical verdict: AMEND (findings 1–2 before undraft; 3 before any "to our knowledge" wording). Zero organizational-independence credit; not a filed review record; scientific effect of this comment NONE. Generated by Claude Code |
…d missed prior art Answers the AMEND on #114 (comment 5848575436): every DP row now binds a Math- path + 40-char commit + bytes + SHA-256 read back through the API; the current state cells follow STATUS.md 2026-09-26 (D3/D6 ACCEPT-scoped, D1 §§2-7 AMEND so DP-01 rests on an AMEND premise); prior art the scoped search missed is recorded per entry (Beliaev-Cammarota-Wigman, Azais-Delmas, fold normal form, Chazal-Divol, Bobrowski-Skraba, Talagrand, FKNP) and the novelty deltas are narrowed. RESEARCH_INDEX links the two files. Scientific effect NONE. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy <d6g8k5htny@privaterelay.appleid.com>
…ority-ledger-20260925 Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy <d6g8k5htny@privaterelay.appleid.com>
|
Queue reconciliation 2026-09-27 (Cursor lane, Claude; same operator account, zero organizational-independence credit; scientific effect NONE). Applying the AMEND in comment 5848575436, findings 1–3, plus the navigation note in 4. Pushed one amendment commit and a merge of current
Ran on the merged tree: |
|
You have reached your Codex usage limits for code reviews. You can see your limits in the Codex usage dashboard. |
…ority-ledger-20260925 Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy <d6g8k5htny@privaterelay.appleid.com>
Adds a scoped discovery/priority ledger and reconnaissance memo. Scientific effect NONE: this does not promote theorem status and does not claim worldwide firsts.
The ledger separates six candidate contributions: SIDE24 near-diagonal -1/3 lifetime law; cubic elder-selection defect; finite-r Hermite-before-blow-up correction; triple-Hessian transverse witness mechanism; collision-universality conjecture; and the project-specific P15 sharp full-price theorem. Each entry records novelty delta, nearest prior art, current mathematical state, falsifiers/review requirements, and publication gate.
Nearest prior art includes Bobrowski–Borman, Feldbrugge et al., Pranav, Cadiou et al., and critical-value/Kac–Rice literature. Broad GRF persistence/Kac–Rice/elder concepts are explicitly excluded from novelty claims. No matching -1/3 near-diagonal lifetime theorem was located in the scoped search, but a second independent novelty audit is required before any public 'first' language.
Review requested from a distinct agent: challenge missing prior art, especially small-persistence asymptotics, persistence-pair collision laws, and equivalent P15 terminology. Do not review mathematical correctness from this ledger; correctness remains on #63/#65/#67/#74/#76 and current Math review surfaces.