Repository navigation
Retain historical 20-target alignment evidence with original source ancestry #268
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Changes from all commits
File filter
Filter by extension
Conversations
Jump to
Diff view
Diff view
There are no files selected for viewing
| Original file line number | Diff line number | Diff line change |
|---|---|---|
| @@ -0,0 +1,76 @@ | ||
| # Statement alignment — 20-target #272 measure bridge | ||
|
|
||
| Dylan Roy — delegated AI review. Actual performer: xAI / Grok 4.7, Cursor Cloud Agent, model `grok-4.7-high-fast`, session `bc-a0687e6b-da3f-4724-86d3-868e01ee676d` (https://cursor.com/agents/bc-a0687e6b-da3f-4724-86d3-868e01ee676d). Transport: Cursor Cloud (`usePrivateWorker: false`, `privateWorkerId: null`). `list-self-hosted-workers` returned `totalCount: 0`. `lake` and `lean` are not on `PATH`; Lean was not re-executed. | ||
|
|
||
| Scientific effect: **NONE**. Organizational-independence credit: **0**. Dylan's personal reading: **PENDING**. | ||
|
|
||
| **Verdict: PASS.** Finding IDs: none. Alignment disposition for this package: **ACCEPTED**, covering exactly the 20 manifest targets at Math-#272 head `270167900b71539d0e2135131a3a96f1f04289f6`. This record is distinct from the 29-target record at `reviews/lean_probability_alignment_20261005/alignment.json` on `8cf6b74472d77a62f4775a5e3568e79d4407adff`. | ||
|
|
||
| ## Lane count for this pickup | ||
|
|
||
| Roll call `5994946754` had 2 confirmed lanes: the OpenAI coordinator and this Cursor Cloud run. Two local Task helpers then launched and returned inside this same slot: | ||
|
|
||
| | ID | Runtime | Scope | | ||
| |---|---|---| | ||
| | `bc-a0687e6b-da3f-4724-86d3-868e01ee676d` | Cursor Cloud, `grok-4.7-high-fast`, no private worker | Parent auditor; statement check, gate, publication | | ||
| | `bc-4ed14bcc-0a62-5c6f-8ecd-9d7e95b45878` | Local Task subprocess, model inherit | Original 13 against preserved sources and `SCOPE.md` | | ||
| | `bc-dde77d90-eb4c-5426-ba20-a338aabef307` | Local Task subprocess, model inherit | New 7 statements and new 9 evidence blobs | | ||
|
|
||
| Deduplicated confirmed external lanes remain **2**. The helpers are not self-hosted workers and are not separately reachable agents. No nested spawn and no timer. | ||
|
|
||
| ## Exposure and authorship | ||
|
|
||
| Before the comparison finished, this session had read `REVIEW.md` at `8f70c102550a6080c2b8f472df8a601fc7f61081`, alignment JSON at `8cf6b744`, and the earlier seven-target audit `5994130542`. The statement comparison then used the frozen #272 sources and the informal extract below. No Lean file, gate, workflow, manifest, or scientific register was edited. Proof bodies were not graded. | ||
|
|
||
| Author of the seven bridge declarations, from `MEASURE_BRIDGE.md` and commit `2701679`: OpenAI / GPT-6 / GPT-6 Astra Pro. Author of the original thirteen companions: OpenAI implementation lane of Math-#92, commit `867d9e34b601` (2026-09-27). That commit does not name GPT-6 Astra Pro. The machine `author` object below is the #272 bridge author, the performer who owns this candidate. The reviewer differs from both OpenAI lanes on provider, family, and agent. Same-provider overlap with the earlier Grok reads is disclosed and earns no organizational-independence credit. | ||
|
|
||
| ## Bound identity | ||
|
|
||
| | Object | SHA-256 | | ||
| |---|---| | ||
| | `formal/manifest.json` | `845d372a459d32f6b4ffb0a4dceb69363ffe27c4ca6da8838238ce8979d9244d` | | ||
| | `formal/SCOPE.md` | `e303550bdd71aa969703fd33dc9808383db13b08072437577d192a7f149a3edb` | | ||
| | `formal/originals/Algebra.lean.txt` | `4c196820c4db8fafc288dd35642828ba577e3544d60aba7d1d6d24f14ad1e8ae` | | ||
| | `formal/originals/ProbabilityCompanions.lean.txt` | `4ace6600a476859982c8851ae9097c89b082d3c96291b3c8330bd4cc00bae65d` | | ||
| | Informal `imports/hardening_ebedb780/P02-LM-008/proof.md.export.txt` at `22876edaaec054d3ab8b0b16668ce3ff8cbf8c73` | `06967d0ba2c2d20550f3bd86ddc97981e324e5f94cd7710996445d507ae2285b` | | ||
|
|
||
| `MeasureBridge.lean` blob `11843e5586ec44c7430f077694c90ac8586c50c0` is the same blob at #273 head `dce1b197be3431673289905259be38b450e9b898`. Current PR heads observed during this read: #272 `2701679`, #273 `dce1b197`, #274 `8cf6b744`. | ||
|
|
||
| Unified diff of each V2 module against its preserved original is exactly the three `COMPATIBILITY.md` repairs: `noncomputable def foldPotential` with the same right-hand side; deletion of the surplus `ring` after `field_simp [hr]` in `ec014_contact_power`; deletion of the surplus `ring` after `field_simp [hr, hcZ]` in `p02_lm008_r2_cancel`. All thirteen theorem statements, from `theorem` through the character before `:=`, match the preserved originals. | ||
|
|
||
| ## Per-target verdicts | ||
|
|
||
| Each verdict is against the #272 `SCOPE.md` row and the cited informal interface. Informal P02-LM-008, lines 80–124 and 215–219, states a uniform family for `0 < r ≤ r_0` and defines `P_r(E) = E[W_r 1_E] / Z_r`. The Lean ratio bound keeps that inequality direction and the lower-normalizer hypothesis `cZ * r ^ 2 ≤ ∫ W`. Construction of `P_r` as a probability measure is outside these 20 declarations; `SCOPE.md` places it under "Not established" for `p02_lm008_measure_transfer`. | ||
|
|
||
| | Target | Verdict | Statement checked | | ||
| |---|---|---| | ||
| | `ec005_fold_gap` | ALIGNED | For every real `s`, `foldPotential s s - foldPotential s (-s) = (2 * s) ^ 3 / 6`. | | ||
| | `ec008_factor_expansion` | ALIGNED | The displayed scalar polynomial identity in unrestricted real `c, s`. | | ||
| | `ec010_generic` | ALIGNED | The displayed four-real polynomial identity. | | ||
| | `ec010_transverse` | ALIGNED | The displayed three-real polynomial identity. | | ||
| | `ec011_scalar_cancellation` | ALIGNED | `(-h * w) * g + w * (h * g) = 0` for real `h, w, g`. | | ||
| | `ec014_contact_power` | ALIGNED | For `r ≠ 0`, `(r ^ 3 / 6) * (1 / r ^ 5) * r ^ 2 = 1 / 6`. | | ||
| | `p02_lm008_r2_cancel` | ALIGNED | For `r ≠ 0` and `cZ ≠ 0`, the displayed `r ^ 2` cancellation. | | ||
| | `p02_lm008_cross_multiplied` | ALIGNED | From `0 < r`, `0 ≤ cW`, `0 < cZ`, `0 ≤ q`, `cZ * r ^ 2 ≤ z`, and `n ≤ sqrt(cW) * r ^ 2 * sqrt(q)`, conclude `n * (cZ * r ^ 2) ≤ (sqrt(cW) * r ^ 2 * sqrt(q)) * z`. | | ||
| | `p02_lm008_quotient_bound` | ALIGNED | Those hypotheses plus `0 < z` conclude `n / z ≤ (sqrt(cW) / cZ) * sqrt(q)`. | | ||
| | `p02_lm009_bad_event_threshold` | ALIGNED | `0 < r` and `ε < r * R ^ 5` imply `ε / r < R ^ 5`. This is deterministic threshold algebra. It is not a Markov measure bound. | | ||
| | `p02_lm009_power40_identity` | ALIGNED | `(R ^ 5) ^ 8 = R ^ 40`. | | ||
| | `p02_lm009_r4_le_r3` | ALIGNED | `0 ≤ r ≤ 1` implies `r ^ 4 ≤ r ^ 3`. | | ||
| | `p02_lm009_palm_r4_to_r3` | ALIGNED | `0 ≤ C`, `0 ≤ r ≤ 1`, and `p ≤ C * r ^ 4` imply `p ≤ C * r ^ 3`. | | ||
| | `p02_lm008_integral_cs` | ALIGNED | One measure, two nonnegative `MemLp` 2 functions, Bochner product bound by the product of L² norms. | | ||
| | `p02_lm008_event_cs` | ALIGNED | One probability, measurable `A`, nonnegative `MemLp W 2`, set-integral bound by `sqrt(∫ W^2) * sqrt((μ A).toReal)`. | | ||
| | `p02_lm008_event_numerator` | ALIGNED | Those event hypotheses plus `0 ≤ cW` and `∫ W^2 ≤ cW * r ^ 4` give `∫_A W ≤ sqrt(cW) * r ^ 2 * sqrt((μ A).toReal)`. No `r > 0` hypothesis on this step. | | ||
| | `p02_lm008_measure_transfer` | ALIGNED | Adds `0 < r`, `0 < cZ`, and `cZ * r ^ 2 ≤ ∫ W`, and concludes the same-law ratio `≤ (sqrt(cW) / cZ) * sqrt((μ A).toReal)`. | | ||
| | `p02_lm009_measure_transfer_r8_to_r3` | ALIGNED | Adds `r ≤ 1`, `0 ≤ K`, and `(μ A).toReal ≤ K * r ^ 8`, and concludes the ratio `≤ ((sqrt(cW) / cZ) * sqrt(K)) * r ^ 3`. | | ||
| | `p02_lm008_sqrt_counterexample` | ALIGNED | Scalar witness `(1 : ℝ) = sqrt(4) * sqrt(1/4)` and the negation of the missing-square-root form. | | ||
| | `p02_lm008_upper_normalizer_counterexample` | ALIGNED | Scalar witness `1 ≤ 2 * 1^2` together with the ratio exceeding the reversed-normalizer expression. | | ||
|
|
||
| `0 ≤ cW` and `0 ≤ q` are the stronger real hypotheses `SCOPE.md` already records. The upper-normalizer counterexample matches informal mutation M1: an upper bound `Z ≤ C r^2` does not upper-bound the ratio. GP214's upper bound is not used as the lower bound. | ||
|
|
||
| ## Fields consumed by `formal/gate.py --alignment` | ||
|
|
||
| `check_alignment` reads `disposition`, `manifest_sha256`, `scope_sha256`, `targets`, `author.provider`, `author.family`, `author.agent`, `reviewer.provider`, `reviewer.family`, `reviewer.agent`, `evidence.repository`, `evidence.commit`, `evidence.sha256`, and `evidence.path`. It compares `targets` by set with `manifest["targets"]` and `scope_sha256` with `files["SCOPE.md"]`. It rejects a shared provider, family, or agent, a stale digest, a partial target set, and any disposition other than `ACCEPTED`. It does not read `source_exposure`, `notes`, or `scientific_effect`. Success prints `SOURCE_IDENTITY_PASS` and returns exit 0; a failed alignment prints `FORMAL_GATE_FAIL` and returns 1. | ||
|
|
||
| ## Boundary | ||
|
|
||
| Accepted here: the 20 Lean statements at the #272 scope, including the same-law ratio and the cubic composition of a supplied eighth-order event bound. Left outside this record: the weighted probability construction on #273; a concrete Gaussian or typed Palm law; a Markov bound from an integrable `R^40` moment; uniformity in `r`; discharged moment, normalizer, or tail premises; P0.2; parent persistence; and any scientific-register change. `alignment_status` in `formal/manifest.json` remains `PENDING_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW`. |
| Original file line number | Diff line number | Diff line change |
|---|---|---|
| @@ -0,0 +1,51 @@ | ||
| # Validation commands for the 20-target #272 record | ||
|
|
||
| Scientific effect: NONE. Lean was not executed. The formal tree used for `gate.py` is Math-#272 head `270167900b71539d0e2135131a3a96f1f04289f6`, checked out locally from `d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-`. Publication of these files is on `d6g8k5htny-coder/main` branch `cursor/lean-probability-alignment-272-20-676d`. Push of that branch to Math- returned `Permission to d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-.git denied to cursor[bot]` (HTTP 403). #272, #273, and #274 refs were not updated. | ||
|
|
||
| ## 20-target record | ||
|
|
||
| Command, with `formal/gate.py` taken from the #272 tree and the JSON taken from this publication: | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| python3 -B -S formal/gate.py --alignment /workspace/reviews/lean_probability_alignment_20261005/alignment_272_20.json | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| Stdout: | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| SOURCE_IDENTITY_PASS (not a Lean build or scientific acceptance): 845d372a459d32f6b4ffb0a4dceb69363ffe27c4ca6da8838238ce8979d9244d | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| Exit code: 0. On this `gate.py`, exit 0 after `--alignment` means `check_alignment` accepted the record. | ||
|
|
||
| Evidence file at commit `644d06ebe06c748e7f62988942fddaeabddd1147`: | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| 5c1b30066fde9cf920ee5ce4534ec3a43770e8209897edd1b20bd14c7005d7ee reviews/lean_probability_alignment_20261005/REVIEW_272_20.md | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| ## Reused 29-target JSON, rejected | ||
|
|
||
| The 29-target `alignment.json` from Math- `8cf6b74472d77a62f4775a5e3568e79d4407adff` was passed unchanged to the same #272-tree gate: | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| python3 -B -S formal/gate.py --alignment /tmp/alignment_29.json | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| Stderr: `FORMAL_GATE_FAIL: stale alignment manifest`. Exit code: 1. | ||
|
|
||
| ## 29-target record on its own tree | ||
|
|
||
| At Math- `8cf6b74472d77a62f4775a5e3568e79d4407adff`: | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| python3 -B -S formal/gate.py --alignment reviews/lean_probability_alignment_20261005/alignment.json | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| Stdout: | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| SOURCE_IDENTITY_PASS (not a Lean build or scientific acceptance): d843ba7b96457a95e6485a4bc30678a8a252acf405d369b26dab81832c596c39 | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| Exit code: 0. |
| Original file line number | Diff line number | Diff line change |
|---|---|---|
| @@ -0,0 +1,30 @@ | ||
| # Verification of the existing 29-target alignment record | ||
|
|
||
| Dylan Roy — delegated AI review. Actual performer: xAI / Grok 4.7, Cursor Cloud Agent `bc-a0687e6b-da3f-4724-86d3-868e01ee676d`. Scientific effect: **NONE**. This file confirms an existing record. It is not a second alignment JSON and it does not relabel that record as a 20-target review. | ||
|
|
||
| ## Immutable bytes | ||
|
|
||
| | Object | Identity | | ||
| |---|---| | ||
| | Review branch tip | `8cf6b74472d77a62f4775a5e3568e79d4407adff` | | ||
| | `REVIEW.md` commit | `8f70c102550a6080c2b8f472df8a601fc7f61081` | | ||
| | `REVIEW.md` blob | `53d4e760b8d8b74c4d27c64937be39428692ebc3` | | ||
| | `REVIEW.md` SHA-256 | `f061aae9e9d1f98b4e5de373d3e0b9f244f43fa37c594d23981ebbb650e2ffbd` | | ||
| | `alignment.json` blob at the tip | `e8a58ef35309694f13047f2edfcd6211155778a5` | | ||
| | Implementation head | `dce1b197be3431673289905259be38b450e9b898` | | ||
| | Manifest SHA-256 | `d843ba7b96457a95e6485a4bc30678a8a252acf405d369b26dab81832c596c39` | | ||
| | Scope SHA-256 | `e8ef291bb7daa334812451a675788b4ee902c0974d9bcd3197407b6b56b63548` | | ||
|
|
||
| `git diff --stat dce1b197 8cf6b744` is only `REVIEW.md` and `alignment.json`. `WeightedLaw.lean` blob `b51ca969a13b27b7e41a1401ea9e10e7dee39fb8` and `WEIGHTED_LAW.md` blob `ab1ece70af77767ab24d6b988fc9ba8159d52565` match at `dce1b197` and `8cf6b744`. `MeasureBridge.lean` blob `11843e5586ec44c7430f077694c90ac8586c50c0` matches #272 and #273. | ||
|
|
||
| The JSON `targets` array equals the 29-element manifest list in order. `disposition` is `ACCEPTED`. Author `OpenAI` / `GPT-6` / `GPT-6 Astra Pro` differs on all three lineage fields from reviewer `xAI` / `Grok` / `Grok 4.7 Cursor Cloud Agent`. Evidence repository, path, commit, and SHA-256 match the table above. | ||
|
|
||
| `python3 -B -S formal/gate.py --alignment reviews/lean_probability_alignment_20261005/alignment.json` was run at `8cf6b744`. Stdout was `SOURCE_IDENTITY_PASS (not a Lean build or scientific acceptance): d843ba7b96457a95e6485a4bc30678a8a252acf405d369b26dab81832c596c39` and the exit code was 0. On this gate, that exit means `check_alignment` accepted the record. | ||
|
|
||
| ## Semantic coverage | ||
|
|
||
| The nine `WeightedLaw` statements match `WEIGHTED_LAW.md` and the weighted-law section of `SCOPE.md` at `dce1b197`: the `withDensity` definition; probability from integrability, a.e. nonnegativity, and a positive integral; the real same-law ratio on a measurable event; absolute continuity; a.e. congruence; zero and unit edges; and the two compositions that keep the moment and lower-normalizer premises, with the cubic theorem also keeping `(μ A).toReal ≤ K * r ^ 8` and `r ≤ 1`. The original thirteen statements match the preserved originals except the three `COMPATIBILITY.md` repairs. The seven bridge declarations are the bytes already compared in `REVIEW_272_20.md`. | ||
|
|
||
| Reviewer of that record: xAI / Grok 4.7, session `bc-3ab4d42c-6316-48de-a53d-152dd0faeb46`. This confirmation is a later same-provider read. Organizational-independence credit for either Grok read remains 0. The single JSON author object names the 2026-10-05 OpenAI performer. The original thirteen companions come from the OpenAI Math-#92 lane, whose commit does not name GPT-6 Astra Pro. That split is disclosed here. It does not change the statement verdict: the reviewer of the 29-target record differs from both OpenAI lanes. | ||
|
|
||
| No statement AMEND. The 29-target acceptance stays on its own manifest and scope. It does not accept the #272 manifest `845d372a459d32f6b4ffb0a4dceb69363ffe27c4ca6da8838238ce8979d9244d`. |
| Original file line number | Diff line number | Diff line change |
|---|---|---|
| @@ -0,0 +1,46 @@ | ||
| { | ||
| "disposition": "ACCEPTED", | ||
| "manifest_sha256": "845d372a459d32f6b4ffb0a4dceb69363ffe27c4ca6da8838238ce8979d9244d", | ||
| "scope_sha256": "e303550bdd71aa969703fd33dc9808383db13b08072437577d192a7f149a3edb", | ||
| "targets": [ | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.ec005_fold_gap", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.ec008_factor_expansion", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.ec010_generic", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.ec010_transverse", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.ec011_scalar_cancellation", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.ec014_contact_power", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm008_r2_cancel", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm008_cross_multiplied", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm008_quotient_bound", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm009_bad_event_threshold", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm009_power40_identity", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm009_r4_le_r3", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm009_palm_r4_to_r3", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm008_integral_cs", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm008_event_cs", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm008_event_numerator", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm008_measure_transfer", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm009_measure_transfer_r8_to_r3", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm008_sqrt_counterexample", | ||
| "ResearchFormalCoreR1.p02_lm008_upper_normalizer_counterexample" | ||
| ], | ||
| "author": { | ||
| "provider": "OpenAI", | ||
| "family": "GPT-6", | ||
| "agent": "GPT-6 Astra Pro" | ||
| }, | ||
| "reviewer": { | ||
| "provider": "xAI", | ||
| "family": "Grok", | ||
| "agent": "Grok 4.7 Cursor Cloud Agent bc-a0687e6b-da3f-4724-86d3-868e01ee676d" | ||
| }, | ||
| "evidence": { | ||
| "repository": "d6g8k5htny-coder/main", | ||
| "path": "reviews/lean_probability_alignment_20261005/REVIEW_272_20.md", | ||
| "commit": "644d06ebe06c748e7f62988942fddaeabddd1147", | ||
|
There was a problem hiding this comment. Choose a reason for hiding this commentThe reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
If this reviewed commit is integrated or cloned without the separate source branch, this evidence pointer is not retained by the repository history: AGENTS.md reference: AGENTS.md:L30-L31 Useful? React with 👍 / 👎. |
||
| "sha256": "5c1b30066fde9cf920ee5ce4534ec3a43770e8209897edd1b20bd14c7005d7ee" | ||
| }, | ||
| "source_exposure": "Read the prior 29-target review and the seven-target audit before finishing the comparison. Compared all 20 statements through := with SCOPE.md, MEASURE_BRIDGE.md, preserved originals, COMPATIBILITY.md, and P02-LM-008 proof.md.export.txt at 22876eda. Proofs were not graded.", | ||
| "scientific_effect": "NONE", | ||
| "notes": "Distinct 20-target record for Math-#272 head 270167900b71539d0e2135131a3a96f1f04289f6. The author object is the #272 bridge performer. Original 13 remain the OpenAI Math-#92 lane. This file is not a relabel of the 29-target alignment.json. Evidence is published on d6g8k5htny-coder/main because cursor[bot] received HTTP 403 when pushing the same bytes to Math-." | ||
| } | ||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
When a controller consumes this
ACCEPTEDrecord, it checks reviewer independence only against this author object, butREVIEW_272_20.md:25states that 13 of the 20 targets came from an earlier implementation whose commit does not identify GPT-6 Astra Pro. Assigning that model’s lineage to the entire target set therefore rewrites the majority author lineage and makes the three-field independence check operate on inaccurate metadata; represent both actual lineages or split the mixed-author targets into separate records before accepting them.AGENTS.md reference: AGENTS.md:L12-L14
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.