Skip to content
Closed
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
6 changes: 6 additions & 0 deletions cbz/evidence/auditor-consolidation/DECISION_ADDENDUM.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
# Proposed append-only ledger entry

[2026-10-29T18:33:13Z] [phase2] [layer B/C] [consolidate overlapping finite source auditors] [ULW29ef5b924 provides the strongest portable basis; retain compatible main687/014K regression requirements and preserve all old declared controls. Repair actual pinned-Lean counterexamples before admission. Use one canonical Main tool pair; do not replace Root's existing census, certify semantic bounds from A3 classes, or infer kernel closure from lexical results.] [reversible: yes — ordinary Git additions] [cbz/evidence/auditor-consolidation/VERIFICATION.json; docs/cbz/CANONICAL_AUDITORS.md]

Canonical Root owns GOVERNANCE/TOOLING/STATUS/DECISIONS integration under B-003.
This file is proposed addenda and does not silently amend those surfaces.
22 changes: 22 additions & 0 deletions cbz/evidence/auditor-consolidation/README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
# Auditor consolidation evidence

Canonical implementation candidate based on ULW29ef5b924, preserving its controls
and integrating compatible peer regressions. Read docs/cbz/CANONICAL_AUDITORS.md.
VERIFICATION.json binds the final working source bytes and observed72-test runs.
REGISTRY.json is proposed addenda for Root, not a claim canonical registry is
already updated. No full federation G0-G11 or CBZ-0 result is claimed.

The independent-review directory preserves a historical frozen-source AMEND
review, exact actual Lean counterexamples and successor replays. Review states
are bound to their written source hashes, not silently transferred to new heads.
current-review-replay.json binds a further replay to the current scanner bytes.
Native-expression raw outputs show four valid Lean theorem proofs using fresh
compiler-trust axioms, all rejected by the repaired source scanner.

Every .lean.txt is deliberately adversarial test data, never a production Lean
module, closed mathematical obligation, or import of closed code. The original
bytes are retained exactly. Tests generate actual standalone source in temporary
areas; the compiler observations establish counterexamples to an earlier scanner,
not accepted proofs. Red logs remain evidence of defects repaired in this unit.
The repository-wide semantic closure and submodule-pin admission are outside
this contribution.
46 changes: 46 additions & 0 deletions cbz/evidence/auditor-consolidation/REGISTRY.json
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,46 @@
{
"tools": [
{
"path": "tools/cbz/layer_a_scan.py",
"purpose": "finite Lean source-token scanner, tracked-Git or explicit filesystem source",
"usage": "python3.11 -B -S tools/cbz/layer_a_scan.py --git REPO --rev EXACT_COMMIT --fail-on all --json OUTSIDE_SOURCE.json",
"verification": "two72-test normal/optimized suites;66source mutants all killed via named assertion failures; actual pinnedLean counterexamples replayed",
"owner": "none — self-contained",
"cbz_criteria": [
4,
9,
11
],
"gates": [
"G0",
"finite necessary source portion of G1"
],
"limitations": [
"Gitlinks require separately pinned admission; ULW45a80ab0 is rejected with exit2 until resolved.",
"Lexical results do not see arbitrary macros/elaboration/imports; G2-G4 remain authoritative."
]
},
{
"path": "tools/cbz/a3_float_census.py",
"purpose": "finite Python AST floating/exact/interval signal inventory, never semantic bound certification",
"usage": "python3.11 -B -S tools/cbz/a3_float_census.py --git REPO --rev EXACT_COMMIT --json OUTSIDE_SOURCE.json",
"verification": "same normal/optimized suites;23source mutants all killed; syntax/import/launch errors not kills",
"owner": "none — self-contained",
"cbz_criteria": [
4,
9,
11
],
"gates": [
"G0",
"A3source triage only"
],
"limitations": [
"A3census does not certify mathematical bounds or exactness; no semantic A3 closure inferred."
]
}
],
"canonical_registration_owner": "Root per B-003; proposed addenda only",
"source_doc": "docs/cbz/CANONICAL_AUDITORS.md",
"verification": "cbz/evidence/auditor-consolidation/VERIFICATION.json"
}
48 changes: 48 additions & 0 deletions cbz/evidence/auditor-consolidation/SHA256SUMS
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
cd29a57928b77c374c5dbaa22c4c73b1d1f75aea3a3fe0ad2058fe345b9475f9 DECISION_ADDENDUM.md
811ac6978a8a0f04631666a45c2f9976c9fb3cc22f8e5ffd368d227ba299d3ea README.md
fd4de11664c7a676f1cbdd6f734c223869e42e53a5946fe6770a353dd510182a REGISTRY.json
43f4428c2ea5667478698e5d821eb7985fa2b7a20876981c0d14a185ea395e74 VERIFICATION.json
b95a14ac932c86bf37232aae5152028996872d8447c4c12adeda5709b8f79fa4 current-review-replay.json
f3eb644fa1c9d38ef42aca1e076f1e300e506a548f778b78e26b02573db2bf6e hardening-red.log
51a910cd883039a99f86d161c0e76bf334184c3efb7105a2c8be27b92262de23 identifier-escape-red.log
640898b95489bc92c7c346db9d31dcd6d53efb5fe88e72a6c60131c85206d5dc independent-p1-red.log
12075d7a3d7515ecf59fd315560101b41ae71cbd99ad7a74ca203ed3ae91fe60 independent-review/REVIEW.md
dd3170a10c561c128a8bb9bebbcf85f343721add9485adff1288b3e6c5a917c8 independent-review/final-five-fixture-results.json
bc79166e4825380ce31cc69aa72534ec05eb55b46ac2f4106e791aedee3c0e7c independent-review/macro-string-final-lean.log
348a7bd4fc30dc9369e62a7fab33a880f0f813c4c6c91e5ee7fcd1838c7d0cf8 independent-review/macro-string-final-scan.json
bc79166e4825380ce31cc69aa72534ec05eb55b46ac2f4106e791aedee3c0e7c independent-review/macro-string-lean.log
10a0dc3b9599fa7e6f5c48bb416aa85b3b19d5deb4cb0a30abb34496b898e707 independent-review/macro-string-scan.json
85f9108ea955174df354f516be46b543d9a597a802338bf99ff73f0fa6f59617 independent-review/macro-string-scan.log
8ac3a070483d0a0b1679db84ea243e2c3465fe700d227c5405c4ab6f23fb2555 independent-review/macro-string.lean.txt
59d3f582434d877f348cfc248ece736a3f667b343135c6e126c04ec065fed3ea independent-review/numeral-adjacency-lean.log
10a0dc3b9599fa7e6f5c48bb416aa85b3b19d5deb4cb0a30abb34496b898e707 independent-review/numeral-adjacency-scan.json
e1aed17d06a9de4d69f17d1cf8426e789224b5a3b152d7aad2cf8661e9539731 independent-review/numeral-adjacency.lean.txt
27f7d7a80eba4fe355322ffbc04a612ffe2726eabdd64d4043165fefcc39d688 independent-review/numeral-command-final-lean.log
21e72992af5a12ea565606d1bb2078595fc939304f3f5128357ff95660d7c1a9 independent-review/numeral-command-final-scan.json
27f7d7a80eba4fe355322ffbc04a612ffe2726eabdd64d4043165fefcc39d688 independent-review/numeral-command-lean.log
10a0dc3b9599fa7e6f5c48bb416aa85b3b19d5deb4cb0a30abb34496b898e707 independent-review/numeral-command-scan.json
f9f3bbbffd6c7e03732f8305473e3ed657089b2a23ad84ddf3511c0687a35075 independent-review/numeral-command.lean.txt
04fd6a3d411d51cf7763e7b1d750bd99ae6612c443e54ddafa5748c56e2ba2bc independent-review/radix-command-final-lean.log
db2f11bb8ae835f5edb53ce3e423231d6716c7703ef1ba6cbab4d954680df0ac independent-review/radix-command-final-scan.json
04fd6a3d411d51cf7763e7b1d750bd99ae6612c443e54ddafa5748c56e2ba2bc independent-review/radix-command-lean.log
19c301bdbc912dd3d456402c058a5b4572e0f9b530ddce08b815ba35cbfdd282 independent-review/radix-command-scan.json
3124a713cafa4bb2cc3664e32d7bf2cceb533c0d2b860299655294d317641d1c independent-review/radix-command.lean.txt
27f7d7a80eba4fe355322ffbc04a612ffe2726eabdd64d4043165fefcc39d688 independent-review/scientific-command-final-lean.log
b357b2f48cca2bc93cacd4339b66515d88f06242850cdea067262fed549bde69 independent-review/scientific-command-final-scan.json
27f7d7a80eba4fe355322ffbc04a612ffe2726eabdd64d4043165fefcc39d688 independent-review/scientific-command-lean.log
10a0dc3b9599fa7e6f5c48bb416aa85b3b19d5deb4cb0a30abb34496b898e707 independent-review/scientific-command-scan.json
c584f4815e38be6b082ce997f7ac4d7adc41a8b4ab0ee5875649cd9d9faeef36 independent-review/scientific-command.lean.txt
3828cd28ef8212aa292d8b4c161ac72552b4e79b1159a2df39c2bcc71f47b5d4 independent-review/successor-two-fixture-scan.json
173e4207cd2442ce88b6b733f0ab8f8df3a89243d133af82dc33b99714e12c61 independent-review/unicode-char-final-lean.log
10a0dc3b9599fa7e6f5c48bb416aa85b3b19d5deb4cb0a30abb34496b898e707 independent-review/unicode-char-final-scan.json
173e4207cd2442ce88b6b733f0ab8f8df3a89243d133af82dc33b99714e12c61 independent-review/unicode-char-lean.log
27e8b66440bac78c28022a0a83cf4ae56faf7b976fca90fe62924a6e2f661dbd independent-review/unicode-char-scan.json
62a75ca0fa51ad8bd00b48b23e3738792b8d3af7eb0a7e810148c798206f65d3 independent-review/unicode-char.lean.txt
2ef3cf7af4aa31bdd418946cb9444dd3a13abcf6f1191896c4c1c54cbd7bbb15 interpolation-layout-red.log
2589f0a942f862e728a10c06ce2097ef8bbdcd8a518fd9d948e36bca2baf47de native-expression-red.log
29044f47ad2d3f821bbe23b6dc9369fadffdb777d731ef1ffa099fb0cec9a56b native-expressions-lean.log
d1bf2e8e1bf03dba99f425685fffdfe93410950842c43494ca877a5b7c62c6b4 native-expressions-scan.json
bd9ec74a033cc04f5b24e83292476b421c2311e79204a7c5bbf6e9df7837f2d6 native-expressions.lean.txt
4cebfae9e19607f16608284826d87c38ea7cf359366f9e69c6a890134a6d22a1 numeral-prime-red.log
2dea1bc8d01355db8a1f9704ef453f6ef23f283d610fea833725796d129f8c89 v4-final-normal.log
9b5fac2a2cd784f6f89e6d60ebd199d7af3b1e97439f4736c57ee61a96ca9c8d v4-final-optimized.log
50 changes: 50 additions & 0 deletions cbz/evidence/auditor-consolidation/VERIFICATION.json
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,50 @@
{
"observed_utc": "2026-10-29T18:33:13.800535+00:00",
"scope": "finite lexical source and AST-signal auditors only; no kernel/semantic/global CBZ qualification",
"python": "CPython3.11.16",
"base_commit": "27c89b05bd2503c580b692f57146d608a7f0f668",
"sources": {
"tools/cbz/layer_a_scan.py": "9ed661b1490f73c4dc3664a33ed688e937c1c7d8fecfb4d48c5349fa41823818",
"tools/cbz/a3_float_census.py": "882b6f611aaf14e30c314ab25ef17a787eed579dbc2591b0720341174df10d90",
"tests/test_cbz_layer_a_scan.py": "3f6f666e0a8cc9d4415d8e87a3cbc4fa879fb34becf3cdf1602137a266d5a0ed",
"tests/test_cbz_layer_a_scan_mutants.py": "170d158de2f3d1a8c1d7d96dc5d8d2893333eea30786eef769ad021d6c31d121",
"tests/test_cbz_a3_float_census.py": "da19b8436089be8300236cd3f363a82e7db1dd3aab10751a75ee9255a45700a9",
"tests/test_cbz_auditor_hardening.py": "f31d43830b807f4c3f593181e2ccbdae8bf08393456b8d464d30d4277f222fdb"
},
"normal": {
"tests": 72,
"exit": 0,
"duration_seconds_decimal": "110.936",
"log": "v4-final-normal.log"
},
"optimized": {
"tests": 72,
"exit": 0,
"duration_seconds_decimal": "118.016",
"log": "v4-final-optimized.log"
},
"source_mutations": {
"lexical": 66,
"a3": 23,
"threshold_percent": 100,
"killed": 89,
"survivors": 0,
"stale_anchors": 0,
"kill_requires": "designated named assertion failure; errors/import/launch/syntax/unrelated failures cannot kill"
},
"scoped_source_probe": {
"repo": "Math-",
"commit": "8151f592918a845bf19eb8eafaf8444540a32734",
"lean_blobs": 162,
"violations": 0,
"lex_errors": 0,
"exit": 0,
"not_final_federation_gate": true
},
"remaining_boundaries": [
"Gitlinks require separately pinned admission; ULW45a80ab0 is rejected with exit2 until resolved.",
"Lexical results do not see arbitrary macros/elaboration/imports; G2-G4 remain authoritative.",
"A3census does not certify mathematical bounds or exactness; no semantic A3 closure inferred.",
"Full preexisting regression/hosted/federation final gates not run by this contribution."
]
}
94 changes: 94 additions & 0 deletions cbz/evidence/auditor-consolidation/current-review-replay.json
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,94 @@
{
"scanner_sha256": "9ed661b1490f73c4dc3664a33ed688e937c1c7d8fecfb4d48c5349fa41823818",
"fixtures": [
{
"fixture": "macro-string",
"source_sha256": "8ac3a070483d0a0b1679db84ea243e2c3465fe700d227c5405c4ab6f23fb2555",
"findings": [
{
"path": "macro-string.lean",
"line": 4,
"col": 58,
"token": "sorry",
"kind": "sorry",
"layer": "A1",
"severity": "violation",
"context": "production"
}
]
},
{
"fixture": "numeral-command",
"source_sha256": "f9f3bbbffd6c7e03732f8305473e3ed657089b2a23ad84ddf3511c0687a35075",
"findings": [
{
"path": "numeral-command.lean",
"line": 1,
"col": 18,
"token": "axiom",
"kind": "axiom",
"layer": "A2",
"severity": "violation",
"context": "production"
}
]
},
{
"fixture": "scientific-command",
"source_sha256": "c584f4815e38be6b082ce997f7ac4d7adc41a8b4ab0ee5875649cd9d9faeef36",
"findings": [
{
"path": "scientific-command.lean",
"line": 1,
"col": 20,
"token": "axiom",
"kind": "axiom",
"layer": "A2",
"severity": "violation",
"context": "production"
}
]
},
{
"fixture": "radix-command",
"source_sha256": "3124a713cafa4bb2cc3664e32d7bf2cceb533c0d2b860299655294d317641d1c",
"findings": [
{
"path": "radix-command.lean",
"line": 1,
"col": 18,
"token": "axiom",
"kind": "axiom",
"layer": "A2",
"severity": "violation",
"context": "production"
},
{
"path": "radix-command.lean",
"line": 2,
"col": 17,
"token": "axiom",
"kind": "axiom",
"layer": "A2",
"severity": "violation",
"context": "production"
},
{
"path": "radix-command.lean",
"line": 3,
"col": 23,
"token": "axiom",
"kind": "axiom",
"layer": "A2",
"severity": "violation",
"context": "production"
}
]
},
{
"fixture": "unicode-char",
"source_sha256": "62a75ca0fa51ad8bd00b48b23e3738792b8d3af7eb0a7e810148c798206f65d3",
"findings": []
}
]
}
Loading
Loading