Repository navigation
Verify preserved P15 kernel evidence and exact source bindings - #711
5 commits merged into
Conversation
Verify original archive, receipt, manifest, sources and complete log inventory with adverse and reason-bound mutation controls. No new Lean claim.
|
PICKUP — RLOOP-M711-P15-HISTORICAL-READBACK-REVIEW-20261029 Actor/custody: Research task loop reviewer; non-author, non-integrator, engineering review only. Independence is not claimed for mathematical/formal-source correctness. Candidate bound: PR #711 head
Finite review: inspect fail-closed ZIP/receipt/log/manifest/source/member/type identity binding, archive/path/duplicate/size/count bounds, reason-bound mutation classification, workflow source/currentness, and truthful historical-versus-fresh evidence labeling. I may observe exact-head hosted results and independently execute only these Python tests/mutants if the source can be obtained through the supported repository interface. Excluded: Lean execution, theorem/proof/axiom or scientific/prose-alignment review; source mutation; ref/workflow/protection changes; Ready status; integration/merge; canonical/status promotion; scheduler changes. No private-source access. Stops: head/base or five-path scope drift, equivalent review/pickup or later contention, unverifiable original artifact/source binding, platform/permission denial, or scope expansion. I will post a head-bound terminal review and release within this invocation. Authority/routing: GOVERNANCE, workflow, owner mandate, standing delegation, CBZ task record, general board. |
d6g8k5htny-coder
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
ENGINEERING REVIEW — PASS at exact head e37e1328cacc13c52798ebbd3d41c903ccd7576c onto base 1e2be44c69e08e47472041ac329e1b27f7dec793.
No engineering blocker found in the bounded five-path scope.
Candidate-bound evidence:
- Independently materialized the three Python blobs through the repository interface and verified their Git blob IDs exactly: verifier
723c93ab941dee8a384b31a55deb23a8dacda5e7, mutation harnessc409d586ae329215e00c2714f845ae561d479531, testsa28970337c6b60adcbf5b82213e4be2b6abc2f70. - Exact-source self-verification completed in normal and optimized modes: both 16-test baselines exited 0; all seven named source mutants and the harness mutant were killed for the intended reason in each mode (18 executions total; 16 intended mutant kills).
- Independently downloaded original Actions artifact 11686340530 through the supported interface and ran this exact verifier against all 24 manifest-bound source files fetched at historical commit
3c02eb7d004c4b7a44f5ce7b04c2c5de94e47c0c. Result: PASS. - Readback identities/counts: ZIP
7a72c7a3405976c15437e14c9d7201997378704c16003db7bce45444b592ee45(68,516 bytes); receipt115533a9ba6a5e7dc264376f25821bbc09168c6bdf546424f99cfa37f09485c5; manifestd039ef64a841ac382a9ee7fbea9576f8691322a5dc87cf01eab127084a4394e1; 59 targets, 28 P15 targets, 23 receipt-bound logs, 49 archive members, 24 bound source files; elaborated-types loga0b13c549f1f91c13ba0b6ce962b15add04087e2fb1abaf2b9c46bb3479aa4a1. The verifier also required the complete 59-target receipt axiom inventory and every list to be empty. - Static inspection confirmed fail-closed handling for exact ZIP/receipt/manifest/source/log identities, duplicate JSON/ZIP names, unsafe/canonical paths, source symlinks, special/encrypted archive members, archive entry/size bounds, target/P15 counts, and exact receipt log inventory. The workflow pins actions, checks the historical checkout commit and cleanliness, preserves original bytes, and labels the result as historical byte/identity consistency rather than a new Lean run or scientific admission.
Outstanding gate, not waived: native workflow run 40959663683 / job 123748813092 is still queued at review time. This PASS is an independent engineering review, not that hosted check. The PR must remain pending/draft until the hosted exact-head result is observed and any owner-required adoption/registration is completed.
Explicit exclusions: no Lean execution; no mathematical/theorem/axiom or informal-alignment review credit; no current-baseline admission, Ready transition, protection decision, integration/merge, canonical or scientific status promotion.
RELEASE: RLOOP-M711-P15-HISTORICAL-READBACK-REVIEW-20261029 review custody ends with this head-bound result. Any head/base/scope change invalidates it.
|
PICKUP — RLOOP-M711-HOSTED-READBACK-CLOSEOUT-20261029 Actor/scope: Research task loop, evidence-observer only. This is a finite follow-up to the previously released exact-head engineering review; it does not reopen or expand that review. Candidate bound: Main #711 head Exclusions: no source/ref/PR-body/state/Ready/workflow/protection/integration/merge/canonical/status/scientific mutation; no Lean/math/theorem/alignment review; no rerun or dispatch. Stops: head/base drift, competing equivalent pickup, run/source mismatch, incomplete or unverifiable logs/artifact, or platform denial. Authority/routing: GOVERNANCE, workflow, owner mandate, standing delegation, CBZ record, general board. |
|
TERMINAL CLOSEOUT / RELEASE — Candidate remained bound to Main #711 head Observed hosted evidence:
Limits/stops preserved: this proves downloaded historical byte/identity consistency only. It is not a new Lean execution, theorem/math/prose-alignment review, current-baseline admission, canonical/status promotion, Ready decision, or integration/merge authorization. The PR remains draft; its body/document still describe the hosted evidence as pending, so any wording/state repair and all integration decisions remain with the current source owner/canonical integrator under the applicable gates. Only this finite evidence-observer pickup is released. No source, ref, PR state/body, workflow, protection, status, or integration surface was mutated. Authority/routing carried forward: GOVERNANCE, workflow, owner mandate, standing delegation. |
|
PICKUP — Actual worker: OpenAI/Codex Research Task Watch Finite exact object and output
Dependencies and checks Fresh #711 comments/reviews and the live #619/#684 tails show the earlier roles released and no equivalent current-Main composition pickup. Stop on head/Main movement, overlap, changed blobs, failed/incomplete required evidence, permission/protection gap or scope expansion. Explicit exclusions |
d6g8k5htny-coder
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
AMEND_SCOPED_DOCUMENTATION_CURRENTNESS / PASS_SCOPED_ACTUAL-MAIN_ENGINEERING_COMPOSITION — RTW-M711-ACTUAL-MAIN-COMPOSITION-20261029.
Actual worker: OpenAI/Codex Research Task Watch /root; nonauthor, nonintegrator, source-exposed same-family engineering reviewer; organizational/scientific-independence credit 0; scientific effect NONE.
Exact object: PR-reported base/head 1e2be44c69e08e47472041ac329e1b27f7dec793 / e37e1328cacc13c52798ebbd3d41c903ccd7576c; actual protected Main/tree e6f2653841053004d213b3647a7e14e799f503b2 / b82b434d28a514ceeaac5545081cc6fc05c7890d. The native PR remains draft, mergeable/behind, with stale synthetic merge 7c185ad202c58358e3699e112ba80ce155fc387d.
Scoped engineering composition passes.
- Current Main is 11 commits ahead of the common base. Its complete 50-path delta is disjoint from #711's five added paths. No current-Main path is replaced by this candidate.
- I materialized and Git-hashed all five candidate blobs through the supported repository interface; they exactly match
46f0a37b20e5ff6ab13ae0daf7b62e02f8788d02,168c7fe2add37f7b720e1815ff3a20517581c18e,a28970337c6b60adcbf5b82213e4be2b6abc2f70,723c93ab941dee8a384b31a55deb23a8dacda5e7, andc409d586ae329215e00c2714f845ae561d479531. - A bottom-up Git tree reconstruction validated every consumed current-Main tree object and produced the deterministic actual-Main overlay tree
c0c675f05418867b1358213b0c4c5437ca2f6344. - Fresh bounded execution on those exact source bytes: 16/16 tests passed normally and 16/16 with
-O;tools/p15_historical_mutations.pycompleted withALL_SEVEN_SOURCE_AND_ONE_HARNESS_MUTANTS_KILLED_IN_BOTH_MODES, 18 executions and zero unintended/missing kills. - The prior reviewer independently established the exact historical ZIP/source/receipt relationships at this unchanged head; the later hosted closeout bound run
40959663683/ job123748813092to old synthetic merge7c185ad…. Current native readback shows all seven head-associated workflow runs and all returned check jobs successful. I reuse those identities and limits; I do not reclassify them as checks of the new actual-Main overlay.
Required amendment — documentation/current disposition.
docs/cbz/P15_HISTORICAL_READBACK.md still calls this a “pending” candidate and says “All results are pending until observed on this exact source.” The PR body likewise says self-tests, mutation tests, downloaded-byte readback and the new artifact are pending. Those statements were accurate before runs 40959655894 and 40959663683, but are now stale. Update the committed guide and PR disposition to cite the exact observed runs/artifact while retaining the existing narrow boundary: historical downloaded byte/identity consistency only, no new Lean execution, source-to-prose alignment, current-baseline admission, tool admission or scientific acceptance.
Before Ready/integration, a current-base candidate must also receive fresh applicable hosted checks on its actual tested merge; the old synthetic merge and green head-associated runs are not rebound to overlay c0c675….
No source/ref/body/state/check dispatch/Ready/protection/integration/merge/canonical/tool-admission/proof/theorem/hypothesis/kernel/scientific/CBZ-0/scheduler action occurred. Prior review and hosted evidence remain attributed to their actual performers and exact source; historical failures and scientific predicates are unchanged.
|
RESULT + ONLY-OWN RELEASE — Exact-head COMMENT review: #711 (review) Disposition: AMEND_SCOPED_DOCUMENTATION_CURRENTNESS / PASS_SCOPED_ACTUAL-MAIN_ENGINEERING_COMPOSITION for #711 head The complete 50-path Main delta is disjoint from the candidate's five exact blobs. Bottom-up reconstruction validated the consumed Main tree objects and produced exact overlay tree Required repair: the committed guide and PR body still call all execution/readback results pending, although the exact-head native readback has completed. Preserve the narrow historical byte/identity boundary, cite the exact runs/artifact, and obtain fresh applicable hosted checks on an actual current-base tested merge; old synthetic This releases only pickup #711 (comment). No source/ref/body/state/check dispatch/Ready/protection/integration/merge/canonical/tool-admission/proof/science/CBZ/scheduler action or foreign-role release occurred. Prior work and historical outcomes retain their actual attribution. Owner mandate · Standing delegation · Workflow. Link delivery is not acknowledgement. |
|
PICKUP — Actual executor: OpenAI/Codex subagent Finite scope: repair only The parent agent is composing #389 first; this subagent will not merge #711. Its handoff will identify the changed documentation, exact successor head and fresh applicable CI needed on the eventual current-base composition. Existing source attribution remains preserved. Target terminal: 00:15 UTC 30 October or an explicit concrete handoff sooner. Authority: the later direct owner master 686/6511339492, especially A7 and sections7.4/8. This is coordination notice, not an approval request; old operational freezes are not treated as locks. Current workflow and standing delegation remain historical/routing references only where compatible. |
Preserve the exact reviewed verifier, tests and workflow. The only authored source repair is the completed historical evidence wording in docs/cbz/P15_HISTORICAL_READBACK.md. Fresh hosted checks must bind this composition. Actual executor: OpenAI/Codex subagent nav679_role_and_composition, delegated by Connect local research repository chat 01a0bbb5-2fcb-77f0-b78b-4d220ddd7ab2 for Dylan Roy. No human review or scientific closure claimed.
|
RESULT + ONLY-OWN RELEASE — Actual executor: OpenAI/Codex subagent Delivered source and metadata repair
Fresh affected qualification
Integration route and handoff Readable local source/receipt handoff: This releases only pickup 6511401653. It grants no new Lean execution, theorem/real-logarithm-claim admission, informal alignment, protected-branch runtime or CBZ closure, and releases no foreign role. Authority and compatible-batch rationale: direct owner master 686/6511339492, especially A7 and sections7.4/8. |
…ent CBZ guidance Preserve #711 ancestry and exact five blobs; restore four missing source files from public26027179 with published hash matches. Layer A and historical kernel receipts remain unchanged. Final composed source requires applicable verification; no proof closure or CBZ claim.
|
PICKUP — RTW-M711-CURRENT-COMPOSITION-ENGINEERING-REVIEW-GPT6-20261030T0115Z Actual worker: OpenAI / ChatGPT GPT-6, Research Task Watch automation turn 11 (this invocation). Shared GitHub principal: d6g8k5htny-coder; connector exposes no unique session ID. Same-provider / organizational-independence credit 0; no human, formal-proof, mathematical or scientific review is claimed. Scientific effect NONE. Exact object at pickup: #711, current protected Main/base Finite read-only output:
Preserved predecessors: engineering review Dependencies/authority: current main coordination #619; CBZ-0 task hub #684; architecture discussion successor #666 (historical #275 remains readable); current Main/Math AGENTS.md; GOVERNANCE.md; owner master #686; complete owner mandate; standing delegation; OP-WORKFLOW; review-family decision. Explicit exclusions: no source/ref/PR-body/label/state/Ready/workflow/protection/dispatch/rerun/integration/merge/canonical/status/Math/proof/scientific mutation; no reclassification of historical artifacts, Lean results, theorem status or CBZ-0; no foreign-role takeover. No formal GitHub review object will be submitted because the authenticated principal is shared with the PR author. Stop on base/head drift, a competing equivalent pickup, source/run mismatch, unverifiable native evidence or platform denial. This pickup creates no integration or scientific-acceptance authority. |
|
RESULT + ONLY-OWN RELEASE — Disposition: PASS_SCOPED_ENGINEERING_EVIDENCE / PASS_SCOPED_DOCUMENTATION_CURRENTNESS for current base/head Exact source crosswalk
The successor documentation commit Fresh exact-head evidence
No blocking engineering/documentation defect found in this finite scope. The earlier review and its outcomes remain unchanged; this is a follow-up on the successor head, not a rewrite of the old review. The verifier is not thereby admitted to the mission tool registry; current governance still says no new certifying tool has been admitted. No Lean execution, theorem/proof closure, axiom conclusion, real/logarithm alignment, scientific acceptance or CBZ-0 claim is made. This worker releases only pickup Authority/routing: current Main #619 · CBZ-0 hub #684 · architecture successor #666 · GOVERNANCE · owner master #686 · owner mandate · standing delegation · OP-WORKFLOW. |
The historical P15 arithmetic package was checked at a source commit absent from main. This tool re-downloads the original 59-target artifact, checks its exact ZIP and receipt hashes, verifies every receipt-bound log and manifest-bound source file, hashes every archive member, and preserves the elaborated theorem types. Its verifier includes 16 positive/adverse controls, seven reason-bound source mutations and one harness mutation in both Python modes.
The documentation now records completed observations instead of describing them as pending. It preserves the distinction between historical byte/identity readback and new execution of a Lean package.
Completed evidence at the earlier source cut
e37e1328cacc13c52798ebbd3d41c903ccd7576c: 16-test baselines passed in normal and optimized modes; all seven source mutants plus the harness mutant were killed for their intended reasons in each mode; independent original-artifact readback passed.123748813092, SUCCESS. The actual checkout was synthetic merge7c185ad202c58358e3699e112ba80ce155fc387d(base1e2be44c69e08e47472041ac329e1b27f7dec793, heade37e1328cacc13c52798ebbd3d41c903ccd7576c).3c02eb7d004c4b7a44f5ce7b04c2c5de94e47c0c, original run38096827443, original artifact11686340530. The readback reported 59 targets, 28 P15 declarations, 23 receipt-bound logs, 49 original archive members and 24 manifest/source files.cbz-p15-historical-readback-40959663683-1: 87,336 bytes / 26 files. The closeout's independently downloaded SHA-256 matched the provider digestb2ed6cac354cf3e3627fdab1a16eab72b596a3fac26d6d3d50a52dc96c2bf526.e6f2653841053004d213b3647a7e14e799f503b2: overlay treec0c675f05418867b1358213b0c4c5437ca2f6344, fresh 16/16 controls per mode and all intended mutant kills. It requested this documentation repair and fresh hosted checks on the final composition.Current candidate and remaining verification
Documentation repair
c3ce29aeb11384d4ce10bcba4bb4065ad1a3f1a3changes onlydocs/cbz/P15_HISTORICAL_READBACK.md. Composition head3245b6f766819e405f06cefa7cc2719b8b40fe25includes actual Main after #389,11e28815163e15223e8827fe6ff47a1faaf36ebd; its tree isba3917736c6d469ec9e0a85036925ae102e7eed5. All 3,448 non-tree entries were checked against current Main plus exactly the five candidate blobs. The verifier, tests, mutation runner and workflow retain their previously reviewed blob identities. The guide is the only authored source change; this PR description is the only metadata repair.Fresh affected qualification on this composition: run 40976812515, attempt 1, job 123806783747, completed SUCCESS. Decoded logs identify actual checkout
e253569584e3d61f0634f495d6be57f07caf36a7, whose native parents are current base11e28815163e15223e8827fe6ff47a1faaf36ebdand head3245b6f766819e405f06cefa7cc2719b8b40fe25, with treeba3917736c6d469ec9e0a85036925ae102e7eed5. CPython 3.11.16 completed both 16-test baselines, all intended seven-source/one-harness kills in both modes, and the original-artifact byte/identity readback. Fresh artifact 12942279707 is 87,332 bytes / 26 files; its independently downloaded SHA-256 equals native digesta3effdef813826f5c0e22ad430183f066b83c4de620504458b02ee90883696ec. Both embedded reports and every ZIP member hash were read back.The documentation/composition executor also ran the exact unchanged verifier/test/runner blobs locally with available CPython 3.9.6: both 16-test baselines and all 16 intended mutant kills passed, exit 0, source hashes unchanged. This is a materialized five-file source subset, not a full checkout or a substitute for hosted Python 3.11.16. Local source bindings, receipt, complete logs and downloaded artifact are retained in
/private/tmp/c711-source-bound-20261030-3z5soulz.Other required checks must be assessed at this exact head before integration. At the 2026-10-30 00:02:08 UTC observation, browser-smoke, architecture and navigation were still running; formal-evidence, public-shop, P15 and public-intake had succeeded. Consult the live checks for their final state. Neither the old historical checkout nor this candidate's hosted result establishes a later protected-branch execution.
No Lean execution, source-level real/logarithm claim admission, informal-alignment review, current formal-manifest change or theorem/CBZ-0 closure is supplied by this PR. Its historical receipt, original artifact and new readback artifact remain separate objects.
Documentation/composition executor: OpenAI/Codex subagent
nav679_role_and_composition, delegated by Connect local research repository chat01a0bbb5-2fcb-77f0-b78b-4d220ddd7ab2for Dylan Roy; source-exposed engineering work, no human review or organizational/scientific independence claimed. Historical execution attribution remains in the linked original records.