Skip to content

Repair bounded G11 active tool attribution - #764

Merged
d6g8k5htny-coder merged 122 commits into
mainfrom
codex/cbz-g11-active-attribution-20261106
Nov 8, 2026
Merged

d6g8k5htny-coder merged 122 commits into
mainfrom
codex/cbz-g11-active-attribution-20261106

Conversation

@d6g8k5htny-coder

@d6g8k5htny-coder d6g8k5htny-coder commented Nov 6, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Scope

Repairs the bounded G11 census' active execution attribution without changing mathematical statements, proof outcomes, bounds, axioms, authorship, failures, or scientific status.

  • base: 299c7fad72f1079b87b2d044b2d30f2098678f29
  • native qualified source: 4e4caefd6455f6a1f684d645eb20d308e59053d5
  • source tree: 0f0a47d015669edb0a92f80b8e2c0140d1e4026e
  • native final head: d962c4e1593cd3b35d655aee9c7a582da6b63ca3
  • final tree: f0c2f81c1ec0d93574a742e2b8bc49e8c34cfd1d

Closed defects

The scanner now recognizes only reachable, provenance-preserving Python and JavaScript process executions. Review repairs cover:

  1. direct interpreter -c/-m payload arguments;

  2. unreachable wrapper bodies;

  3. unrelated same-line JavaScript bindings;

  4. filesystem-root parent traversal;

  5. reachable function-local process imports;

  6. destructured target/value correspondence;

  7. wrapper-parameter rebinding before execution;

  8. function-local/static path-name shadowing;

  9. quoted JavaScript arguments, property positions, and object keys;

  10. interpreter command-mode filtering through wrapper-forwarded arguments;

  11. stale static values after augmented assignment;

  12. property calls masquerading as named child-process imports;

  13. unresolved command elements shifting a later path into executable position;

  14. reversed Boolean or traversal;

  15. lexical callees inheriting same-named module wrappers;

  16. quoted JavaScript call text masquerading as a child-process call;

  17. class methods registering same-named bare module wrappers;

  18. mutually exclusive conditional command alternatives being merged;

  19. JavaScript URL bindings retaining provenance after reassignment;

  20. multi-component pathlib.Path values crediting only the first component;

  21. command element/slice writes retaining a stale aggregate binding;

  22. function parameters impersonating same-named child-process imports;

  23. wrapper element/slice writes retaining caller provenance;

  24. helper-local element writes falling back to stale module bindings;

  25. interpreter mode switches after script selection being treated as interpreter controls;

  26. JavaScript default-initializer references being mistaken for parameter bindings;

  27. interpreter options with operands selecting the operand as the script;

  28. an element write through one alias leaving another alias with stale command provenance;

  29. a function parameter failing to shadow a same-named JavaScript URL binding;

  30. supported list-mutator calls retaining stale direct, alias, or wrapper command provenance;

  31. function-local JavaScript declarations inheriting same-named imported child-process callees;

  32. function-local new URL bindings escaping to outer calls;

  33. mutation through an alias of a wrapper parameter retaining caller provenance;

  34. reassignment of a registered wrapper binding leaving the original wrapper active;

  35. an enclosing-function JavaScript declaration failing to shadow an imported callee in a nested call;

  36. wrapper traversal continuing after unconditional return/raise and accepting an unreachable process call;

  37. deferred caller wrapper availability being judged from the nested call's lexical line instead of the caller's activation point;

  38. a later non-forwarding function definition retaining an earlier same-named wrapper registration;

  39. list augmented assignment splitting static alias identity;

  40. unreachable JavaScript child-process calls in literal-false branches or uncalled named helpers;

  41. a deferred Python caller resolving a module value assigned only after invocation;

  42. JavaScript helper reachability bootstrapping through an uncalled caller;

  43. mutually exclusive cache-guard branch states combining into an impossible path;

  44. a node:test registration inside an uncalled helper making its callback a false execution root; and

  45. a shadowed test registrar inheriting the imported registrar identity;

  46. calls inside mutually exclusive cache-guard alternatives sharing a sequential binding environment; and

  47. nested Python helper effects being deferred until after caller continuation;

  48. a declared Python global assignment being stored only in the helper-local static environment;

  49. command element or slice deletion retaining a stale aggregate and identity aliases; and

  50. a rebound JavaScript helper still contributing reachability from its replaced body.

  51. wrapper element deletion retaining stale forwarding provenance;

  52. a declared Python global remaining in the helper-local static-shadow set; and

  53. a lexically shadowed JavaScript helper call inheriting the module helper's reachability.

  54. Python helper side effects in a call argument occurring after enclosing process attribution;

  55. a reassigned Python helper retaining its original executable body; and

  56. a deferred JavaScript helper validating a module URL binding at definition time instead of activation.

  57. an earlier Python call argument being re-evaluated after a later argument changed its source binding; and

  58. assignment invalidating its target helper before evaluating an RHS helper call.

  59. list/tuple element values being reconstructed after later element effects changed their source bindings; and

  60. a module-level JavaScript lexical-block declaration failing to shadow a same-named imported child-process callee.

  61. captured sequence values being lost through supported list concatenation;

  62. ordinary Python helper expansion continuing after unconditional termination, including a selected literal branch; and

  63. destructured JavaScript lexical-block declarations failing to shadow same-named imported child-process callees.

  64. a named operand in supported concatenation being re-evaluated after a later operand rebound its source name;

  65. selected Python branch traversal continuing after definite termination inside the branch; and

  66. a semicolonless JavaScript lexical declaration failing to shadow a same-named imported child-process callee under ASI;

  67. repeated sequential calls to the same Python helper being suppressed by a shared visited identity;

  68. a declared global reassignment invalidating only the helper-local function identity; and

  69. literal Boolean short-circuiting traversing an unreachable loader operand;

  70. a literal conditional expression traversing its unreachable arm; and

  71. coroutine creation being treated as execution of an async helper body;

  72. async forwarding-wrapper creation being treated as execution;

  73. generator creation being treated as body execution;

  74. comprehension bodies being traversed without established iteration or generator consumption;

  75. chained comparisons evaluating past a proven false prefix; and

  76. a JavaScript const/let URL binding escaping its lexical block;

  77. generator-method object creation/closure being treated as body execution;

  78. eager comprehension targets inheriting same-named outer static bindings; and

  79. forwarding-wrapper discovery traversing unreachable Boolean operands;

  80. forwarding-wrapper discovery traversing an unreachable conditional-expression arm;

  81. declared global/nonlocal wrapper reassignment being indexed in the lexical helper scope or lexical rather than runtime order;

  82. lambda construction traversing its deferred body instead of only evaluating defaults; and

  83. declared nonlocal helper reassignment failing to invalidate the nearest enclosing active helper identity;

  84. forwarding-wrapper discovery registering a call before later keyword-argument effects mutated its command;

  85. forwarding-wrapper discovery traversing beyond a proven-false chained-comparison prefix; and

  86. generic try traversal crediting an unproven exception handler while preserving reachable try/finally execution.

  87. writes in skipped exception branches leaving stale downstream static bindings;

  88. forwarding-wrapper discovery traversing an unproven exception handler;

  89. forwarding-wrapper discovery treating empty comprehensions or unconsumed generators as execution;

  90. a terminating finally failing to terminate its enclosing statement sequence;

  91. a destructured JavaScript lexical declaration failing to shadow an outer URL binding; and

  92. a Python nonlocal static assignment remaining helper-local instead of updating its nearest enclosing binding;

  93. unknown Python branch effects being discarded instead of invalidating downstream provenance;

  94. definite termination in a handler-free try body failing to terminate the enclosing sequence;

  95. a decorated Python helper retaining the pre-decoration executable body;

  96. a non-string executable reaching interpreter-membership logic;

  97. a destructured JavaScript declaration failing to shadow a same-named helper;

  98. composite JavaScript arguments crediting URL provenance from identifiers in unselected operands; and

  99. a shadowed fileURLToPath binding being trusted without an unshadowed node:url import;

  100. exception-boundary possible effects retaining active helper and forwarding-wrapper identities;

  101. exception target names retaining stale static command bindings;

  102. truthy non-iterable literals crediting comprehension bodies;

  103. unsupported, attached command-mode, or exit-only interpreter options selecting later script arguments;

  104. assignment expressions retaining stale static bindings;

  105. nested aggregate writes retaining reachable alias provenance;

  106. decorated forwarding wrappers being registered as their undecorated bodies; and

  107. JavaScript URL names in child-process options positions being credited.

  108. multiline process-call events being resorted by source line instead of evaluation order;

  109. possible loop writes retaining stale direct and wrapper command provenance;

  110. subprocess executable overrides retaining argv execution credit;

  111. class-body bindings leaking into the enclosing namespace;

  112. class runtime shadows being ignored during attribution;

  113. subprocess shell mode or extra positional options retaining ordinary-argv credit;

  114. a shadowed JavaScript URL constructor being trusted as the intrinsic;

  115. rooted URL property mutations retaining stale path provenance;

  116. literal short-circuit expressions activating unreachable JavaScript process calls; and

  117. repeated Python helper invocations reusing local bindings, imports, or nested definitions.

  118. possible effects in skipped Boolean operands retaining stale direct or forwarding provenance;

  119. unknown wrapper branches retaining stale forwarding aliases;

  120. incomplete JavaScript URL initializers retaining unsupported provenance;

  121. unselected JavaScript conditional-expression arms being treated as reachable;

  122. aggregate str(...) conversion retaining argv semantics;

  123. helper calls missing required arguments still expanding their bodies;

  124. nested helper free names falling back to unrelated module bindings;

  125. unknown conditional-expression arms retaining possible direct or wrapper effects;

  126. wrapper invocations receiving forwarding credit when their signatures cannot bind;

  127. assignment expressions leaving imported callable identities stale;

  128. unbraced literal-false JavaScript branches being treated as active;

  129. tuple augmented assignment mutating aliases as though tuples were lists;

  130. concise JavaScript arrow bodies being treated as module execution;

  131. annotation-only assignments invalidating existing import identities;

  132. helper aggregate arguments losing positional, keyword, default, *args or **kwargs object identity;

  133. unittest setup effects being applied after the test or only once;

  134. quoted JavaScript URL declarations being treated as executable bindings; and

  135. mutable JavaScript URL-object aliases retaining stale path provenance after escape.

  136. executable assignment-target subexpressions being skipped before rebinding;

  137. unresolved chained-comparison suffixes retaining possible stale mutations;

  138. unresolved eager-comprehension bodies or guards retaining possible stale mutations;

  139. uninvoked JavaScript class/object method bodies being treated as module execution; and

  140. literal-true JavaScript conditions treating dead else arms as reachable;

  141. helper-mediated writes inside unresolved Python branches retaining stale downstream provenance;

  142. quoted JavaScript child-process import text being trusted as an executable import; and

  143. unreachable JavaScript URL initializers registering provenance for function-scoped var bindings.; and

  144. helper aggregate mutation through a bound parameter inside an unresolved branch retaining caller provenance, while simple local parameter rebinding remains local.;

  145. a selected enclosing JavaScript branch stopping before a nested dead branch is checked;

  146. unproven while/classic-for loop bodies receiving module-root activation; and

  147. process calls after direct unconditional return or throw in an invoked helper being activated;

  148. an augmented-assignment target being reloaded only after RHS helper effects rebound its name; and

  149. an uninvoked JavaScript helper's parameter default initializer being treated as module execution.

  150. a possible Python branch rebind retaining trusted function-local import identity;

  151. a direct JavaScript loop break or continue leaving its unreachable tail active; and

  152. an unselected JavaScript switch case receiving module-root activation.

  153. a supplied JavaScript argument still activating its parameter default initializer;

  154. nested parentheses preventing deferred arrow/method parameter-scope discovery;

  155. an unproven JavaScript catch handler receiving module-root activation;

  156. Python helper identity being resolved after argument side effects;

  157. a skipped nullish-coalescing right operand receiving process-call activation;

  158. a JavaScript regular-expression literal being searched as executable call text; and

  159. direct termination in a completed standalone block failing to stop later helper activation.\n160. function declarations under unresolved Python branches dropping decorator/default/keyword-default definition-time effects;\n161. aggregate mutation through a helper-local alias of a bound formal failing to invalidate caller provenance; and\n162. optional JavaScript call arguments being activated without proof that the optional call executes;

  160. chained-assignment target stores being delayed until after later target effects;

  161. lambda default effects under unresolved Python branches being ignored;

  162. optional named-property calls or computed accesses activating subexpressions without proven evaluation;

  163. unconstructed JavaScript instance-field initializers being treated as module execution; and

  164. regular-expression literals after control headers being searched as executable call text.

  165. unresolved-branch class construction dropping decorator, base, keyword or body mutation effects while method bodies remain deferred;

  166. helper definition-time parameter mutation failing to invalidate the bound caller argument;

  167. continuous optional JavaScript named-property chains bypassing optional-chain suppression;

  168. computed-name JavaScript instance-field initializers being treated as module execution;

  169. optional-chain suppression ending before later computed accesses or intermediate calls;

  170. computed-name JavaScript method bodies being treated as module execution; and

  171. semicolonless instance-field boundaries activating a later deferred initializer.

  172. class-construction mutation through a helper-bound parameter retaining stale caller provenance;

  173. child-process calls after an unsupported JavaScript await receiving downstream activation; and

  174. nested computed JavaScript method names being left unbalanced so deferred bodies fall through as module execution.

  175. stores inside one destructuring target being delayed until all target effects completed;

  176. quoted JavaScript class/object method bodies being treated as module execution;

  177. nested computed JavaScript instance-field names being left unbalanced so deferred initializers fall through as module execution;

  178. destructured leaf values being recomputed after intermediate target effects instead of snapshotted before stores; and

  179. executable computed assignments inside class static blocks being suppressed as deferred instance fields.

  180. nested Python destructuring freezing inner leaves before the nested target is reached;

  181. quoted or numeric JavaScript instance-field initializers being treated as class-definition execution; and

  182. direct unconditional termination inside an executable class static block failing to suppress its unreachable tail;

  183. exponent, leading-decimal, or numeric-separator JavaScript instance-field names being treated as class-definition execution; and

  184. a direct static-block throw suppressing evaluation of its operand along with the unreachable tail.

  185. mutation through an omitted mutable-default helper parameter failing to invalidate its captured caller aggregate;

  186. parameter aliases assigned inside nested helper statements losing their originating formal;

  187. numeric-name JavaScript class/object method bodies being treated as module execution; and

  188. an instance field literally named static being treated as a class static member.

  189. mutation through a captured mutable default being redirected to a later rebound default-expression name instead of the definition-time object and its surviving aliases; and

  190. competing helper-alias assignments in an untaken or unresolved branch overwriting the actual or possible formal origins.

  191. an already-executed helper-alias mutation losing its formal origin after a later local rebinding; and

  192. mutation through a nested aggregate in a captured mutable default leaving a surviving external child alias trusted;

  193. helper-induced mutation after alias rebinding losing one of the mutation-time or final formal origins; and

  194. value-bearing annotated assignment aliases failing to preserve their helper-parameter origin.

  195. a nested-helper mutation before later alias rebinding losing the caller origins active at the exact call site;

  196. a brace-containing JavaScript class heritage expression being mistaken for the class body; and

  197. recursive helper-graph collector re-entry causing RecursionError instead of terminating with bounded possible effects.

The preceding helper-parameter aggregate-mutation defect was reported again by exact-head review; both records are preserved, but that duplicate is not recounted.

Each review-supplied counterexample was reproduced red in both modes before repair. The two independent audit regressions were also reproduced red before repair and now have dedicated adverse mutants that recreate their failures in both modes. Dedicated controls and designated mutants preserve the fail-closed boundary.

The sound position-preserving repair initially exposed eight additional unproven paths. Explicit controls then admitted only resolved starred elements, a statically proven tool prefix with dynamic suffixes, unittest lifecycle methods, and trusted loader-wrapper forwarding. Recursive JavaScript reachability truthfully exposed tools/museum_conditionals.mjs; callbacks are admitted only through a reachable, unshadowed local node:test import. Intermediate observations remain historical diagnostics, not passing evidence.

Actual verification

On native source 4e4caefd6455f6a1f684d645eb20d308e59053d5 (parent 3f3dc9166a79b7d0bb7ec97b6422621a7da90f85, tree 0f0a47d015669edb0a92f80b8e2c0140d1e4026e), reconstructed from that exact hosted Git commit after transient scratch loss:

  • unit controls: 249/249 PASS in normal and optimized modes;
  • designated mutations: 314/314 killed in normal and optimized modes with zero skips;
  • mutation inventory SHA-256: 4d98c77db9bfa666cecb0bb967dc9ea5fb5f0f2b56be543684efbcd6d60174a4;
  • normal/optimized mutation receipts are byte-identical, 194,963 bytes, SHA-256 c3d778617ba328841033104cefacdf0b4fb2b4e4f414c3ec22ea1a00ade9e8e5;
  • whole-tree census: zero production findings, exactly 32 retained no-current-exercise or documentation tool candidates, 1,365 files, and 93 tools;
  • native source normal/optimized reports are byte-identical, 56,059 bytes, SHA-256 88760e3878bce1cb2e1dfd9bad7c7deade0d8a8b33b195e1643232eb4a882007;
  • both census commands exit 1, truthfully retaining G11 FAIL.

The first native implementation 3f3dc9166a79b7d0bb7ec97b6422621a7da90f85 actually failed both whole-tree censuses with RecursionError and receives no qualification credit. The replacement uses a signature-checked per-call mutation map and has a recursive-helper termination control. Its stronger exact call-site capture makes the older defect-196 union mutant behaviorally equivalent; that mutant is explicitly retired while the historical RED control remains.

On native final head d962c4e1593cd3b35d655aee9c7a582da6b63ca3 (tree f0c2f81c1ec0d93574a742e2b8bc49e8c34cfd1d):

  • fresh unit controls: 249/249 PASS in normal and optimized modes;
  • fresh designated mutations: 314/314 killed in normal and optimized modes with zero skips;
  • fresh final-head mutation receipts are byte-identical, 194,963 bytes, SHA-256 c3d778617ba328841033104cefacdf0b4fb2b4e4f414c3ec22ea1a00ade9e8e5;
  • fresh final-head censuses are byte-identical, 56,059 bytes, SHA-256 a6382c855e201dfe5d81c85d46f254464441d6c1bdd86a6820c83132f964964e, contain zero production findings, retain exactly 32 candidates, and exit 1;
  • G11 therefore remains truthfully FAIL.

Boundary

This PR closes the 20 original active-attribution gaps and the 200 distinct review/adverse defects above only. It does not qualify the 32 retained tool candidates, provide the missing common final G0–G11 orchestrator, close CBZ-0, or rebind any historical evidence.

Defects 201–206 and final hosted qualification

Fresh exact-head review findings 201–203 and adjacent independent-audit defects 204–206 are repaired:

  • outer JavaScript class-body discovery skips nested braced class/function expressions in heritage;
  • ordinary and annotated Python assignment RHS effects are visited before formal-alias rebinding;
  • multiline computed JavaScript names use balanced delimiter discovery;
  • malformed or unbalanced class structures fail closed;
  • valid private names such as #class and #function remain executable; and
  • import/export specifier reserved words do not impersonate expression-keyword reachability.

Assignment-order mutants retain RHS traversal and change only ordering. Earlier 319/320-case harness attempts did not meet that exact contract and receive no credit.

Exact hosted source 8038863c04cc96acfcfc0d2953ab8575ccce213e has tree de8e2c664116803643cfda2f324756e7716c57af and parent d962c4e1593cd3b35d655aee9c7a582da6b63ca3. Local exact-tree qualification at 1616b31889a8b242ff6950dbd7af4d437e54648c observed:

  • 256/256 controls PASS in normal and optimized modes;
  • 321/321 mutations killed, zero skips, in both modes;
  • byte-identical mutation receipts, 199,677 bytes, SHA-256 367a13fed18c0880fcc73590ffb1f615bb48ba1baf76ecc621f427637f31f687;
  • sealed inventory SHA-256 d7021d5cc7e464c423335c7b56b67b5ef1844c09865683d728a998e1661a5652; and
  • byte-identical source-tree censuses, 56,059 bytes, SHA-256 bcd9605e448a4e3d121f8e9a03733190f376367e5c2ab690b17a90675605ef8f, with zero production failures, 32 retained candidates, and expected exit 1.

Exact hosted final head f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501 has tree 42fe1c0d231535133fc93921f5121c7bf2c275ac and parent 8038863c04cc96acfcfc0d2953ab8575ccce213e. Fresh final-tree unit and mutation runs reproduce the same 256/321 results and mutation SHA. After reconstructing the exact hosted Git objects locally, normal and optimized censuses run directly against f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501 were byte-identical, 56,059 bytes, SHA-256 5b3b9f9ddc202b63e743f028ef7c86461bc4c3e1a151ed14654a70995bebab35; they contain zero production failures, retain 32 candidates across 1,365 files and 93 tools, skip nothing, and correctly exit 1.

The bounded repair now closes 206 distinct review/adverse defects. G11 remains truthfully FAIL. The 32 retained candidates, missing common final orchestrator, federation gate matrix, pin refresh, and CBZ-0 remain outside this PR's closure.

Superseding exact-head closure — findings 201–203

Hosted head 8b84aef751dc61d89567fdf5cc2d0fdce2a2b2b0 (parent f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501) has exact tree a57c943af8643ca9fddb8a3e4632cf6c27d8022e. This supersedes earlier head/count receipts without rebinding their historical outcomes.

Closed exact-head review defects:

  1. helper destructuring now propagates formal origins through exact positional tuple/list unpacking and conservatively clears unsupported shapes;
  2. JavaScript import/export specifier recognition accepts a default import followed by named specifiers; and
  3. deferred instance-field recognition accepts Unicode identifier starts and JavaScript Unicode escapes.

Fresh tree-bound execution on the byte-identical local tree: 259/259 focused controls pass in normal and optimized modes with zero skips; the sealed inventory SHA-256 is cbea8a86d2ddd35357e19e38f79d83dadd014da45a3f287f4190960b4dd5c02d; 324/324 designated mutants are killed in each mode, with every child attributed to its selected AssertionError.

Fresh hosted-SHA censuses at 8b84aef751dc61d89567fdf5cc2d0fdce2a2b2b0 return the expected status 1 in both modes and are byte-identical, SHA-256 856dc8de6509411171eefee9fe66d7d7236bd01ed264c0982392b973878532f0: 1,366 files / 5,484 tracked entries / 93 tools / 145 scoped findings / zero production failures / 32 retained unexercised-or-undocumented tool candidates / zero skips.

Scope remains G11 only. This does not establish CBZ-0, close the retained 32 maintenance candidates, or change any mathematical statement, bound, axiom, proof outcome, authorship, failure, or scientific status.

@chatgpt-codex-connector

chatgpt-codex-connector Bot commented Nov 6, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Codex Review Summary: ✅ Completed

This comment shows the latest Codex review activity on this pull request.

Review Status Commit Review trigger
📝 Code Review ✅ Completed 2026-11-07T18:47:50.254017Z f715b2d Manual request
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review" or "@codex security review".

Codex reacts with 👀 while any review is running, comments if it has suggestions, and reacts with 👍 once all reviews finish with no findings.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: 25d0bc09c7

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

@codex review

Please review the current exact native head 12f1737d5b783597116f8c9a65b065b8cfb6d350. The preceding review's six findings are repaired with adverse controls and designated mutants; all prior threads are resolved.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: 12f1737d5b

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

@codex review

Please review the current exact head 487e55d377d6992cf59b74b77cc1e5bddb04bbc0 after the three latest provenance repairs. Earlier-head findings and outcomes remain preserved in the thread; assess only the current diff against base 299c7fad72f1079b87b2d044b2d30f2098678f29.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: 487e55d377

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

@codex review

Please review the current exact head 4ba83a2051e18fb05babbccbaca6a8d33bf4b33b after the three latest provenance repairs. Earlier-head findings and outcomes remain preserved in the thread; assess only the current diff against base 299c7fad72f1079b87b2d044b2d30f2098678f29.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: 4ba83a2051

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

@codex review

Please review the current exact head 03d8782b4f3bd2e7a64e96d0b1297abcb9a9ebee after the four latest provenance repairs and the sound recovery of eight explicitly executed tool paths. Earlier-head findings, intermediate red censuses, and outcomes remain preserved; assess only the current diff against base 299c7fad72f1079b87b2d044b2d30f2098678f29.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: 03d8782b4f

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

@codex review

Please review exact final head 81541510b5f278cdf8771b337eb47c3418352401 after the three repaired P2 findings and documentation-only qualification commit. Source under review is native parent a104a29af571b760738c50ebfc5b07ad7a1b6d98 (tree 157ae0ce007c182883b2bfb0a796ba0e3c967c67); the final tree is a8b701863e9ba139f55d5425ac7f52b3b1e8f4f0. All earlier findings, red controls, and historical 28-tool results remain preserved; assess only the current diff against base 299c7fad72f1079b87b2d044b2d30f2098678f29.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: 81541510b5

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Durable checkpoint v88 published for the exact G11 defects 194–195 qualification.

  • hosted source: b8d5472271d16aeb4fca4e4ed62e1984f51cb9c8, tree 6b501bc7cd2dbf92da864ef6b24a34835ad85c12
  • hosted final: 82a29b2c66845fe39be3bea825fc520aeccf84bc, tree 495b454c1a60015b7728272236acde7067b58508
  • status: 375,744 bytes, SHA-256 c3b37d1e864e95b4e48040dd59722c17714e1795d60bb3014f9e6ede0249ebb5
  • evidence: 24,445,797 bytes, SHA-256 4220854c9e98f5994254cbb8d838aa0c1cca6b5ab5c7897f9b1da264c30f4846
  • ZIP: 11,560 unique entries, zero duplicates, all 11,521 v87 entry paths retained, embedded status byte-matches, 31/31 internal evidence sums and unzip -t clean
  • durable identities preserved at version 88
  • exact final qualification: 244/244 controls and 311/311 sealed mutants in both modes, zero skips; exact hosted-final censuses retain 32 candidates and G11 FAIL

Review threads PRRT_kwDOQpeC2s604F00 and PRRT_kwDOQpeC2s604F03 are answered and resolved. Fresh exact-head review was requested in comment 6709753657; a pending review result receives no clear credit. At the v88 observation, three hosted workflows were successful while research navigation and workspace-landing remained in progress and received no passing credit. No CBZ-0 or terminal Partial is claimed, and Main default was not written.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

@codex review

Please review exact head 24fe2a09c03a6eaab6a5c049ec854bbe414d7f01 after the adverse-tested repairs for findings 196–197. Both modes pass 246/246 controls and kill 313/313 sealed mutants with zero skips. The exact final censuses remain truthfully G11 FAIL on 32 retained candidates.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: 24fe2a09c0

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Durable contribution checkpoint v89 is published in place for exact final head 24fe2a09c03a6eaab6a5c049ec854bbe414d7f01.

  • status: 380,114 bytes; SHA-256 359de7156b7a794db43311a6dac92d1f22b26f619c88a0c45271586d54d16d5c; Library version 89
  • evidence ZIP: 24,721,696 bytes; SHA-256 98425641aa86847c64978a570735f409470e39a91822384b4bfe528bf75e825a; Library version 89
  • 11,599 unique ZIP members; zero duplicates; all 11,560 v88 member paths retained
  • new evidence manifest: 32 files; SHA-256 ccdb4798ff6652bcce797f30e129059c049377e45c16c4f3328f399991632836

This is bounded G11 criterion-9 component evidence only. G11 remains FAIL with 32 retained candidates; no CBZ-0, no terminal Partial Baseline, no default-ref write, and no broader mathematical/scientific claim.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

@codex review

Please review exact head d962c4e1593cd3b35d655aee9c7a582da6b63ca3 (tree f0c2f81c1ec0d93574a742e2b8bc49e8c34cfd1d), including the repairs for review findings 198–199 and the bounded-recursion repair for the failed intermediate implementation (defect 200).

Fresh exact-head receipts:

  • controls: 249/249 PASS in normal and optimized modes;
  • adverse mutations: 314/314 killed in both modes, zero skips, byte-identical SHA-256 c3d778617ba328841033104cefacdf0b4fb2b4e4f414c3ec22ea1a00ade9e8e5;
  • whole-tree censuses: byte-identical SHA-256 a6382c855e201dfe5d81c85d46f254464441d6c1bdd86a6820c83132f964964e, exit 1, status FAIL, zero production findings, 32 retained candidates, zero skips.

The failed 3f3dc916… RecursionError outcome is preserved and receives no qualification credit. G11 remains FAIL; no CBZ-0 claim is made.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: d962c4e159

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Durable contribution checkpoint updated in place to version 90.

  • status: libfile_9551d0182bcc819188edfe9f998165b3, version 90, 384,899 bytes, SHA-256 f50105ba7c23e8b810f8d2efc0c19fb673425561a93f30e4a8543a65c81179f9
  • evidence: libfile_1f9ec8ce62708191972f9e2bf6295816, version 90, 25,039,175 bytes, SHA-256 4a39f5d1869f1a05a97f1e030d44c46c967f2583c6d759f362eb59af6ff86de7
  • ZIP: 11,651 unique members, zero duplicates; every one of v89's 11,599 member paths retained
  • new evidence: RED reproductions for findings 198–199, uncredited 3f3dc916… RecursionError censuses, qualified source 4e4caefd…, exact final head d962c4e…, 249-control/314-mutation receipts, canonical surfaces, and hosted observations

The checkpoint remains active and incomplete. G11 remains FAIL with 32 retained candidates. No CBZ-0 or terminal Partial Baseline is claimed; Main default was not written. Fresh exact-head review remains pending.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

G11 defects 201–206 are repaired and freshly qualified at exact hosted final head f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501.

Three review findings were closed at source 8038863c04cc96acfcfc0d2953ab8575ccce213e: assignment RHS effects now precede alias rebinding, unparenthesized nested class/function heritage bodies are skipped, and multiline computed names are balanced. Independent adjacent audit added fail-closed malformed-class handling, positive private #class/#function reachability, and import/export specifier exclusion. The original review threads have exact replies and are resolved.

Fresh final qualification:

  • 256/256 unit controls PASS in normal and optimized modes;
  • 321/321 designated mutants killed in both modes, zero skips;
  • byte-identical mutation receipts: 199,677 bytes, SHA-256 367a13fed18c0880fcc73590ffb1f615bb48ba1baf76ecc621f427637f31f687;
  • hosted-SHA normal/optimized censuses: byte-identical 56,059 bytes, SHA-256 5b3b9f9ddc202b63e743f028ef7c86461bc4c3e1a151ed14654a70995bebab35;
  • census result: zero production failures, 32 retained candidates, 1,365 files, 93 tools, zero skips, expected exit 1.

G11 remains truthfully FAIL. No proof, theorem, axiom, mathematical bound, kernel outcome, authorship, prior failure, or scientific status is changed or rebound.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

@codex review

Please review exact head f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501, including the source repairs for defects 201–206 and their adverse controls/mutants. Treat G11’s retained 32-candidate FAIL as an intentional truthful boundary, not a requested green result.

@chatgpt-codex-connector chatgpt-codex-connector Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

💡 Codex Review

Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.

Reviewed commit: f715b2d7d9

ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub

Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you

  • Open a pull request for review
  • Mark a draft as ready
  • Comment "@codex review".

If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.

Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".

Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved
Comment thread tools/cbz/g11_census.py Resolved

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Exact-head CI completion: all five pull-request workflows at f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501 are now completed successfully. Runs: federation drift 42402012534, public-shop 42402012375, G11 component self-tests 42402012250, research navigation/public source checks 42402012502, and workspace landing 42402012256. Workspace landing’s formal and architecture jobs both completed successfully. This hosted CI evidence does not change the truthful G11 FAIL boundary or establish CBZ-0.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Exact-head review receipt is now present for f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501: review PRR_kwDOQpeC2s8AAAABWpCvIg, submitted 2026-11-07 18:47:42 UTC. The review introduced no unresolved thread; the PR currently has zero unresolved review threads. Together with all five successful exact-head workflows, this completes the bounded #764 review/CI closure evidence. G11 remains FAIL on the 32 retained candidates, and CBZ-0 remains unestablished.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Durable contribution checkpoint v92 is published in place for exact head f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501.

  • status: libfile_9551d0182bcc819188edfe9f998165b3, version 92, 391,966 bytes, SHA-256 e673de6f29356159f74165abd0c2204760729c5eb2942fd0207ef0a67e148e0b
  • evidence: libfile_1f9ec8ce62708191972f9e2bf6295816, version 92, 25,283,443 bytes, SHA-256 43dd6a4eec7303e2696c9a4e47f7a604f05782108b717b879582426073842305
  • ZIP: 11,682 unique members, zero duplicates; every one of v91's 11,677 paths and bytes retained; unzip -t clean
  • later hosted closure preserved separately: all five exact-head workflows successful; review PRR_kwDOQpeC2s8AAAABWpCvIg submitted at 2026-11-07 18:47:42 UTC; zero unresolved review threads

This closes only bounded #764 CI/review evidence. G11 remains truthfully FAIL on 32 retained candidates. CBZ-0 and terminal Partial remain unestablished, the continuation remains enabled, and Main default was not written.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

CBZ checkpoint correction (v93; supersedes the review-thread portion of v92 comment 6711646371 / receipt comment 6711564441):

Native GitHub enumeration at exact head f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501 returns 201 review threads / 3 unresolved, not zero. All three were created by exact-head review PRR_kwDOQpeC2s8AAAABWpCvIg at 2026-11-07T18:47:42Z:

  • PRRT_kwDOQpeC2s605s1e — tools/cbz/g11_census.py:1221 — helper-destructuring origin propagation.
  • PRRT_kwDOQpeC2s605s1g — tools/cbz/g11_census.py:3699 — named specifiers after a default import.
  • PRRT_kwDOQpeC2s605s1j — tools/cbz/g11_census.py:3915 — Unicode/escaped identifier field handling.

The five exact-head workflow successes and earlier 256/256 control + 321/321 designated-mutant results per mode remain historical observations, but they do not cover these newly reported cases. No G11 closure or integration credit is awarded until repair and fresh adverse qualification. G11 also remains FAIL on the 32 retained candidates.

Durable checkpoint files are now version 93. This correction made no branch/default-ref write, resolved no thread, reran no workflow, and merged nothing. CBZ-0 is not established; no terminal Partial Baseline is declared.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Exact-head repair for the three remaining native threads is hosted at 8b84aef751dc61d89567fdf5cc2d0fdce2a2b2b0 (parent f715b2d7d94f651d7c0612ef3981a3ff4cb80501, tree a57c943af8643ca9fddb8a3e4632cf6c27d8022e). The hosted tree is byte-identical to the freshly qualified local tree.

Actual evidence:

  • focused controls: 259/259 PASS, normal and optimized, zero skips;
  • sealed adverse inventory: SHA-256 cbea8a86d2ddd35357e19e38f79d83dadd014da45a3f287f4190960b4dd5c02d;
  • mutations: 324/324 selected kills in each mode, every child attributed to its authorized AssertionError;
  • hosted-SHA census: exit 1 in both modes, byte-identical JSON SHA-256 856dc8de6509411171eefee9fe66d7d7236bd01ed264c0982392b973878532f0; 1,366 files, 5,484 tracked entries, 93 tools, 145 scoped findings, zero production failures, 32 retained maintenance candidates, zero skips.

The fixes are limited to helper destructuring formal-origin propagation, default-plus-named import specifiers, and Unicode/escaped instance-field identifiers. No mathematical statement, bound, axiom, proof result, authorship, historical failure, or scientific status changed. CBZ-0 is not claimed. I am reading hosted CI and review state before resolving the three threads.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Durable CBZ contribution checkpoint v94 published

The existing durable checkpoint IDs now each have version 94:

  • status libfile_9551d0182bcc819188edfe9f998165b3: 399,411 bytes, SHA-256 f529888ae39b5e068cbb2b70ce450bd50e0142b6d38a541619bf07b0fdba9dba
  • evidence libfile_1f9ec8ce62708191972f9e2bf6295816: 25,579,569 bytes, SHA-256 3c192b2114c12cfca44e7d9dc6f4f034c6c451f1d1eda5fe6b6d09fb68b8f357, 11,705 unique members, zero duplicate paths, clean unzip -t

A fresh extracted-tree comparison proves all 11,690 v93 member paths and every v93 file byte are retained; the only additions are CHECKPOINT_V94_MANIFEST.json, checkpoint_v94_status/, and main_pr764_g11_201_203_20261107/.

Exact #764 head 8b84aef751dc61d89567fdf5cc2d0fdce2a2b2b0 / tree a57c943af8643ca9fddb8a3e4632cf6c27d8022e now has all five exact-head workflows successful. Fresh GraphQL enumeration returned 201 review threads and zero unresolved; repaired threads PRRT_kwDOQpeC2s605s1e, PRRT_kwDOQpeC2s605s1g, and PRRT_kwDOQpeC2s605s1j are resolved with their repair receipts.

The bounded qualification remains 259/259 controls PASS and 324/324 designated mutants killed in each mode. The hosted-SHA census remains byte-identical across modes and exits 1 with 32 retained maintenance candidates, so G11 truthfully remains FAIL. #764 remains open/unmerged; Main default was not written. Main #765 and Math #558 also remain open. CBZ-0 and terminal Partial remain false.

@d6g8k5htny-coder
d6g8k5htny-coder merged commit 0fd3c37 into main Nov 8, 2026
13 checks passed
@d6g8k5htny-coder
d6g8k5htny-coder deleted the codex/cbz-g11-active-attribution-20261106 branch November 8, 2026 04:15

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

CoS HOLD — do not merge (04:16Z). GROK-H01 claimed INTEGRATE-764 on #738 (6717118448). Non-author engineering review REVIEW-764-ENG is still open (results prepared, not yet posted; current drafts recommend FAIL/HOLD). Live tip is 299c7fad, head 8b84aef7. Merge stays held until that review posts and closes. Details on #738. credit 0 · OBL OPEN

@d6g8k5htny-coder d6g8k5htny-coder left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

REVIEW-764-ENG RESULT — FAIL / HOLD (post-merge, exact head 8b84aef751dc61d89567fdf5cc2d0fdce2a2b2b0)

This closes the previously unposted engineering disposition; it does not rebind the historical green outcomes.

Blocking A8 finding: unsupported alias shapes do not fail closed

At the immutable merged head, each fixture below executes an admitted unknown-branch helper that mutates the exact command list before subprocess.run(command). The census nevertheless returns referenced: true, status: PASS, and no failing finding for tools/unused.py:

  1. Helper-return alias
    def identity(x): return x
    def replace(argv):
        alias = identity(argv)
        alias[:] = ['echo']
  2. Attribute/nested-object alias
    box.value = command
    def replace(argv):
        argv.value[:] = ['echo']
  3. Container/subscript alias
    def replace(argv):
        holder = [argv]
        alias = holder[0]
        alias[:] = ['echo']

Each is called under the same established possible-effect form used by the existing controls:

flag = True
if flag:
    replace(command)          # box for case 2
subprocess.run(command, check=True)

Observed fresh exact-head result in normal mode: all three cases printed True [] (tool credited; empty failing list). This contradicts the documented boundary that unsupported dynamic-language forms fail closed, and for the nested cases also contradicts the registered recursive nested-aggregate/alias invalidation scope.

Existing-suite readback

Fresh at the same head:

  • normal unit: 259/259 PASS, zero skips/errors;
  • optimized unit: 259/259 PASS, zero skips/errors;
  • normal designated mutations: 324/324 killed, 324 executed;
  • an optimized mutation replay was started but the execution environment disconnected before its result was recovered, so this review gives it no fresh credit. Historical exact-head optimized evidence remains historical.

Therefore the green suite does not cover these false acceptances. This is an A8 coverage/soundness defect, not a refutation of the 259/324 outcomes themselves and not a change to mathematical statements, proofs, authorship, or kernel results.

Disposition

HOLD / revert-or-repair required. Do not advance Workspace's Main pin to 0fd3c37b… as a qualified G11 tooling state. A repair must first add RED adverse controls for all three shapes (both modes), make unsupported provenance fail closed without manufacturing references, add designated mutations, rerun the exact unit/mutation/census matrix, and obtain a fresh non-author readback. G11 and CBZ-0 remain FAIL/open.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant