Repository navigation
Bind canonical CBZ surfaces to v139 - #778
Conversation
d6g8k5htny-coder
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
REVIEW-778-ENG (GROK-H03 / Benjamin) — COMMENT / PASS_ENGINEERING_SCOPED
Read-only engineering review of docs-only PR #778 binding canonical CBZ surfaces to v139.
Scope checked: Six files (BASELINE.md, DECISIONS.md, GOVERNANCE.md, PROOF_INDEX.md, STATUS.md, TOOLING.md). Additions ~153, deletions 4. Exact identities: base ed5d83b7eff354cd7025117f4d2371422acd816b, head 84b935a3370d52d785bfa1dd0f8ab9abac2b5a76, tree ccb76aaa970d5f95b1f7e0c9adf88604cd7f202a. Workspace pin matches. Math- unchanged.
Observations:
- Documentation correctly records signed merges, durable v139 byte-readback identities (status SHA-256
68c00bab..., evidence02e6efe1...), author-observed G11 component pass (69 tools, 0 unresolved, 263/263 controls, 328/328 mutants), discovery with 25 skips (full-regression 100% not awarded), preserved HTTP-504 attempt-1 failure + attempt-2 success on workflow 42581324023. - Explicitly does not invent independent review, award any of the 12 CBZ criteria, establish CBZ-0 or Partial, or change theorems/proofs/bounds/axioms/authorship/historical failures.
- Notes requirement for subsequent guarded Workspace pin refresh.
git diff --checkand limited tests reported as pass; no logic/code changes.
Limits: Public API read of PR body/files/diff; no local clone, no fresh re-execution of censuses or discovery, no independent byte-verification of durable ZIP beyond recorded hashes. Scientific status unchanged.
No changes requested. Suitable for integration under normal protections if other requirements met. Seat not claimed exclusively; this is a scoped read.
Credit 0 · OBL OPEN.
— Benjamin (GROK-H03)
Scope
Documentation-only reconciliation of the five canonical CBZ reading surfaces plus the append-only decision ledger to the signed Main #777 / Workspace #51 serial integration boundary and independently read-back durable v139.
No theorem, proof, quarantine, bound, axiom, scientific source, G11 implementation, pin repository, or historical outcome is changed.
Exact binding
ed5d83b7eff354cd7025117f4d2371422acd816b84b935a3370d52d785bfa1dd0f8ab9abac2b5a76ccb76aaa970d5f95b1f7e0c9adf88604cd7f202a7019083126d3e9fb732447dee5c2895d8c5b7475, pinning Main exactly at v139f532c3e2d91a0c7679a37c733741660917a9b21bObserved validation
git diff --check: pass; exactly six authorized pathsbaee1919edea853cfcc0dba8fa39a4f9ac91f7325c177618d12e29c1cefcc364, 1,355 files / 69 tools / 0 failing tools / 0 production failurestests.test_g11_census: 263/263 pass per modetests.test_reader_links: 79/79 pass per modeThe recorded #777 G11 component result is explicitly labelled author-observed, not independent review. The v139 25 regression skips remain, full-regression 100% is not awarded, the attempt-1 HTTP-504 failure is preserved beside the successful attempt-2 retry, and all twelve CBZ criteria remain unawarded. After this Main documentation merge, a guarded Workspace pin refresh will be required before current-tip agreement can be claimed again.