You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Load the whole agentic-engineering plugin on kagent's Claude harness (kagent#3388) #4868
kagent's Claude harness loads only the selected skills of a plugin that has both a root plugin.json and a .claude-plugin/plugin.json. It drops that plugin's agents, hooks, commands and .mcp.json servers (kagent-dev/kagent#3388). The agentic-engineering plugin ships both manifests, so the lane would run without its role definition: a partial brain, which the one-brain requirement forbids.
Until a release carries it, the lane runs only on a reviewed workaround that loads the full plugin at the reviewed gitlink, never on a hand-copied role.
Verified: on the harness, the plugin's agentic-engineer agent and its skills are both available in a test session.
kagent's Claude harness reads a plugin's root plugin.json whenever one exists. The agentic-engineering plugin ships one for Copilot CLI and VS Code, without the Agent Plugins $schema, so kagent currently refuses the plugin outright: no skills load, not only the agents.
Even with a valid Agent Plugins root manifest, the harness would copy only the selected skills (at most 50, and the plugin has 87) and drop the four agents.
In-portfolio alternatives fall short. Deleting the root manifest breaks the Copilot CLI and VS Code consumers. A second, Claude-only copy of the plugin would split the one brain. Both would need upkeep for as long as the harness ignores the Claude manifest.
I ran Claude Code 2.1.317 locally with the harness's exact flags and the plugin at main passed with --plugin-dir. All 4 agents, all 87 skills and the subagent tool loaded. The 12 MCP servers did not start, because the harness passes --strict-mcp-config. That gap is the first item of kagent-dev/kagent#3388 and stays separate.
Upstream PR: kagent-dev/kagent#3570. It covers the second item of kagent-dev/kagent#3388. Its main CI waits for a kagent maintainer to approve workflow runs from a first-time contributor.
The third acceptance criterion, a test session on the harness that shows the agent and its skills, still needs a kagent release that carries the fix, or the reviewed workaround in the second criterion.
Evidence for the third acceptance criterion, from the kagent lane's 2026-11-13 scheduled run on the harness:
The plugin's agents were available in the session: the run dispatched agentic-engineering:portfolio-surveyor as a subagent, and it completed. agentic-engineering:agentic-engineer, agent-improver and flux-troubleshooter were listed too.
The plugin's skills were available: the run loaded agentic-engineering:portfolio-maintenance through the Skill tool.
The install at /opt/agent-plugins/agentic-engineering matches the reviewed gitlink. plugin-definition-currency.sh --runtime claude --installed /opt/agent-plugins/agentic-engineering exits 0 (CURRENT, 302 pinned files match), and a direct diff -r of agents/ and skills/ against agent-plugins at the pinned commit finds no difference.
This run did not check the first two criteria (the upstream fix and the reviewed status of the workaround).
New evidence from the kagent lane's 2026-11-14 run, on the second criterion ("loads the full plugin at the reviewed gitlink"):
plugin-definition-currency.sh --runtime claude --installed /opt/agent-plugins/agentic-engineering reports DRIFT, 8 findings, against the gitlink a5a0d77. On 2026-11-13 it reported CURRENT.
Second criterion: the installed plugin now matches the reviewed gitlink a5a0d77 on 299 of 303 pinned files. The only differences are 4 files in the two Stripe skills, from the newer deployed plugin commit. No role or run-loop file drifts.
Third criterion: in this scheduled session, the plugin's agents (agentic-engineer, portfolio-surveyor, agent-improver, flux-troubleshooter) were offered as dispatchable agent types, and its skills (portfolio-maintenance, product-engineering, self-improvement and the rest) were invocable. The run dispatched the bundled portfolio-surveyor and it completed. The plugin loads through --plugin-dir, not through the kagent skill selector, so this is evidence for the reviewed workaround rather than for the upstream fix in [FEATURE] Plugins on the claude and codex harnesses: mcp.json, dual manifests, Claude-format on codex kagent-dev/kagent#3388.
Activity
devantler commentedon Nov 8, 2026
Why the fix has to go upstream:
plugin.jsonwhenever one exists. Theagentic-engineeringplugin ships one for Copilot CLI and VS Code, without the Agent Plugins$schema, so kagent currently refuses the plugin outright: no skills load, not only the agents.I ran Claude Code 2.1.317 locally with the harness's exact flags and the plugin at
mainpassed with--plugin-dir. All 4 agents, all 87 skills and the subagent tool loaded. The 12 MCP servers did not start, because the harness passes--strict-mcp-config. That gap is the first item of kagent-dev/kagent#3388 and stays separate.Upstream PR: kagent-dev/kagent#3570. It covers the second item of kagent-dev/kagent#3388. Its main CI waits for a kagent maintainer to approve workflow runs from a first-time contributor.
The third acceptance criterion, a test session on the harness that shows the agent and its skills, still needs a kagent release that carries the fix, or the reviewed workaround in the second criterion.
🤖 Generated with Claude Code
devantler-tech-engineering commentedon Nov 13, 2026
Evidence for the third acceptance criterion, from the kagent lane's 2026-11-13 scheduled run on the harness:
agentic-engineering:portfolio-surveyoras a subagent, and it completed.agentic-engineering:agentic-engineer,agent-improverandflux-troubleshooterwere listed too.agentic-engineering:portfolio-maintenancethrough the Skill tool./opt/agent-plugins/agentic-engineeringmatches the reviewed gitlink.plugin-definition-currency.sh --runtime claude --installed /opt/agent-plugins/agentic-engineeringexits 0 (CURRENT, 302 pinned files match), and a directdiff -rofagents/andskills/against agent-plugins at the pinned commit finds no difference.This run did not check the first two criteria (the upstream fix and the reviewed status of the workaround).
devantler-tech-engineering commentedon Nov 14, 2026
New evidence from the kagent lane's 2026-11-14 run, on the second criterion ("loads the full plugin at the reviewed gitlink"):
plugin-definition-currency.sh --runtime claude --installed /opt/agent-plugins/agentic-engineeringreports DRIFT, 8 findings, against the gitlinka5a0d77. On 2026-11-13 it reported CURRENT.e7ba7bf.The run followed the reviewed definitions it fetched at
a5a0d77, as the currency check directs.devantler-tech-engineering commentedon Nov 14, 2026
New evidence from the kagent lane's second 2026-11-14 run, after devantler-tech/platform#6255 deployed:
a5a0d77on 299 of 303 pinned files. The only differences are 4 files in the two Stripe skills, from the newer deployed plugin commit. No role or run-loop file drifts.agentic-engineer,portfolio-surveyor,agent-improver,flux-troubleshooter) were offered as dispatchable agent types, and its skills (portfolio-maintenance,product-engineering,self-improvementand the rest) were invocable. The run dispatched the bundledportfolio-surveyorand it completed. The plugin loads through--plugin-dir, not through the kagent skill selector, so this is evidence for the reviewed workaround rather than for the upstream fix in [FEATURE] Plugins on the claude and codex harnesses: mcp.json, dual manifests, Claude-format on codex kagent-dev/kagent#3388.