Skip to content

[G3] Gate: certify advanced research workflow #47

Description

@dkritarth

Gate purpose

Final planned-depth certification for cross-paper analysis, evidence navigation, writing, and import reliability.

Dependencies

Blocked by #43, #44, #45, and #46, plus every blocker defect discovered during verification.

Exit criteria

  • Cross-paper synthesis claims are source-checked on real corpus.
  • Citation graph sampled edges have provenance and no known fabricated relation.
  • Writing workflow preserves user content and evidence links across failure/restart/export.
  • Zotero import is idempotent and preserves existing state.
  • Security review covers paper prompt injection, external metadata, file paths, and import data.
  • Full suite, typecheck, build, E2E, performance smoke, and diff check pass.
  • Independent reviewer posts complete representative workflow evidence.
  • All linked blockers are closed.

Closing this gate means planned workflow is verified, not that Vellum has no future work.

Required evidence

Focused PR uses Closes #47. Provide a written design first, failing tests/baseline, focused/full tests, typecheck, build, diff check, exact live Electron procedure, real-paper evidence, screenshots, console state, performance observations, and limitations. Independent reviewer repeats representative workflow.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    gatePhase or release gate; must close before dependents unlockphase:3-depthPhase 3: advanced analysis and polishstatus:blockedDo not start; dependency or phase gate remains open

    Projects

    No projects

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions