Separate domain for satellite image and nowcast output#10
Separate domain for satellite image and nowcast output#10KristianHMoller wants to merge 14 commits into
Conversation
|
@irenelivia you are our cloud expert - does the additional extent of the |
|
@KristianHMoller great work! My only consideration is that the nowcast ultimately changes if we use a larger domain (or a smaller domain, for that matter). You can see it in the case you showed - the advected clouds don't have the same exact shape in the two nowcasts run with different domains. So, we are ultimately providing a new model that we have not validated, and before making this kind of change, we should ideally "prove" that it improves the scores (or, at least, does not worsen them) over Denmark. |
|
Will need updating to be compatible with this (much needed) functionality: #11 |
|
Without explicit specification of |
|
CHANGELOG needs updating |
| DOMAIN_OPTIONS: dict[str, str | None] = { | ||
| "DENMARK": "4,50,18,62", | ||
| "NW_EUROPE": "-10.75,47.25,20,63.5", | ||
| "NW_EUROPE_SATELLITE": "-20.75,37.25,30,73.5", |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
For discussion: Can a smaller domain be used here?
|
@elbdmi do you think that it would make sense for you to review this from a technical point of view? Whether or not we should activate this operationally will require separate validation, possibly prior to next tagging |
I agree about the validation. Yes I think it makes sense to take a look from the technical point of view. |

Currently, the nowcast is provided on the same domain as the satellite image. This results in odd effects where the NaN values from outside the domain of the satellite image are blown into the domain of interest.
This PR allows for separation of the domains for satellite images and nowcast output, so that a larger domain can be used for the satellite image.
Based on back-of-the-envelope calculations assuming maximum (relevant) cloud velocities of 100 km/h, the domain NW_EUROPE_SATELLITE has been introduced as an example of a domain which can be used for producing nowcasts on the NW_EUROPE domain. The new domain extends 10 degrees outside of NW_EUROPE to all sides.
This PR does not change the default behavior, so prior to validation and active choice of using a different domain for the satellite image, this does not change the operational output. This simply allows for the option of changing.