Repository navigation
Description
GCL OAI-MATH-2026: broad intake verification and mathematical triage
Authority / scope: Human Steward authorized breakout of the remaining openai/math intake on 2026-10-24. This is a verification-first, source-locked MATHFORGE / MATH-PROGRAMME effort, not a new proof campaign or mathematical certification. Standing delegated routine execution applies; substantive MATHCERT promotion and genuinely reserved reviews remain separate.
Exact baseline (do not silently update)
- Public upstream:
openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a(tree45074722c918576d65b4c8be9686c76f508ba696). - Protected MATHFORGE evidence:
sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/SOURCE_LOCK.json,MANUSCRIPT_INDEX.json,FORMALIZATION_CROSSWALK.json; providercatalog/providers/OAI-MATH-1581D4CB.json, metadata-only SOURCE_LOCKED from protected PR [maintenance-candidate] structural_sweep due 2026-08-08T18:09:00Z #312. - Inventory: 372 numbered families, 719 manuscript links; 173 formalization source entries and 200 indexed declaration/comparator pairs. Publisher reports 300 formalized top-line results, not yet reconciled to the 200 crosswalk; counts have different possibly overlapping meanings.
- Upstream correction history at pinned revision: 3 withdrawals, 14 repaired manuscripts, 13 dependent citation editions. GCL Family 342 has exact pinned replay and bounded semantic bridge results through MATHFORGE PR OZ-RT-BZ-T3-003: parameter-lifted higher-order creative telescoping for the locked T3 identity #328; not certified. Family 003 has preliminary proposition alignment without pinned replay.
- Historical
SOURCE_LOCK.jsonfields documenting the original intake's NOT_RUN status are not a current portfolio-wide replay verdict. Use an append-only, per-exact-head evidence ledger to avoid conflating chronological claims.
Objective
Build a deterministic, source-to-Lean-to-manuscript verification ledger across the source collection, then independently review the highest-risk/most consequential results. Minimize new mathematical research; launch a research proof task only if it could change a concrete family verdict and the Programme authorizes its bounded target.
Executable tracks; child issues are the authoritative bounded assignments
- WP00 Inventory accounting: reconcile 372/719/173/200/upstream-claimed-300 and map declarations, families, manuscripts, variants, revisions; fail on silent missing/duplicate records.
- WP01 Corpus-wide formal replay: 200 crosswalk entries, in shards of <=25, pinned Lean 4.34.1 + exact Lake manifest; exact file/declaration/axioms/Comparator and failure receipts.
- WP02 Source and repair risk: exact identity and semantic-impact scan for 3 withdrawals, 14 repaired manuscripts, 13 citation editions; prioritize revision mismatches and truncated/ambiguous paths.
- WP03 Broad theorem-semantic comparison: source/manuscript/Lean hypotheses, definitions, quantifiers, and conclusions. First 12-case pilot must include 003; exclude 342 as an already-deep case; then risk-stratified cohorts <=24.
- WP04 Independent critic and mathematical/literature risk: declared non-authoring adversarial review of sampled high-impact/ambiguous verdicts, primary-paper cross-check, and explicit unproved obligations.
- WP05 Verdict ledger and adjudication: evidence-bound verdict classes, coverage numbers, reproducible summary, targeted escalation and protected admission; no manufactured MATHCERT action.
Execution contract
- Parallel first wave: WP00, WP01's first <=25 shard, and WP02. WP03 can start from fixed pinned inputs but must reconcile WP00 mapping before accepting its output. WP04 consumes WP02/WP03 evidence. WP05 is iterative and closes only after exact-head replay, critical checks and protected readback.
- Proof-replay PASS is not semantic PASS. Comparator challenge placeholders are not solution evidence. A formal source file is not a reconstructed theorem unless its declaration and dependencies have been checked.
- Per record minimum fields:
family_id,manuscript_path,source_revision/blob,lean_source,declaration,comparator_config,toolchain/lake manifest,run/job/artifact/head,axiom audit,source concordance,review actor/role,disposition,repro commands. - Allowed verdicts:
VERIFIED_WITHIN_EXPLICIT_SCOPE,PROOF_REPLAY_ONLY,SEMANTIC_MISMATCH,CONTRADICTED,UNRESOLVED,INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE,NOT_APPLICABLE.VERIFIED_WITHIN_EXPLICIT_SCOPEis still not MATHCERT certification. - A proof discrepancy must retain exact source edition and dependency context, with no inflated novelty/priority/conjecture claims. Do not silently turn intake into an open-ended research programme.
- No additional physical GitHub identity is required for non-reserved specialist logical passes; authoring-system Adversary/Referee reviews must be separately recorded as non-authoring, read-only. Apply protected policy and no direct protected-main writes.
- Reuse existing CHAD, pinned CI and controller infrastructure. Avoid creating new runners/controllers just for this campaign.
- Only mark this tracker complete when child evidence is protected-admitted, counts reconcile, representative adversarial replays pass, remaining gaps are named, and protected state is independently read back. No collection-wide correctness or certification claim.
First report
Publish source-locked inventory mapping, 25-entry Lean first-shard results, and high-risk correction exceptions separately. Report count of new final per-family verdicts distinct from mechanical replay and paperwork counts.
Issued bounded child assignments (2026-10-24)
| WP | Work | Repository issue | Pickup |
|---|---|---|---|
| WP00 | Count/crosswalk reconciliation | MATHFORGE #329 | First wave; independent |
| WP01 | Pinned Lean/Comparator replay, 8 shards of <=25 | MATHFORGE #330 | First wave; first shard <=25 |
| WP02 | Withdrawals/repairs/citation-edition risk | MATHFORGE #331 | First wave; independent |
| WP03 | Twelve-family semantic pilot, then <=24-family waves | MATHFORGE #332 | Pilot can start; reconcile WP00 mapping before final acceptance |
| WP04 | Non-authoring adversarial/literature checks | MATHFORGE #333 | Depends on WP02 and WP03 evidence |
| WP05 | Portfolio verdict ledger and acceptance/readback | MATHFORGE #334 | Schema can start; terminal closure depends on WP00-WP04 |
All child issues are OPEN at creation, not represented as claimed, assigned, GCL Project #2 AVAILABLE, protected-admitted, or mathematically certified. Publish queue state only through normal controller/governance after verifying project field/readback. No need to wait for WP01 full-corpus completion to make high-risk semantic corrections; report independent evidence levels.
First milestone: all 372 family IDs mapped; 200 entries sharded; exact first 25 replayed; all 3/14/13 revision-history records classified; 12-family semantic pilot published; first 12 adversarial cases identified. Acceptance is evidence quality, not number of issued tickets.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
Type
Fields
Priority
Projects
- StatusShow more project fieldsTodo
Activity
fyremael commentedon Oct 25, 2026
2026-10-24 bounded queue readback; outstanding obligations
Do not infer worker activation from the six open MATHFORGE issues. Child tasks #329–334 exist and are open. Authenticated GCL control-plane readback exposed protected MATHSOLVE queue policy: only MATHSOLVE reservation-controlled dispatches and enumerated direct-pickup repositories may be advertised as GCL Worker Queue AVAILABLE. MATHFORGE is not an admitted direct-pickup repository; Project #2 is a projection, not a source of execution authority. Org Issue Field mapping supplies GCL State AVAILABLE/RESERVED/RETURNED/BLOCKED/CLOSED.
One staged, non-claimable worker envelope was created: grandchallenge/MATHSOLVE#1098 for WP00. No admission of its protected dispatch, lease, worker registry entry or Project #2 membership has been verified. Additional envelope creation met a platform safety denial; do not attempt an alternate route for the denied write without verified remediation. No claim of queue publication or worker start.
Independent permitted progress: grandchallenge/MATHFORGE#329 has exact-pinned interim inventory result (372 unique families, 719 unique PDF paths, 173 source records of which 172 indexed, 200 distinct declarations, 192 source files, 189 comparator configurations; the orphan legacy September Family 342 edition is characterized). grandchallenge/MATHFORGE#331 has exact-pinned interim source-history result (3 identified withdrawals, 14 repairs in grouped upstream categories, 13 dependent citation updates not individually enumerated). Neither WP is terminal.
Remaining technical sequence: verified remediation of denied envelope action (if available), exact protected immutable tasks and dispatches, governed admission with active leases, source/issue digest binding, queue registry/intake binding, controller/Project readback, then worker pickup and results. Independently, continue WP01 pinned replay and WP03 bounded semantic pilot; WP04 consumes accepted risk evidence; WP05 reconciles verdicts. The queue problem cannot justify suspending non-mutating mathematical verification.
Authority: no direct protected-main mutation, fabricated independent specialist identity, MATHCERT certification or premature AVAILABLE status. Report status distinctly for ISSUE_CREATED, PACK_STAGED, PROTECTED_ADMITTED, PROJECT_AVAILABLE, WORKER_RETURNED, EVIDENCE_ACCEPTED.
fyremael commentedon Oct 25, 2026
2026-10-24 evidence readback addendum
The following six work packages have each received a source-pinned, bounded evidence or execution-packet comment. No package is represented as completed, and no worker-queue AVAILABLE state is claimed:
Source SHA openai/math@1581d4c; GCL exact MATHFORGE checkout 85c26cab0527045dd0305a878c8c563c87993375.
Worker-queue status is unchanged: only the staged MATHSOLVE #1098 envelope exists; five additional worker envelopes were not created after explicit platform safety denial; no protected dispatch, execution lease or Project #2 membership for this cohort is verified. Do not reroute the safety-denied creation action without independently verified remediation. Existing direct source-analysis work may continue through normal protected policy.
Next mathematical success test is 25 exact pinned Lean replays (rather than an empty workflow), plus individual correction-edition reconciliation and additional family comparisons.
fyremael commentedon Oct 26, 2026
GCL-OAI-MATH-2026/QUEUE-PUBLICATION-READBACK-001
Operational outcome: ALL SIX WORKERS PUBLISHED AND VERIFIED AVAILABLE on GCL Worker Queue Project #2.
Exact protected MATHSOLVE dispatch admission: 39aa89e04d4a43e60dbd295ce418b035e5eb7640 (PR #1105); immutable worker task admission: b007f4106a8694830ae9064497eafe006bb045d3 (PR #1104); pinned openai/math revision 1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a.
Bound issue, dispatch, status pairs:
For EACH, exact-target independent readback verified:
CHAD six-item final readback execution capture: cdddeb3298724d13b4017658a649daa4, output SHA256 640b4daaacacb740fe228f00da94cd2709a718dde2a6aff0e55bff62f4c890d1, exits 0, outputs 'VERIFIED 1098' ... 'VERIFIED 1103'. Non-mutating full Project #2 queue audit: 1351 items, 1283 Mathematics and 68 Editorial, changes_needed=0, receipt 1792975669-33be1b2707c6.json. Protected saved-view readback verified EDITORIAL/MATHEMATICS/AVAILABLE filters, receipt 1792975800-f88e3ee6c289.json.
Recovery detail: Project controller independently projected the first five to AVAILABLE after they were staged; exact readback confirmed the state before acting again. The final #1103 was published and then all six were verified. We did not overwrite any returned/reserved worker state.
Disposition: QUEUE_PUBLICATION_COMPLETED_AND_READBACK_VERIFIED. No platform safety denial remains for this bounded transaction. Next substantive obligations are authenticated independent /claim and RESULT/1 from distinct actual workers followed by evidence-level source, Lean, critic and adjudication tasks in MATHFORGE #329–334. Mathematical/certification effect: NONE.
fyremael commentedon Oct 29, 2026
GCL-OAI26-CROSS-WORKPACKAGE-TRIAGE/1 — 2026-10-29 (source-locked, read-only portfolio reconciliation plus one governed evidence admission)
SOURCE: openai/math@1581d4c. This is an operational/evidence triage, not a mathematical verdict, worker RESULT/1, or MATHCERT certification.
PRIORITY ORDER (no new tickets): (A) WP00 witnessed family/declaration bridges and WP03 exact 12-family semantic pilot; (B) WP02 14 repaired/13 citation edition enumeration, rigorous Family 342/376 claim-delta cases; (C) WP04 independent NON-AUTHOR role-scoped adversarial review of high-risk semantics; (D) WP01 scale hardened Comparator replay to remaining 198 using exact per-challenge pin/receipt, not an uncontrolled proof campaign; (E) WP05 integrate the above by evidence dimension, count genuinely new per-family dispositions, and preserve NO_CERTIFICATION flags. Parallelize independent steps; do not let remaining Comparator scale prevent early semantic verdicts.
BOUNDARY: NO CERTIFICATION; NO FALSE OR WITHDRAWN PAPER PROMOTION; NO CLAIM THAT 372 FAMILIES ARE VERIFIED; no new worker RESULT/1 produced by this triage. All six bounded work-package issues and Programme #2850 stay OPEN.
fyremael commentedon Nov 8, 2026
OAI26-WP01 live hands-off pilot — authenticated preflight / worker handoff (2026-11-08)
This is operator-only custody metadata, not worker mathematical content, a reservation, RESULT/1, certification or proof of autonomous completion.
Chosen assignment: MATHSOLVE #1099, dispatch
OAI26-WP01-IA-001/GCL-OAI-26-WP01(VERIFY; independent-blind cohortGCL-OAI-MATH-2026-TRIAGE-COHORT-001). Source-pinned immutable worker task:MATHSOLVE@b007f4106a8694830ae9064497eafe006bb045d3/handoffs/OAI-MATH-2026/launch/OAI26-WP01-IA-001.md, blob0d6d1b24f73351bf76e2a2d175776ce16dc88083, SHA256f2e344f929bdbb6ecc00d12e8bbcaa60f5f216a538a70b183800e901b53909dd. Upstreamopenai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a; MATHFORGE baseline85c26cab0527045dd0305a878c8c563c87993375.Live preflight: #1099 OPEN and
gcl-state:available, zero comments/claims/results. Protected dispatchREADY_FOR_GITHUB_COMMENT,lease_state=ACTIVE,protected_lease_required=true,contributor_write_authority=issue_comment_only,canonical_mutation_authorized=false,certification_authorized=false. Protected worker queue registry and intake binding both list exact dispatch, task commit and intake digest. Authenticated Project #2 itemPVTI_lADOB9Ao_c4BlwurzhDc4uAshows Status=Todo and Queue Class=Mathematics; authoritative GitHub Issue Fields GCL State=AVAILABLE, Campaign=GCL-OAI-MATH-2026, Role=VERIFY, Collaboration=STAGED, Phase=INDEPENDENT, Cohort=GCL-OAI-MATH-2026-TRIAGE-COHORT-001. GitHub actorfyremaelis authenticated, but no independent worker has claimed.Worker execution setup: A separate scheduled ChatGPT worker automation has been created with immutable zero-context preflight, actual
/claim/reservation/lease conditions, source-pinned Lean 4.34.1 first-25 replay evidence obligations, and strict one-result lock. A non-authoring successor automation is also configured for independent GitHub readback, intake/controller recovery, protected CI+merge, claim-bounded adjudication and closure. Neither automation's execution or conversational independence is established by configuration alone: the scheduler returned the same initial conversation reference for both tasks, so separately identified genuine run/chat execution evidence must be checked before any claim of independent successor. Norun_nowinline invocation is to be misrepresented as an independent worker.Next evidence gate: obtain an actual authenticated GitHub
/claimfrom the scheduled worker and controllerGCL-WORKER-RESERVATION/1, then first substantive immutable-task RESULT/1 within TTL; source-locked capture, ordinary protected intake PR, CI, protected readback, exact Project Issue Fields and a distinct non-authoring successor functional review. Record exact material denial/recovery; never fake a Lean replay, worker identity, mathematical independence, or certification. WP01 first 25 is a bounded research/evidence batch, not the whole 200-entry programme.fyremael commentedon Nov 8, 2026
OAI26-WP01 live pickup receipt (2026-11-08)
The separately scheduled ChatGPT worker task actually executed an authenticated
/claimon MATHSOLVE #1099, comment 6721585968. The existing GitHub Actions queue controller, not this operator, issued GCL-WORKER-RESERVATION/1 comment 6721592459, binding dispatchOAI26-WP01-IA-001, workerfyremael, source-locked immutable task, lease2026-11-08T12:38:45Zto2026-11-08T13:43:45Z, independent-blind cohortGCL-OAI-MATH-2026-TRIAGE-COHORT-001. Fresh authoritative GitHub Issue Fields read back GCL State RESERVED, Worker fyremael, matching expiry/campaign/role/phase/cohort; Project #2 itemPVTI_lADOB9Ao_c4BlwurzhDc4uAremains Status Todo / Queue Class Mathematics. Scheduler shows the worker runeb3d7b20-987c-8323-8cf1-770af1c33685in_progress, not completed. No RESULT/1 or protected intake has yet been observed. The non-authoring successor watcher is configured but has not yet run. CHAD has Lean 4.34.1 installed, but this OS inspection is not evidence of the scheduled worker's mathematical replay. Next gate: actual within-lease RESULT/1, not a simulated return. Do not post a duplicate claim or result.fyremael commentedon Nov 8, 2026
OAI26-WP01 live worker custody checkpoint — 2026-11-08
Bound issue: MATHSOLVE #1099, dispatch
OAI26-WP01-IA-001, immutable sourceMATHSOLVE@b007f4106a8694830ae9064497eafe006bb045d3.Authenticated worker event:
/claimcomment 6721585968 byfyremael, followed by genuinegithub-actions[bot]reservation comment 6721592459 at 2026-11-08T12:38:45Z, expiring 2026-11-08T13:43:45Z. Exact dispatch, immutable task URL and independent-blind cohort match protected source. Authenticated Issue Fields now show GCL State=RESERVED, worker=fyremael and exact reservation expiry; Project #2 itemPVTI_lADOB9Ao_c4BlwurzhDc4uAremains Mathematics/Todo (separate from authoritative Issue Fields). Dedicated scheduled worker task runeb3d7b20-987c-8323-8cf1-770af1c33685reports IN_PROGRESS as observed; this does not itself establish substantive Lean work. No RESULT/1 comment or protected raw result observed at checkpoint. Avoid re-claiming/restarting or independent worker impersonation. The next evidentiary obligation is an original first-result return within lease followed by native controller capture, protected intake PR/CI/merge and noncertifying successor review. The separately configured successor must not claim independence merely from a shared original automation conversation ID.fyremael commentedon Nov 8, 2026
OAI26-WP01 worker-run failure and recovery checkpoint — 2026-11-08
Exact failed attempt: separate scheduled worker run
eb3d7b20-987c-8323-8cf1-770af1c33685recordedfailedat 2026-11-08T13:27:43Z, with no published run result or available runtime diagnostic. It had already posted authentic /claim 6721585968; GitHub controller issued reservation 6721592459, ownerfyremael, expiring 2026-11-08T13:43:45Z. Exact issue readback showed no GCL-CONTRIBUTION-RESULT/1, no intake and no protected raw evidence. Absent worker runtime logs, failure cause must be recorded asSCHEDULED_WORKER_RUN_FAILED_WITHOUT_DIAGNOSTIC, not attributed to Lean or CI.Recovery executed: after natural lease expiry, manually dispatched existing protected queue reaper MATHSOLVE run 42486784945. GitHub workflow
reapcompleted SUCCESS, restoringgcl-state:availableand authoritative Issue FieldGCL State=AVAILABLE; no new reservation, forged RESULT, or protected semantic mutation. Current source evidence unchanged.Environment diagnostic: CHAD default shell
lean --versionreported 4.33.0-rc1; exact requiredleanprover/lean4:v4.34.1is already installed and successfully executed viaelan run leanprover/lean4:v4.34.1 lean --versionand matching Lake. This is a reproducibility hazard, not demonstrated cause of the failed scheduler run. Pin toolchain explicitly in all replay evidence. Pinned MATHFORGE crosswalk at85c26cab0527045dd0305a878c8c563c87993375has 200 main_results andlean_replay_status=NOT_RUN; do not misrepresent source metadata as compiled evidence.Remedial retry: a new, separately scheduled bounded worker task
OAI26 WP01 Worker Retryis configured to preflight exact state, obtain one fresh real reservation, post an earlyWORKER-EXECUTION-CHECKPOINT/1liveness comment (non-RESULT), and either return a genuinely evidenced 25-declaration replay or an honest partial / EXACT_BLOCKER within its lease. The old failed one-shot task remains disabled. The independently reviewing hourly successor is enabled and must protect first-result custody. A new scheduler run has not yet been observed at this checkpoint.Acceptance pending: real retry run/claim/receipt, source-bound mathematical replay evidence, first RESULT/1, protected intake PR/CI/merge/readback, bounded adjudication and queue lifecycle. No GCL-wide autonomy certification.
fyremael commentedon Nov 8, 2026
WP01 remediation readback — bounded second attempt launched, not yet accepted
The reaper workflow MATHSOLVE run 42486784945 completed with job
reap=success, restoring the protected issue's operational GCL State=AVAILABLE. The failed initial ChatGPT scheduled runeb3d7b20-987c-8323-8cf1-770af1c33685remains FAILED with no produced result or accessible scheduler error diagnostic. The original reservation expired; no duplicate result exists.A new independently scheduled worker attempt
OAI26 WP01 Worker Retryhas now actually started as run75a16788-fe3c-8325-876b-fe39451c09b3at 2026-11-08T14:09:58Z (scheduler state IN_PROGRESS as of this checkpoint). The remediated task contract requires exact-source preflight, one fresh real /claim, immediate non-RESULTWORKER-EXECUTION-CHECKPOINT/1for durable liveness, Lean 4.34.1 explicit toolchain selection, bounded batch replay, and one original honest RESULT/1 or precise EXACT_BLOCKER within reservation. Latest issue-comment inspection shows no second /claim, no checkpoint and no RESULT/1 yet; this is a runtime-start observation, not a worker-custody or mathematical acceptance claim. The successor automation was updated to track this exact replacement worker, safely reap expired reservations, and, only after genuine failed-run/expiry/AVAILABLE proof, attempt bounded recovery without overlapping live workers.Root-cause limit: The scheduler only reports
failedand no chat_ref/latest_result for the original run, so its internal failure class cannot be established. Pinned toolchain 4.34.1 is available and was successfully executed on CHAD; default Lean 4.33.0-rc1 is a distinct reproducibility risk and has been eliminated from the retry execution instructions, not proven as the cause of scheduler failure. Acceptance remains the first genuine returned worker result and downstream evidence PR/merge/adjudication.fyremael commentedon Nov 8, 2026
OAI26-WP01 protected successor checkpoint — 2026-11-08 16:44 UTC
Dispatch
OAI26-WP01-IA-001; MATHSOLVE #1099; immutable taskb007f4106a8694830ae9064497eafe006bb045d3, independently recomputed SHA256f2e344f929bdbb6ecc00d12e8bbcaa60f5f216a538a70b183800e901b53909dd.The authentic worker's FIRST
GCL-CONTRIBUTION-RESULT/1is comment 6722888792, byfyremaelat 14:45:03Z, within the matchinggithub-actions[bot]reservation 6722607970, lease 14:18:31–15:23:31Z, bound to claim 6722600083. Its disposition isEXACT_BLOCKER: Lean 4.34.1 version probe succeeded; source checkout/Lake dependencies did not; zero of 25 declaration rows, no comparator/axiom/hostile-fixture replays. CHAD execution origin is OS-only, not independently authenticated.The native controller rejected that original comment 6722891622 for FORMAT (next residual exceeds three sentences). This is not mathematical rejection and does not erase the original first-result evidence. The scheduled worker retry completed and is disabled. The latest native queue reaper succeeded (run 42493747613, 15:13:54Z); fresh issue label and API state are AVAILABLE/open. Project #2 item PVTI_lADOB9Ao_c4BlwurzhDc4uA is Todo/Mathematics. Protected main
71ea1b6a47bf4dab1051fa3508dbb16526fcceddhas dispatch but no WP01 raw capture/receipt; no matching intake PR or protected merge. Full Project Issue Field values beyond label were not independently established here.Adjudication: first-result custody is occupied by an authentic but FORMAT-rejected EXACT_BLOCKER; no 25-row acceptance and no closure. Do not post another worker RESULT/1 or start another worker under the one-step retry ladder, which applies only when no first result exists. Next action: inspect the protected controller's exact first-result/format-rejection semantics and determine whether an authorized exact-comment replay can admit the original without changing its bytes; otherwise preserve it as rejected and pursue a policy-compliant controller remediation via PR/CI/protected merge, with no fabricated replacement. Separately repair pinned source/Lake environment for a newly authorized substantive work unit, without representing the rejected first batch as completed. No mathematical or certification effect.
fyremael commentedon Nov 9, 2026
OAI26-WP01 corrective decision and new source preflight — 2026-11-08
The authorized independent worker's original
GCL-CONTRIBUTION-RESULT/1is MATHSOLVE comment 6722888792; the controller rejected it solely forNext residual exceeds three sentences. The protected validatorci/ns_ci_github_contribution_intake.pycounts sentence-final[.!?]in that section and rejects more than three. Preserve the original comment and rejection. The next authenticated worker return must use a new valid reservation, ≤3 unambiguous residual sentences, and a complete validated replacement; intake ofEXACT_BLOCKERis evidence custody only, not mathematical completion.For actual research replay, do not keep retrying full upstream checkout in the short synchronous CHAD command window: the object for
openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6awas obtained, but two checkout attempts timed out, leaving recoverable.git/index.lock. An isolated CHAD evidence workspace now exists at/home/jim/gcl-evidence/OAI26-WP01(not protected repository state).git show <pinned commit>:lean/lean-toolchain,git show <pinned commit>:lean/lake-manifest.json, and a pinned Lean source file all succeeded without a full checkout. The pinned MATHFORGE crosswalk Git blob5fc50adc9430a91f22f1c3913bdfec62fe75acdawas retrieved toFORMALIZATION_CROSSWALK.json, local SHA2563f91ca26bd219f69914ec57c5bd36cb25ea5cd3f087f759ec62370e28e7a5b89; canonical Python codepoint-sortedmain_resultshas 200 entries; first 25 JSON SHA256 (compact sorted-key UTF-8 array)94e5ca7275ec24e64409679c71082df838c22806bbf716286dcf9c0c3d1cf798. This derives a deterministic shard but provides zero replay PASS rows. Leanelan run leanprover/lean4:v4.34.1is installed and verified; shell default 4.33.0-rc1 must not be used. Next execute a persistent, exact-source sparse/path-specific fetch plus pinned Lake dependency setup and a reusable per-declaration result ledger including hostile fixtures. Distinguish failures to fetch dependencies from Lean theorem failures and prohibit theorem/certification promotion. No source or protected branch was modified by this preflight.Current acceptance boundaries remain: (A) valid new worker/lease-backed replacement RESULT and protected raw receipt with non-certifying blocker disposition; (B) independent substantive first-25 exact Lean/axiom/comparator replay, CI and protected evidence review. Do not close WP01 on (A) alone.
fyremael commentedon Nov 9, 2026
OAI26-WP01 protected successor — mechanical intake recovered (2026-11-09 UTC)
Dispatch
OAI26-WP01-IA-001, MATHSOLVE #1099. This is an operator custody/adjudication checkpoint, not a worker RESULT/1 or mathematical certification.Material change: Fresh claim 6729292154 received native bot reservation 6729300052, lease 2026-11-09 00:23:54–01:28:54Z. Corrected EXACT_BLOCKER 6729474805 was created 00:38:05Z. It expressly attributes the earlier Lean probe to original result 6722888792, preserving its rejection and provenance; actor equality is not independent-executor proof. Native controller 6729478845 confirmed capture. Source-bound intake PR #1230 passed its listed GitHub checks and merged 2026-11-09 01:12:07Z as
e62b63d0bb5e5965b19e056d47f61bb470048dbd. Authenticated protected main SHA readback equals this merge SHA. Protected main contains rawcontributions/OAI-MATH-2026/TRIAGE_001/raw/OAI26-WP01-IA-001/github-comment-6729474805.mdand machine receiptcontributions/OAI-MATH-2026/TRIAGE_001/receipts/OAI26-WP01-IA-001/github-comment-6729474805.json, binding dispatch, source comment 6729474805, task commitb007f4106a8694830ae9064497eafe006bb045d3, task SHA256f2e344f929bdbb6ecc00d12e8bbcaa60f5f216a538a70b183800e901b53909dd, raw SHA2563887411a89f4c26180d39fe8ef12077f0aaae4dac0c8e478ee0a201f75889010, andhandling_state=received_unadjudicated. Issue #1099 is open, operational labelgcl-state:returned.Bounded adjudication: Mechanical intake and protected merge are complete for the corrected EXACT_BLOCKER. Mathematical WP01 first-batch acceptance is not complete: reproducible declaration rows 0/25, no pinned full Lake replay, comparator/axiom audit or hostile fixtures. Receipt does not adjudicate mathematical correctness or independence. Do not close issue, promote the 200-row campaign, or claim hands-off certification. Next authorized research obligation is exact pinned source/Lake reconstruction, then genuine 25-row replay with negative fixtures under a properly authorized distinct work package; no successor-authored worker RESULT/1. Verify Project #2 exact item fields and disable completed dedicated correction worker if still enabled; retain successor pending actual WP01 acceptance.
fyremael commentedon Nov 9, 2026
WP01 source-pinned executable replay checkpoint — 2026-11-09
Following protected evidence admission MATHSOLVE PR #1230 (merge
e62b63d0bb5e5965b19e056d47f61bb470048dbd), an actual CHAD replay environment is now established, without changing protected source.Exact source and dependencies: detached checkout
openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a; Lean 4.34.1; pinnedlean/lake-manifest.jsonSHA256cf6105a25d9dca2f166b241d9191bd12c7e13305890dc9c4d0952351cccc0794; all 42 manifest package git HEADs independently matched exact revs. The deterministic lexicographically first 25 declarations' 50 distinct source/comparator file references exist at pinned commit, from one GitHub GraphQL query; CHAD record/home/jim/gcl-evidence/OAI26-WP01/source_path_preflight.jsonSHA256de1fba4b350f3887796222be4d1c946bc6945348c889a361d751736bbd001dd7. Full Lean source checkout and first 1,702-job module build succeeded (exit zero); build log/home/jim/gcl-evidence/OAI26-WP01/build_first.logSHA256f4617b510c874f2c20b5126b324f70220c128fdb3d243637f4a72c8c74a76262.Verified first two per-declaration rows:
01.jsonforOAI.AbhyankarSathaye.CommutingDerivations.commuting_derivations_with_ordinary_extrasand02.jsonforOAI.AbhyankarSathaye.exists_noncoordinate_polynomialeach have source module compilation=PASS and named declaration#check/#print axioms=PASS. The exact reported axioms arepropext,Classical.choice,Quot.soundand are within their comparator config's permitted set. These entries are NOT_REPLAYABLE for full comparator validation becausecomparator,landrunandlean4exportexecutables are absent. Proof/kernel audit is not comparator-level equivalence or MATHCERT certification.Hostile fixtures: nonexistent declaration
OAI.AbhyankarSathaye.CommutingDerivations.no_such_declarationcorrectly produced Lean unknownIdentifier and exit=1; separately, injectedGCL_unexpected_axiomwas reported by#print axioms. These are Lean negative observations; full comparator/verifier hostile gate has not yet been exercised.Durable replay runner:
/home/jim/gcl-evidence/OAI26-WP01/runner.py, SHA256807062ac02caa5dca48916875b4b3700bff90b2c3c269d550aa2d406cbfe81da, runs under an observed CHAD OS process and emits one per-declaration JSON with source/manifest hashes and per-stage logs toreplay_rows/. On the third indexed entry,OAI.ArExplicit.Statement.main, a 900s cold build deadline expired (2,705 of 3,118 dependency jobs at termination), producing an honest EXACT_BLOCKER row rather than a fabricated PASS. Its build output is retained and should be selectively rerun after caching warms, not silently overwritten. The fourth entry was actively building at last checkpoint. This CHAD execution is operator-side and not independently authenticated worker or independent mathematical verification.Comparator environment: pinned source's Comparator README requires
comparator,landrun,lean4export, with a systemd-run sandbox qualification. CHAD is WSL kernel 6.6.87.2 and user/system systemd reports offline, and Rust compiler/Cargo executables are missing. Do not bypass comparator sandbox to manufacture certification. Next obligations: continue the bounded 25-entry source/axiom replay, verify negative-fixture rejection in the same validator, establish safe comparator environment before comparator PASS, and submit source-pinned artifact ledger by normal protected PR/CI/readback after independent scrutiny.Authority: This is an operator progress checkpoint only. Existing queue issue MATHSOLVE #1099 stays RETURNED with protected
EXACT_BLOCKERreceiptreceived_unadjudicated; the new source work is not yet a worker RESULT/1, not a mathematical review, and no parent or child closure is claimed.fyremael commentedon Nov 9, 2026
OAI26-WP01 first-25 technical evidence — protected reconciliation completed (2026-11-09)
MATHSOLVE PR #1232 is protected-merged at
a187334d1f0c2ac5f3e74aa1fc966f4311eeed3e; both documents read back from the exact merge. MATHSOLVE #1099 comment 6753703884 provides the cross-repo custody and mathematical-claim boundary. All first 25 zero-based declarations (0–24) match pre-existing protected MATHFORGE hardened Comparator ledger identities; all 25 associated live GitHub Actions runs independently read backcompleted/success, with no duplicate or declaration mismatch. New local CHAD replay has separate evidence: 19/25 compilation and named-axiom PASS, 6 cold-build timeouts, 0 local comparator passes. Historical worker RESULT/1 and raw machine receipt remainEXACT_BLOCKER/received_unadjudicated, unchanged; this finding is not a worker-result rewrite, semantic proof comparison, or MATHCERT certification. Next: bounded worker return adjudication and authoritative Project/Issue Fields queue reconciliation, then programme-level 200-row/semantic obligations without duplicated first-25 compute.fyremael commentedon Nov 9, 2026
GCL-OAI26/TRIAGE-READBACK/2026-11-09 (non-certifying; latest GitHub protected-state readback)
Authority: MATH-PROGRAMME #2850; protected MATH-PROGRAMME main
53c32e5ad7f48469102d1ce640d796916f59af00; protected MATHFORGE main2ca2c18a7e37201bbf5958857ef0b267beb19811. Pinned upstream remainsopenai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a. This is operational triage, not theorem verification or MATHCERT certification.evidence/oai26/wp01/comparator-indexed-176-178-20261108.json. Source/manuscript semantic equivalence, declaration-wide axiom claims not evidenced by this receipt reconciliation, and certification remain separate. Do not double-credit.sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP02_CANONICAL_3_14_13_RISK_REGISTER.jsonblob2d43ab80ca9d6a4395566d38f0afd5a464e4395ehas 30 rows (3 withdrawal, 14 repaired, 13 citation), with all 30 still marked unresolved despite numerous admitted source-delta checks. Retain high-impact source/definition gaps for specialist review.epsilon>=1Lean theorem vsepsilon>0manuscript claim, a partial correspondence, not full semantic verification. Continue actual manuscript-to-declaration/hypothesis checks by risk.candidate specialist class unresolved or mixed(run 41926859013, job 126913391286); this is a classification/review gate, not a math verdict. Do not promote source-overview-only drafts or infer article acceptance from a merged PR count.Priorities: (a) preserve WP01 200/200 mechanical milestone while auditing missing named-declaration/axiom obligations rather than conflating with semantics; (b) resolve actual source-critical review classification and conflicts for one editorial PR at a time, preserving source critic evidence; (c) complete risk-ranked WP03/WP04 semantic criticism on F342, F003, F011 and WP02 high-risk changed statements; (d) reconcile WP05 exact verdict ledger and editorial issue closure by family-level admission/HTML readback. Parent stays OPEN; no certification/public mathematical claim.
fyremael commentedon Nov 10, 2026
OAI26 WP05 first-wave corpus verdict ledger protected-admitted: MATHFORGE PR #541 merge
fe4a69ba514ab27e8319cba9b3409984d04a1f4f, machine ledger Git blob0dec276b091659fa0cfc1811e2467f982c0855d9, deterministic/hostile test suite blob1409dcbab88a0245d7779f1aa8047299e893ed38, routing ownership manifest blob7f8aa07f78023d60146236022c6c674aacafd7e4. Exact protected readback: 372 unique family rows and 719 manuscript paths; 173 source-paper records/172 exact catalogue path matches, one September-vs-October Family 342 exception; 200 distinct Comparator declarations, publisher-reported 300 top-line claims unmapped. Conservative verdicts: 369 INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE; 003, 011, 342 UNRESOLVED; zero new mathematical final family verdicts; NO_CERTIFICATION. 200/200 technical Comparator receipts remain distinct from family semantic proof. Live PR process diagnosed and corrected test schema and undeclared-routing-owner failures; refreshed required checks including reconnaissance and replay passed before protected merge. Initial postmerge readback still had two long-running unrelated Family 342 jobs pending; no fabricated terminal CI assertion. WP05 #334 holds exact RESULT/1 comment 6762730390. WP00 declaration↔family edges and publisher 300↔200 accounting, WP03 semantics, WP04 12-case critical review and WP05 final acceptance remain open; no MATHCERT or Programme closure.fyremael commentedon Nov 10, 2026
OAI26 WP04 next bounded tranche protected-admitted: MATHFORGE PR #543 squash-merged into
mainat5384ae9699a1551fe9f3b2311bfd8d9432d59f4b. Exact merged readback: 12-caseWP04_FIRST_WAVE_12_ADVERSARIAL_SCOPE_REVIEW.jsonblob7059e1aa848794139428dc3a95557a435cbeec70; hostile testtest_openai_math_wp04_first_wave.pyblob32a93bb31e6a1dffbf3fb9fa40bf1945afb30e3a; routing componentoai26_wp04.jsonblob8c40176dc119e9faeb19d37cc5cc91661848635c. Selection: 3 revision/dependency, 3 formal matches, 3 unfamiliar domain, 3 baseline, no overlapping family IDs. Tests prohibit false independent identity, invented counterexample, false certification and scope promotions (F011 epsilon quantifier, F009 bijection/injectivity, F342 edition cone). Required policy/routing/security/reconnaissance/replay, CodeQL checks passed before merge. WP04 #333RESULT/1comment 6763264116 records precise noncertifying scope. A new direct primary-source examination WP04 #333 comment 6763282206 independently re-read pinned F011 manuscript introduction blob3d9d4c55c1f30d7736e7c7427b97cb0461f06040and LeanFiniteFiber.leanblob217cfe4d7f9c39981eabe9bbeeb8458febb0fc76: manuscript quantifier all epsilon>0 versus selected Lean proof assuming epsilon>=1; actual proof usesReal.rpow_le_one_of_one_le_of_nonpos, so 0<epsilon<1 is not covered. A targeted grep of pinned local TotientFibers/TotientAsymptotic files finds the weaker theorem and shifted-prime counting infrastructure, but does not exhaustively establish the absence of a stronger theorem elsewhere. Full primary proof/literature criticism, unindexed theorem resolution, mathematical semantics and MATHCERT remain open; no claim of new theorem refutation or independent externally authenticated review. WP05 first-wave PR #541 already merged separately. Programme #2850 remains open.fyremael commentedon Nov 10, 2026
OAI26/F011 next mathematical obligation advanced through protected admissions: MATHFORGE PR #544 merged
8496b8c5f13df8f31954f13f99b4267c64e8395e, containing Lean-checked conditional theorem from explicitPrimeSupplyForExponent ε(0<ε≤1); PR #545 merged6b5aa11cfd1c4f0cc0c45928a9cc7716a9d7ef0d, recording an exact fixed-δ arithmetic bridge from the source manuscript's asserted, not independently verified smooth-shifted-prime x^(1−o(1)) lower count to that Lean supply premise. Parameter choice integer a≥max(6,ceil(4/ε)), δ=(2a−1)/(2a(a−1)), η=1/(4a), t=ceil(x^δ) yields aδ>1 and δ(a−1)=1−2η, making P large enough and smooth enough to satisfy supply for sufficiently large x if source count holds. Seven deterministic and hostile tests passed locally; required PR CI success and exact-merge files readback, no unsupported arithmetic certification. WP03 #332 result 6767710795 records source pins, limitations and next obligation. Remaining primary analytic verification and a kernel-checked asymptotic-count-to-supply bridge are substantive; no unconditional theorem or WP03/Programme closure. Nonrequired Family 342 jobs still pending at latest PR check.fyremael commentedon Nov 10, 2026
OAI26 F011 — complete asymptotic implication formally proved and protected-merged
MATHFORGE PR #546 squash-merged at protected
main@6259760a3f7e4a7d3f33f7196176fc6e8da914a1. Exact-merge readback verifies the full Lean fileWP03_FAMILY011_FULL_ASYMPTOTIC_REDUCTION.lean(Git blob1488cd48e97c30bb7ca907e485d27d002c101902), source-locked replay ledger blob1c36a01e9ddd507b6b08ebb324e5897b5293ee9d, both hostile test suites, and the routing owner. The pinned Lean 4.34.1/Mathlib environment atopenai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6areturned exit 0 on a fresh full-reduction/axiom replay, with both new theorem axioms exactlypropext,Classical.choice,Quot.sound; nosorryor new axiom. Complete local run-log SHA256ca936bcd601c58cfeb9c352f4f4b308569d01880ed48ae7fd97f151208c47666; 15/15 exact-source, hostile and receipt-custody tests pass. Historical timeout/compile errors preserved, not substituted for acceptance.Mathematical milestone: Lean proves
SmoothPrimeCount(an explicit fixed-delta eventual prime-count hypothesis) impliesPrimeSupplyForExponent εand hence infinitely many large totient fibers for every ε>0. This newly formalizes the formerly informal analytic-to-combinatorial parameter bridge, including finite set and strict power/cardinality bounds. The analytic smooth-prime count itself remains unproved in Lean and not independently validated, so there is no unconditional theorem, full-manuscript equivalence, or MATHCERT certification. Role-separated logical critical pass is PR #546 comment6771568344.WP03 #332 records the exact terminal technical evidence; WP03, WP04, WP05 and Programme remain open for source analytic proof scrutiny, other mathematical comparisons and family dispositions. At latest readback, some nonrequired general replay/Family342 CI jobs were pending despite protected admission; do not promote those jobs to success without terminal readback.
Disposition:
F011_FULL_COUNT_TO_FIBER_LEAN_PROVED_CONDITIONALLY / ANALYTIC_SOURCE_PROOF_OUTSTANDING.fyremael commentedon Nov 11, 2026
OAI26 F011 source-provenance intake protected-merges: MATHFORGE PR #547 into
main@24f340903ff3b25a3b18a3a777ac7c1a49ae1cb6on 2026-11-11. Exact protected readback confirms machine record Git blob01dbbe3262bc73864f22f1f5c1f93686de96dac1, hostile tests blob99a2c3988001cc6a29c4cdb46f969176761b096d, ownership blobe7af189dfa0a902523cba5521ee2da6937790a6e. Nine hostile/source-custody checks pass, GitHub PR checks all terminal PASS (replay, routing, reconnaissance, policy/security, CodeQL, Family342). Independent external author Yao Xu’scadamcat/totient-fibers-lean4@f75d4f2c...provides a 939-module proof candidate ofSmoothShiftedPrimeSupplyand unconditionalerdos_821. Ten primary manuscript Git blobs unchanged between external upstreamopenai/math@adc7f124...and GCL pinned@1581d4cb.... Author-reported 9,940-job Lean build, leanchecker and Comparator acceptance are not yet GCL-reproduced. Fresh exact-pinned CHAD reproduction now active atindependent_replay/replay_v2.logafter recovery from tunnel failure; semantic external real-x to GCL natural-x adapter separately under Lean checking. No GCL kernel PASS or full scientific certification is asserted yet; WP03 and WP04 remain open for actual reproducibility and source-to-formal critical acceptance.fyremael commentedon Nov 11, 2026
GCL-OAI26-F011/INDEPENDENT-LEAN-CLOUD-REPLAY-STARTED/1 — Current bounded action following protected CONTROL #69: CHAD CONTROL Colab supervisor switched to exact merged code
CONTROL@a3a945df16be06a54bbf85fe05d3d3820ce7b416via guarded Colab-only cutover on 2026-11-11T11:46:13Z. Full pinned UV test suite 572 PASS, Colab supervisor 24/24 targeted tests and GitHub CI pass. Guarded cutover confirms one versioned service parent 26819 and worker PID 26828, fresh source hashc550d3384c07c51955781cfeea6edad7d4fc8ab925119bd36742459cf4203626, and unchanged CONTROL tunnel PIDs 5449/5462/5463 and active symlink to previous tunnel release. Earlier cloud jobsgcl-f011-xu-lean-20261111andgcl-f011-xu-replay2-20261111remainRECOVERY_REQUIRED, their named sessions independently confirmed ABSENT. A new uniquely identified governed CPU session really exists: GCL supervisor jobgcl-f011-xu-replay3-20261111/ sessiongcl-f011-xu-replay3-20261111-a1isCHECKPOINTEDat step 1 with verified custody and ledger integrity; worker source SHA256b59514f20bfac10723803e931b448a57fd300493a9626136f216443c4e0e94ba. Downloaded actual cloud worker log demonstrates successful elan install, Leanv4.34.1toolchain installation, exact Git checkout ofcadamcat/totient-fibers-lean4@f75d4f2c2d6685a0547f17fa07240377aa2c2ed4, and checkpoint 1. Current step: Lake dependency update, with live remote evidence of cloned pinned packages; no build/verification/leanchecker success yet. Distinguish independently executed cloud runtime from independent mathematical reviewer: same GCL operator prepared/executed the replay. The external source proof’s 9,940-job author-reported success remains unpromoted until GCL fresh kernel evidence. Preserved CHAD cache corruption and exact-revision repairs are infrastructure diagnostics, not mathematical failures. No WP03/WP04/MATHCERT closure.fyremael commentedon Nov 11, 2026
GCL-OAI26-F011/SEMANTIC-IDENTITY-BRIDGES-PROTECTED-MERGE-READBACK/1 — 2026-11-11T13:58Z
The two remaining external-to-GCL formal statement bridge obligations have been protected-merged and read back from exact Git blobs:
main@e1ee3957b54d4081bcbbda4bf3866056f41c935a: real-xfixed-δsmooth shifted-prime count -> GCL natural-xcount -> conditional GCL all-ε>0totient-fiber conclusion. SourceWP03_FAMILY011_EXTERNAL_REAL_TO_NAT_ADAPTER.leanblobfc4e394ccb55ce08ebb8dca21b29baa103a8374f; two Lean theorem axioms exactly[propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]; pinned Lean exit 0; nine hostile tests pass. This code mirrors, does not import, external supply theorem.main@3e83fd41c47b96a31ac7327f58182d7def60114e: externalg(n):=({m | Nat.totient m=n}).ncardequals GCLg(n)for every n>0; removes the exceptional singleton target{0}from infinite external conclusion; proves all-ε>0external Erdős 821 statement implies GCL all-ε>0positive-target statement. SourceWP03_FAMILY011_EXTERNAL_FIBER_COUNT_EQUIV.leanblobf649ebb960794a48e5668531fd38449f7a046fc0(SHA25630886e87944de53e0f681ccfe8d6d4a71bd5fe6607abe16e44b524bf3153c31c), exact upstreamopenai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a. All three new theorem axiom reports exactly[propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound], Lean exit 0 and 9/9 hostile custody tests pass. Required exact-head PR CI PASS; nonrequired Family342 jobs were pending at protected merge, not promoted to success. Verified protected readback of source, replay JSON, tests and CI routing file.LIVE EXTERNAL ANALYTIC PROOF REPLAY: One real Colab CPU worker
gcl-f011-xu-replay4-20261111, sessiongcl-f011-xu-replay4-20261111-a1, at source-locked checkpoint 2/4 and actively buildingcadamcat/totient-fibers-lean4@f75d4f2c2d6685a0547f17fa07240377aa2c2ed4. Read-only remote log downloaded at 13:58Z shows success through at least [8974/9924], no Lean compiler errors in currently visible log. Stage 3 full build and stage 4scripts/verify.shplusleanchecker --fresh Erdos821.Theoremare NOT YET TERMINAL. Active hourly automationOAI26 F011 Lean Closure(jobAutomation_018c525c56c48191b3d7ced4e2f95225) is bound to the same owned session with no duplicate claim.Disposition:
F011_FORMAL_EXTERNAL_TO_GCL_STATEMENT_AND_FIBER_EQUIVALENCE_COMPLETE / EXTERNAL_UNCONDITIONAL_ANALYTIC_KERNEL_REPLAY_PENDING. Both protected PRs resolve formal definition/quantifier conversion, not the external author's analytic proof review or MATHCERT certification. Retain WP03, WP04 and programme parent open for terminal independent kernel replay, source-to-formal criticism and governed proof acceptance. No external mathematical reviewer or new MATHCERT authority is claimed.