Skip to content

GCL OAI-26 WP03 — breadth-first manuscript-to-Lean theorem-semantic triage #332

Open

Description

@fyremael

WP03: executable zero-context assignment

Programme: grandchallenge/MATH-PROGRAMME#2850
Exact upstream: openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a; GCL catalog sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/, provider catalog/providers/OAI-MATH-1581D4CB.json. The provider is metadata-only SOURCE_LOCKED. GCL's original 372 families / 719 PDF links, crosswalk of 200 comparator/declaration pairs, publisher's 300 formalized top-line claims must not be conflated. Start by reading AGENTS.md and relevant issue evidence, reuse independent logical roles within existing authenticated identity, protected PRs only; no MATHCERT or research promotion. Return RESULT/1 with exact SHA, evidence, scoped disposition, reproducible commands, PR and protected readback.

Task: For each selected indexed family, compare the theorem actually claimed in the pinned/current manuscript edition against its corresponding pinned Lean theorem. Check ambient objects, hypotheses, quantifiers, conclusion, definitions, hidden assumptions, import dependencies, scope and manuscript version. Explicitly distinguish a displayed proposition match from full mathematical equivalence and distinguish unformalized from failed. Reference WP00 canonical family/declaration mapping and WP02 revision flags.

Pilot (twelve family IDs, not arbitrary cherry-picking): 001,002,003,004,005,006,007,008,009,010,011,012, including the prior preliminary 003 match. Verify each index entry exists. Family 342 is excluded from the first pilot because it already has a deep investigation; record it as legacy evidence requiring a separate closure verdict. After pilot, process risk-stratified cohorts <=24 families, selected from WP02 revision risk, high-impact, ambiguous and random baseline strata. Avoid lengthy theorem proving here.

Per-result classifications: FULL_SEMANTIC_MATCH_PROVED only with a proof of definition/model bridge, otherwise PROPOSITION_LEVEL_ALIGNMENT, ASSUMPTION_GAP, DEFINITION_GAP, VERSION_MISMATCH, UNFORMALIZED, UNRESOLVED. Include both positive and falsifying witnesses. Check imports; #print axioms is WP01's separate job.

Acceptance: all 12 pilot families have one source-edition-bound disposition (including UNRESOLVED when exact manuscript is missing), an independent critic-suitable evidence packet and explicit list of any blockers that actually affect the mathematical interpretation. Verify record coverage denominator; keep 003's pre-existing unbuilt observation preliminary until independently replayed. Subsequent wave selection must be reproducible and risk-stratified.

Terminal: SEMANTIC_PILOT_COMPLETE then bounded rolling cohorts; no campaign-wide theorem validation and no autonomous proof campaign.

RESULT format: RESULT/1\nASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03\nSOURCE_SHA: 1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a\nDISPOSITION: ...\nEXACT_HEAD: ...\nEVIDENCE: ...\nREPLAY: ...\nUNRESOLVED: ...\nCLAIM_BOUNDARY: NO_MATHCERT_CERTIFICATION. Do not mark a purported protected admission complete without independent readback.

Activity

  1. fyremael commented on Oct 25, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-OAI26-WP03/INTERIM-SEMANTIC-PILOT-003

    Exact source lock: openai/math@1581d4c.
    Source files and Git blobs:

    • lean/docs/003.md: cf794e93da2e1a494434153f5b91f2990fe9fd60
    • lean/OAI/NumberTheory/DirichletL/Nonvanishing.lean: 46c67f4000906b1391a471d6e6396ac0da3c16a5
    • lean/ComparatorChallenges/QuasiRiemannHypothesis.lean: e7d1caf6c579dc9afbf0d2b01f79e5cd2511b028
    • lean/ComparatorChallenges/QuasiRiemannHypothesis.json: acf552468fc23c1a27d685d33983c58c50040542

    Bounded direct source readback:

    1. Solution theorem OAI.riemannZeta_ne_zero_of_seven_eighths_lt_re quantifies arbitrary s : ℂ with (7/8 : ℝ) < s.re and concludes riemannZeta s ≠ 0. Comparator challenge exposes the literally same displayed statement. Comparator source has a 'sorry' challenge placeholder and is not executable proof evidence.
    2. Dirichlet solution theorem OAI.DirichletCharacter.LFunction_ne_zero_of_seven_eighths_lt_re quantifies q : ℕ with NeZero q, χ : DirichletCharacter ℂ q, s : ℂ; assumes 7/8 < s.re and ¬(χ = 1 ∧ s = 1), and concludes DirichletCharacter.LFunction χ s ≠ 0. The pole exclusion is explicit, not silently dropped.
    3. lean/docs/003.md attributes the wider family to both quasi-Riemann and uniform Landau–Siegel-zero papers; it additionally describes finite-order Hecke and uniform logarithmic real-zero gap, which are not verified by inspection of the two declarations above. The later paper applications are expressly not formalized according to that scope note.
    4. Both displayed zeta theorems align at the proposition/text syntax level; this says nothing about imported foundation/assembly soundness, exact Lean build or the truth of the paper's unstated auxiliary assumptions.

    Disposition: PROPOSITION_LEVEL_ALIGNMENT for the pinned zeta 7/8 statement only, DIRICHLET_POLE_EXCEPTION_PRESERVED in identified solution file; REPLAY_NOT_PERFORMED; FAMILY_003_FULL_SEMANTICS_UNRESOLVED; CERTIFICATION_NONE.

    Falsification/replay checks: compile solution module under exact Lean 4.34.1/manifest; query full theorem axioms; separately inspect the Dirichlet, Hecke and Siegel comparator statements; compare all manuscript theorem hypotheses, especially quantification and poles, to imported foundation declarations. Preserve any mismatch by edition/commit, do not promote an entire family from this source-only sample.

  2. fyremael commented on Oct 29, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F005
    SOURCE_SHA: openai/math@1581d4c
    DISPOSITION: FAMILY005_PRINCIPAL_PROPOSITION_LEVEL_ALIGNMENT_PROTECTED_ADMITTED_NOT_CERTIFIED
    LINKED_PR: #397
    EXACT_CANDIDATE: b5646bf
    PROTECTED_MERGE: 6cc18c5
    PROTECTED_MAIN_READBACK: exact match 6cc18c5
    LEDGER: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY005_CATALAN_SEMANTIC_REVIEW.json Git blob f266276d11ab260be7e63f2ee10724e91cca5335, exact merge and current protected main same Git object
    REVIEW: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY005_CATALAN_SEMANTIC_REVIEW.md Git blob 163af0554698cc015c39f37572fe0ad64f3589d1
    TEST: tests/test_openai_math_wp03_family005.py Git blob 1c399af6a572e9f77da1992fc20b1b72595b9733
    REPLAY: Focused candidate test 2/2 PASS incl positive provenance and 10 hostile corruption/overclaim controls; JSON parse, py_compile, git diff --check PASS at exact candidate SHA. Four required candidate CI contexts policy / policy, security / action-policy, routing-enforcement, reconnaissance SUCCESS. Candidate CodeQL and Analyze checks also SUCCESS at last observed candidate.
    PAPER: Pinned 44-page paper.pdf blob ecbe60eb89d2d25c1d07da6232f8d9869e6c0c1d, SHA256 4023d0344abceb79dc46a16380dac3a662193f9d4f23e6c340b2162068b04c0e. Principal Theorem 1.1 on PDF p1; manuscript proof conclusion on p42, cross-checked original introduction/conclusion TeX. Both manuscript and Lean theorem assert irrationality of the same sum G=sum_{j>=0}(-1)^j/(2j+1)^2 with no additional displayed hypotheses.
    LEAN: Exact theorem OAI.InternalCatalan.catalan_irrational from Results/Conclusions.lean Git blob a21cbc0e56a4e71ec21ce765b16e6ef0adb864f0; selected Comparator config Catalan.json Git blob 78b89138b45ecbe09c061b25c2e2f6177ffd4b9b; challenge file Git blob f7941ef960ec9d0ec745f15f2ee7b2ff46bd6058 has intentional sorry placeholder, not the actual source proof.
    ADVERSARIAL: Nonauthoring read-only critic found unreviewed manuscript geometric volume consequences, unproved model/definition bridge, and unverified imported-axiom and actual Comparator replay. No claim that an error-bound lemma name establishes a manuscript error.
    CROSSWALK: Family005 is in 372-family index, with its own formalization and comparator; not among the distinct 200-main-result/173-source-paper crosswalk, so WP01 200-row replay evidence must NOT be inherited. No evidence counts inflated.
    CLAIM_BOUNDARY: PROPOSITION_LEVEL_ALIGNMENT_ONLY; NO_FULL_SEMANTIC_MATCH, NO_MATHCERT_CERTIFICATION, NO_COMPARATOR_OR_AXIOM_REPLAY, NO_NOVELTY_ASSERTION, NO_GEOMETRIC_COROLLARY_ACCEPTANCE.
    POSTMERGE: GCL conformance 40955560052 SUCCESS; Forge checks 40955559507 and Push on main 40955558598 were in_progress at initial post-merge check, terminal results NOT YET CLAIMED.
    UNRESOLVED: WP03 parent #332 open; 11 other families in first semantic pilot plus full independent semantic proof/model bridge as appropriate. This completed case does not close WP03 or MATHFORGE entire 2026 campaign.

  3. fyremael commented on Oct 29, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-POST-MERGE-CI-READBACK/1
    ASSIGNMENT: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F005
    PREDECESSOR_RECEIPT: #332 (comment)
    EXACT_PROTECTED_MERGE_AND_MAIN: 6cc18c5 (PR #397); independently reread main matches.
    TERMINAL_CI_AT_EXACT_MERGE: GCL conformance run 40955560052 SUCCESS; Forge checks run 40955559507 SUCCESS; Push on main run 40955558598 SUCCESS.
    PROTECTED_BLOBS: semantic ledger f266276d11ab260be7e63f2ee10724e91cca5335; critic report 163af0554698cc015c39f37572fe0ad64f3589d1; focused hostile test 1c399af6a572e9f77da1992fc20b1b72595b9733. All exact-merge retrieved.
    DISPOSITION: FAMILY005_PROPOSITION_ALIGNMENT_BOUNDARY_COMPLETE. Only narrow principal theorem-source match admitted, not full proof/semantic equivalence or MATHCERT certification; WP03 pilot remains open for other 11 families.

  4. fyremael commented on Oct 29, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F008
    DISPOSITION: PROPOSITION_LEVEL_ALIGNMENT_PROTECTED_ADMITTED
    SOURCE: openai/math@1581d4c
    MANUSCRIPT: The Deligne–Drinfeld conjecture (2026-09-23), 41-page pinned PDF SHA256 5ae63f326803a634e7c6dc5684ce7062ea0ac6940a88a75c7052875382dbc762; Theorem 1.1 PDF page 2 and proof PDF page 40 inspected.
    LEAN: OAI.DeligneDrinfeld.main with MainStatement from Foundations.lean; rational odd-weight graded free Lie algebra solution space, Ihara bracket and continuous completion are proposition-level aligned.
    WP01_PREEXISTING_EVIDENCE: index 38, pinned run 40490625900, build_exit=0, axioms_exit=0, extra_axioms=[]; no Comparator acceptance inferred or re-executed in this case.
    LINKED_PR: #404
    EXACT_CANDIDATE: 8b91d4d
    PROTECTED_MERGE_AND_MAIN_READBACK: 80ce793
    LEDGER: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY008_DELIGNE_DRINFELD_SEMANTIC_REVIEW.json blob 59e6f0c8f4a84e64789f8df3a478bb804e684295
    REVIEW: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY008_DELIGNE_DRINFELD_SEMANTIC_REVIEW.md blob bcd1503e1b703f524afab7e811e2e487d145cfcb
    TEST: tests/test_openai_math_wp03_family008.py blob 5a18886c5a3eeddc39b527727c7f871809d0ef85; positive and eleven hostile mutation fixtures PASS on pre-correction exact branch revision; change thereafter confined to explanatory source-file count; required candidate CI SUCCESS.
    POSTMERGE_EXACT_SHA: GCL conformance 40973339612 SUCCESS; Forge checks 40973339155 SUCCESS; Push on main 40973339484 SUCCESS.
    CLAIM_BOUNDARY: family008 principal-proposition semantic comparison only, NOT entire manuscript equivalence, actual Comparator success, graph-complex corollary acceptance or MATHCERT certification. WP03 #332 OPEN for other pilot families.

  5. fyremael commented on Oct 29, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F007
    DISPOSITION: BOUNDED_THREE_RESULT_STATEMENT_ALIGNMENT_PROTECTED_ADMITTED_NOT_CERTIFIED
    LINKED_PR: #406
    EXACT_CANDIDATE: 80c3bbd
    EXACT_PROTECTED_MERGE: 254d0ef
    PROTECTED_MAIN_READBACK: same exact merge commit at initial check.
    SOURCE: openai/math@1581d4c; 87-page manuscript final.pdf SHA256 ccb6f339a7505db7ab158dae4b739164ed8dda32be4012b0310198dd32f5c70a; PDF source Git blob a1fa025a59ecbfc5176d16cfdc6e0afd418cc82e.
    REVIEWED: Three displayed manuscript claims matched to Lean theorem signatures OAI.OrdinaryTwoPointCorrelations.liouville_log_saving, OAI.OrdinaryTwoPointCorrelations.binary_corrected_elliott, OAI.OrdinaryTwoPointCorrelations.affine_corrected_elliott. Separate quantitative and qualitative claims retained. Ordinary (not logarithmically weighted) averages, positive slopes, affine nonproportionality, and uniform nonpretentiousness conditions preserved.
    PROTECTED_LEDGER: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY007_ORDINARY_CORRELATIONS_REVIEW.json blob 2a8e449e7bb5e7bbaa4a6a067f1c5c3da61ddc80.
    PROTECTED_TEST: tests/test_openai_math_wp03_family007.py blob e0c2303e12b62c888d4181cd9f01b9f945d2c3cc; focused two test methods PASS, including eight hostile mutations. Four required candidate checks (policy, security, routing, reconnaissance) SUCCESS at exact candidate before protected squash merge.
    BOUNDARY: This work does NOT prove complete imported Lean definitions or full manuscript proof correspondence, does NOT execute or claim Comparator PASS, does NOT certify mathematical truth or novelty, and does NOT close WP03 #332.
    POSTMERGE: GCL conformance 40976235460, Forge checks 40976234862, Push on main 40976234683 were still running at initial readback; terminal status not yet claimed.

  6. fyremael commented on Oct 29, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-POSTMERGE-CI-READBACK/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F007
    PREDECESSOR: #332 (comment)
    EXACT_PROTECTED_MERGE: 254d0ef
    EXACT_MAIN_READBACK: 254d0ef
    TERMINAL_POSTMERGE_CI: GCL conformance 40976235460 SUCCESS; Forge checks 40976234862 SUCCESS; Push on main 40976234683 SUCCESS.
    ADMITTED: Family 007 three displayed manuscript-result/Lean-theorem signature alignments, source-pinned, bounded, not full semantic equivalence or certification. WP03 parent #332 remains OPEN.

  7. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F012
    DISPOSITION: FAMILY012_PROPOSITION_LEVEL_ALIGNMENT_PROTECTED_ADMITTED
    SOURCE: openai/math@1581d4c, manuscript "The joint Dickman law for consecutive integers", edition September 24 2026.
    EVIDENCE_PR: #416
    EXACT_CANDIDATE: 5d7d5b6
    PROTECTED_MERGE_AND_INITIAL_MAIN_READBACK: 90eb3fa
    LEDGER: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY012_DICKMAN_SEMANTIC_REVIEW.json Git blob 7f7ad96bd8e710051b19039d245d66aa8c2710bb
    TEST: tests/test_openai_math_wp03_family012.py Git blob 140b5f5ebabf5eeddff294ef9ceb7c7544fa546b; one positive and eight hostile mutation fixtures PASS locally on exact PR head.
    RESULTS: manuscript joint ordinary-natural-density theorem for 2<=n<=X at real cutoffs, both thresholds n^a and n^b, fixed a,b in (0,1), Dickman marginal product; two strict ordering half-density conclusions; source-aligned to OAI.JointDickmanPaper.joint_law, increasing_order, decreasing_order. Pinned proof source blob ccc0cf7b37c5163324aec1a6b91dd9efd22d7aec; Comparator config blob 7267219acc9f42d882a8704c66c94435235d5b9c.
    GOVERNANCE: protected candidate checks security / action-policy, policy / policy, routing-enforcement, reconnaissance all SUCCESS; squash protected merged, readback verified.
    POSTMERGE: GCL conformance 41012184164, Forge checks 41012183405, Push on main 41012182750 in progress on initial observation; no terminal CI claim yet.
    CLAIM_BOUNDARY: bounded principal proposition statements only; NOT full imported definition/semantic equivalence, proof-verification equivalence, Comparator execution, mathematical truth certification, novelty evaluation or whole 12-family WP03 closure.
    UNRESOLVED: other pilot families and deeper semantic bridge.

  8. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-POSTMERGE-CI-READBACK/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F012
    PREDECESSOR: #332 (comment)
    EXACT_PROTECTED_MERGE: 90eb3fa
    EXACT_MAIN_READBACK: 90eb3fa
    TERMINAL_POSTMERGE: GCL conformance 41012184164 SUCCESS; Forge checks 41012183405 SUCCESS; Push on main 41012182750 SUCCESS.
    BOUNDARY: family012 displayed proposition-level review complete; no full mathematical semantic equivalence/Comparator execution/certification; other WP03 families remain open.

  9. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F009
    DISPOSITION: PARTIAL_MAIN_THEOREM_COVERAGE_INJECTIVITY_ONLY_PROTECTED_ADMITTED
    EVIDENCE_PR: #417
    EXACT_CANDIDATE: a933d9e
    EXACT_PROTECTED_MERGE_AND_MAIN_READBACK: 79064cd
    SOURCE: openai/math@1581d4c. 2026-09-23 Bogomolov–Pop manuscript 26 pages, original PDF SHA256 4d805627401fffef78e1f0d8e21a0585f6c733e8be90643d0065cd27ffaa24f2. Original source introduction Git blob a1b052285ded0ec86649397e97f8509c56fa561a.
    MATHEMATICAL_BOUNDARY: The manuscript's central theorem says the canonical correspondence is BIJECTIVE, including existence/surjectivity and uniqueness/injectivity. The selected Comparator theorem OAI.BogomolovPop.main_graph_injective in upstream Lean solution blob 13e184237fe9ba63a29a37759380186b3966edac establishes only the INJECTIVITY component under its listed assumptions; no selected surjectivity statement. The two other family 009 papers have not been reviewed in this unit.
    PROTECTED_LEDGER: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY009_BOGOMOLOV_POP_PARTIAL_REVIEW.json Git blob bbecd08ebc9a7f7ca3fd2e7e2036e10ff0084780.
    PROTECTED_TEST: tests/test_openai_math_wp03_family009.py Git blob 62339291b76a9bd4441bee09d1c7e6d676f54d0c; contains one positive and ten hostile falsification fixtures. CHAD local test execution repeatedly failed due to intermittent CONTROL transport: local PASS is NOT claimed. Candidate required security/policy/routing/reconnaissance checks SUCCESS; CodeQL and analysis checks also SUCCESS.
    POSTMERGE_TERMINAL: GCL conformance run 41014581535 SUCCESS; Forge checks run 41014581076 SUCCESS; Push on main run 41014580618 SUCCESS at exact protected merge commit. Separate Comparator workflow 41014798525 in progress and unrelated to this semantic-review claim.
    CLAIM_BOUNDARY: NO complete manuscript equivalence, NO surjectivity proof, NO actual Comparator acceptance claimed, NO full imported-model bridge, NO MATHCERT certification, NO complete family 009 coverage. Parent WP03 #332 remains OPEN; recover surjectivity/source bridge and review other two family 009 manuscripts.

  10. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F001
    DISPOSITION: UNFORMALIZED_IN_PINNED_INDEXED_COMPARATOR_SCOPE (bounded negative-index finding)
    SOURCE: openai/math@1581d4c, Milne's rationality conjecture manuscript 2026-10-07, 36-page PDF Git blob 3780abc1f47a23e546f28190bd3db7b24419f1f9, PDF SHA256 640701a0ea8d8026d2f019e571e052f2d106cad3f5216cf6f7fca0d643873234.
    RESULT: Manuscript Theorem asserts rational common intersection trace of specialized rational Hodge class against complementary divisors across ℓ-adic and crystalline realizations. Not the stronger algebraicity assertion.
    SCOPE CHECK: No lean/docs/001.md in pinned upstream; no Milne/Hodge/rationality mapping among the 200 main-result declaration crosswalk; no named Milne/Hodge/rationality/specialization file in 833-file ComparatorChallenges directory. This does NOT establish that no corresponding Lean theorem exists under an unrelated name.
    EVIDENCE_PR: #418
    EXACT_CANDIDATE: 798ae47
    PROTECTED_MERGE_AND_MAIN_READBACK: 8a31c14
    LEDGER: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY001_MILNE_INDEXED_COVERAGE.json blob 3bff24bfde28b5f6e07ea16922a6971874006cad.
    TEST: tests/test_openai_math_wp03_family001.py blob 77a4a1e39670eb3d26b588b096ae85176bc0b7b4. Positive/hostile code committed; local execution NOT verified because CHAD tool unavailable.
    CANDIDATE_ADMISSION: policy / policy, security / action-policy, routing-enforcement and reconnaissance all success, protected squash merge completed.
    POSTMERGE: GCL conformance run 41016477180 SUCCESS; Forge checks 41016476948 and Push on main 41016476894 not terminal at initial readback.
    BOUNDARY: bounded indexed coverage lookup only, not proof absence of any formalization, not manuscript-to-Lean equivalence, not mathematical certification. Parent #332 OPEN.

  11. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-POSTMERGE-CI-READBACK/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F001
    PREDECESSOR: #332 (comment)
    EXACT_PROTECTED_MERGE: 8a31c14
    EXACT_MAIN_READBACK: 8a31c14
    TERMINAL_POSTMERGE: GCL conformance 41016477180 SUCCESS; Forge checks 41016476948 SUCCESS; Push on main 41016476894 SUCCESS.
    DISPOSITION: bounded family001 indexed comparator mapping absent, NOT a proved absence of all Lean formalization or a mathematical certification. Remaining family pilot obligations continue.

  12. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI-26-WP03/F006
    DISPOSITION: UNFORMALIZED_IN_PINNED_INDEXED_COMPARATOR_SCOPE (bounded source-index coverage review)
    SOURCE: openai/math@1581d4c.
    MANUSCRIPTS: Goldfeld analytic density conjecture and 2-converse, 2026-10-07, pinned PDF Git blob 58b8904f39b2a12534732010191fd35435559a61; Mean analytic rank of quadratic twists, 2026-10-06, pinned PDF Git blob fef228e3a2a26c0b1302fbd6f85de0da1c87a3ba.
    SUBSTANTIVE REVIEW: First manuscript claims equality of full 2-power Selmer corank 0/1, analytic rank and Mordell–Weil rank plus finiteness of Sha, and half-density each of analytic ranks 0 and 1 among signed squarefree twists. Second asserts mean analytic rank 1/2 and separately requires control of the rank-weighted high-rank tail; half-density alone is insufficient. These are not silently conflated.
    INDEXED COVERAGE: Family 006 in manuscript index, two source manuscripts; no pinned upstream lean/docs/006.md, no identified mapped main-result or Goldfeld-named Comparator within scoped indexes. This does NOT establish absence of all formalization under other names.
    PROTECTED_ADMISSION: #420 ; candidate 7e2062a ; exact protected merge/main readback 93c0b33.
    LEDGER: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY006_GOLDFELD_INDEXED_COVERAGE.json Git blob b4756c3b6d7239adcd7b0771033ced9803352402.
    TEST: tests/test_openai_math_wp03_family006.py Git blob 9f3e8c60b7c2fbf8ade42d178b97965f4f0700bf; local pytest 1/1 PASS on exact PR head via authenticated CHAD.
    GOVERNANCE: Four required candidate checks policy, security, routing, reconnaissance SUCCESS; protected squash merged. Postmerge GCL conformance 41019728375, Forge checks 41019727753, Push on main 41019727266 initially running, no false terminal success claim.
    BOUNDARY: no complete paper-to-Lean equivalence, no Comparator execution or MATHCERT certification. Remaining unreviewed pilot families 002/003/004/010/011. Family 009 remains partial. Parent WP03 #332 remains open.

  13. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-POSTMERGE-CI-READBACK/1 — WP03/F006. PR #420 protected merge 93c0b33. Exact postmerge results: GCL conformance 41019728375 SUCCESS; Forge checks 41019727753 SUCCESS; Push on main 41019727266 SUCCESS. Family006 indexed-scope review complete; no full theorem correspondence or certification claimed. Parent WP03 #332 stays open.

  14. 9 remaining items

  15. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-POSTMERGE-CI-READBACK/1 — WP03/F011. Prior RESULT/1 issue comment 6519557382. Protected merge and exact main readback 9eb0f43. Terminal exact-head workflows GCL conformance 41034164191 SUCCESS, Forge checks 41034163582 SUCCESS, Push on main 41034162558 SUCCESS. Twelve of twelve initial pilot family reviews protected-admitted, not twelve fully verified theorem-level equivalences or certifications. Parent WP03 #332 remains OPEN for deeper semantic review and residual indexed gaps.

  16. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1 WP03/F011-DEEP-NEIGHBOR. PR #430 protected-merged at exact main 8c41bc2, candidate a36282d. Four pinned named Comparator configs and matching Lean source modules inspected: TotientAsymptotic concerns asymptotic totient distributions, TotientCompanionZero is a companion zero case not established as family011's fiber-growth theorem, SmoothObstruction concerns ergodic smooth-volume models, SmoothInitialForm is a determinantal algebra theorem. None is evidenced as an exact prime-predecessor smoothness, PD(1), parity or totient-fiber main theorem. Ledger sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY011_NEIGHBOR_DECLARATION_DISAMBIGUATION.json blob dad09d438a351cbace5fd3761ca8193107a44581; test blob 58fe399cbcb52ff495e6856fd9c207b0a6a66533; postmerge exact-head local tests 2 PASS including eight hostile mutations. Required protected PR checks SUCCESS. No complete semantic match, no claim that unindexed formalization is absent, no certification. Parent WP03 #332 OPEN. Postmerge workflows 41035513564,41035513166,41035512787 initially running.

  17. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-POSTMERGE-CI-READBACK/1 — WP03/F011-DEEP-NEIGHBOR; predecessor issue comment 6519830946. Protected merge and exact main readback 8c41bc2. Terminal postmerge exact-head workflows: Forge checks 41035513166 SUCCESS; GCL conformance 41035513564 SUCCESS; Push on main 41035512787 SUCCESS. Additional exact-merge local unittest positive and eight hostile fixtures PASS. Four superficial Comparator neighbors now dispositioned as not evidenced source-proposition matches; actual family011 semantic formalization remains unmatched and WP03 #332 remains OPEN.

  18. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1 — WP03/F011 actual unindexed theorem search. PR #431 protected merged at exact main 38007b1; exact candidate b819c50. Pinned openai/math@1581d4c includes unindexed OAI.TotientFibers.g and lemmas in lean/OAI/NumberTheory/TotientFibers/FiniteFiber.lean blob 217cfe4d7f9c39981eabe9bbeeb8458febb0fc76. Formal infinitude theorem totient_large_fibers_of_one_le requires epsilon >=1, while manuscript main totient-fiber theorem requires every epsilon>0, including 0<epsilon<1. Theorem-level support is PARTIAL, not a full match. Conditional finite_pigeonhole is not proof of unconditional smooth-prime supply. Evidence ledger blob 369343a5a133d29b1f403cf186d4cb79b1c14b59; corrected test blob 47ffc0d21bc7cd3b99e9f06a7ea6461da461a186. Initial reconnaissance CI failed due to regression-test field lookup; exact candidate corrected and local positive/hostile unittest 2 PASS, required PR checks all SUCCESS before protected merge. Postmerge GCL conformance 41040788433, Forge checks 41040787961, Push on main 41040787076 initially running. No certification; WP03 #332 OPEN.

  19. fyremael commented on Oct 30, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    WP03 F011 postmerge readback: protected main 38007b1. GCL conformance 41040788433 SUCCESS, Forge checks 41040787961 SUCCESS, Push on main 41040787076 SUCCESS. PR 431 identifies partial TotientFibers support; epsilon>=1 does not establish all epsilon>0. Parent remains open.

  20. fyremael commented on Nov 10, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    RESULT/1 — OAI26 WP03/Family011 fixed-delta analytic-to-Lean supply parameter bridge. Protected MATHFORGE PR #545 merged at exact commit 6b5aa11cfd1c4f0cc0c45928a9cc7716a9d7ef0d; exact merged files read back: sources/OPENAI-MATH-2026/WP03_FAMILY011_PRIME_SUPPLY_PARAMETER_BRIDGE.md blob 026f41831443959347a4d2b8bfaf9e78d7d2a933, deterministic/hostile tests tests/test_openai_math_wp03_f011_parameter_bridge.py blob 69679cab07b64d1f93b09e318275d5ce6ab63eff, CI ownership manifest blob 9bfeb5543ab8ec72b1a0535f4b018d469517dcd5. Mathematical reduction: choose integer a≥max(6,ceil(4/ε)), fixed δ=(2a−1)/(2a(a−1)), η=1/(4a). Then aδ>1 and δ(a−1)=1−2η, so for sufficiently large x the manuscript-asserted prime set P(x,δ) with count x^(1−o(1)) yields t=ceil(x^δ), 5x≤t^a, t^(a−1)<x^(1−η)≤|P|, t≥a,T, and every prime divisor of p−1 at most t. Hence if the manuscript's prime-count assertion is valid, this supplies the explicit PrimeSupplyForExponent ε hypothesis of the Lean-checked conditional theorem from PR #544. No uniformity as δ→0 is assumed. This parameter implication was independently reviewed as a separate logical pass PR #545 comment 6767455527; seven source-bound arithmetic and hostile tests passed locally, all required PR checks (replay, reconnaissance, routing, security, policy, CodeQL) passed; nonrequired Family 342 comparator and family jobs were still pending on last readback. Unresolved: the source manuscript's analytical smooth-shifted-prime count has not been independently proved or critically authenticated; the count→supply asymptotic implication remains an informal mathematical derivation not Lean-kernel checked. Therefore no unconditional Family011 theorem equivalence, MATHCERT certification, WP03 closure or programme closure is justified. Next executable mathematical obligations: formalize fixed δ and eventual-count input in Lean, and independently scrutinize the source's analytic proof.

  21. fyremael commented on Nov 10, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-OAI26-WP03/FAMILY011-COMPLETE-ASYMPTOTIC-IMPLICATION-LEAN-REPLAY/1

    Disposition: COMPLETE_CONDITIONAL_COUNT_TO_SUPPLY_AND_FIBER_IMPLICATION_FORMALIZED / ANALYTIC_PRIME_COUNT_UNPROVED.

    Protected admission: MATHFORGE PR #546 merged on 2026-11-10 at protected commit 6259760a3f7e4a7d3f33f7196176fc6e8da914a1; exact-commit readback confirms:

    • Lean proof, Git blob 1488cd48e97c30bb7ca907e485d27d002c101902; SHA256 15e1690a19be5b319184225da89b0f99be23f867cd388c7323aad04a569490a5;
    • Machine replay and axiom receipt, Git blob 1c36a01e9ddd507b6b08ebb324e5897b5293ee9d;
    • source-integrity hostile test blob aaeacef8449bdfd18d832a95646ad687e4225a9c, receipt-custody hostile test blob 4a3008068bd3eddd93552be1280429e50f4769d5; CI owner blob 1afa9acc6cba76034910cbf6892700083065275c.

    Exact pins: upstream openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a; Lean leanprover/lean4:v4.34.1, Mathlib d13f23b723b8a846827a245b89c10fc7d3f11612, Lake manifest SHA256 cf6105a25d9dca2f166b241d9191bd12c7e13305890dc9c4d0952351cccc0794. CHAD exact-source replay 2026-11-10T15:28:15Z→15:28:24Z returned LEAN_EXIT 0 and no errors; audit log SHA256 ca936bcd601c58cfeb9c352f4f4b308569d01880ed48ae7fd97f151208c47666. #print axioms for both GCL.OAI26.Family011.prime_supply_of_smooth_count and GCL.OAI26.Family011.infinite_fibers_of_smooth_count reports [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound] only. Source has no sorry, admit or new axiom. All 15/15 exact-source/receipt hostile tests passed locally. Protected GitHub routing, reconnaissance, policy, security, CodeQL and code-analysis checks passed; several longer-running (Family 342 and general replay) CI jobs were still pending at last postmerge readback and are not falsely marked complete.

    What Lean proves: SmoothPrimeCount explicitly assumes that for every fixed 0<δ<1/4, every η>0, and all sufficiently large natural x, the finite set of primes 2x<p≤5x whose prime divisors of p-1 are ≤x^δ has size at least x^(1-η). Lean proves that assumption implies PrimeSupplyForExponent ε for any ε>0, using a≥6, aε≥4, c=a²−1, δ=a/c, η=1/c, x=N^c, t=N^a; it then proves infinitely many n>0 satisfy g(n)>n^(1−ε), with the old ε≥1 theorem covering that range. This now covers the entire formal asymptotic reduction, not merely its finite combinatorial part.

    Unresolved mathematical boundary: The manuscript's analytic smooth-shifted-prime lower count is an unproved external hypothesis in this formalization. There has been no independent complete proof-and-literature validation of that count, no full primary-paper semantic certification or MATHCERT acceptance. Refrain from saying the manuscript's unconditional totient-fiber claim has been proved by GCL. WP03 remains open for the independent analytic and source-semantics audit and other families. The role-based critical review PR #546 comment 6771568344 is a separate logical audit by the same authenticated operator, not an externally independent researcher.

  22. fyremael commented on Nov 11, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-OAI26-WP03/F011-EXTERNAL-INDEPENDENT-FORMALIZATION-INTAKE/1 — SOURCE-PINNED, PRELIMINARY, NONCERTIFYING

    New independent candidate: Yao Xu (@cadamcat), cadamcat/totient-fibers-lean4, HEAD f75d4f2c2d6685a0547f17fa07240377aa2c2ed4; v1.0.0 verified source commit dfce35707a67fce7362cb2bd95af8b80a0b0373e. The repository includes 939 mathematical Lean modules; no sorry, admit, fresh axiom, opaque, unsafe, partial, native_decide or extern match found in mathematical modules by the bounded static audit. The only Lean file diff since v1.0.0 is documentation in Erdos821/Challenge.lean; verified mathematical modules unchanged. This scan is not kernel verification.

    Exact theorem: Erdos821/Supply.lean, blob f69b9e229635324ac6dde085cf92254c8082a3f5, defines SmoothShiftedPrimeSupply: for all fixed real 0<δ<1/4, σ>0, eventually over real x the Finset.Ioc ⌊2x⌋₊ ⌊5x⌋₊ of primes whose every prime divisor of p-1 is at most x^δ has cardinality at least x^(1-σ). Erdos821/Final/Assembly.lean blob 8216cca9bc541c22efbe3c50e3c699f99a85edb8 assembles ten specified packages from concrete proofs into Erdos821.Final.supply : SmoothShiftedPrimeSupply; Erdos821/Theorem.lean blob 0d4c86cc63e1fc44e506a7fa688ea4bdbcaf0623 defines the unconditional Erdos821.erdos_821 from that supply.

    Release verification claimed by original author: docs/verification.md, blob 6a4f16a3c04bd89b04d83fa8e2c329a88736099d, reports 2026-10-14 9,940-job lake build success, lake env leanchecker --fresh Erdos821.Theorem exit 0, nanoda + default kernel Comparator acceptance and axioms [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound] for Erdos821.erdos_821. GCL has not yet reproduced those external build/checker claims. Google DeepMind formal-conjectures PR #7314 merged 2026-10-22, labeling #821 solved and linking the proof, but does not itself substitute for GCL source-level audit.

    Source revision and custody reconciliation: the external proof depends on openai/math@adc7f1241b42e322a6451854ab7e4b4c146bf78a, older than GCL's 1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a. All eight manuscript section blobs, build/paper.tex, and bibliography match exactly between those two commits (10/10); the manuscript source is identical. Mathlib pin d13f23b723b8a846827a245b89c10fc7d3f11612 equals GCL's pinned Mathlib revision.

    Actual GCL reproduction in progress: authenticated CHAD read-only clone at /home/jim/gcl-evidence/OAI26-F011/totient-independent; exact HEAD f75d..., original manifest SHA256 8df0747916e81c4d13f3ed226a6ffa5dd04760ffc13668241d603a3595c634cf. Durable log /home/jim/gcl-evidence/OAI26-F011/independent_replay/run.log, running lake update at this checkpoint, to continue patch, cache, build, verification and fresh checker. No PASS or new theorem acceptance is claimed before those exact-run outputs. An independent semantic adapter proof checking real-x to natural-x count is also being compiled locally; no success claimed yet.

    Current disposition: INDEPENDENT_LEAN_ANALYTIC_PROOF_CANDIDATE_FOUND / SOURCE_CUSTODY_MATCH / GCL_FRESH_REPLAY_PENDING. The prior GCL PR #546 remains a valid conditional implication, but the "analytic premise entirely unformalized externally" description must no longer be repeated. Do not overwrite historical GCL evidence, mark WP03 terminal, or claim external reviewer certification on this preliminary intake.

  23. fyremael commented on Nov 11, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    OAI26 F011 source-provenance intake protected-merges: MATHFORGE PR #547 into main@24f340903ff3b25a3b18a3a777ac7c1a49ae1cb6 on 2026-11-11. Exact protected readback confirms machine record Git blob 01dbbe3262bc73864f22f1f5c1f93686de96dac1, hostile tests blob 99a2c3988001cc6a29c4cdb46f969176761b096d, ownership blob e7af189dfa0a902523cba5521ee2da6937790a6e. Nine hostile/source-custody checks pass, GitHub PR checks all terminal PASS (replay, routing, reconnaissance, policy/security, CodeQL, Family342). Independent external author Yao Xu’s cadamcat/totient-fibers-lean4@f75d4f2c... provides a 939-module proof candidate of SmoothShiftedPrimeSupply and unconditional erdos_821. Ten primary manuscript Git blobs unchanged between external upstream openai/math@adc7f124... and GCL pinned @1581d4cb.... Author-reported 9,940-job Lean build, leanchecker and Comparator acceptance are not yet GCL-reproduced. Fresh exact-pinned CHAD reproduction now active at independent_replay/replay_v2.log after recovery from tunnel failure; semantic external real-x to GCL natural-x adapter separately under Lean checking. No GCL kernel PASS or full scientific certification is asserted yet; WP03 and WP04 remain open for actual reproducibility and source-to-formal critical acceptance.

  24. fyremael commented on Nov 11, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-OAI26-F011/INDEPENDENT-LEAN-CLOUD-REPLAY-STARTED/1 — Current bounded action following protected CONTROL #69: CHAD CONTROL Colab supervisor switched to exact merged code CONTROL@a3a945df16be06a54bbf85fe05d3d3820ce7b416 via guarded Colab-only cutover on 2026-11-11T11:46:13Z. Full pinned UV test suite 572 PASS, Colab supervisor 24/24 targeted tests and GitHub CI pass. Guarded cutover confirms one versioned service parent 26819 and worker PID 26828, fresh source hash c550d3384c07c51955781cfeea6edad7d4fc8ab925119bd36742459cf4203626, and unchanged CONTROL tunnel PIDs 5449/5462/5463 and active symlink to previous tunnel release. Earlier cloud jobs gcl-f011-xu-lean-20261111 and gcl-f011-xu-replay2-20261111 remain RECOVERY_REQUIRED, their named sessions independently confirmed ABSENT. A new uniquely identified governed CPU session really exists: GCL supervisor job gcl-f011-xu-replay3-20261111 / session gcl-f011-xu-replay3-20261111-a1 is CHECKPOINTED at step 1 with verified custody and ledger integrity; worker source SHA256 b59514f20bfac10723803e931b448a57fd300493a9626136f216443c4e0e94ba. Downloaded actual cloud worker log demonstrates successful elan install, Lean v4.34.1 toolchain installation, exact Git checkout of cadamcat/totient-fibers-lean4@f75d4f2c2d6685a0547f17fa07240377aa2c2ed4, and checkpoint 1. Current step: Lake dependency update, with live remote evidence of cloned pinned packages; no build/verification/leanchecker success yet. Distinguish independently executed cloud runtime from independent mathematical reviewer: same GCL operator prepared/executed the replay. The external source proof’s 9,940-job author-reported success remains unpromoted until GCL fresh kernel evidence. Preserved CHAD cache corruption and exact-revision repairs are infrastructure diagnostics, not mathematical failures. No WP03/WP04/MATHCERT closure.

  25. fyremael commented on Nov 11, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-OAI26-F011-INDEPENDENT-EXTERNAL-LEAN-REPLAY/LIVE-CHECKPOINT-2/4

    Exact external worker: gcl-f011-xu-replay4-20261111, owned remote Colab session gcl-f011-xu-replay4-20261111-a1, CHAD supervisor job ce810b94ca684c9b9228c8cceb619586, pinned worker SHA-256 a410b203c934da98aa6c03a6dde8f1bbb8eca7ba272962e77216f3a39ab160b3. Worker is a real separate CPU runtime (not a simulated controller test); authenticated Colab status returned session ID m-s-usc1a7-bt69ljaw2q15 and PROCESS readback verified active /usr/bin/python3 worker PID 576 with active Lake and Lean child processes. Original external proof revision cadamcat/totient-fibers-lean4@f75d4f2c2d6685a0547f17fa07240377aa2c2ed4, Lake manifest SHA-256 8df0747916e81c4d13f3ed226a6ffa5dd04760ffc13668241d603a3595c634cf; Mathlib d13f23b723b8a846827a245b89c10fc7d3f11612.

    Verified progress: remote checkpoint 2/4 hash 95b00888dc6acaa74b010985de926fd8982e2a59c346d97c8732131e74510ab4, retained by supervisor. Exact-pinned checkout/Lean toolchain and packages established; lake exe cache get exited 0. Real remote build log downloaded read-only to CHAD from /content/gcl_colab_job/build.log; it contains passing outputs through [8948/9025], including Erdos821 sieve/candidate/Fourier separation modules, plus ordinary compiler warnings. Independent Colab process readback confirms live lake build Erdos821 Challenge Verification and multiple active Lean elaboration processes. No mathematical failure has been reported, but the build and leanchecker --fresh Erdos821.Theorem are still pending.

    Recovery history: earlier replay3 worker reached a source-pin checkpoint but stopped on a documented Lake update failure; its owned session was released with verified absence. Two earlier failed jobs remain separately recorded RECOVERY_REQUIRED. A protected CONTROL supervisor status/PATH repair PR #69 and a later owned supervisor revision enabled the present real runtime without changing the authenticated CONTROL tunnel singleton. Do not spawn another worker while replay4 is active. No GCL_F011_CLOUD_REPLAY_SUCCESS, unconditional kernel proof certification, or MATHCERT claim until exact terminal result, fresh kernel checker and source-to-formal critical audit.

  26. fyremael commented on Nov 11, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-OAI26-F011/EXTERNAL-TO-GCL-STATEMENT-DELTA-READ-ONLY-CRITIC/1 — exact source cadamcat/totient-fibers-lean4@f75d4f2c2d6685a0547f17fa07240377aa2c2ed4 versus openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a.

    Source-semantic examination, not a newly kernel-proved adapter: The external package Erdos821/Supply.lean defines SmoothShiftedPrimeSupply over eventually real x; GCL SmoothPrimeCount is eventually over natural x. At integer x=n, external Finset.Ioc ⌊2n⌋₊ ⌊5n⌋₊ has the same endpoints as GCL Finset.Ioc (2*n) (5*n); both predicates restrict p−1 prime divisors by n^δ. Fixed-δ quantification precedes the eventual threshold in both. Thus the real-x assertion logically implies the natural-x assumption; an exact source mirror and candidate Lean proof smooth_count_of_external is staged privately for kernel replay. No successful adapter exit/axiom report is claimed yet.

    Totient-fiber definition discrepancy: Erdos821/Challenge.lean defines external g n := {m | Nat.totient m=n}.ncard (includes (m=0)). GCL OAI/NumberTheory/TotientFibers/FiniteFiber.lean defines g n := {m | 0<m ∧ Nat.totient m=n}.ncard. These sets coincide for every n>0, since Nat.totient 0=0; at n=0, external records the extra zero preimage, but deleting a singleton cannot change infinitude. This is a genuine definition-level difference that requires an explicit formal bridge; it is not a counterexample to the manuscript claim nor permission to certify full equivalence without replay.

    Current live proof execution: Unique external worker gcl-f011-xu-replay4-20261111, remote session gcl-f011-xu-replay4-20261111-a1, source-locked checkpoint 2/4 with hash 95b00888dc6acaa74b010985de926fd8982e2a59c346d97c8732131e74510ab4; exact remote readback shows a real ongoing lake build Erdos821 Challenge Verification with successful outputs through at least [8956/9924], not a terminal result. Fresh kernel proof acceptance and independent full analytic source review remain open.

  27. fyremael commented on Nov 11, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    GCL-OAI26-F011/SEMANTIC-IDENTITY-BRIDGES-PROTECTED-MERGE-READBACK/1 — 2026-11-11T13:58Z

    The two remaining external-to-GCL formal statement bridge obligations have been protected-merged and read back from exact Git blobs:

    1. MATHFORGE PR #548 merged main@e1ee3957b54d4081bcbbda4bf3866056f41c935a: real-x fixed-δ smooth shifted-prime count -> GCL natural-x count -> conditional GCL all-ε>0 totient-fiber conclusion. Source WP03_FAMILY011_EXTERNAL_REAL_TO_NAT_ADAPTER.lean blob fc4e394ccb55ce08ebb8dca21b29baa103a8374f; two Lean theorem axioms exactly [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]; pinned Lean exit 0; nine hostile tests pass. This code mirrors, does not import, external supply theorem.
    2. MATHFORGE PR #549 merged main@3e83fd41c47b96a31ac7327f58182d7def60114e: external g(n):=({m | Nat.totient m=n}).ncard equals GCL g(n) for every n>0; removes the exceptional singleton target {0} from infinite external conclusion; proves all-ε>0 external Erdős 821 statement implies GCL all-ε>0 positive-target statement. Source WP03_FAMILY011_EXTERNAL_FIBER_COUNT_EQUIV.lean blob f649ebb960794a48e5668531fd38449f7a046fc0 (SHA256 30886e87944de53e0f681ccfe8d6d4a71bd5fe6607abe16e44b524bf3153c31c), exact upstream openai/math@1581d4cbdd69a0faf34b2089614fe2a814316a6a. All three new theorem axiom reports exactly [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound], Lean exit 0 and 9/9 hostile custody tests pass. Required exact-head PR CI PASS; nonrequired Family342 jobs were pending at protected merge, not promoted to success. Verified protected readback of source, replay JSON, tests and CI routing file.

    LIVE EXTERNAL ANALYTIC PROOF REPLAY: One real Colab CPU worker gcl-f011-xu-replay4-20261111, session gcl-f011-xu-replay4-20261111-a1, at source-locked checkpoint 2/4 and actively building cadamcat/totient-fibers-lean4@f75d4f2c2d6685a0547f17fa07240377aa2c2ed4. Read-only remote log downloaded at 13:58Z shows success through at least [8974/9924], no Lean compiler errors in currently visible log. Stage 3 full build and stage 4 scripts/verify.sh plus leanchecker --fresh Erdos821.Theorem are NOT YET TERMINAL. Active hourly automation OAI26 F011 Lean Closure (job Automation_018c525c56c48191b3d7ced4e2f95225) is bound to the same owned session with no duplicate claim.

    Disposition: F011_FORMAL_EXTERNAL_TO_GCL_STATEMENT_AND_FIBER_EQUIVALENCE_COMPLETE / EXTERNAL_UNCONDITIONAL_ANALYTIC_KERNEL_REPLAY_PENDING. Both protected PRs resolve formal definition/quantifier conversion, not the external author's analytic proof review or MATHCERT certification. Retain WP03, WP04 and programme parent open for terminal independent kernel replay, source-to-formal criticism and governed proof acceptance. No external mathematical reviewer or new MATHCERT authority is claimed.

  28. fyremael commented on Nov 12, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    F011 source-locked independent replay: confirmed operational failure (2026-11-12 15:19 UTC)

    CHAD supervisor reports gcl-f011-xu-replay5-20261112 as RECOVERY_REQUIRED, attempt 3, WORKER_FAILURE_RELEASE_VERIFIED (status updated 14:35:38 UTC). The worker's failure.json records build exit=124 at 14:35:31 UTC, last durable checkpoint 2/4. colab sessions reports no active sessions; the supervisor confirms release completed. This is not a verified Lean theorem failure: code 124 is the worker's subprocess.TimeoutExpired mapping for the lake build Erdos821 Challenge Verification command, which is configured with a 16,000-second command timeout. The exact cause of the elapsed timeout versus runtime scheduling needs further reconciliation; no theorem/build success receipt was captured.

    Authorized source and custody: CONTROL protected PR #71 merged at 51c26fc2f69aa5a0b0408e2c77f0a51915dda5ee; worker worker_v3_merged_51c26fc.py SHA256 f621680a2bda36efe5c52a7eeab363251bc5768725e970687b5956ee4467f857 (recomputed, matches spec). Checkpoint SHA256 b7f81cdd54651fc3bb4efd7f2380df3e9cf160308399c13eaee067e47bc63a9b; pinned upstream source f75d4f2c2d6685a0547f17fa07240377aa2c2ed4, manifest SHA256 8df0747916e81c4d13f3ed226a6ffa5dd04760ffc13668241d603a3595c634cf, Mathlib d13f23b723b8a846827a245b89c10fc7d3f11612. Lease ends 15:52:47 UTC. No unauthorized restart, duplicate worker, or lease/source mutation was made.

    The remote attempt-3 build had reached 9,285/9,945 modules at the prior inspection, with active Lean compiler processes; this proves progress but not completion. Each fresh Colab session reconstructs toolchain, source, dependency cache and build tree; the checkpoint stores metadata rather than a compiled filesystem snapshot. This is a reproducible operational limitation of the present recovery design. A governed successor should address persistent build-artifact custody or bounded target compilation and adequate runtime budgeting, with exact source/pin preservation, protected admission and session ownership checks. Do not resume original replay4 or its worker v2; do not treat the present checkpoint as stage 3.

    Outstanding: successful lake build, scripts/verify.sh, lake env leanchecker --fresh Erdos821.Theorem, exact axioms/no-sorry receipts, fixed-real-delta versus natural-positive-fiber semantic comparison, role-separated critical adjudication, CI, protected merge and issue disposition. MATHCERT and the overall programme remain open. This is a failure-evidence update, not mathematical certification.

  29. fyremael commented on Nov 12, 2026

    @fyremael
    CollaboratorAuthor

    OAI26 F011 source-locked recovery diagnostic — 2026-11-12 16:48 UTC (CHAD readback)

    RESULT/1
    ASSIGNMENT_ID: GCL-OAI26-F011-REPLAY5-RECOVERY-DIAG
    DISPOSITION: RECOVERY_REQUIRED; LEASE_ENDED_RELEASE_VERIFIED; NO_REPLACEMENT_ADMITTED
    JOB: gcl-f011-xu-replay5-20261112
    WORKER_SHA256: f621680a2bda36efe5c52a7eeab363251bc5768725e970687b5956ee4467f857 (live file independently rehashed)
    CHECKPOINT: 2/4, SHA256 b7f81cdd54651fc3bb4efd7f2380df3e9cf160308399c13eaee067e47bc63a9b
    SOURCE_COMMIT: f75d4f2c2d6685a0547f17fa07240377aa2c2ed4
    LAKE_MANIFEST_SHA256: 8df0747916e81c4d13f3ed226a6ffa5dd04760ffc13668241d603a3595c634cf
    MATHLIB_PIN: d13f23b723b8a846827a245b89c10fc7d3f11612
    LEASE_END: 2026-11-12T15:52:47.115147Z
    FAILURE: build exit=124 at 2026-11-12T14:35:31.414832Z; no stage-3 or stage-4 evidence.
    SUPERVISOR: status RECOVERY_REQUIRED, reason LEASE_ENDED_RELEASE_VERIFIED, release_pending=false; health ledger lists this job LEASE_ENDED_RELEASE_VERIFIED; colab sessions reports no active sessions.

    Code-level root-cause hypothesis, not a proven platform diagnosis: the immutable admitted worker calls execute("build", ["lake", "build", "Erdos821", "Challenge", "Verification"], ROOT, ENV, 16000) and explicitly states its checkpoint is metadata, not a filesystem snapshot. Thus a fresh Colab attempt reconstitutes the source/toolchain and does not restore prior .lake/build compilation artifacts. The previous attempt reached ~9,285/9,945 modules before termination, but no complete build receipt. Exit 124 is consistent with the worker subprocess timeout; the exact origin should be checked against full worker and supervisor logs before claiming a definitive root cause.

    Governed next step: create a distinct protected, source-locked recovery PR (do not alter replay4 or replay5), implementing independently verified durable build-artifact recovery keyed by source commit, manifest SHA, Mathlib pin, toolchain and worker digest, with atomic archive and digest checks and hostile mismatch tests. Alternatively admit a bounded build environment whose measured wall-time safely covers full compilation and verification. Require independent role-separated technical review, CI, protected merge readback and explicit new job admission; confirm absence of owned sessions before launch. No lease extension, duplicate launch or unreviewed worker mutation. On success require actual lake build, scripts/verify.sh, leanchecker --fresh Erdos821.Theorem, axiom/no-sorry receipts and fixed-real-delta vs natural-positive-fiber semantic comparison. No mathematical certification or whole-programme closure.
    CLAIM_BOUNDARY: NO_MATHCERT_CERTIFICATION.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Fields

    Priority

    None yet

    Projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions