Problem
Two files define the same three-axis finding taxonomy with divergent vocabulary. The executable taxonomy added in #9 (NEUROSYM.a2ml [finding-taxonomy]) was not reconciled against the pre-existing META.a2ml [maintenance-axes]:
| Axis |
META.a2ml [maintenance-axes] (pre-existing) |
NEUROSYM.a2ml [finding-taxonomy] (#9) |
| intent (deontic) |
must > intend > like |
must / intend / wish |
| maintenance |
corrective > adaptive > perfective |
corrective / adaptive / perfective / preventive |
| locus |
systems > compliance > effects |
systems / compliance / externalities |
Divergences: like vs wish, effects vs externalities (the latter chosen explicitly while building #9), and NEUROSYM adds a 4th maintenance class preventive.
Proposed resolution (option 2 — contingent on the canonical decision)
Make NEUROSYM.a2ml [finding-taxonomy] the canonical definition — it is the richer one, is executable via policies/finding_taxonomy.ecl, and already encodes the chosen externalities — and then:
- align
META.a2ml [maintenance-axes]'s three axis lines to it (wish, externalities, add preventive);
- have
META cross-reference NEUROSYM [finding-taxonomy] as the single source of truth.
This is dependent on which definition becomes canonical. If instead META's like / effects is preferred, flip the direction: update NEUROSYM [finding-taxonomy] + policies/finding_taxonomy.ecl + policies/README.adoc to match.
Affected files
.machine_readable/6a2/META.a2ml — [maintenance-axes].machine_readable/6a2/NEUROSYM.a2ml — [finding-taxonomy]policies/finding_taxonomy.ecl, policies/README.adoc (only if the NEUROSYM vocabulary is the side that changes)
Surfaced during the post-extraction stale-reference sweep (#11).
Problem
Two files define the same three-axis finding taxonomy with divergent vocabulary. The executable taxonomy added in #9 (
NEUROSYM.a2ml [finding-taxonomy]) was not reconciled against the pre-existingMETA.a2ml [maintenance-axes]:META.a2ml [maintenance-axes](pre-existing)NEUROSYM.a2ml [finding-taxonomy](#9)must > intend >likemust / intend /wishcorrective > adaptive > perfectivecorrective / adaptive / perfective /preventivesystems > compliance >effectssystems / compliance /externalitiesDivergences:
likevswish,effectsvsexternalities(the latter chosen explicitly while building #9), and NEUROSYM adds a 4th maintenance classpreventive.Proposed resolution (option 2 — contingent on the canonical decision)
Make
NEUROSYM.a2ml [finding-taxonomy]the canonical definition — it is the richer one, is executable viapolicies/finding_taxonomy.ecl, and already encodes the chosenexternalities— and then:META.a2ml [maintenance-axes]'s three axis lines to it (wish,externalities, addpreventive);METAcross-referenceNEUROSYM [finding-taxonomy]as the single source of truth.This is dependent on which definition becomes canonical. If instead
META'slike/effectsis preferred, flip the direction: updateNEUROSYM [finding-taxonomy]+policies/finding_taxonomy.ecl+policies/README.adocto match.Affected files
.machine_readable/6a2/META.a2ml—[maintenance-axes].machine_readable/6a2/NEUROSYM.a2ml—[finding-taxonomy]policies/finding_taxonomy.ecl,policies/README.adoc(only if the NEUROSYM vocabulary is the side that changes)Surfaced during the post-extraction stale-reference sweep (#11).