Lost Luggage#223
Conversation
📁 Previous CI results (run #23410141044)Test ReportThis comment was generated automatically by a GitHub Action. It summarizes the test results for this pull request. The GitHub Action run can be found here: Base Branch ✅The PR's base branch is Changed Files ❌The PR changes files that should not be changed:
Please ensure that only allowed files are modified. Any changes in the Framework Tests ❌Some framework tests failed. Please check the details below: lost_luggage ❌This log was automatically created at 2025-12-22 11:25:30 UTC. |
|
Review of First Submission Adjusted init function in LostLuggageRenderer before being able to run the game Modularity: 4/4
ALE-similarity: 1.5/4
JAX nativeness: 2.5/4
Performance: 4/4 Through consistent JAX usage, good performance is achieved. The game loads quickly and renders without stutters |
|
Quite nice work so far! I think the biggest thing you need to work on, as well said in the review, is the ALE similarity. Really take your time and use the ALE_RAMStateDeltas.py script to play the original version and try to see where your reviewer saw the "weak points" (no insult!). Then I would also suggest you look at the report from the github actions bot and fix those issues (inconsistent files, tests, etc.) Keep up the nice work! |
|
PKI Review: ALE-Similarity: X/4 implementation quality: 3/4 |
📁 Previous CI results (run #23510144799)Test ReportThis comment was generated automatically by a GitHub Action. It summarizes the test results for this pull request. The GitHub Action run can be found here: Base Branch ✅The PR's base branch is Changed Files ❌The PR changes files that should not be changed:
Please ensure that only allowed files are modified. Any changes in the Framework Tests ❌Some framework tests failed. Please check the details below: frostbite ✅skiing ✅lost_luggage ❌ |
📁 Previous CI results (run #23511573946)Test ReportThis comment was generated automatically by a GitHub Action. It summarizes the test results for this pull request. The GitHub Action run can be found here: Base Branch ✅The PR's base branch is Changed Files ❌The PR changes files that should not be changed:
Please ensure that only allowed files are modified. Any changes in the Framework Tests ❌Some framework tests failed. Please check the details below: frostbite ✅lostluggage ❌ |
📁 Previous CI results (run #23512283856)Test ReportThis comment was generated automatically by a GitHub Action. It summarizes the test results for this pull request. The GitHub Action run can be found here: Base Branch ✅The PR's base branch is Changed Files ❌The PR changes files that should not be changed:
Please ensure that only allowed files are modified. Any changes in the Framework Tests ❌Some framework tests failed. Please check the details below: frostbite ✅skiing ✅bankheist ❌This log was automatically created at 2026-03-24 21:01:41 UTC. |
📁 Previous CI results (run #23512529861)Test ReportThis comment was generated automatically by a GitHub Action. It summarizes the test results for this pull request. The GitHub Action run can be found here: Base Branch ✅The PR's base branch is Changed Files ❌The PR changes files that should not be changed:
Please ensure that only allowed files are modified. Any changes in the Framework Tests ❌Some framework tests failed. Please check the details below: frostbite ✅lostluggage ❌ |
📁 Previous CI results (run #23513037642)Test ReportThis comment was generated automatically by a GitHub Action. It summarizes the test results for this pull request. The GitHub Action run can be found here: Base Branch ✅The PR's base branch is Changed Files ❌The PR changes files that should not be changed:
Please ensure that only allowed files are modified. Any changes in the Framework Tests ❌Some framework tests failed. Please check the details below: frostbite ✅lostluggage ❌ |
📁 Previous CI results (run #23513358486)Test ReportThis comment was generated automatically by a GitHub Action. It summarizes the test results for this pull request. The GitHub Action run can be found here: Base Branch ✅The PR's base branch is Changed Files ❌The PR changes files that should not be changed:
Please ensure that only allowed files are modified. Any changes in the Framework Tests ❌Some framework tests failed. Please check the details below: frostbite ✅lostluggage ❌ |
📁 Previous CI results (run #23515019428)Test ReportThis comment was generated automatically by a GitHub Action. It summarizes the test results for this pull request. The GitHub Action run can be found here: Base Branch ✅The PR's base branch is Changed Files ❌The PR changes files that should not be changed:
Please ensure that only allowed files are modified. Any changes in the Framework Tests ❌Some framework tests failed. Please check the details below: frostbite ✅lostluggage ❌ |
Test ReportThis comment was generated automatically by a GitHub Action. It summarizes the test results for this pull request. The GitHub Action run can be found here: Base Branch ✅The PR's base branch is Changed Files ✅There are no forbidden file changes. Nice 👍 Framework Tests ❌Some framework tests failed. Please check the details below: lostluggage ❌ |
Added modifications
|
@sebiwtt, report submitted, I'm close to be done, so some feedback would be greatly appreciated! Here are the mods I used:
|
No description provided.