Add replicated GPT-5.6 Sol, Terra, and Luna evaluations - #30
Conversation
Shchoholiev
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Please add complete, auditable artifacts for all three GPT-5.6-Terra runs and all three GPT-5.6-Luna runs (six full-corpus executions total) before merging.
The PR currently retains full predictions, evaluation_report.json, run_metadata.json, and per_sample_status.tsv only for each model's selected run 1. The replicate directories retain aggregate summary.json files, while runs 2 and 3 remain ignored scratch artifacts. That means reviewers cannot independently reproduce those four runs or calculate three-run averages for the Structural, Scale-control, tier, family, stressor, and per-document metrics shown by the leaderboard.
Requested changes:
- Preserve each of the three Terra runs and three Luna runs as separate complete result packages, including all 32 per-document predictions,
evaluation_report.jsonwithdetailed_resultsand scorer breakdowns,run_metadata.json, andper_sample_status.tsv(plus the Markdown report if that is part of the release convention). - Record enough provenance to verify that all six runs used the same 32 transcripts, contracts, prompts, model/effort settings, isolation policy, and scorer. Retain input/contract fingerprints, execution status and attempt counts, timestamps, CLI versions, and prediction hashes.
- Link each replicate-summary entry to its exact saved result package.
- Add verification that recomputes every report from the retained predictions and checks that the three-run summary aggregates match the underlying reports.
This evidence is required before presenting Terra or Luna as three-run leaderboard results. A summary-only aggregate is not enough to audit the full leaderboard row.
|
Added the requested audit trail in
Local verification and both GitHub checks pass. |
Shchoholiev
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Verified the retained Sol, Terra, and Luna run packages, provenance, replayed reports, aggregate checks, leaderboard export, and current test suite. The requested auditability changes are addressed.

Summary
Verification
PYTHONPATH=. .venv/bin/pytest -q.venv/bin/python benchmarks/check_replicate_summary.py.venv/bin/python benchmarks/export_leaderboard_space.py --overwritegit diff --check