Skip to content

cinewright-script: bookend, want and need, beat tests, revise step (0.6.29) - #153

Merged
m4bwav merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
books-1120
Nov 21, 2026
Merged

m4bwav merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
books-1120

Conversation

@m4bwav

@m4bwav m4bwav commented Nov 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Book harvest 2026-11-20 into cinewright-script: Blake Snyder, Save the Cat! (2005); Karl Iglesias, The 101 Habits of Highly Successful Screenwriters (2011); Jessica Brody, Save the Cat! Writes a Novel (2018). All paraphrased, book rules marked unverified.

Adopted

  • Bookend pair in the brief (opening image:, final image:, axis:), and want: (concrete) against need: (inner, with a visible task; need: none for flat-arc films and ads).
  • Snyder attribution fixed in logline-and-beats: the 35-word cap and goal/obstacle/stakes form are now a house rule; Snyder's tests (irony, time frame, hero and opponent adjectives, primal goal) added; his midpoint is a false high or low mirrored by all is lost; the knowledge flip is kept but credited to nobody.
  • New step 4 in SKILL.md: revise before hand-off, with the new entry revision-and-feedback (three passes, fix known problems first, fresh reader per draft, 1/2/3 reader count, keep the problem not the fix, same-model subagents are not independent readers).

Adopted partly

  • New entry beat-positions-and-tests: beat fractions (Snyder default, Brody alternative, with 60 s and 3 min seconds), beat tests (catalyst no way back, active choice, midpoint direction flip, all is lost bigger and partly the hero's fault, act-two world opposite), named failures, scene jobs and a seconds budget, a finale scaled to 2-5 min and collapsed to one beat at 30-60 s.
  • scene-turns: who against whom and who wins beside the charge; Snyder's caution on strict alternation beside McKee; leave early beside enter late.
  • dialogue: split read, hidden speaker, cut what cannot be said aloud.
  • Example brief (three-shot) shows want/need and the bookend at 14 s.

Noted only (RESEARCH.md): Brody's ten-genre table and per-POV beat lists.

Measurement: no script reads brief.md (checked shared/lib/cine.py and scripts/cine.py), so BOOKEND, WANT-NEED and WANT-CONCRETE are by-eye warnings in Verify; no lint added, nothing to measure. By eye on the only brief in the repo (examples/three-shot): before, all three would warn (fields absent); after, none.

Checks: unittest 170 OK; kb lint 0 errors; budget YELLOW with the same worst rows as main (logline-and-beats 1196 tokens, under the 1200 red); claude plugin validate passed on root and the three plugins; scrub 250 hits before and after, none in touched files.

@m4bwav
m4bwav merged commit 4136396 into main Nov 21, 2026
5 checks passed
@m4bwav
m4bwav deleted the books-1120 branch November 21, 2026 02:08
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant