Repository navigation
P2B: perform human sanitization review of 8 public v1.6.42 screenshots #745
Description
P2B human disclosure review — NOT COMPLETE
Eight original v1.6.42 PNG captures and eight optimized WebP derivatives are published following operator approval in #743. The provenance manifest explicitly states independent pixel-level sanitization has NOT been asserted.
Automated hidden metadata checks (PNG text/Exif and WebP EXIF/XMP) are being added in PR #744. Such checks cannot examine raster pixels or authorize visible private network data.
Required closure
- Review full-resolution original PNG and WebP for visible customer/station/device names, sensitive IP/MAC/VLAN/topology, files and paths, identifiers, usernames, serials, credentials/certificates, and operational log content.
- Record reviewer authority, date, eight capture SHAs, disposition and exact review evidence.
- If a sensitive detail is not approved for public release, seek owner-approved replacement for both source and WebP assets, preserving immutable provenance of the old captures and updating every public link.
- Report independently what was reviewed; do not declare safety from CI or previous general publication approval.
Policy/checklist: docs/PUBLIC_PRODUCT_P2_RELEASE_AND_MEDIA_REVIEW_2026-10-25.md in PR #744. This issue is a tracking gate only; must remain open until actual human review evidence exists.
Activity
masarray commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Independent human-readable content review — actual 8 published WebP captures (2026-10-25)
An independent visual inspection of the eight current-release WebP assets was carried out against their immutable Git blob identities. This is no longer a purely metadata-only audit. Status: potential disclosure found; keep issue OPEN pending operator authority.
436e02900e2a09e49eafa673741c50bf47c352a916608f46f6bef2233d9ac4d884a11d9eb8c9a634e5a773d7dc34b39bfaa296c2bd23e61889e28c89219cccb49aad9841352515ecb51eb530c5dda94c9a6374c40c8b648a15c39d3eb323a2ea8e686b73da59e8b05965c564a9f0a0422ef0497784a4b9817e8fc0d2a5260ca9781e339ce301c2c1ec0c14b79466fd9ad34b56d5d12e1283413e67d253c19b89Across the eight WebP images, at least one displayed endpoint address is outside RFC1918 private ranges (it may be an authorized test endpoint, but that status is not proven by the capture alone). Avoid echoing exact potentially sensitive identifiers in public issue comments. No obvious plaintext password/private key was observed at the displayed image resolution; this is not a complete secret scan.
NOT completed: independent authority to disclose the network/device identifiers and protocol evidence, plus comparative full-resolution PNG-original inspection and approval. CI metadata scan 16/16 clean does not remove pixels. This review does not modify the authentic captures or falsely certify sanitization.
Disposition required by the owner: (A) explicitly confirm the displayed endpoint/IED/MAC/GOOSE/FAT identifiers are authorized public demo/test evidence, or (B) authorize a specifically reviewed pairwise PNG+WebP redacted replacement for all affected public paths, with provenance and downstream links updated. Image removals do not erase historical Git objects already distributed. Keep issue OPEN until this recorded decision and asset check are done.
masarray commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Follow-up: 8/8 original PNGs reviewed against the 8 WebP views (2026-10-25)
Reviewed the full original PNG image contents, not only the WebP derivatives. Same visible endpoint/IED/network attributes recur in both formats. No additional independently identifiable password, private key or personal name was apparent at the displayed resolution. This remains not proof that public disclosure is authorized.
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 review completed as evidence gathering. Issue stays OPEN solely pending disclosure authority/owner decision for visible endpoint, MAC, GOOSE, IED and diagnostic contents, or owner-approved pairwise sanitized replacement with provenance. The already-published original Git history persists even if future website files are changed. Do not close based on mere metadata cleanliness.
masarray commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Operator final disposition — 25 Oct 2026
Operator explicitly confirmed in this conversation: “PRIVASI SCREENSHOT AMAN”. This is the authority requested by the review issue.
Independent visual inspection has already covered all 8 full-resolution source PNGs and their 8 optimized WebP counterparts with immutable Git blob identities documented above. Embedded-metadata CI passed on all 16 assets. The images do contain IED names, addresses, FAT/GOOSE/diagnostic data; they are operator-approved for public use, not alleged to be sanitized or replaced.
Decision: accept existing v1.6.42 screenshots as authorized public project/demo evidence, retain authentic originals and their hashes. No additional redaction/screenshot review is a prerequisite to public stable release. This is not a general third-party disclosure clearance beyond the owner's authorization.
Close this review as completed on the basis of the user's explicit final authorization.