You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
fix(planning): read back answers that depart from the recommendation before marking them answered #11187
Parent: #9794 (split from #7269, now closed). Eval-first case interview-readback-dictated-answer from #7247 fails on main; #7303's eval-first page items depend on these results.
Problem
The terminal lane records a dictated or departing answer as settled. In all three with-arm runs the reply interpreted "fee chair flag" as a feature flag and noted the Q3 change, then marked Q2 and Q3 answered and moved to round 2 without asking the user to confirm them. The page lane already has this rule (context/surface.md R-D); the terminal lane does not.
Change
In plugins/planning/skills/interview/context/loop.md, in the after-every-reply check ("The open-question register"), add: an answer that departs from the recommendation, or that is dictated or unclear, is restated in the skill's own words (naming any interpretation, such as a misheard term) and kept open until the user confirms or corrects that restatement; an answer that simply accepts the recommendation needs no read-back.
Evidence
Host run on 2026-10-30, Claude Code 2.1.314, claude plugin eval against an out-of-git copy of plugins/planning at 543166dde6, --runs 3 --judge-model opus --threshold 0.8, default with/without ablation. run-validity.py: VALID (warning: skill fired, since the slash command loads the hub without a Skill tool call; the with-arm output follows the hub's procedure). Scores: with 0.67, without 0.67, delta 0; grader reads-back-and-confirms failed 3 of 3 in both arms (unanimous FAIL votes). No with-arm tool call errored or was denied, including every read under skills/interview/context/, so the result is not the bare-path defect. Judge uncalibrated. Full record on #9794.
Done when
The rule above is in the named spoke (or hub line), stated once, with the case named as its eval evidence.
scripts/check-affected.sh --tests passes on the committed head, including plugins/planning/tests/interview-defenses.test.sh with any digest it pins re-pinned.
scripts/check-changelog-fragments.sh passes.
The PR body asks for a host rerun of interview-readback-dictated-answer (3 runs, opus judge); the case reaching a with-arm score of 0.8 or more in a VALID run is that rerun's check, not this slice's gate.
Proposed work class: work-class: scoped
Basis: automated intake triage; the lanes App applied this class.
Size: Small
Complexity: Low
Uncertainty: Known
Flags: none
Blocked by: none
Understood: the terminal lane of the planning interview skill marks dictated or departing answers as answered without a read-back. The fix is one rule in context/loop.md's open-question register, mirroring the page lane's R-D. The done-when items are checkable in a lane run. The host rerun of the eval is requested in the PR body and is not this slice's gate. No duplicates found.
The work-resolve-issue lane stopped on this issue (host-only): the run reports the work needs a host run the lane cannot make.
It added host-run and removed agent-ready: an agent run on a host builds it, and it waits on no decision from a person.
In the run's words:
host-only: the rule landed inside the digested region of plugins/planning/skills/interview/context/loop.md ("## The open-question register" to "## Step 3. Recognize the stop condition"), so plugins/planning/tests/interview-defenses.test.sh's pin "loop.md open-question register section is unchanged" (e562afcd...) fails until it is re-pinned. Re-pinning needs bash plugins/planning/tests/repin.sh 'loop.md open-question register section is unchanged' '<why the defense still holds>' or a sha256 tool, and this lane can run neither. A host run should re-pin with the justification: 'Re-pinned for #11187: adds a read-back rule that keeps a departing, dictated or unclear answer open until the user confirms the restatement; it only holds more rows open, so no gap, blocker or gate binding is loosened.' Then it should run scripts/check-affected.sh --tests.
What the run says it did not do:
plugins/planning/tests/interview-defenses.test.sh pin 'loop.md open-question register section is unchanged' is not re-pinned. The edit is inside its digested region, and this lane cannot run tests/repin.sh or a sha256 tool to compute the new digest, so the test fails until a host run re-pins it.
scripts/check-affected.sh --tests (including interview-defenses.test.sh) was not run. The lane runs check-affected only with no arguments. It is expected to fail on the pin above until that pin is re-pinned.
Tidy did not run every pass. Passes 1-2 had no code lines. Pass 3 (write-for-agents) dropped 'simply' from loop.md. In pass 4 (ai-slop), the rubric found nothing, but the deterministic detector (detect.sh) was skipped because lane Bash runs only the named wrappers.
The host rerun of eval case interview-readback-dictated-answer (3 runs, opus judge, with-arm >= 0.8 in a VALID run) needs a host with claude plugin eval. The PR body should ask for it. It is that rerun's check, not this slice's gate.
The PR's CI runs the other CI-only checks that check-affected lists (evals-schema, lychee-offline, purged-em-dashes, and the rest)
Partial work is on the branch work-resolve-issue/issue-11187-41022490483-1. The next run continues from it while it is not behind the default branch, and otherwise starts fresh.
Activity
github-actions commentedon Oct 30, 2026
Proposed work class: work-class: scoped
Basis: automated intake triage; the lanes App applied this class.
Size: Small
Complexity: Low
Uncertainty: Known
Flags: none
Blocked by: none
Understood: the terminal lane of the planning interview skill marks dictated or departing answers as answered without a read-back. The fix is one rule in
context/loop.md's open-question register, mirroring the page lane's R-D. The done-when items are checkable in a lane run. The host rerun of the eval is requested in the PR body and is not this slice's gate. No duplicates found.Automated triage, applied by the lanes App.
melodic-automation-lanes commentedon Oct 30, 2026
The work-resolve-issue lane stopped on this issue (
host-only): the run reports the work needs a host run the lane cannot make.It added
host-runand removedagent-ready: an agent run on a host builds it, and it waits on no decision from a person.In the run's words:
What the run says it did not do:
claude plugin eval. The PR body should ask for it. It is that rerun's check, not this slice's gate.Partial work is on the branch
work-resolve-issue/issue-11187-41022490483-1. The next run continues from it while it is not behind the default branch, and otherwise starts fresh.Run: https://github.com/melodic-software/claude-code-plugins/actions/runs/41022490483
To hand it back to the lane, remove
host-runand addagent-readyagain.