[P0][CHAT UPDATE] 1回の「pgextwinを更新して」→全拡張更新処理（公開版維持） #311

Activity

1. ShutenOishi

   changed the title [-]Replace GitHub cron with authenticated external orchestration across 17 extensions[/-] [+]Replace GitHub cron with hourly ChatGPT Task initiation and authenticated orchestration[/+] on Oct 28, 2026
2. ShutenOishi

   changed the title [-]Replace GitHub cron with hourly ChatGPT Task initiation and authenticated orchestration[/-] [+]One Chat request to completion: event-driven orchestration without cron or recurring tasks[/+] on Oct 28, 2026
3. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

   

   ShutenOishi

   on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

   ContributorAuthor

   More actions

   2026-10-29 JST — R01 authenticated fleet inventory and R02 original event proof (NONPUBLISHING; recovery pending)

   Canonical contract: #311 R01–R12, parent #75 #6473214580. Old M/T and all recurring-Chat/extra-cron options are withdrawn, not completed. This checkpoint uses new authenticated GitHub GET; no previous successful CI was rerun.

   R01 inventory (GET snapshot)

   • Central protected pgextwin/build/main started d8904ebc377e33034b71108d42de940d6b6c9979; after R02 protected PR test(issue311): R02 protected-main push entry canary (nonpublishing) #312 it is d9a09ae962b077c4142599daebc6b57746bccf27. Central 23 Workflow files include fleet-upstream-watch.yml (blob f09fad0e50d9b12e6d77486636b62dd1fec9c99b), operator-update-auto.yml (0c44b25652b2ac87e76d18e8cd1081fff6879f2e), publisher-candidate-intake.yml (a8b65a32659fc04a58f130bcb5c4cf16bdedc55d), native PR recovery, signed requalification, PostgreSQL watch, fleet-status, canary, and existing validation/postmerge. metadata/automation-fleet.json blob 69918265dabb86b11a9406533cbe0ce495137b94 still models scheduleUtc and automatic-signed-schedule. Do NOT treat this old sourceKind as new request authority.
   • 17/17 current local main protected=true, exact SHAs:
     pg_bigm=713a76b8650f61097b5d5a55f15cd7f2ebcb4ec0;
     pg_cron=a36e180a3922e070cde03642ec9fcc40e171567e;
     pg_hint_plan=40e68cc8177a3d0707ac87f346e3d88c3247769c;
     pgaudit=f53e97d7c4a51c089f8bdc7b33f3ae005f516b29;
     set_user=4f02f925e7bc0534af421441c1b2fb1ecd755846;
     pg_repack=b9da885a4ef132b5f3d5af448fb09e5bfe56e6a7;
     pg_ivm=6e3904af78cccbd67ce84eef183ceda9f4eef553;
     pg_qualstats=fa31026f041070c821d317041b8f973ccd0a794d;
     plpgsql_check=b75d9c90f2c349788b21a7f47d59ca31f3c8ebdd;
     orafce=e96941dd3ec09f88011feb1165a3f6f83231460f;
     hypopg=6c6ddfb7b62dd220fdea4004e5e5f6a0a054f271;
     wal2json=51850b29b4eca4cc85ac648342d490605557a2ff;
     pg_partman=4e3be24b9b2523cc6b1979d61f6be912be6d3e31;
     pg_stat_monitor=97f1f41054bed4a3900e0ae924d04cbe5b2f08e4;
     pgtap=c536e9d90760eea88f7c42ba4b675e05a0d0fcf8;
     pg_variables=0662ed8757e2f0c821a0a300c6f98df9374d8a8c;
     pg_store_plans=7d3d4a1b099fb5d408de4f50ee72b4e49854734b.
     Each local update-watch.yml is still schedule + push + workflow_run, with genuine :30 hourly cron; hypopg additionally :41. All 17 promote.yml use workflow_dispatch only. Per-repo workflow source blob SHAs independently GET-ed. No active in-progress run or open PR in 17 local repos at this snapshot.
   • catalog/main=dc8390fd816aa7bf0bf3b541e822b1320a47846e, protected=true, 14 workflows, including catalog-drift-readonly.yml (schedule/push), sync-verified-release.yml (schedule/manual), App-scoped opt-in proposal, CLI/feed/canary, and issue112-p1-fleet-readonly.yml (schedule/push); 5 Dependabot PRs open; no in-progress runs.
   • website/main=2eb3bd618f230cea424b99dac5148ca72d923cd7, protected=true; pages-smoke.yml has workflow_call, push, workflow_dispatch, repository_dispatch, schedule; 1 Dependabot PR open; no in-progress run.
   • build had only Dependabot build(deps): bump actions/create-github-app-token from 3.2.0 to 3.3.0 #180 and build(deps): bump actions/setup-python from 6.3.0 to 7.1.0 #309 open prior to R02. Authenticated user login is ShutenOishi. Required build PR check is the App 15368 resolver job. Effective admin-level branch protection/required-check configuration GET returned 403 Resource not accessible by integration, so enforcement details remain UNKNOWN beyond the observed protected=true, latest-head CI and GitHub-accepted expected-head PR merge. No assumed App/Secret/permissions change.
   • [P2][OPTIONAL FEATURE] オンライン/オフライン配布CLI・バンドル共通基盤 #112 is independent historical offline bundle + online/offline CLI work; do not conflate its 70-source proof or weekly Catalog audit with [P0][CHAT UPDATE] 1回の「pgextwinを更新して」→全拡張更新処理（公開版維持） #311 coordinator acceptance or rerun [P2][OPTIONAL FEATURE] オンライン/オフライン配布CLI・バンドル共通基盤 #112 historical source jobs. No new release or public-publish authorization here.
   • Historical X01/X02 merges/postmerge, 13/17 old typed receipt ZIP PASS and Fleet40688819922 original ZIP hash remain preserved per [P0][PUBLISH PATH] Chat更新・適格な正式Release→Catalog/Website連結（既存安全ゲート維持） #75 #6472293647. Old four true-schedule deficits are NOT R01/R02/R03 blockers; new 17/17 is a fresh R07 gate.

   R02 actual connector → protected main → push evidence

   • Chat connector wrote branch issue311/r02-protected-push-probe, dedicated strictly AUDIT_ONLY fixture and read-only .github/workflows/issue311-r02-nonpublishing-proof.yml (contents:read, no signing/write/dispatch/Release).
   • PR #312, HEAD 030bdb81b3e811bb6902e22db09ebfa318a2ad12, original required App15368 resolver Run 40717715045 completed/success. Expected-HEAD protected merge succeeded; main merge SHA d9a09ae962b077c4142599daebc6b57746bccf27, merged_by ShutenOishi.
   • Genuine R02 Run40717966364, event=push, attempt=1, actor/triggering_actor=ShutenOishi, main SHA exact. The real original job log printed NONPUBLISHING_ORIGINAL_PUSH_OBSERVED, sender/pusher=ShutenOishi, request-byte SHA256 5d4fa8d958e66e0e794cc71657acae8222e836e2eb22b1250a92b64cb95b4027. This independently demonstrates connector-mediated merge push is not suppressed like a GITHUB_TOKEN-origin push.
   • However original Run40717966364 final FAILURE: upload-artifact skipped the dot-prefixed .issue311-r02-receipt.json by default. Do not upgrade this failed run to success. Build postmerge validation Run40717966641 completed SUCCESS.
   • Protected correction PR #313, HEAD 96fee41c05b2d8246395b6799b5c8aad0e966f4c, changes receipt to a nonhidden filename and uses a new immutable request issue311-r02-20261029-02, avoiding a fake replay/rerun. This is pending its original exact-head required CI and safe merge. No old successful run is rerun.

   Still unproven

   R02 original uploaded receipt / corrected postmerge run; R03 request/approval ADR; R04 durable CAS/lease/idempotence; R05 two-stage autonomous event continuation and missing-event terminal; R06–R12 new mode admission including original SHA256, signed identity, PG rows, SPDX/Grype, independent replay deny. workflow_run depth and GITHUB_TOKEN event-suppression require design and negative proof, NOT long-chain assumptions. PUBLISH_DENY unchanged; no Release/tag/secret/policy/cron/permission/actor expansion, real publish, Catalog change, or Work/ChatGPT cron.

   Next: verify #313 latest-head App15368 CI, merge with expected HEAD if clean, GET new original push run/jobs/artifact/log and final postmerge CI. Then R03 ADR minimal protected PR; progress and evidence remain on #311 and #75.
4. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

   

   ShutenOishi

   on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

   ContributorAuthor

   More actions

   2026-10-29 00:4x JST — R02 protected-push original receipt independently verified (NONPUBLISHING)

   Latest canonical plan is #311 R01–R12, not the withdrawn hourly schedule plan. New authenticated GitHub GET found protected build/main=24085fa17eb9e14be5ccb8f66b5c61039e8f54ae (merge PR #313, head 96fee41c05b2d8246395b6799b5c8aad0e966f4c). PR-head validation Run 40718173252 SUCCESS; postmerge validation Run 40718397814 SUCCESS, attempt1. Prior #312 probe Run40717966364 failed only at the hidden artifact upload; do not rewrite that failed run as PASS.

   New original successful R02 proof: push Run40718397824, event=push, attempt1, exact protected main SHA, original job 122922259639 SUCCESS. Original raw job log reports NONPUBLISHING_ORIGINAL_PUSH_OBSERVED, actor/triggeringActor/sender/pusher=ShutenOishi, before SHA d9a09ae962b077c4142599daebc6b57746bccf27, after SHA 24085fa17eb9e14be5ccb8f66b5c61039e8f54ae, requestId issue311-r02-20261029-02, mode=AUDIT_ONLY, publishAuthorized=false, permissionModel contents:read. Original receipt artifact 12829007351 (issue311-r02-original-push-receipt) downloaded; independently hashed original 559-byte ZIP SHA256 4452a10173d9769955bcfebc7c06d6ebde3dde65479685fd2af32346b7a9d1d1, matching authenticated GitHub artifact digest exactly. ZIP contains only issue311-r02-receipt.json; member SHA256 c73a39975139e93f633769be7d835409a69cb01ffe13e8449e391c33a1457bc9. Parsed receipt binds event/run/attempt/main SHA/requestId and publishAuthorized=false.

   Scope: R02 protected-main push-to-nonpublishing receipt is observed; this alone does not establish R02's full event-suppression/actor policy or R03–R12, and is NOT release authorization. Old X02 13/17 is historical only; new 17/17 remains unproven. No reruns, dispatch, cron/policy/App/Secret changes, or Release. PUBLISH_DENY maintained.

   Next: Verify R02 event suppression and credential/actor boundary against actual original runs, then R03 versioned request/approval/evidence ADR and R04/R05 durable coordinator. Avoid re-running the now-successful Run40718397824/40718397814.
5. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

   

   ShutenOishi

   on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

   ContributorAuthor

   More actions

   2026-10-29 JST — R01 inventory, R02 original event/ZIP proof, R03 protected ADR, R04/R05 nonpublishing foundation + genuine two-stage terminal (NO RELEASE)

   Authenticated GitHub GET + original connector operations and independent actual ZIP SHA256. This updates #6473458864. Issue #311 R01–R12 remains canonical; #75 #6473214580 direction stands. Old M/T, extra-cron and recurring-Chat alternatives remain withdrawn, not marked complete. No real Release, tag, Catalog publication, publisher credential, secret, effective actor policy or protection change.

   Protected PR / exact-head / original required CI / postmerge ledger

   Gate	PR / HEAD	Original required PR CI (App15368 resolver)	Protected merge commit	Main-push CI
   R02 first actual push signal	#312, 030bdb81b3e811bb6902e22db09ebfa318a2ad12	40717715045 SUCCESS	d9a09ae962b077c4142599daebc6b57746bccf27	40717966641 SUCCESS
   R02 original artifact repair	#313, 96fee41c05b2d8246395b6799b5c8aad0e966f4c	40718173252 SUCCESS	24085fa17eb9e14be5ccb8f66b5c61039e8f54ae	40718397814 SUCCESS
   R03 versioned declarative contract	#314, 75e6ac3319a1f03e4abb839ab53bd76e3a0fde1b	40719220820 SUCCESS	d4e4ac7973809d19bd7030b5f9789e50f06433dc	40719448707 SUCCESS
   R04 pure state & R05 needs proof	#315, 887e9d213dd7078bf1b4cea402dc9520a92fdfa8	40720097575 SUCCESS	e555ba09917efcd55cda96c804fccbb4c6b043f2	40720418395 SUCCESS

   All four PRs used expected_head_sha protected merges, returned merged=true, live main GET protected=true, and merged_by=ShutenOishi. All original successful CI are reused, never rerun. The GitHub integration's admin-level GET of the actual branch protection required-status configuration returns 403, so effective rule detail remains UNKNOWN, not independently asserted PASS. Actual App15368 exact-HEAD PR CI and GitHub-accepted protected merge are observed.

   R02 true single-push canary

   • First genuine main push Run40717966364 event=push, actor/sender/pusher/triggeringActor ShutenOishi, exact original main HEAD. The job independently verified request raw SHA256, but final result is FAILURE because actions/upload-artifact excludes dot-prefixed file by default. Preserve original FAILURE; no rerun or synthetic proof.
   • New request/isolated correction via fix(issue311): complete original R02 push receipt after hidden-artifact failure #313: Run40718397824 completed/success, original push, attempt1. Original Artifact 12829007351 (issue311-r02-original-push-receipt) ZIP 559 bytes, GitHub metadata SHA256 = actual independently downloaded ZIP SHA256 4452a10173d9769955bcfebc7c06d6ebde3dde65479685fd2af32346b7a9d1d1. Inside original ZIP issue311-r02-receipt.json: requestId issue311-r02-20261029-02, request raw SHA256 a14ae8fddb2b7f21bb1ae3b73e8757f07f861f3675350c7676f842dc92f6f84a, headSha=24085fa17eb9e14be5ccb8f66b5c61039e8f54ae, original beforeSha=d9a09ae962b077c4142599daebc6b57746bccf27, actor/sender/pusher/triggeringActor ShutenOishi, publishAuthorized=false. R02 minimum one genuine connector merge → push proof PASS. Does NOT prove GITHUB_TOKEN-generated secondary events or privileged publishing.

   R03 actual merged contract

   Protected main now contains docs/adr-0311-event-driven-request-v1.md, schema/issue311-execution-request-v1.schema.json, scripts/issue311-request-contract.py, tests/test-issue311-request-contract.py and required CI invocation. A bounded request declaration v1 fixes targets/SHA, request ID, max attempts/operations/walltime, expiry, AUDIT_ONLY/PREPARE/PUBLISH_ELIGIBLE, and grants; rejects duplicate keys, unknown repos/refs, invalid SHA, extra fields, stale/expired/oversized requests, unauthorized publish declarations and mismatch in approval. Every schema-valid request is INERT and returns actorAuthenticated=false, publicationAuthorized=false. Authenticated GitHub actor/PR merge, original bytes, effective branch rules and required CI must be proved separately; no production listener or privileged new sourceKind is active. R03 design/schema/tests are accepted, live adoption pending R04/R05 and later migration.

   R04 pure state transition completed, durable state still unproven

   PR #315 protected merged scripts/issue311-state-core.py, tests/test-issue311-state-core.py and CI. In-process/pure/offline tests cover revision CAS, exact duplicate replay idempotence, mismatched same-key conflict, immutable stage input on retry, finite attempts/operation budget, terminal per-target SUCCESS/NO_UPDATE/FAILED/BLOCKED_APPROVAL/QUARANTINED, and no blind retry on unknown privileged write result (QUARANTINED). It writes no GitHub state, has persistenceAccepted=false and no Writer privilege. R04 overall PENDING: choose an approved durable protected checkpoint CAS/lease writer and independently verify its permission scope, concurrency and restart. Neither Issue text nor Actions artifact alone is a trusted CAS ledger; no undocumented App/Secret/permission expansion.

   R05 independently observed two-stage one-shot chain + terminal (single-run proof, not full coordinator)

   • test(issue311): R04 CAS state-core and R05 one-push two-stage nonpublishing proof #315 introduced strictly bounded AUDIT_ONLY file .github/execution-requests/r-20261029-r05nonpublishing001.json with fixed orafce/main=e96941dd3ec09f88011feb1165a3f6f83231460f, prior central SHA/blob, 16-hour expiry and publishAuthorized=false. A path-limited push Workflow .github/workflows/issue311-r05-nonpublishing-needs.yml has contents:read only, no cron, workflow_dispatch, workflow_run chain, OIDC, Publisher/Catalog credential or GitHub write. Workflow logic: admit authenticates real push/current SHA/schema/byte hash → stage2 needs:admit independently rehashes exact immutable request bytes → aggregate needs:[admit,stage2] if:always() records explicit terminal NO_UPDATE/FAILED.
   • Genuine original Run40720418388, event=push, attempt1, actor ShutenOishi, merged main e555ba09917efcd55cda96c804fccbb4c6b043f2: all THREE jobs completed/success; run completed/success. This required no additional Chat invocation or manual dispatch after the one protected request merge.
   • Downloaded original three ZIPs separately and computed real ZIP SHA256; all MATCH authenticated GitHub metadata:
     • Stage1 original Artifact 12829987276, 410 bytes, d5978e0b96d8fc5fa56d4c633a43351ebd63b163528628f03b8eb4b7297c9eb6.
     • Stage2 original Artifact 12828949285, 349 bytes, 5dfb6cd54c1276485cddf6cd38c6db31103ed94ad5352b255f7bce4884c8ce86.
     • Terminal original Artifact 12829883183, 471 bytes, f025c81eb8f08b6cb7856b3075af3284d9b427851e3f964ef52e00ebe06cabb6.
   • Three original inner JSONs bind identical rawSha256=7a8761dd458aeb88c20d13ff5ac8e92aa5f07dd5b89e6b0c395cffa6d5aad75f and headSha=e555ba09917efcd55cda96c804fccbb4c6b043f2 for stage1/stage2. Final receipt requestId=r-20261029-r05nonpublishing001, runId=40720418388, runAttempt=1, stage1=success, stage2=success, terminal=NO_UPDATE, statePersistenceAccepted=false, publishAuthorized=false. A real two-step needs + always terminal inside ONE trusted Workflow is proven; full R05 PENDING cross-repo Windows jobs, durable checkpoints/restart, independent event transport and missing-event terminal detection.

   Scope and forward conditions

   • R01 authenticated source/repo/cron coverage DONE (effective admin branch settings UNKNOWN). R02 original nonpublishing signal PASS. R03 declarative ADR/schema/negative CI PASS. R04 pure core PASS but durable CAS/lease PENDING. R05 nonpublishing two-stage needs pilot PASS but full coordinator PENDING. R06–R12 NOT ACCEPTED. No new R07 17/17 receipts, signer/sourceKind acceptance, Publisher or Release gate acceptance.
   • Original historical X01/X02 protected success, old 13/17 accepted raw receipts, Fleet40688819922 original ZIP SHA256 remain preserved and reused; old four schedules are no longer prerequisites to migration. No original verified receipt in a new sourceKind is claimed from the R02/R05 audit-only artifacts.
   • Existing PUBLISH_DENY, PG14–18, original ZIP actual SHA256, OIDC/Sigstore dual independent audit, SPDX/Grype, replay DENY, create-only, publisher token same-live revoke/HTTP401, policy/actor/protection untouched. Never claim unsigned audit-only artifacts constitute a new Release or Catalog admission.
   • Existing pgextwin hourly ChatGPT automation id 6ad9d3b661948191932974b4b3716e49 was privately checked and is already is_enabled=false. It was NOT restarted; other unrelated automations untouched. The old GitHub on.schedule triggers still exist until R11 safely migrates after new controls are proven; no cron additions.
   • Next concrete step: R04 trusted durable CAS/lease/checkpoint writer and identity/permissions proof (admin GET 403 leaves UNKNOWN); R05 cross-repo bounded actor/App event handshake and failure terminal with no long workflow_run chains or implicit GITHUB_TOKEN triggering. Then R06 local preflight per new request; pilot orafce and new 17/17 proof R07, independent OIDC/Sigstore/Publisher R08, Catalog/CLI/Website R09–R12 only under each existing gate. [P2][OPTIONAL FEATURE] オンライン/オフライン配布CLI・バンドル共通基盤 #112 offline bundle/CLI trust is independent and must not be overwritten/overcounted.

   Stopping boundary: No authorized durable state writer/lease or original cross-repo execution trigger has yet been established without extra privileges. Consequently R04/R05 full acceptance and any publication/Catalog changes are not authorized. Protected main and historical release assets are intact, all four PRs merged and all latest-head/postmerge CI success, no required follow-up to replay earlier success.
6. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

   

   ShutenOishi

   on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

   ContributorAuthor

   More actions

   2026-10-29 JST — R04 live connector CAS + protected adapter, R05 genuine 17-repository read-only fanout (NO RELEASE)

   Canonical #311 R01–R12 unchanged; prior #6473821604 retained. New authenticated GitHub GET and original-run byte verification; no old successful CI rerun, new cron, ChatGPT task, Secret/App/protection/publisher permission, tag, Release or Catalog write. Old 13/17 receipt and Fleet40688819922 remain historical, not counted as new R07 admission.

   R04 — durable CAS observed only for authenticated Chat connector, NOT yet Actions writer

   • Isolated test branch issue311/r04-isolated-state-probe-20261029, original checkpoint commit c44b3266c88b31bee8ec03b90f5cdb800cd76d4e; revision 0→1 persisted at commit 26eda155458ccff9e9d4a0a64328e6dce793ce18, blob 91df0cf8cb41c9a456d4acb4793cbdc8780fff2d. A second update using the stale original blob 2e1c01eede7116677034b6636d50df5e93e3e5d6 was rejected HTTP 409 CONFLICT, followed by independent read confirming revision 1 unchanged. This is one real GitHub Contents CAS proof, not trust in Issue text or artifact.
   • Protected PR #316 HEAD dc31efc1206fd73dbb7391bfd7d01628ab058214: inert fixed issue311-state Contents CAS adapter, bounded READONLY lease generations, owner/expiry, stale conflict and timeout-after-commit/unknown outcome DENY, hostile tests. Original App15368 resolver PR CI40731759262 SUCCESS; expected-head protected merge fda9e1b2a5b243851eb77a7280c1712855013f49; original postmerge 40731971328 SUCCESS.
   • Adapter remains INERT: no Actions contents:write scope granted, no production trusted state branch/writer/lease installed, no crash/resume across runner demonstrated. GitHub admin branch protection effective rules remain UNKNOWN (403). R04 full acceptance PENDING, and no Writer credential is inferred from Chat connector success.

   R05 — genuinely launched one-shot 17-way authenticated read-only fleet

   • All 17 local main refs independently re-GET-ed: exact #6473458864 listed SHA still matches, protected=true on every repo. This is a point-in-time immutable snapshot, not assumed future head.
   • Protected PR #317 HEAD 02fe10aac762c896d1ab40a3a0e17d240dae23d4: new AUDIT_ONLY immutable declaration r-20261029-r05readonly17b, strict original protected-main push+actor ShutenOishi, source/registered roster of all 17, read-only Actions GITHUB_TOKEN, at most 4 parallel GET jobs, fail-fast:false, always() final aggregator, failed/skip/missing/duplicate negative tests. No dispatch, cross-repo write, Windows CI, signing or publication path.
   • Original required App15368 resolver PR CI40732216656 SUCCESS. Expected-head protected merge 53fa1ce02f2f87a88bedc7502ff9324a697769a6, live main protected=true; original postmerge 40732395943 SUCCESS.
   • Genuine original Run40732396047: event=push, original attempt 1, actor ShutenOishi, exact merged main SHA, 1 admit + 17 actual matrix jobs all SUCCESS + 1 always terminal SUCCESS, no second Chat/dispatch/cron. Original admit job122971871467 logged request raw SHA256 73a930a3951a471e2a975ac92ffe3e4d16f5a4ca953a6c6c359ed1812613aac7; original aggregator job122972379328 logged all 17 statuses success, terminal NO_UPDATE, publishAuthorized=false, persistenceAccepted=false.
   • Independently downloaded all 18 ORIGINAL ZIP files (17 target receipts + terminal); computed SHA256 over actual outer ZIP bytes and compared with authenticated GitHub artifact metadata: 18/18 MATCH. Each ZIP had one parsed JSON, proper requestId, runId=40732396047, runAttempt=1, all 17 exact protected remote SHAs and success, terminal 17/17 NO_UPDATE, no publish permission.
   • Original terminal artifact 12836031017, 445 bytes, outer ZIP SHA256 1811738e70ae62a1ef8b30cbbd8d3abfb9d29ba1794e9d466d77084b8907ec11, matching GitHub sha256: digest. Other 17 artifact IDs/digests remain independently retrievable on Run40732396047; NO new scheduled preflight/sourceKind receipt was claimed.

   Remaining admission boundaries / next exact work

   • R04: independently authorize/test a trusted Actions durable CAS writer and branch/credential trust; real lease contention, stale-run resume and unknown write reconciliation without privilege widening. The isolated Chat CAS is a safe capability probe only; publisher token must never be repurposed.
   • R05: 17 authenticated remote GETs PASS but real remote Workflow/Windows initiation, persisted cross-run checkpoint, missing-event timeout and failure terminal proof PENDING. Explore central single-run reusable matrix/needs as alternative to cross-repo dispatch; no long workflow_run chains or GITHUB_TOKEN event assumptions.
   • R06→R12 stay gated: new original central scan ZIP + exact local sourceKind/17 raw preflight receipts, orafce pilot, independent OIDC/Sigstore dual audits, guarded Publisher/Catalog/feed/Website. PUBLISH_DENY, create-only and live token revocation/401 unaffected. No publication approval implied. [P0][PUBLISH PATH] Chat更新・適格な正式Release→Catalog/Website連結（既存安全ゲート維持） #75 remains OPEN; [P2][OPTIONAL FEATURE] オンライン/オフライン配布CLI・バンドル共通基盤 #112 offline CLI separate.

   This checkpoint is new measured R04 partial + R05 bounded read-only subproof, not R04/R05 full PASS.
7. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

   

   ShutenOishi

   on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

   ContributorAuthor

   More actions

   2026-10-29 JST — R04 recovery hardening + original Windows R05 controlled-negative acceptance (NO RELEASE)

   Authenticated current build/main = a0cf784edf3cea11df9d925a605a78177c46f9c8, protected=true. This ledger extends #6475528265; it does not revise R01–R03 or the already accepted R05 17/17 remote GET evidence. #311 R04/R05 remain PARTIAL, R06–R12 unaccepted.

   Protected exact-head implementation and original CI

   PR	Scope	Required App15368 original resolver	protected expected-head merge	postmerge
   #318	Read-only R04 ambiguous lease reconciliation; Windows R05 two-target negative fixture	40771670177 SUCCESS	9942a056ea293c0b120d45a557c4f6c8348ab692	40771820388 SUCCESS
   #319	Correct immutable Git blob byte read across Windows CRLF and cross-host ZIP bearer redirect	40772124088 SUCCESS	a0cf784edf3cea11df9d925a605a78177c46f9c8	40772260647 SUCCESS

   Both PRs merged to protected main with exact expected HEAD after actual original App15368 required CI. No successful workflow reruns.

   R04 specific progress and still missing

   • scripts/issue311-state-github.py now offers an independently READ-ONLY reconciliation of an ambiguous lease PUT using an authoritative GET: exact current intended state => COMMITTED; old unchanged => UNRESOLVED (no retry entitlement); changed state => CONFLICT; GET error => UnknownWriteOutcome/QUARANTINE. Real adapter remains INERT. Hostile tests added and required CI PASS.
   • The isolated Chat connector CAS proof and previous HTTP409 remain accepted as previously recorded; they are not Actions credential scope.
   • New authenticated GET refs/heads/issue311-state was 404. No production state branch/approved Actions Writer exists; branch-admin effective rules remain UNKNOWN (prior 403). No Actions contents:write, token, App, Secret, unprotected branch workaround or permission widening added. R04 full Actions Writer / protected CAS / lease across runs / crash resume NOT accepted.

   R05 genuine original Windows NEGATIVE, failures preserved

   • Original Run40771820478, request r-20261029-r05winnegative01, real push/attempt1, ended FAILURE. Windows checkout worktree line-ending transformation made raw request SHA256 differ from immutable Git bytes, both Windows child jobs safely rejected. Initial aggregator hit HTTP401 on cross-host ZIP redirect with inherited bearer. These are preserved as original failures; NOT rerun, waived or called controlled acceptance.
   • Protected fix fix(issue311): preserve immutable request bytes on Windows and safe artifact redirect (NO RELEASE) #319 introduced new immutable request r-20261029-r05winnegative02; the Windows runner hashes git show HEAD:<path> immutable blob bytes (with HEAD == actual GITHUB_SHA), and artifact download strips GitHub Authorization on cross-host redirect. Regression tests now cover both defects.
   • New genuine Run40772260487: exact protected main a0cf784e..., event=push, attempt1, actor ShutenOishi. Original admit SUCCESS; actual windows-latest job pgextwin/orafce SUCCESS after exact protected main GET e96941dd3ec09f88011feb1165a3f6f83231460f; actual Windows pgextwin/pg_ivm GET 6e3904af78cccbd67ce84eef183ceda9f4eef553 independently verified remoteVerified=true before an intentionally injected child FAILURE. always() aggregator independently fetched original ZIPs, hashed the actual outer bytes and returned terminal FAILED, controlledNegativeProved=true, persistenceAccepted=false, publishAuthorized=false. Run overall FAILURE by design; never represent it as workflow success. Original request SHA256: 2be265ce6f2e93ed0593fbe90725025719d65bd50a306a073df265287f60ac27.
   • Independently re-downloaded all 3/3 original ZIPs through authenticated GitHub artifact access and calculated actual outer SHA256, matching artifact metadata and the original aggregator ledger:
     • orafce Artifact 12853566086, 417-byte ZIP SHA256 5431ba01f72bd10da1303b9ca3b377d62bd3178eef243ea3e6b3ae8336c9b7f9;
     • pg_ivm Artifact 12852248618, 505-byte ZIP SHA256 814c5696e8e6c6b5c4950688de30ea09676965323108cfc57a2932132666dc76;
     • terminal Artifact 12853446033, 525-byte ZIP SHA256 1c09f10f79d87565922d619b07b25600f7b556aa4b4c4e3fa827aef70d5b4888.
       Each original ZIP had exactly one parsed JSON bound to requestId/runId/attempt and proper true Windows evidence; terminal contains exact original child ZIP hashes and controlledNegativeProved=true.

   Boundaries and next

   R05 real two-repository Windows GET and actual controlled failure/skip-safe terminal are a NEW SUBPROOF, NOT R05 end-to-end. No remote Windows Workflow dispatch, build/signing, cross-run persisted checkpoint, missing-event timeout recovery or original R06/R07 new-mode 17/17 typed admission. Current local windows.yml (at least orafce/pg_ivm) is NOT workflow_call; central direct cross-repo reuse is not yet a proven ready-made replacement for authorized remote build initiation.

   Next: (1) independently establish an approved narrow Actions state Writer and protected CAS ref, or exact BLOCKED_APPROVAL contract if permission unavailable; test real lease contention/unknown-write read reconciliation across stopped runs; (2) implement least-authority, bounded Windows workflow initiation, durable final assembly, missing-event/timeout/429/5xx failure terminal; (3) R06 new central scan and R07 1→17 authentic typed receipts only after matching prerequisites. Old 13/17 and R05 17 READONLY GET do not count toward R07. No cron/ChatGPT scheduled tasks, dispatch, unpublished credentials, PUBLISH_DENY bypass, tag/Release, Catalog write or successful CI rerun. #311/#75 remain OPEN.
8. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

   

   ShutenOishi

   on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

   ContributorAuthor

   More actions

   2026-10-29 JST — authenticated continuation: explicit R04/R05 BLOCKED_APPROVAL boundary (NO RELEASE)

   Continuation of #6481164173; no successful stage rerun. Latest authenticated GET confirms protected build/main a0cf784edf3cea11df9d925a605a78177c46f9c8; production git/ref/heads/issue311-state returns 404; branches/main/protection returns 403 Resource not accessible by integration. Open central PRs are unrelated dependency PRs #309/#180; no existing R04 writer implementation PR was found.

   Terminal of this continuation, not completion of #311

   BLOCKED_APPROVAL / R04_ACTIONS_STATE_WRITER_NOT_ESTABLISHED. This is an evidence/authority stop, not a GitHub automatic approval rejection. No new execution request was admitted, no runtime terminal checkpoint exists, and this Issue comment is NOT a CAS root. R01–R03 remain DONE, R04/R05 PARTIAL, R06–R12 NOT ACCEPTED. Prior original Run40772260487 remains FAILURE by design, with previously accepted original 3/3 ZIP hashes; no redownload or rerun was needed.

   Current protected ADR docs/adr-0311-event-driven-request-v1.md requires an independently authorized durable writer and verified protected state-ref trust; it explicitly says to report BLOCKED_APPROVAL when that cannot be established under existing authority. Current state adapter is inert; existing R05 jobs grant contents:read, not an Actions state writer. Chat connector Contents write does not establish an Actions token capability. The instruction to continue approved writer work does not identify an existing approved credential/protected-ref policy and does not override the explicit prohibition on unauthorized privilege expansion.

   Concrete minimum unblock contract (proposal only; NOTHING granted)

   1. Designate the already-approved state-writer identity and authoritative policy/approval evidence, including exact repository/ref scope. If none exists, separately approve its establishment. Do not reuse Publisher/Catalog credentials or export the Chat connector credential.
   2. Establish pgextwin/build:refs/heads/issue311-state as the independently trusted checkpoint root, with effective rules/actor restrictions independently evidenced. Required data scope: checkpoints/<validated-requestId>.json; approved immutable protected-main writer code only. GitHub contents permission is repository-level: claiming it is natively path-scoped would be false. A plain unprotected branch plus concurrency group is not an acceptable substitute; a writer needing a protection bypass requires an explicit, separately reviewed decision.
   3. Minimum requested runtime operations are authenticated checkpoint GET and SHA-CAS create/update on that designated state root, finite lifetime/lease, durable receipt and quarantine on ambiguous response. No general workflow/Release/tag/Catalog write. Production request admission remains disabled until identity/rule evidence is independently verified.
   4. Administrative verification, if needed, is limited to https://github.com/pgextwin/build/settings/rules and https://github.com/pgextwin/build/settings/branches plus the designated writer's approved settings. Capture effective ref rules and actor/credential capability without exposing keys/tokens. Do not relax main/required CI, add cron, grant Publisher authority, or silently install an App/Secret. Existing connector cannot verify the administration endpoint (403); no browser/admin change was attempted.

   Exact resume and acceptance sequence

   After the above authority/trust evidence exists: implement a fixed-scope nonpublishing writer through a protected PR; verify original App15368 resolver on latest exact HEAD; protected expected-head merge and original postmerge. Use a NEW bounded proof request, preserving successful earlier evidence. Demonstrate two actual Actions owners contending for the same checkpoint (stale CAS fails), stop/restart across separate original runs, lease expiry with generation/fencing checks, independent ambiguous-write GET reconciliation, and reuse of successful stage receipts. Expired lease never permits retry of an uncertain privileged write. Until these pass, persistenceAccepted stays false.

   Only then R05: original orafce .github/workflows/windows.yml currently supports pull_request/push/workflow_dispatch, not workflow_call (blob 790bba7df9e48bb290597dfa4a02aa0ddec9e685). Do not pretend GET starts its Windows Workflow or assume central GITHUB_TOKEN can trigger remote CI. Select an approved existing initiation transport or introduce a separately reviewed nonpublishing reusable interface; pin immutable source and bind request/main/run/attempt. Define bounded queue/event deadline, finite 429/5xx read retries, failed/skipped child final aggregation, and persist FAILED/QUARANTINED with resume pointer for absent event or uncertain initiation. Whole-run cancellation needs a separately proven already-authorized recovery event; an always() job alone cannot guarantee it. No manual dispatch, long workflow_run chain, cron or periodic Chat fallback.

   No implementation PR/CI was created merely to repeat an already-proven read-only subproof or install an unauthorized writer. PUBLISH_DENY, original evidence, existing releases, all public gates and #112 ownership remain unchanged. #311/#75 stay OPEN.
9. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

   

   ShutenOishi

   on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

   ContributorAuthor

   More actions

   2026-10-29 JST — authenticated state-root / existing Writer authority recheck (NO RELEASE)

   Continuation of #6481514824 and parent #6481519344. New authenticated GitHub GET, not a CI rerun.

   Evidence	Current observation
   git/ref/heads/main, branches/main	a0cf784edf3cea11df9d925a605a78177c46f9c8; protected=true; branch response exposes required resolver App15368, enforcement everyone
   git/ref/heads/issue311-state	404 Not Found
   branches/issue311-state/protection	403 Resource not accessible by integration; effective state-root protection/actor authority UNKNOWN
   rulesets?includes_parents=true	successful GET returned []; this does not prove classic protection or authorize a writer
   Open PRs	only unrelated #309 and #180; no state Writer implementation/authorization PR
   #311 comments / #75 comments since prior checkpoint	no newer approval evidence observed before this record
   Exact-main recursive tree + all 27 workflow sources	no workflow references issue311-state; #311 R02/R05 workflows retain contents:read. Existing contents:write jobs concern candidate/promotion; Publisher/Catalog credential references are purpose-specific and are NOT state Writer authority
   State adapter	blob 76ffba94b84e64aee2d1f2cb33da7930f90af771, still dependency-injected/inert; no new runtime credential or protected-ref trust evidence

   BLOCKED_APPROVAL / R04_ACTIONS_STATE_WRITER_NOT_ESTABLISHED remains. Existing connector App permission metadata is not proof of an approved Actions checkpoint writer. No protected state root, designated existing approved runtime Writer identity/scope, or independent effective actor-policy evidence was established. This is an authority/evidence stop, not an automatic approval rejection. No production request admitted; this comment is not a durable runtime checkpoint.

   R01–R03 DONE; R04/R05 PARTIAL; R06–R12 NOT ACCEPTED. Previous successful receipts and accepted original ZIP hashes are reused; original Run40772260487 remains FAILURE by design. No successful CI rerun, implementation PR, workflow execution, state-ref creation, permission expansion, credential reuse, cron/recurring Chat, Release/tag/Catalog write or PUBLISH_DENY bypass.

   Resume only when authoritative evidence identifies the approved Writer and exact repo/ref scope plus effective protected state-ref actor rules and runtime capability (without exposing credentials). Then protected PR → exact-head App15368 required CI → expected-head merge → original postmerge → real Actions CAS contention/lease/fencing/stopped-run recovery and ambiguity reconciliation. Only after R04 acceptance proceed to approved real Windows workflow transport, bounded missing-event terminal and R06–R12. Both Issues remain OPEN.
10. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-10-29 JST — R04 Writer承認対象 v1（提案のみ／未付与／NO RELEASE）

    照合と現在位置

    認証済みGETでmain=a0cf784edf3cea11df9d925a605a78177c46f9c8を再確認。#311/#75の取得したコメントと、build内のWriter関連Issue検索から、既存の承認済みActions state Writerを特定できなかった。既存ADR blob 7135cd0585642c35c41f43089549bfca86c77b8d は独立Writerの信頼・権限判断を要求する。前回Work UIのClassic main単独ルール／Installed Apps（Connector、Publisher）は歴史観測として再利用し、今回の新UI監査とは扱わない。

    R01–R03 DONE、R04/R05 PARTIAL、R06–R12未受入。以下は承認可能な設定案であり、承認済みWriterの実証ではない。設定・App・Secret・refは未作成。

    承認対象A：指定済みbuild state refを維持する最小App案

    項目	提案する具体値
    専用主体	organization所有の新規GitHub App、希望名 pgextwin-state-writer（名称可用性未確認）。App ID、installation ID、bot user IDは作成後の実値を採取・固定。既存Publisher/Catalog/Connectorを転用しない
    installation	selected repositories = pgextwin/build 1件のみ
    App permissions	Repository Contents: read/write、Metadata: read（必須）。Actions/Workflows/Pull requests/Issues/Administration/organization permissionsを追加しない。Webhook受信・外部常駐サービスなし
    データroot	pgextwin/build:refs/heads/issue311-state。アプリケーション上の許可パスは checkpoints/<validated-requestId>.json、必要な競合鍵は同じレコードに集約。複数ファイルの同時原子更新をContents API単体に仮定しない
    bootstrap	承認後に管理者が1回、workflowを含まないseed commitとrefを作成し、commit/tree SHAとactorを記録。最終保護の有効化・照合前はruntime admission停止。bootstrapの臨時例外は除去
    資格情報	新規Environment issue311-state-writer に専用App private keyを隔離。IDは非秘密変数、秘密鍵はEnvironment secretのみ。repo/org共用Secret・既存資格情報・長寿命PATは使わない
    Environment	Selected branchesのbranch main のみ（tag許可なし）。新規の毎回手動承認は設けず、保護mainで承認済みのコードを信頼境界とする。Environmentはworkflow単位の隔離ではなく、そのEnvironmentを参照できるmainコード全体が信頼範囲となる
    実行	protected mainの固定workflow/scriptのみ。PR/forkコード・未検証artifactを実行しない。mint jobを最小化し、installation tokenをbuild/署名/Publisher/Windows子jobへ渡さない。checkoutへのcredential永続化なし
    token	発行時にrepositoryをbuildに明示限定、permissionsをContents writeに明示限定。GitHub標準installation tokenは最大約1時間であり、任意の短いTTLを設定できるとは主張しない。writer jobは10分上限、終了時失効を試み、同一tokenの401確認を記録。強制停止時は即失効を保証せず標準期限までの残存リスクを記録

    state refの実効ルール案（追加の限定bypass判断を含む）

    1. Active ruleset issue311-state-actor、対象は正確に refs/heads/issue311-state のみ。Restrict creations / Restrict updatesを設定。bypassは上記新Appのみ・Always allow。runtime CASの直接更新のための明示的な例外で、mainや他のrefには適用しない。
    2. 別Active ruleset issue311-state-integrity、同じexact ref。Restrict deletions / Block force pushes、bypassなし。actor rulesetの例外でこの別rulesetまで回避できるとは扱わない。
    3. mainのClassic保護・resolver/App15368・既存全保護は維持。新Appにmain bypassを付けない。管理者が設定を変更可能なことは残存管理権限として明記。
    4. 設定後に親を含むルールとactor ID・effective ref評価を独立採取。正当Appのfast-forward checkpoint CASを正例、既存の許可された非Writer試験主体のstate更新拒否を否定例として実測する。削除/force否定試験は本番台帳を破壊しない方法を別途審査し、設定表示だけで実測PASSにしない。

    必ず承認判断に含める残存リスク

    Contents writeはrepoレベルであり、ref/path/API操作別にネイティブ限定できない。buildのRelease/tagや他ブランチ操作のAPI能力も含まれる。 上記のルール・固定コード・Environmentはstateの信頼を制限するが、漏えいしたtokenからbuildのRelease API能力を消す仕組みではない。PUBLISH_DENYは運用とコードの禁止であり、API能力の不存在ではない。この残存能力を受け入れない場合は案Aを承認せず、専用state repositoryにinstallationを隔離する別案を設計し、root変更のADRを別途審査する。拡張17repo・Catalog・Websiteへのinstallationは案Aに含まない。

    Work実施範囲と完了条件

    承認後のみ、専用App登録・build限定installation・上記2 ruleset・専用Environmentを設定する。秘密鍵の生成・入力は安全な資格情報フロー／必要ならユーザー操作で扱い、Chat・Issue・ログ・artifactに秘密値を出さない。実ID、installation対象一覧、permission一覧、Environment branch policy、ruleset ID/対象/例外/有効状態、seed SHAを非秘密証跡として保存する。想定外の課金・追加権限・main保護変更が必要なら停止する。今回これらの設定操作は未実施。

    承認後の順番（承認だけでR04 PASSにしない）

    設定・主体・scopeの証跡成立 → 固定scope Writerの保護実装PR → 最新exact HEADのApp15368必須CI → expected-head保護merge → original postmerge → 新規の有界非公開proof要求で実Actions CAS競合・stale拒否、lease期限/fencing、別run停止復旧、曖昧writeの独立GET照合、成功済みreceipt再利用を証明。read-only retry最大3回、job上限10分、lease120秒を初期設計値としてコード審査し、期限切れを特権writeの無条件retry許可にしない。異なる要求間の候補競合を1 checkpoint単位に閉じられない場合は、原子的なglobal index/transaction設計を先に審査する。

    R04受入後のみR05実Windows transport・有界イベント欠落終端へ進む。always()だけでwhole-run取消復旧を保証しない。R06–R12は依存成立後。成功工程の調査rerun、cron/定期Chat、Release/tag/Catalog操作なし、PUBLISH_DENY維持。

    承認文（未承認）

    「R04 Writer承認対象A v1を承認する。専用Appのbuild限定Contents writeに含まれるrepoレベルの残存能力、state exact-refのactor rulesetに限るApp bypass、専用main限定Environmentの信頼範囲を理解した上で、記載した設定と非公開受入実証を許可する。公開操作・Publisher/Catalog転用は許可しない。」

    根拠となるGitHub公式仕様:

    • https://docs.github.com/en/rest/apps/apps （installation token期限・Contents能力）
    • https://docs.github.com/en/repositories/configuring-branches-and-merges-in-your-repository/managing-rulesets/available-rules-for-rulesets
    • https://docs.github.com/en/repositories/configuring-branches-and-merges-in-your-repository/managing-rulesets/creating-rulesets-for-a-repository
    • https://docs.github.com/en/actions/reference/workflows-and-actions/deployments-and-environments
11. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-10-29 JST — 承認案A v1のユーザー承認受領／共通化方針（NO RELEASE）

    ユーザーが本Chatで「全体を共通化しつつ承認案Aを承認」と明示。対象は #6482026029 の案A v1。後続の貼付引継ぎ内の「未承認」は以前の状態記述であり、この新しい承認で更新する。build限定Contents writeの残存API能力、state exact-ref限定App例外、main限定Environment信頼範囲を含む案Aへの承認として記録する。承認は実主体作成・実認証・R04受入とは別。

    共通化はbuild中央のstate adapter／厳格schema／CAS・lease・fencing／曖昧write照合／receipt契約とテストを共有する方針。17拡張ごとに資格情報やWriter実装を複製せず、承認された固定中央コードへ集約する。『全体を共通化』はinstallationを17repo/Catalog/Websiteへ拡大する承認ではない。候補横断競合はrequest別ファイルの個別CASだけで安全と断定せず、global indexの同一commit/ref transaction等の原子性を実装前に審査する。

    新規認証済みGETでmain=a0cf784edf3cea11df9d925a605a78177c46f9c8を確認。Workで組織所有App一覧を新規確認：catalog-dispatcher、catalog-proposer、classic-protection-audit、publisher。state-writerは一覧になし。New GitHub App操作で https://github.com/organizations/pgextwin/settings/apps/new に到達したが、GitHub sudo再認証が必要。安全なbrowserAuth経由でユーザーがGitHub Mobileを選択し、現在端末側承認待ち。認証情報・秘密値は取得していない。

    今回この記録時点ではApp登録、installation、Secret、Environment、ruleset、state-ref作成は未実施。次は再認証成立を新規画面で検証し、案Aの設定を具体化して実施する。ブラウザーが実行時確認を要求するsecurity-sensitive変更は、その最終操作の具体的内容で扱う。秘密鍵入力等がユーザー操作必須なら、他の実施可能な準備を完了して最小限の引継ぎにする。

    R01–R03 DONE、R04/R05 PARTIAL、R06–R12未受入。停止理由は承認未受領から『SETUP_PENDING / GitHub sudo device verification』へ進展したが、R04実行ゲートは未解除。成功工程再実行・cron/定期Chat・公開操作なし。PUBLISH_DENY維持。主体/scope/実効ルール証跡成立後のみ保護PR→exact-head App15368必須CI→保護merge→original postmerge→R04実Actions証明→R05→R06〜R12。
12. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-10-29 JST — GitHub sudo再認証成功をWorkのCreate GitHub App画面で確認。新規Appフォームをpgextwin-state-writer、Homepage=#311、Contents read/write + mandatory Metadata read、Webhook inactive、Only this account=pgextwinで入力済み。その他permissionは追加せず、未送信。App/installation/Secret/Environment/ruleset/refは未作成。案Aの承認は受領済みだが、ブラウザーのsecurity-sensitive access変更に対する実行時確認規則に従い、Create/installation/build限定権限付与/state exact-ref限定例外の最終実行確認待ち。これは自動承認レビュー拒否でも案A承認の撤回でもない。共通実装は中央集約、build以外のinstallationなし。R04/R05 PARTIAL、PUBLISH_DENY維持。
13. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-10-29 JST — 承認案Aの実設定開始：App登録・main限定Environment作成成功（NO RELEASE）

    ユーザーの『まとめて送信して』という実行時確認を受領し、Workから登録を送信。GitHubはRegistration successfulを表示。

    • organization-owned App: pgextwin-state-writer、App ID 5517840、Client ID Iv23liW538PyWUAlkZ8M（公開識別子）。設定 https://github.com/organizations/pgextwin/settings/apps/pgextwin-state-writer
    • 登録フォームはContents read/write + mandatory Metadata readのみ、Webhook inactive、Only this account=pgextwin。既存Publisher/Catalog/Connector資格情報転用なし。
    • Environment issue311-state-writer, ID 25626604517 作成成功。Selected branches and tags、branch main の1件、0 tags。GitHubの保存成功表示を確認。Required reviewers/wait timerなし。既定のadministrator environment bypassは表示上ON（main branch policyの不存在と混同しない。secret投入前に最終設定照合）。Secret/variablesは0。
    • Environment URL: https://github.com/pgextwin/build/settings/environments/25626604517/edit

    新規App画面は『private key生成がinstallation前に必要』と表示。Key pairs画面は0／You have no key pairs。鍵生成・入力はブラウザーの認証資格情報変更に対する本人操作必須規則に従ってユーザー操作に引継ぐ。秘密鍵を生成・読取・保存・公開していない。鍵画面 https://github.com/organizations/pgextwin/settings/apps/pgextwin-state-writer/key_pairs

    未成立: installation ID/build限定selected-repo実証、bot ID、秘密鍵Environment格納、state ref bootstrap、actor/integrity ruleset、runtime token/実CAS/lease/停止復旧。App登録成功をruntime認証・R04受入に読み替えない。

    次: 本人が鍵を安全に生成し、専用Environment secret STATE_WRITER_PRIVATE_KEYへ入力（Chat/Issueへ貼らない）。既存鍵転用・OAuth client secret追加不要。その後buildのみinstallation→実ID/scope→state exact-ref 2 ruleset/seed→証跡成立後保護PR/最新head App15368必須CI/安全merge/original postmerge→R04実証→R05→R06〜R12。

    R01–R03 DONE、R04/R05 PARTIAL、PUBLISH_DENY維持。コード/成功CI再実行/cron/公開操作/main保護変更なし。共通化は中央実装、build以外へのinstallation拡張なし。
14. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-10-29 JST — 専用Writer installation成立、GUI停止で保護設定は未成立（NO RELEASE）

    ユーザーの秘密鍵登録完了報告を受け、新規reloadで存在だけ確認。秘密値は表示・編集・取得していない。

    成立した非秘密設定証跡

    • App pgextwin-state-writer ID 5517840、鍵ペア1件。UI key ID5079882、fingerprint SHA256:2pQ6iHiHWnKcLxEyvtrgQHtE3HD2T2kaqQCGqGi55lc=、added by ShutenOishi。fingerprintは公開鍵識別用で秘密鍵ではない。
    • build Environment issue311-state-writer ID25626604517に STATE_WRITER_PRIVATE_KEY のsecret名を確認。値の正しさ・App鍵との一致はruntime未検証。branch main 1件/tag0、reviewer/waitなし、admin environment bypass ONを再確認。
    • 専用Appをpgextwinへinstallation成功。GitHubの成功表示と設定ページで Only select repositories / Selected 1 repository / pgextwin/build (repo ID1405931353) を確認。Metadata read、code read/writeのみ表示。
    • installation ID176347451。設定URL https://github.com/organizations/pgextwin/settings/installations/176347451
    • 他repo、Publisher/Catalog/Connector資格情報、main保護には変更なし。共通化は中央Writer実装、installation範囲はbuildのみ。

    今回の具体的な阻害

    次に https://github.com/pgextwin/build/settings/rules を開くブラウザー呼出しが300秒timeout。規定のbrowser-troubleshooting文書を読む復旧呼出しも300秒timeoutとなり、現在browser runtimeが利用不能。GitHubのbot検知・認証失敗・自動承認レビュー拒否と断定しない。新規ルールフォームの入力/保存操作はしていない。成功画面の画像保存もこの停止により未取得（AXによる成功観測は上記）。ユーザーに案A承認や鍵登録の再実施を求めない。

    ブラウザー停止後に独立した認証済みAPI GETで：

    • main a0cf784
    • rulesets?includes_parents=true []
    • git/ref/heads/issue311-state 404
      を再確認。したがって保護state root信頼・runtime token・R04実CASを成立扱いにしない。

    再開時の残作業（承認済み案Aを維持）

    1. GUI再利用可能時、既存App/installation/secret名/main限定Environmentの非秘密状態を照合。Appや鍵を重複生成しない。非秘密のApp ID/installation IDを固定設定へ結合。
    2. workflowを含まないstate seed commit/refを承認済みbootstrapとして作成し、actor/commit/tree SHA保存。信頼根の固定前はruntime admission無効。
    3. Active issue311-state-actor: exact include refs/heads/issue311-state、rules creation, update、bypass actor Integration 5517840 / always（installation IDと取り違えない）。main等へ拡張しない。
    4. 別Active issue311-state-integrity: exact同ref、rules deletion, non_fast_forward、bypass空。actor用例外がintegrityを迂回しないことを検証。
    5. 親を含むeffective rule/ID/actor例外を独立取得。App bot ID、実トークンscope、鍵一致はruntime実証が必要。設定表示だけを実認証正例にしない。
    6. 前提成立後のみ共通Writerの保護実装PR→最新exact head App15368必須CI→安全merge→original postmerge→新規有界非公開proofで実Actions CAS競合/stale拒否、lease120秒/fencing、停止別run復旧、曖昧write独立GET照合、同token revoke/401、成功receipt再利用。複数request候補競合を単一global ledger/transactionで原子的に扱う設計を審査する。成功工程rerun禁止。
    7. R04全体受入後にR05実Windows workflow transportとイベント欠落終端、以後R06〜R12。

    今回全工程完了ではない。 R01–R03 DONE、R04/R05 PARTIAL、R06–R12未受入。現停止はSETUP_PENDING / BROWSER_RUNTIME_TIMEOUT。PUBLISH_DENY維持、実装PR/CI/dispatch/cron/Release/tag/Catalog writeなし。#311/#75 OPEN。
15. ShutenOishi commented on Oct 28, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Oct 28, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-10-29 JST — GUI復旧／state seedとexact-ref二重保護成立／非Writer拒否実測（NO RELEASE）

    前回#6482728149から継続。ブラウザーJS接続をresetして既存Chromeタブを再取得したところGUI復旧。App/installation/鍵は重複作成していない。ユーザー承認案A・設定一括送信確認の範囲内で以下を実施。

    Bootstrap（runtime無効）

    • state ref: refs/heads/issue311-state
    • seed commit 0d0a8ed
    • seed tree bb48b8c49f191ddd1b8a87325fb53535a2c87100
    • parent protected-main a0cf784（main自体は更新していない）
    • treeはREADME.mdとcheckpoints/bootstrap.jsonのみ。workflow/実行コードなし。bootstrapにApp5517840、installation176347451、runtimeAdmission=false/publishAuthorized=falseを固定。
    • bootstrap操作は既存Chat接続を用いた承認済み1回限りの初期化であり、Actions Writerの実認証正例ではない。credentialを取得/転用していない。

    保存済みActiveルールを認証済みGETで独立照合

    ID/name	exact include	rules	bypass
    26084063 issue311-state-actor	refs/heads/issue311-state（excludeなし）	creation, update	Integration 5517840 / always の1件のみ
    26084017 issue311-state-integrity	refs/heads/issue311-state（excludeなし）	deletion, non_fast_forward	空

    両rulesetともcurrent_user_can_bypass=never。mainの既存Classic保護・resolver/App15368は変更していない。rulesets?includes_parents=trueにはこの2件を確認。
    個別原本GET：
    https://api.github.com/repos/pgextwin/build/rulesets/26084063
    https://api.github.com/repos/pgextwin/build/rulesets/26084017

    effective rules専用 /rules/branches/issue311-state はconnectorの許可URL外（HTTP400 INVALID_ARGUMENT）で取得不可。これを空ルールと扱わない。個別ルールのexact対象と実否定試験を証拠とし、専用Appの正例はまだ別途必要。

    実否定試験（非Writer）

    seedと同じtreeの子commit 3e4de92 を作成し、既存Chat接続からstate refにexpected seed SHA付き・force=falseのfast-forward更新を1回試行。
    GitHub GraphQL UNPROCESSABLEで Cannot update this protected ref と拒否。
    独立GETでrefはseed 0d0a8ed のまま。再試行/例外追加なし。非Writerによる更新拒否の実測が成立。削除/forceは実操作していない（設定証拠のみ）。

    次の実装境界

    App主体/installation scopeとstate-ref設定・非Writer拒否まで進展した。専用Appの鍵一致・mint token・書込正例・revoke/401・CAS/lease・停止復旧はNOT_PROVEN。R04全体をPASSにしない。
    次は既存state adapterを調査して、App5517840/installation176347451/seedとルールIDを固定した非公開のruntime proofと共通Writer実装を準備。実装保護PR→exact-head App15368必須CI→安全merge→original postmergeから、承認済み固定mainコードで初めて鍵一致/実token正例を検証する。proof requestの運用state保存権限と公開Publisher権限を分け、AUDIT_ONLYから汎用候補/公開Writerを起動しない。lease期限切れは未知writeの再試行許可ではない。複数要求の候補競合はglobal ledgerの原子的CAS設計を先に確定。

    R04受入後のみR05実Windows連携・イベント欠落終端→R06〜R12。R01–R03 DONE、R04/R05 PARTIAL維持。PUBLISH_DENY、原本、成功工程再実行禁止、cron/定期Chat禁止、build限定installation維持。#311/#75 OPEN。
16. 199 remaining items

    Load more

    Load more actions

17. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-11-02 Chat update continuation: genuine UPDATE_PRESENT handling fixed, fresh one-shot source

    • original PR#511 17 protected source scan 41370519208 SUCCESS, genuine 17 App child original 41370589063 SUCCESS, but downstream CAS 41370838703 FAIL_CLOSED: R06_APP_CAS_DENY unaccepted 17-App local terminal child. Real upstream version hypopg 1.4.5 yields lawful UPDATE_PRESENT_NOT_AUTHORIZED outcome, which coordinator accepted but terminal CAS incorrectly required all 17 NO_UPDATE. Finite original watchdog 41370519124 independently wrote durable QUARANTINED revision2 state and revoked same token HTTP401. Old failed run/state are IMMUTABLE and not replayed.
    • Fix PR#512 protected merge new main b8463adc1e623ab852d0816ae489adfd69ed5ae1, App15368 mandatory resolver 41371311269 SUCCESS, source-bound original child result strict matching NO_UPDATE/UPDATE_PRESENT_NOT_AUTHORIZED; if updates detected store nonpublishing SUCCESS (not fake NO_UPDATE), retain detected repo list and independent keyless reader exact binding, all publisher grants false, hostile tests incl spoofing successful.
    • First post-fix new request PR#513 protected merge 9778fbd9c96f932ac6d73fe93d9df4d0eb690325 with App15368 CI 41371516220 SUCCESS, but new request targets had an unwanted diagnostic protected field; original scan 41371642735 strictly schema FAILED and 17 App never dispatched. Failed one-shot remains preserved; no retry/rerun or forged evidence.
    • Corrected NEW immutable request r-20261102-r06preparechatupdate03 in PR#514, targets exact schema {repo,mainSha} for each 17 independently verified protected heads; source main 9778fbd9c96f932ac6d73fe93d9df4d0eb690325. App15368 CI 41371797210 SUCCESS, protected squash merge new main 3593a5d75a21bdd47e84b76a162b6f6ed18c6b0c. New genuine central scan 41371898195 SUCCESS, postmerge Validate 41371898175 SUCCESS. Authentic 17-child 41371947491 and independent guarded watchdog 41371898178 IN_PROGRESS at this comment, subsequent CAS/readback not yet verified. Never count as signed Release or full completed acceptance until actual terminal proof.
    • Actual public signed official pgextwin releases remain at existing 17/17 version; hypopg#57 native PR action_required and plpgsql_check#78 manual signed publication remain distinct candidate-specific release gates. Both source-specific issues updated; never bypass App15368, PUBLISH_DENY, runtimeEnabled=false, signature/Attestation, previous quarantine or removed schedule gates.

    Next: inspect actual completion 41371947491 then new CAS workflow_run and original independent separate Runner readback. If CAS fail, record exact failure and do not claim readback. Formal Release separate.
18. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-11-02 JST — pgextwin Chat update: NEW 17-extension PREPARE + genuine independent CAS/keyless readback VERIFIED (no formal release).

    New one-shot request r-20261102-r06preparechatupdate03, build PR#514 protected + App15368 required CI Run41371797210 SUCCESS; merged protected main 3593a5d. Real update-present status handling fix PR#512 protected+CI success. No safety policy changes.

    Genuine central original 17-source scan Run41371898195 SUCCESS original ZIP artifact13110195239 sha256:923f37ff30dde687fcd4798ff6f1c51248b2ceb48ff0f24ac21cf7cdccf8b09f.

    Genuine scoped App 17 local original child verify Run41371947491 SUCCESS, 17 original ZIP receipts verified, source artifact13109328296 sha256:9314bf5b1e70bb4bcd285bb1bda8bd5ad4589f26950705a9bdc95c6f20d53b4e.

    Genuine State Writer CAS terminal Run41372172432 SUCCESS with exact log: ISSUE311_APP_CAS_TERMINAL {publisherAuthorized:false,reason:'',result:'UPDATE_PRESENT_17_APP_CAS_DURABLE_READBACK_PENDING',targetCount:17}. Proof artifact13110185842 sha256:a9dc335d234d8278429fff25b3ad40cfc01e0684f17f9fbe5cad89e6b30a0f63.

    Independent separate key-free Runner in same Run41372172432 SUCCESS, exact log: ISSUE311_APP_CAS_INDEPENDENT_READBACK ORIGINAL_17_GET_CAS_READBACK_DENIAL_PASS; output artifact13110280531 sha256:e35e2f9fcd7dec4231fb1819ee473d96d51dc0ff289fdc5ad4bbaad34461b092. App token revocation/replay DENY gates preserved. Protected postmerge Validate Run41371898175 SUCCESS. Finite independent watchdog Run41371898178 is IN_PROGRESS when this evidence was captured; never claim its success before terminal check.

    Prior authentic request r-20261102-r06preparechatupdate01: scan/17 local source succeeded but CAS rejected real update-present, watchdog quarantined real failed state; never replay it. Following request02 had malformed target key and was strictly schema-rejected; no App originals dispatched. Genuine fresh request03 fixed both; no past successful Runs rerun.

    Critical distinction: this COMPLETES NONPUBLISHING 17 PREPARE/State CAS/key-free readback, NOT a new signed formal Release. Public release 17/17 unchanged; historical formal 85/94 unchanged. hypopg 1.4.5 candidate PR pgextwin/hypopg#57 remains draft, original required native pull_request Run41326133217 action_required, only dispatch Run41326131241 passed. plpgsql_check 2.10.16 is merged in main but formal manual-only signed Release/PUBLISH gate not yet satisfied; public v2.10.15-windows.1. No unsafe merge/publish, old schedule retirement, branch protection waiver, or publication grant.

    NEXT: native GitHub UI approve-and-run of hypopg PR#57 existing PR head if authorized, wait required CI, then protected merge/signed candidate and official Publisher under policy. For plpgsql_check check candidate-specific original signed promotion input and operator-specific PUBLISH authorization; no generic Chat PREPARE substitution. Independently verify new published assets after legit Release.
19. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-11-02 Work-minimization audit: connected Chat GitHub actions can create branch/file/PR, mark Draft ready, review actual CI, protected expected-head merge, issue/evidence; connector does NOT expose approve workflow run or workflow_dispatch. Hypopg#57 marked READY_FOR_REVIEW by Chat; only PR Run41326133217 remains action_required as human GitHub UI gate. Existing central fleet + both local configs/release-promotion.json are releasePolicy=automatic-signed-schedule, so old manual-only promote.yml must NOT be blindly triggered by Work: legacy fleet-promotion-gate requires central/local manual-only and exact successful workflow_dispatch candidate run. plpgsql_check 2.10.16 head c83e03b... PR native CI Run40243414614 SUCCESS but only candidate workflow_dispatch 40227911216 FAILED on older head b3138e...; manual promote inputs not eligible. Prefer existing signed-schedule Publisher path after its valid evidence and gates, not a Work manual RELEASE bypass. Hypopg approval is the narrow only Work UI task today. No publication made, release safety unchanged; public versions still hypopg 1.4.4, plpgsql_check 2.10.15. Reference #501 for optional watchdog issue, not blocking signed-release work.
20. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    Last edited by ShutenOishi

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    hypopg PR #57 — 指定Runの実行承認（2026-11-02 JST）

    依頼範囲はGitHub Actionsの実行承認と同一Run結果の記録のみ。

    • PR: chore: candidate hypopg 1.4.5 hypopg#57 （hypopg 1.4.5、Draft解除済み）
    • Run: https://github.com/pgextwin/hypopg/actions/runs/41326133217 （Windows CI/CD / windows.yml）
    • PR HEADおよびRun head_sha: a30dd0ccbc790c76079c5d4cc287c0ad42097003。期待HEADとの完全一致を認証済みGETで確認。
    • GitHub正規画面で「Status Action required」「This workflow is awaiting approval from a maintainer in Truthful compiler provenance for SQL-only extension packages #57」と「Approve and run」を確認。
    • 2026-11-02 11:43 JST、同画面の Approve and run のみ実施。承認待ちが解除され、同一Run IDのattempt 2がqueued → in_progressへ移行。GitHub画面では「Re-run triggered」と表示されるが、Re-run all jobsボタンやrerun APIは使用していない。承認前attempt 1はsuccessではなくaction_required。
    • 最終結果: 同一Run ID 41326133217 / attempt 2 = completed / SUCCESS（2026-11-02 11:48:55 JST、認証済みGETで確認）。HEADは期待値から不変。別Runの成功は代用していない。

    同一Runのジョブ	Job ID	結果
    windows / Resolve extension and PostgreSQL matrix	125066053102	SUCCESS
    windows / PostgreSQL 15 / Windows x64	125066112517	SUCCESS
    windows / PostgreSQL 18 / Windows x64	125066112557	SUCCESS
    windows / PostgreSQL 17 / Windows x64	125066112562	SUCCESS
    windows / PostgreSQL 16 / Windows x64	125066112564	SUCCESS
    windows / PostgreSQL 14 / Windows x64	125066112621	SUCCESS
    Windows required summary	125067572400	SUCCESS
    Verify candidate Windows matrix and immutable artifacts	125067573342	SKIPPED

    候補成果物レポートのSKIPPEDをSUCCESSや成果物検証済みとは扱わない。今回の範囲では公開ZIP照合・署名公開・保護マージの判定は実施していない。

    通常Chatへの引き継ぎ: このコメントを正本として、最新のPR HEAD・必須チェック・既存公開認可条件を確認し、以降の保護マージ／postmerge／署名公開／公開ZIP照合を別工程で継続する。成功済みの本Runを再実行しない。

    ブランチ保護・必須CI・権限設定の変更なし。実装変更・PRマージ・Release・Catalog・Website変更なし。現行automatic-signed-scheduleを維持し、旧manual-only promote.ymlは起動していない。
21. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    hypopg 1.4.5 — 承認済み真正PR CIから保護マージ（2026-11-02 JST）

    Work承認の正本: #311 コメント 6567816099。

    • 対象: hypopg PR #57、bot-owned 1ファイル更新 (config/extension.json)、上流正式タグ1.4.5固定SHA 9ab5c4fd3701b14ca3c996da360bba9fa5e9b970。
    • 期待/実HEAD: a30dd0ccbc790c76079c5d4cc287c0ad42097003、真正 pull_request Run 41326133217 attempt2 SUCCESS、PG14–18各成功・required summary SUCCESS、candidate_report=SKIPPED（成功と誤認せず）。
    • 既存の同HEAD workflow_dispatch Run 41326131241 PG14–18 + candidate-audit SUCCESS。これを真正PR CIの代替にはしていない。
    • 原本PR HEAD lease付きで保護 squash MERGED、GitHubが merged_by=ShutenOishi を確認、現在の保護 hypopg/main=cea2745bb201b894da2eb3730771589e675e75fd。
    • 新しいmainの独立 postmerge Windows CI Run 41388390468 と、postmerge署名候補 Run 41388390506 はマージによって自動起動。現時点は実行中、SUCCESSは未主張。
    • 中央 automatic-signed-schedule + local automatic-signed-schedule、中央 UNATTENDED と専用Publisher ENFORCE 維持。既存の自動署名原本、別Runner監査、独立署名確認、正式Publisherを待ち、正式Release/公開ZIP/Signature/Attestation/Catalog/Websiteは未完了。旧 manual-only promoteは起動せず。
    • 成功済みRun再実行なし、保護・CI・権限緩和なし。別の古いCIの成功を正式受入に代用せず。

    次は自動postmergeの実結果を確認し、成功した真正署名原本だけを現行中央scheduled Publisherへ連結。正式Release生成後にRelease資産・SHA256/署名・Catalog/Websiteの公開証跡を独立GETで確認する。
22. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    hypopg 1.4.5 — postmerge・署名原本確認／正式Publisher未実行（2026-11-02 JST）

    正本: 前回監査 #311 コメント6569055540。最新の認証済みGitHub GET、Runジョブ/ログ、Release、Catalog、保護設定を確認。成功Runの再実行、Workflow dispatch、Publisher代行、保護設定変更、未認可Releaseはしていない。

    1. 今回成立した証跡（更新1.4.5 / PG14〜18）

    • hypopg PR#57 は期待HEAD a30dd0ccbc790c76079c5d4cc287c0ad42097003 から保護squashマージ済み。現 hypopg/main=cea2745bb201b894da2eb3730771589e675e75fd、保護維持。
    • 真正PR Run41326133217 attempt2 SUCCESSを既存原本として再利用（candidate_report=SKIPPEDはそのまま）。
    • postmerge Run41388390468 attempt1 は push/main・期待main SHAに一致し SUCCESS。PG14,15,16,17,18の5 Windows build/install/functional smoke/package/SPDX/Grypeが全成功、Windows required summary SUCCESS。postmerge通常Artifacts 5件を確認。候補専用jobのSKIPPEDは成功に置き換えない。
    • 真正署名候補 Run41388390506 attempt1 は同一main SHAの push 原本、SUCCESS。PG14〜18のWindows実ビルド・機能スモーク、Build Provenance Attestation/SBOM Attestationの生成と検証、署名候補Artifacts 5件が成功。元監査Job 125097830702 は VERIFIED_REAL_SIGNED_CANDIDATE_BUILD_ONLY; PUBLISH DENY、独立再検証Job 125098047994 は再取得した原本に対し INDEPENDENT_SIGSTORE_SECOND_OPINION_MATCH; PUBLISH DENY。署名候補ZIP/SPDX/Grypeの実バイト・Sigstore・Run/attempt突合はこの別Jobの検証成功証跡であり、正式Release資産のハッシュではない。
    • config/extension.json は upstream version/ref=1.4.5、上流固定commit=9ab5c4fd3701b14ca3c996da360bba9fa5e9b970、PG14〜18。

    2. 独立Publisherの現状（未成立）

    • 中央 build/main=3593a5d75a21bdd47e84b76a162b6f6ed18c6b0c は保護状態。中央Fleet・release-promotionおよびhypopg local release-promotionは全て automatic-signed-schedule。中央 UNATTENDED/既定DENY、専用Publisher App境界 ENFORCE を変更せず。
    • 最後に確認できた実 schedule Publisher Run41378368707 は 2026-11-02 02:33:30Z 起動。ログでは staticPublisherReady=true だが、当時は署名候補原本より前で NO_ORIGINAL_SIGNED_PUSH_ON_CURRENT_MAIN:17、has_candidates=0、独立実バイト検証/正式Publisherジョブは SKIPPED。これは正常なDENYで、1.4.5への出版実行や認可の証跡ではない。
    • 署名原本の独立監査完了は 2026-11-02 04:40:12Z。これ以降に起動した真正scheduled 独立Publisher は確認範囲の中央Run一覧に無く、1.4.5に対する独立 Publisher/Sigstore再照合、create-only Release認可・実行は 未確認／未完了。
    • 正式 v1.4.5-windows.1 Release/tagは現GitHub GETで存在せず、最新公開は v1.4.4-windows.1 (2026-10-26 20:34:56Z)、PG14〜18公開ZIP5件。したがって 1.4.5公開資産のSHA256/署名/Attestation照合は未実施。候補ArtifactsのSHA256を公開ZIPの検証結果に流用しない。
    • 現 catalog/main=edb355a78558aa0e848861de04ba6dd406117b18 の extensions/hypopg.json は upstream=1.4.4 / releaseTag=v1.4.4-windows.1。Website main=2eb3bd618f230cea424b99dac5148ca72d923cd7 は公開Catalogを参照。1.4.5 Catalog/Website更新未完了。既存1.4.4公開維持。

    3. 完了条件・次の最短工程（安全ゲート維持）

    1. 新しい真正 schedule event の独立中央 .github/workflows/publisher-candidate-intake.yml Runを認証済みGETで特定。1.4.5 signed original Run41388390506 attempt1・保護main・原本監査2系統・fresh ZIP/SPDX/Grype/Sigstore・タグ提案を、新しいRun自身の独立Runnerで確認。古いPublisher Runのsuccessを代用しない。
    2. 現行 automatic-signed-schedule と独立 scoped Publisher App のlive gateを満たしたcreate-only正式Release の成功原本を確認。未成立なら DENY 維持。手動only経路で迂回しない。
    3. その実際に公開された v1.4.5-windows.1 のPG14〜18 ZIP5件＋SPDX/Grype＋SHA256SUMSとAttestationをGitHub Release GET・実バイトSHA256・真正Sigstoreから独立検証。
    4. 実公開物に対応するCatalog hypopg一件PRの必須CI→保護マージ、その後Website JA/EN公開読み取り・実ダウンロードを確認して [P0][CHAT UPDATE] 1回の「pgextwinを更新して」→全拡張更新処理（公開版維持） #311 追記。無条件にCatalog/Websiteのversionを先上げしない。

    判定: PR保護マージ ✅ / main postmerge PG14〜18 ✅ / 候補の真正署名・独立監査 ✅ / 現行独立Publisherによる正式Release ❌未成立 / 公開SHA256・署名・Attestation ❌未実施 / Catalog・Website 1.4.5 ❌未反映。正式受入85/94など歴史台帳は変更なし。
23. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    hypopg 1.4.5 — owner release approval, scheduled Publisher catch-up protected change (2026-11-02 JST)

    Owner explicitly approved the minimum necessary processing through formal publication in Chat, subject to all existing hard gates. Signed original and earlier audit details: #311 comment6573532538.

    Actual changes made this turn

    1. build PR #515 only changes .github/workflows/publisher-candidate-intake.yml's genuine schedule from 15 * * * * to 15,30,45 * * * * to offer 3 genuine scheduling windows per hour. This does not add workflow_dispatch, force reruns, generate fake schedules or change any Publisher runtime admission, Sigstore verification, dedicated App/environment, create-only tag gate, local/central promotion policy or branch protection.
    2. Exact PR HEAD a80445c8328a6d56e5e3e79991ea74875f59793c; native PR validation Run41422680959 SUCCESS. Protected squash MERGED to build/main=2a4470d6e141ab772ddb7d293929a99448e7dad2. postmerge validation Run41422890519 SUCCESS.
    3. The automatic push Publisher read-only Run41422890678 at new central main completed SUCCESS. Actual authenticated intake logs: NO_ORIGINAL_SIGNED_PUSH_ON_CURRENT_MAIN:16, SIGNED_RUN_FOUND_REVERIFICATION_REQUIRED:1 (hypopg 1.4.5); READ_ONLY_ORIGINAL_SIGNED_SOURCE_RECHECK=1. Its independent Fresh independent ZIP/SPDX/Grype/Sigstore GET for signed original (hypopg) job SUCCESS. The push event appropriately SKIPPED all scheduled-only Publisher/Release jobs.
    4. Original signed source hypopg Run41388390506 attempt1 and original postmerge Run41388390468, each SUCCESS, never rerun.

    Release completion criterion still pending

    As of this authenticated snapshot, no later genuine schedule Publisher run has completed for the signed source. Latest public hypopg Release is still v1.4.4-windows.1; there is no v1.4.5-windows.1 official Release or published PG14–18 ZIPs. Therefore public ZIP SHA256 and public attestations remain NOT VERIFIED, and Catalog extensions/hypopg.json and Website remain on 1.4.4. Do not pre-update Catalog or claim formal PUBLISH.

    Resume directly at first genuine scheduled central Publisher Run on build/main=2a4470d6e141ab772ddb7d293929a99448e7dad2: observe source Run41388390506 attempt1, fresh same-run independent ZIP/SPDX/Grype/Sigstore, original scheduled admission and scoped App/create-only Release. If eligible, verify new public Release bytes/SHA256/attestations, then one-record Catalog PR with native required CI/protected merge and Website JA/EN public readback. Any failed authorizing gate must stay DENY. Once public complete, restore hourly cadence in a separate protected change to reduce recurrent automation usage.

    Status: protected schedule-catchup change COMPLETED; real pre-Publisher separate-source recheck COMPLETED; formal 1.4.5 Release/Catalog/Website NOT COMPLETE.
24. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-11-02 — 「pgextwinを更新して」＝公開までの一指示承認、17拡張共通の現行運用契約を保護反映

    所有者の今回の明示意思（今後のChat運用）

    「pgextwinを更新して」だけで、実在する真正stableの対象候補を保護PR→必須Windows CI→保護マージ→正規署名→独立Publisher正式Release→公開資産検証→Catalog→Website JA/ENまで承認した意味と扱う。ユーザーへ途中で「公開して」と再確認しない。無指定は登録済み17件、指定があればその対象のみ。更新差分が無ければNO_UPDATE。候補ごとに独立して利用可能な状態まで完了させる。

    安全境界: Chat自然言語の承認はGitHub runtime PUBLISH receiptそのものではない。真正scheduled event、固定SHA、原本Run/attempt、別Runner Sigstore、SPDX/Grype/Attestation、専用Publisher App、create-only、失効、Catalog/Websiteのゲートを維持。WorkはChat接続ができないGitHub Approve and run 等のGUI操作に限定。既存ガードを弱めず、無理なworkaroundsで公開成功扱いしない。

    今回実施・検証

    • build PR#516: 現行17件・一指示の公開承認を docs/chat-first-publication.md に実体化し README_ja.md から参照。旧14件manual-onlyの説明を履歴化。workflow、コード、release/Publisher policy、権限、ゲートは変更なし。
    • 正確なPR HEAD 670a396d9e2fd326504bd1b531ebec1f34548cee、真正native PR Run41427002636 SUCCESS → 保護squash MERGED、build/main=c5840c033d13a251522553ebc11fc488a8357f4d → original postmerge Run41427189204 SUCCESS。文書のmain readbackと #311先頭更新を確認。
    • #75へも現行承認を監査記録。文書と#311先頭が正本。

    hypopg 1.4.5 の現在の公開状態

    • PR#57/main cea2745bb201b894da2eb3730771589e675e75fd、main postmerge Run41388390468、signed original Run41388390506 attempt1、PG14〜18・元と独立したSigstore証拠はSUCCESS（既存成功を再実行せず）。
    • 新中央main直前の Publisher push Run41422890678 は登録17のうち hypopg 一件を SIGNED_RUN_FOUND_REVERIFICATION_REQUIRED で発見、独立ZIP/SPDX/Grype/Sigstore検証ジョブ SUCCESS。しかし push event なので正式Publisherジョブは正規にSKIPPED。
    • 19:16 JST 時点のGitHub認証済みGETで、候補署名後の真正 central scheduled Publisher Runは未確認。既存唯一の直近scheduled Publisher Run41378368707は候補署名前でhas_candidates=0。公開正式Releaseはまだ v1.4.4-windows.1、Catalog extensions/hypopg.jsonも 1.4.4、Websiteも公開Catalogを参照。1.4.5公開・公開ZIP SHA256・公開Attestation・Catalog/Websiteは未完了。
    • 前ターンの build PR#515 はPublisher真正scheduleを毎時 :15/:30/:45 に増やして保護マージ済み。追加の成功Run再実行や偽schedule発火はしない。

    次の一手: 最初の genuine schedule Publisher Runで原本Run41388390506と中央live条件・専用Appによる正式1.4.5 Releaseを確認し、出た時点で公開5 ZIP/SHA256/署名/Attestation独立照合→Catalog保護PR/CI/マージ→Website JA/EN実証→本Issue更新。GitHub scheduleが継続欠落している場合はActions GUIの有効状態/スケジュールを確認し、保護・署名ゲートを緩めず修復。Workは必要なGUIに限定。
25. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-11-02 20:52 JST — one-command authorized update, exact blocker and GUI repair boundary

    Owner instruction: pgextwinを更新して carries consent through eligible Release, signed asset verification, Catalog and Website, per current runbook. No additional publication-consent dialog is required. Do NOT treat Chat consent as a substitute for independently authenticated Publisher gates.

    Fresh authoritative status

    • pgextwin/build/main=c5840c033d13a251522553ebc11fc488a8357f4d protected. PR #515 already increased genuine Publisher schedule to 15,30,45 * * * *; PR #516 documented single-command authorization. PR/main CI success; do not rerun.
    • Latest existing central scheduled Publisher Run41378368707 was created 2026-11-02 02:33:30Z, before original hypopg signed candidate. No later event=schedule Run of .github/workflows/publisher-candidate-intake.yml exists in the authenticated central Actions-run inventory as of this check. In contrast, genuine central upstream scan Run41439951772 at 11:50:31Z completed SUCCESS: this is a workflow-specific scheduling/registration issue rather than proof all schedules are down. The exact cause (disabled vs missed scheduler events/other) is NOT established.
    • The safe push Publisher Run41422890678 detected hypopg as the 1/17 signed candidate and completed the independent real ZIP/SPDX/Grype/Sigstore job SUCCESS; scheduled-only formal Publisher correctly SKIPPED.
    • hypopg protected main=cea2745bb201b894da2eb3730771589e675e75fd; postmerge Run41388390468 SUCCESS and original signed Run41388390506 attempt1 SUCCESS. Latest public Release v1.4.4-windows.1 (NOT 1.4.5); Catalog extensions/hypopg.json still 1.4.4; Website still references public Catalog. Thus 1.4.5 Release and public ZIP/SHA256/Attestation/Catalog/Website are NOT COMPLETE.
    • Other source check: plpgsql_check protected current manifest is already upstream 2.10.16 at pinned SHA 9a5c0ec4babebd5eb8e0db104c54f7ddb43fcc07; latest formally published version and Catalog are 2.10.15, but no same-current-main original signed update-watch.yml push Run (only schedule and unrelated Windows CI). Do not falsely claim its newer Release.

    Minimum next action — GitHub UI (Work only if necessary)

    Check https://github.com/pgextwin/build/actions/workflows/publisher-candidate-intake.yml in the official GitHub UI:

    1. Confirm workflow is enabled; if the official UI offers Enable workflow, enable only this existing workflow. Check that main has on.schedule: 15,30,45 * * * * and inspect Actions workflow state. Do not weaken branch protection/Environment/Apps, reveal Secrets, dispatch a fake schedule, publish a manual replacement, or rerun successful Runs.
    2. If workflow was already enabled, document that fact: repeated no-op cron edits are not a substitute for a real GitHub scheduler. Follow GitHub's documented schedule-actor/re-registration and relevant status investigation, preserving original event trust boundaries; use GitHub Support only after available safe registration/GUI repair attempts.
    3. Once an authentic new schedule Publisher Run appears, continue in Chat: exact signed-source verification and scoped automatic Release; then public five PG ZIP/SHA256/Attestations, Catalog one-record protected PR/CI/merge, Website JA/EN public readback; update this Issue.

    This is a real external event/GUI blocker, not an excuse to downgrade acceptance or represent already-published 1.4.4 as a new 1.4.5 publication.
26. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    Last edited by ShutenOishi

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-11-02 JST — Publisher schedule registration repair attempt

    • Owner requested official GitHub Actions UI repair of .github/workflows/publisher-candidate-intake.yml, preserving all publication and security gates.
    • Before the action, the workflow was enabled (the official workflow menu offered Disable workflow). Its latest genuine schedule was Run 41378368707, created 2026-11-02 02:33:30 UTC, before hypopg 1.4.5 signed source. The subsequent Run 41422890678 was a push, not a schedule.
    • Immediately before repair, authenticated GitHub GET for build Actions runs showed 0 in_progress, 0 queued, 0 waiting, 0 requested. No running Publisher was canceled.
    • In the official Actions UI, disabled only this workflow, confirmed GitHub displayed This workflow was disabled manually, then clicked Enable workflow. GitHub displayed Workflow enabled successfully around 2026-11-02 12:01 UTC / 21:01 JST.
    • Protected build/main=c5840c033d13a251522553ebc11fc488a8357f4d; the workflow on main contains cron: '15,30,45 * * * *'. No code or policy was changed.
    • hypopg signed original Run 41388390506 is event=push, attempt=1, completed/success, with source SHA cea2745bb201b894da2eb3730771589e675e75fd; it was not rerun.
    • Pending: a new authentic event=schedule run after re-enablement, its independent verification and formal Publisher outcome. Re-enablement is a repair attempt, not proof that GitHub scheduling has recovered. Public latest was still v1.4.4-windows.1 at this check; do not represent 1.4.5 as released.
    • No fake schedule or manual replacement; branch protection, mandatory CI, Environment, App, secrets, signature and Attestation settings remain untouched.

    21:20 JST observation: The first configured :15 window after re-enablement has passed; authenticated GET still shows no new Publisher schedule run. GitHub may delay scheduled events, so recovery remains unproven. The next configured window is :30.

    21:35 JST observation: Both configured :15 and :30 windows after re-enablement have passed. Authenticated GET still shows no newer Publisher event=schedule Run; the latest is the earlier Run 41378368707. No build-repository scheduled runs created after 12:00 UTC were present in the first 100 scheduled runs at this check, including the separate fleet scanner configured for :00/:07. This does not establish the cause: GitHub may delay/drop scheduled events and may show aggregate status as healthy while an individual schedule is late. See GitHub scheduled-event troubleshooting. Do not describe the re-enable as proven recovery.

    Fleet commonality: #510 comment 6577118182 records source-bound GET of all 17 protected mains: all 17 use this same central Publisher and have enabled=true / automatic-signed-schedule local release opt-in. Actual workflow differences and four supplemental nonpublishing requalification paths are recorded there; those differences were not changed. Avoid moving hypopg main solely for cosmetic uniformity, because its current signed original is bound to that SHA.

    Outstanding: new genuine scheduled Publisher Run ID; its same-run independent hypopg proof and Publisher result; real Release/asset/Sigstore/attestations and Catalog/Website after eligible publication. At this check latest public hypopg release is still v1.4.4-windows.1. Continue at the next real schedule; do not fabricate an event or rerun successful Runs.
27. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-11-02 JST — owner-requested on-demand update, stop depending on cron

    Owner correction: pgextwinを更新して should start work at the user's chosen time. It is acceptable to use the official GitHub UI through Work if the available Chat connection cannot issue a workflow dispatch. Do not wait for a cron event to begin or finish the requested update. This instruction replaces the previous assumption that the Publisher must await a new schedule; it does not permit forging event=schedule, rerunning successful Runs, relaxing branch protection/required CI, changing App/Secret/Environment, or treating an unverified Release as published.

    Current findings:

    • The actual current central Publisher admits only genuine schedule: its selector, live issuer, typed receipt, formal Publisher and Catalog's independent provenance verifier all check that event. Its workflow has no workflow_dispatch. Merely pressing a button cannot satisfy the existing gate.
    • A genuine GitHub workflow_dispatch is a separate authenticated event. A protected, explicitly designed owner-dispatch path can retain source main/push Run 41388390506 attempt 1 and fresh independent signed-byte/SBOM/Grype checks, current protected branches, isolated Publisher App scope, tag create-only and revocation. It must record and verify the real event/owner identity rather than pretend it was a schedule.
    • The available GitHub connector here has no workflow-dispatch operation. Where necessary, Work can use GitHub's official Actions UI; do not claim that ordinary Chat can dispatch until an actual capability is verified.
    • The upstream fleet scan and per-extension candidate preflight also contain genuine-schedule dependencies; removing only Publisher cron would not make the full update flow on-demand. Catalog sync already has manual dispatch, but its current automatic signed provenance verifier assumes a central scheduled Publisher.
    • Do not disable or delete still-needed schedules until a safe on-demand replacement covers the same function and has passed required CI and a real end-to-end run. Plan the removal after that proof, rather than adding more cron entries.

    At 21:46 JST, latest hypopg public release remains v1.4.4-windows.1; no later scheduled central Publisher Run than 41378368707 is shown. The existing signed original remains unchanged.
28. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    2026-11-02 22:4x JST — owner-on-demand signed Publisher protected deployment (Chat)

    Owner request: pgextwinを更新して explicitly approves eligible formal Release, Catalog and Website, but never bypasses independent security gates.

    Implemented and deployed

    • Protected build PR #517 squash-merged at 88a907dac1466afa758080efbb0faf67ec74a1cc (expected PR HEAD 46d732a3b39b1443037f5a50240749a086d661c3; original PR CI Run 41451415713 SUCCESS).
    • Protected build/main readback matches 88a907dac1466afa758080efbb0faf67ec74a1cc. Original postmerge Validate Run 41455274945 = push/SUCCESS. Original postmerge Publisher intake Run 41455274691 = push/SUCCESS, independent hypopg signed source recheck; as push this is intentionally NONPUBLISHING.
    • Central Publisher cron removed, replaced by first-class owner-origin workflow_dispatch, one registered repository per invocation, default dry_run=true; production requires genuine ShutenOishi actor/triggering_actor and numeric ID, protected metadata/owner-dispatch-publication.json, authentic original signed main/push Run, source-byte Sigstore/SPDX/Grype and Publisher App/Environment/create-only. Existing security restrictions retained. Catalog PR #182 merged distinct owner-dispatch provenance verification.
    • Existing downstream scan and local update-watch schedule flows still exist; their removal requires independently proven replacements. No fake schedule, successful-run rerun, weakening of safety policy, or premature Release.

    Latest eligible candidate and external UI boundary

    • pgextwin/hypopg protected main cea2745bb201b894da2eb3730771589e675e75fd; exact genuine signed main/push Run 41388390506 attempt 1 is successful, independently verified. Public latest still v1.4.4-windows.1, not 1.4.5.
    • The Chat GitHub connection exposes no workflow-dispatch POST action. Next allowed action is owner via official GitHub Actions UI (Work if used) on publisher-candidate-intake.yml: choose branch main, target_repository=pgextwin/hypopg, dry_run=false, click Run workflow exactly once, obtain new genuine event=workflow_dispatch Run ID, preserve gates. Never rerun previous success or modify App/Secrets/Environment/protection.
    • After authentic dispatch: Chat validates Publisher result / public five PG14-18 ZIPs+SHA256/SPDX/Grype/Attestations, performs Catalog protected PR/CI/merge and Website JA/EN public readback. Only mark published after independent verification.
    • plpgsql_check is also 2.10.16 on protected main with Windows CI and genuine scheduled requalification signed dual-audit Run 41409112431, but the current central source admission requires a separate original signed update-watch push on current protected main; do not misclassify scheduled requalification as push. Public latest remains 2.10.15. Address this path separately through a genuine safe on-demand signed-source mechanism.

    Completion boundary: Shared owner-dispatch code+postmerge PASS; formal hypopg 1.4.5 publication still awaits genuine owner UI dispatch, not a cron schedule. Historical acceptance 85/94 unchanged.
29. ShutenOishi

    added a commit that references this issue on Nov 2, 2026

    Allow Chat-only owner Issue #311 release trigger (no Work, no cron) (#…

    ...

    a82609d
30. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    /pgextwin publish pgextwin/hypopg
31. ShutenOishi commented on Nov 2, 2026

    

    ShutenOishi

    on Nov 2, 2026 – with ChatGPT Codex Connector

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    /pgextwin publish pgextwin/hypopg