Skip to content

[K3] Cut the source-bound compiler at the active carrier bridge - #1157

Open
scottdhughes wants to merge 13 commits into
przchojecki:mainfrom
scottdhughes:codex/k3-source-bound-closure
Open

[K3] Cut the source-bound compiler at the active carrier bridge#1157
scottdhughes wants to merge 13 commits into
przchojecki:mainfrom
scottdhughes:codex/k3-source-bound-closure

Conversation

@scottdhughes

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Stack and review boundary

This is a success-condition-B K3 route-cut packet stacked on ready PR #1152 at exact head ed4877cce5f227f33311fa93f5ff5e5f4150ae63.

The net review boundary is:

ed4877cce5f227f33311fa93f5ff5e5f4150ae63..d7f0fd9370b3c13ff93293f08e03cadddb59b921

PR #1152 is still open and its artifacts are absent from main, so GitHub shows the dependency stack until #1152 integrates. After integration, replay only this one packet commit onto the integration head.

Result

The maximal source-bound K3 attack terminates rigorously in route cut B, not a K3 payment.

The packet is scoped only to the declared active residual slice Z_BC^(m=2,r=4). It does not claim a source-bound membership predicate for that slice or an exhaustive reduction from all Z_BC.

It identifies the first missing implication:

declared-slice bad slope
  -> total canonical selector into a supplied actual record/component
  -> reconstruction preserving line, support, slope, owner, and chronology
  -> exact finite projection-fiber bound
  -> raw workboard
  -> distinct-affine-slope payment

A two-sided inverse would suffice but is stronger than necessary. The pinned source-pencil theorem works per supplied actual endpoint record and explicitly distinguishes its parameter line from the evaluation carrier.

Exact workboard and route cuts

  • Replays the raw 433-1b -> O0a exclusion at public-DAG commit 8df0903391a2: 15 cells, 1,575 labels, 25,200 signed systems, zero survivors.
  • Reconstructs the exact thirteen-route table: two raw-empty routes and eleven unresolved raw-workboard routes.
  • Keeps both raw-empty routes at surviving_raw_systems=0 but distinct_affine_slope_payment=null.
  • Reconciles [K3] Cut the 433-1b cell-11 guard transplant #1155 as a valid guard-transplant route cut with its exact surviving point; it is not a payment.
  • Cuts the proposed 433-1b -> O0b / closed-O0a transport only in the frozen natural record/role/gauge/typed-incidence class:
    • repeated BC has parallel-product ratio +1 versus -1;
    • split BC has zero isomorphisms under all six typed outside-role permutations.
  • Makes no claim against arbitrary orientation-changing algebraic maps.
  • Records 11304 only as a conditional candidate abstract-label-orbit workload—not a census, elimination, representative count, or payment.
  • Records eight unresolved candidate source-cover row/passport combinations—not terminal cells.

Exact ledger output

All requested K3 quantities remain deliberately undefined:

U_remaining       = null
U_positive        = null
U_sourcecover     = null
U_K3              = null
U_K3_allocation   = null
signed_slack      = null
ledger movement   = 0

The tangent manifest declares U_paid=981104, but this packet does not bank it: the manifest expects grande_finale.tex blob 8a5d979..., while #1152 contains 6b21d6e.... Both tangent-verifier modes fail exactly at that stale proof-source gate. The derived reserve is manifest arithmetic, not a K3 allocation.

Validation

  • primary Python replay, normal and -O: PASS;
  • 13 routes, 2 raw-zero, 11 open, 32/32 shipped hostile mutations rejected;
  • 23/23 direct source bindings checked;
  • independent Sage replay: PASS, including all 10,395 involutions;
  • independent FLINT replay: PASS;
  • raw aggregate verifier and all three raw node verifier/audit pairs: PASS;
  • [K3] Cut the 433-1b cell-11 guard transplant #1155 normal and -O: PASS, OPEN_GAP, 16/16 mutations rejected;
  • Draft 2020-12 schema and canonical manifest checks: PASS;
  • exact tree on the published branch matches the locally reviewed tree;
  • fresh independent proof review: GREEN / PR-ready for success condition B;
  • fresh independent certificate/custody review: GREEN / PR-ready, plus 41 additional promotion mutations rejected.

The tangent verifier's expected stale-source failure is a quarantined diagnostic, not a passing test.

Upstream overlap and nonclaims

A refreshed audit of all 23 open K3 PRs found no duplicate packet path or active-slice selector/projection theorem. #1130-#1132 explicitly leave the relevant bridge open; #1155 is a distinct guard-transplant cut; draft #1156 repairs a different scalar-locator source pin and does not repair the tangent adapter.

This PR does not close K3, the KoalaBear row, all of Z_BC, any of the eleven unresolved raw routes, source-cover, or the stale tangent payment. It moves no ledger value.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants