Repository navigation
Say What the Registry's Python Profile Means Once the Profile Is Per Directory #3556
Description
Summary
spec/type-model.md "Profiles: build vs lint-only" now says Python's profile belongs to each declared Python directory. The registry still declares one profile per type per repository, as profiles: { "python": "build" }. spec/validate.py accepts that one value, and the schema has no per-directory form.
So a repository whose declared directories differ cannot state its Python profile in the registry. Take a constructed repository declaring render/ (build) and tools/ (lint-only). Either value it declares contradicts one directory's shape.
The same section's "A declared python profile that contradicts the pyproject shape is a false declaration" reads one shape per repository too.
Expected
The spec says what a registry profiles.python value means once the profile is per directory. Two candidate shapes:
- Drop
pythonfromprofiles, since each directory's shape states its profile andpythonDirectorieslists the directories. - Give
profiles.pythona per-directory form keyed by thepythonDirectoriesentries.
Either way, type-model.md, project-types.schema.json, validate.py, and the registry entries agree.
Found while fixing #3552, whose file bounds covered only the spec's Python profile text.
🤖 Generated with Claude Code
Activity
Bring the Remaining Python Profile Text Onto the Per-Directory Rule (#…
ptr727 commentedon Oct 28, 2026
Maintainer decision, 2026-10-28: drop
pythonfrom the registryprofiles. Each declared directory'spyprojectshape states its profile, a lock or requirements file meaning build, andpythonDirectorieslists the directories.spec/type-model.md,spec/project-types.schema.json,spec/validate.pyand the registry entries that set it change to agree.ptr727 commentedon Oct 28, 2026
Backlog burndown round 4 claim. Branch:
feature/3556-drop-registry-python-profile. Files:registry/repos.json(theprofiles.pythondeclarations only, ProjectTemplate and ESPHome-Config),spec/project-types.json(the python type's allowedprofilesand any text saying the registry declares it),spec/type-model.md("Profiles: build vs lint-only" and the registry paragraph),spec/validate.py,spec/audit.py(only if it reads a python profile),tests/test_spec_validate.py,tests/test_audit_helpers.py. PR #3534 also touchesregistry/repos.json, and its owner released the hold for this change.Drop the Registry Python Profile in Favor of Per-Directory Shape (#3569)
Promote Develop: Registry Python Profile, Codestyle and PR Review Sen…