Skip to content
Draft
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
103 changes: 103 additions & 0 deletions LEAN_PAPER_EQUATION_COVERAGE_MAP.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,103 @@
# Lean Paper Equation Coverage Map

**Status:** First-pass Lean coverage audit / review draft
**Date:** 2026-06-28
**Repository:** `rickyjreyes/wct-lean`

This file answers a narrow question:

> Are the major equations from the WCT papers represented in Lean?

This document does **not** change canonical equations, physical claims, paper text, SymPy status, or Lean theorem status. It only maps paper families to the current Lean formalization state.

---

## Current maintained Lean coverage

The canonical WCT registry contains 142 objects.

Current maintained Lean direct/supporting mappings cover 18 canonical IDs:

```text
E1A E1B E2 E3 E5 E6 E7 E9 E13 E14 E17 E18 E58 E78 CM9 CM12 CM13 CM16
```

The maintained index says the other 124 registry objects do **not** have direct completed Lean mappings.

Important rule:

```text
A SymPy PASS is not a Lean proof.
A Lean theorem is not empirical validation.
```

---

## Summary answer

```text
Does Lean include all major equations from all papers?
No.

Does Lean account for the 142-object registry?
Yes, through FORMAL_COVERAGE_INDEX.md.

How much has direct/supporting maintained Lean coverage?
18 of 142 canonical IDs.

Is the core mass/phase/energy spine partially Lean-supported?
Yes.

Is full paper-level Lean coverage complete?
No.
```

---

## Paper-level Lean status

| Paper / branch | Lean status | Current Lean IDs / notes |
|---|---|---|
| Geometry of Resonance | PARTIAL | E17, E18 only; M2/M6/M7 and many descendants not complete |
| Phase-Flux Field | PARTIAL | E9, E13, E14, E58 |
| Rest Energy / Loop Curvature | PARTIAL / strongest | E1A, E1B, E2, E3, E5, E6, E7; missing M1/E4/E8/full variational closure |
| Hard Dimensionality Bound | NOT COVERED directly | M4, E24-E27, E65-E70, TOP1-TOP9 need Lean work |
| Physical Constants | MOSTLY NOT COVERED | E6/E7 skeleton only; parameter derivations not complete |
| Fourier Cymatics | PARTIAL | E13, E14, E58; entropy/support/convergence not complete |
| Effective Mass | PARTIAL | E1A/E1B/E5/E6/E7; CLE/E19/E49 not complete |
| Log Curvature Flow | NOT COVERED in maintained index | G1, EX, EY, EZ, FA not direct Lean mappings |
| Koide Mass Relation | PARTIAL / adjacent | Koide.lean and KoideDerivation.lean exist, but canonical ID integration incomplete |
| Water cavity | NOT COVERED / empirical | could formalize Q/power algebra later |
| Photodiode ledger | NOT LEAN TARGET yet | needs prediction/experiment object mapping first |
| JUNO ghost-mode | PARTIAL definitions only | CM12/CM13 definitions; G1 and smearing not complete |
| LHCb C9 | NOT COVERED | needs object extraction |
| B0 -> K* spectra | NOT COVERED | needs object extraction |
| NIST Atomic Line List | NOT COVERED / data-analysis | needs object extraction |
| WCC / P-NP equivalence | MOSTLY NOT COVERED | E78 adjacent TODO only; M5/E35-E40/E71-E76 not complete |
| WCC model separation | NOT COVERED | needs formal computational model |
| P vs NP critique | NOT LEAN TARGET yet | claim mapping before Lean |
| WaveLock | NOT COVERED | only nearby E17/E18 generic pieces |
| RCA / safe superintelligence | NOT LEAN TARGET yet | concept/protocol mapping first |
| AI drift audit | NOT LEAN TARGET | prediction audit, not equation formalization |
| Fusion tokamak control | NOT COVERED | handoff gate/control equations need extraction |

---

## Best next Lean targets

```text
M1 / E4 / E8: full locking solution and weighted identity family
M2 / E17: full complex modulus-squared curvature operator
E13/E14: full generalized Euler-Lagrange / gradient-flow theorem
E18: full functional chain rule and coercivity route
M4 / E24 / E65-E70: Sobolev dimensional threshold and corrected high-regularity route
EX / EY / EZ: log transform and Cole-Hopf reduction
CLE1-CLE10: curvature-locking/electron sector
Koide files -> explicit canonical KOIDE IDs and declaration map
```

---

## Conclusion

Lean is a serious formal scaffold, but it does **not** include all major equations from all papers yet. The correct next step is to expand Lean coverage from the 18 maintained IDs toward the core mathematical spine first.
Loading