You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
M2-00: Hackathon delivery tracker and GitHub setup #21
Type: Parent Tracker / Project Setup
Priority: P0
Initial status: Ready
Owner: Maintainer or Product/Ops
Depends on: none
Blocks: no code; controls all later work
Writable: GitHub milestones, labels, tracker bodies and relations
complete changed-path set: exactly the 18 authorized paths
unresolved review threads: 0
merge state: CLEAN
Both prior trust-boundary findings are closed. Independent Node 22.23.1 / pnpm 11.16.0 Maintainer verification passed adapter build/typecheck, 5 adapter files / 38 tests, public package import, full pnpm check with 21 files / 728 tests, browser bundle scan, production start/health smoke, diff checks, and the prior adversarial reproductions.
PR #72 remains Draft at this checkpoint. The next serialized action belongs to Maintainer Qy: leave Draft, re-read the final exact Head/Base/check/thread/mergeability gates, and squash merge only if every value remains stable.
Lifecycle remains unchanged until merge and merged-main CI:
Do not release #26 until PR #72 is squash-merged and the resulting main push quality-gate succeeds. Any PR code/head/base change invalidates the exact-head acceptance and requires a new complete Maintainer review.
The #25 Moss adapter port dependency is now satisfied. The single Builder execution slot moves to #26 for planning only. #23 remains Ready/unassigned, while #27 and later dependent issues remain Blocked until their own dependency and Scope Gates are satisfied.
This record does not authorize #26 implementation, Review, Merge Gate, or merge. Issue #26 must submit a closed Work Plan from exact main@a0f3a3e8605812c9f0997059b4a30ea7a736022c before implementation begins.
The first plan already closes many important decisions: an explicit 16-path writable set; one public adapter entry; canonical integer-string/BigInt amount handling; byte-stable protocol tie-breaking; per-protocol terminal outcomes; collector-local 8-second timeout and late-settlement drainage; timing exclusion from selection and digest; Quote-not-execution-evidence wording; and independently checked canonicalize@3.0.0 package metadata.
Four contract blockers remain before implementation can be authorized:
the caller-controlled request can self-assert MAINTAINER_APPROVED asset-catalog authority; the revised plan must separate untrusted request data from server-owned catalog configuration and freeze catalog identity/version/provenance/failure behavior;
candidate outcomes, normalized/timing/failure records, and selected/NOT_SELECTED top-level results are not yet exact discriminated unions, leaving contradictory optional-field combinations and failure precedence open;
the plan overclaims underlying source cancellation; it must distinguish collector terminality, signal propagation, and unverified source cancellation, and test cooperative plus signal-ignoring late fulfillment/rejection;
RFC 8785 acceptance evidence is not frozen to named published vectors, exact canonical UTF-8 output, and an exact project payload with expected lowercase SHA-256.
The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: leave the first plan and review unchanged as history, reconfirm the same main baseline, and submit one complete revised Work Plan restating the full path list, dependencies, API/port change, exact public contracts, catalog trust boundary, timeout semantics, digest/time rules, tests, non-goals, stop conditions, and requested decision.
Do not create the #26 branch, worktree, file change, dependency update, commit, push, or PR before a later Maintainer SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZED record.
RFC dependency metadata and project/catalog digest vectors are independently stated.
Two exact blockers remain:
The exported INELIGIBLE union still permits contradictory combinations because its raw field accepts the entire RawQuoteRetentionV0_1 union. The public type therefore permits UNSNAPSHOTTABLE + ASSET_DIRECTION_MISMATCH and UNSNAPSHOTTABLE + AMOUNT_BASIS_MISMATCH, even though prose says only MALFORMED_QUOTE may be unsnapshottable. The revised type must use correlated branches that make invalid combinations unrepresentable, with compile-time/type-level and runtime evidence.
The RFC 8785 vector is internally inconsistent. The displayed canonical text contains the invalid JSON form \\^O, while the declared bytes and SHA encode the valid lowercase Unicode escape \\u000f. The next plan must use one valid canonical text and independently prove that its UTF-8 bytes, expected hex, canonicalize output, and SHA-256 are identical.
The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: keep v1 and v2 unchanged as audit history and submit one complete self-contained Work Plan v3 from the same main baseline, restating the full 16 paths, two dependencies, public contracts, catalog boundary, timeout semantics, exact correlated unions, corrected RFC vector, tests, non-goals, and stop conditions.
No #26 branch, worktree, dependency installation, lockfile generation, file change, commit, push, or PR is authorized until a later Maintainer SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZED record.
The v2 correlated-union blocker is closed at plan level. V3 now has separate malformed, asset-direction-mismatch, and amount-basis-mismatch members, making both UNSNAPSHOTTABLE mismatch combinations unrepresentable. Its compile-time satisfies / AssertNever / @ts-expect-error evidence and runtime correlation matrix are acceptable. Previously accepted catalog, timeout, late-drainage, BigInt, digest, raw-evidence, Quote-not-execution-evidence, exact 16-path, exact two-dependency, and #27 isolation decisions remain intact.
One P0 RFC vector blocker remains. In the actual final v3 comment body, both JSON blocks encode the U+000F position as the three ASCII characters backslash-caret-O, hex 5c 5e 4f. That is not a valid JSON escape. The frozen expected byte vector instead uses the required six ASCII characters backslash-lowercase-u-000f, hex 5c 75 30 30 30 66. Consequently both displayed JSON blocks fail JSON.parse, their actual byte length and SHA differ from the declared 118-byte vector and 2d5e01a3... hash.
The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: preserve v1-v3 and all reviews as history, then submit one complete self-contained Work Plan v4. Both reference-input and canonical-output JSON blocks must contain the literal six ASCII bytes 5c 75 30 30 30 66, not caret notation and not an actual control byte. Before requesting review, re-fetch the posted GitHub comment and prove both JSON parses succeed, the decoded character is U+000F, canonical text is 118 UTF-8 bytes, hex matches the frozen vector, SHA-256 is 2d5e01a318d0f0879ab568c4be289c8b1f64ef8921a53c6277d5e069978baacb, and canonicalize@3.0.0 output equals the canonical text byte-for-byte.
Keep all accepted v3 decisions unchanged: the exact correlated unions, compile-time/runtime matrix, 16 paths, two dependencies, catalog boundary, timeout semantics, vectors outside the corrected RFC text, tests, non-goals, and stop conditions.
No #26 branch, worktree, dependency installation, lockfile generation, file change, commit, push, or PR is authorized until a later Maintainer SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZED record.
The P0 RFC vector blocker is closed. Readback proves both JSON blocks parse, decode the intended U+000F value, produce the exact 118-byte canonical UTF-8 vector, match the frozen full hex, match SHA-256 2d5e01a318d0f0879ab568c4be289c8b1f64ef8921a53c6277d5e069978baacb, and match canonicalize@3.0.0 byte-for-byte. The correlated outcome unions, compile-time and runtime correlation matrix, exact 16 writable paths, exact two dependencies, catalog boundary, timeout and late-drainage semantics, BigInt comparison, digest contract, raw-evidence separation, Quote-not-execution-evidence boundary, #27 isolation, tests, non-goals, and stop conditions are accepted exactly as frozen in v4.
At this checkpoint there is no #26 implementation branch, worktree, commit, push, or pull request. Authorization is not implementation completion.
The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: re-fetch and verify the exact baseline, then create codex/issue-26-quote-selection in isolated worktree /Users/qy/Documents/moss-mini-demo-issue-26 and implement only the frozen v4 scope. If origin/main has moved, Builder must stop and request a revised Scope Gate before creating implementation changes.
The authorized writable-path count is now 17. The sole added path is packages/moss-adapter/test/server-only.test.ts, and its sole authorized semantic change is adding collectAndSelectQuotesV0_1 to the existing exact runtime-export allowlist in default JavaScript sort order.
Reason: frozen Work Plan v4 already requires that exact sole new runtime export and requires all existing server-only/full tests to remain green, while current main contains an independent closed export allowlist in this previously omitted test. This is a v4 writable-list correction, not a contract/version change.
All other v4 authority, two-dependency limit, #27 isolation, non-goals, tests, and stop conditions remain unchanged. Any eighteenth path or any second semantic change in the added test remains a stop condition.
PR head, reported frozen head, implementation commit, and CI head are identical;
exact changed-file count is 17;
all 17 paths match Work Plan v4 plus the approved path-17 amendment;
packages/moss-adapter/test/server-only.test.ts changes by exactly one allowlist insertion for collectAndSelectQuotesV0_1;
package manifest adds exactly @moss-mini-demo/report-schema: workspace:* and canonicalize: 3.0.0;
lockfile delta is limited to those importer/package records;
Builder reports Node 22.23.1 / pnpm 11.16.0, 102 adapter tests, 23 files / 792 full tests, package import, Web bundle, Web production, diff check, and exact path audit passing.
The next serialized action belongs to Maintainer Qy: independently review and reproduce the frozen exact head, with particular focus on fail-closed request/catalog boundaries, correlated outcomes, timeout and late-settlement drainage, raw evidence ownership, BigInt/UTF-8 ordering, frozen RFC/catalog/selected digest vectors, exact runtime exports, and #27 isolation.
Builder Qy must keep head 97e2806d43caae1881adae9b1c620a2b79d8ce84 frozen during review. Any head change invalidates current-head QA and requires a fresh exact-head CI and handoff.
proposed branch after authorization: codex/issue-27-capability-integrity
proposed isolated worktree after authorization: /Users/qy/Documents/moss-mini-demo-issue-27
The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: produce one closed, exact Work Plan for #27 covering writable paths, public/internal contracts, amount conversion, exact raw Capability identity, independent snapshot/digest, simulator identity handoff, mutation detection, dependencies, tests, non-goals, and stop conditions.
No #27 branch, worktree, code change, commit, push, dependency installation, or PR is authorized until a Maintainer SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZED record is published.
The 15-path list, viem@2.55.11, BigInt-only amount boundary, #26 exclusion, and #28 isolation are directionally acceptable. Four P0 trust-boundary gaps must be resolved in a replacement Work Plan:
MAINTAINER_APPROVED address metadata is caller-asserted without an authority-backed tracked record or a synthetic-only fail-closed contract.
Builder must preserve v1 as history and submit a complete self-contained Work Plan v2 resolving all four items. Do not edit v1 in place. Until a new Maintainer SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZED record exists:
V2 resolves the prior production-authority, authoritative-snapshot, #26 digest-helper reuse, exact path/dependency and #28 isolation blockers. One P0 descriptor-closure blocker remains.
The planned registered exact-input validator only closes own enumerable data values. The exact object forwarded to the simulator may still expose non-enumerable own data, Symbol keys, sparse arrays, or extra non-index array properties that RFC 8785/JSON evidence can omit or normalize. The simulator could therefore observe state not represented by a reported MATCH digest.
Builder must preserve v1 and v2 as history and publish a complete immutable Work Plan v3 requiring one shared JSON-exact validator for integrity verification and exact-identity simulate delegation. It must use trap-safe Reflect.ownKeys, enforce closed record descriptors, enforce dense canonical arrays, reject descriptor violations, and add the exact non-enumerable/Symbol/sparse-array/extra-array-property regression matrix. The 15-path and dependency set may remain unchanged if sufficient.
Until a new Maintainer SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZED record exists:
Lifecycle remains #27 Open / Qy assigned / Project In Progress for planning only. This checkpoint is not implementation authorization, QA PASS, Review, READY_TO_MERGE, Merge Gate, or merge authorization.
Issue #27 is now implementation-authorized with exactly 15 writable paths, sole direct dependency viem@2.55.11, sole new runtime export constructCapabilityV0_1, and only the two named type exports.
Frozen requirements include synthetic-only policy, reuse of #26's authoritative source-boundary snapshot and createSelectedQuoteDigest, one shared JSON-exact descriptor validator for integrity and registered simulate input, synchronous exact-identity delegation after validation, the four descriptor regression cases, and strict #28 isolation.
publish Implementation Report and Pre-PR QA Handoff;
freeze the exact head.
No #27 implementation branch, worktree, file change, commit, push, or PR existed at this checkpoint. Authorization is not QA PASS or merge authorization.
The delivery matches the 15-path, sole viem@2.55.11, sole runtime-export and #28-isolation boundaries, and all reported/local/CI tests are green. Maintainer review nevertheless found four P1 frozen-contract defects:
capability construction re-applies catalog freshness through Date.now(), breaking offline determinism and returning INVALID_INPUT / quote instead of the action boundary;
selected Quote and action evidence build identities are not associated;
a shallow-frozen forged snapshot is accepted without proving deep immutability;
caller-controlled repeated object aliases are accepted even though v3 requires rejection before action delegation.
The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: fix all four defects within the existing authorized 15 paths, add exact regressions, run the complete Node 22.23.1 / pnpm 11.16.0 matrix, push a new head, wait for new exact-head CI, publish a replacement Implementation Report and QA Handoff, then freeze the new head.
No Scope expansion is currently authorized or required. If the repeated-alias requirement cannot be met without weakening/changing the frozen contract, Builder must stop and request a replacement Scope Gate rather than silently changing semantics.
PR #74 remains Draft and is not authorized for READY_TO_MERGE or merge. #28 remains Blocked; #23 remains Ready/unassigned.
BATCH_A / M2 COMPLETE: all 13 child Issues are Closed/Completed and Project Done; non-UI Gate PASS; main 41a32cabd12702fa4786bdf72160db381fa6f542; quality-gate run 31248130228 SUCCESS; zero open PRs.
Activity
11 remaining items
pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_25_READY_TO_MERGE_CHECKPOINT
Current main remains
1e42babfa457ad20ac1efcecca227aceb4995c2b; merged-mainquality-gaterun30999528946remains successful.PR #72 is the sole open pull request and has passed complete current-head Maintainer review:
1b45d53e8307b579a6840b01e472f03d896867e3main@1e42babfa457ad20ac1efcecca227aceb4995c2bquality-gate: SUCCESS, https://github.com/Moss-Mini-Demo/moss-mini-demo/actions/runs/31069505170/job/92514274448Both prior trust-boundary findings are closed. Independent Node
22.23.1/ pnpm11.16.0Maintainer verification passed adapter build/typecheck, 5 adapter files / 38 tests, public package import, fullpnpm checkwith 21 files / 728 tests, browser bundle scan, production start/health smoke, diff checks, and the prior adversarial reproductions.PR #72 remains Draft at this checkpoint. The next serialized action belongs to Maintainer Qy: leave Draft, re-read the final exact Head/Base/check/thread/mergeability gates, and squash merge only if every value remains stable.
Lifecycle remains unchanged until merge and merged-main CI:
Do not release #26 until PR #72 is squash-merged and the resulting
mainpushquality-gatesucceeds. Any PR code/head/base change invalidates the exact-head acceptance and requires a new complete Maintainer review.pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
M2_EXECUTION_BASELINE_UPDATE - post-#25 merge
Issue #25 was completed through PR #72: #72
1b45d53e8307b579a6840b01e472f03d896867e3main@1e42babfa457ad20ac1efcecca227aceb4995c2ba0f3a3e8605812c9f0997059b4a30ea7a736022c2026-08-06T04:13:31ZThe #25 Moss adapter port dependency is now satisfied. The single Builder execution slot moves to #26 for planning only. #23 remains Ready/unassigned, while #27 and later dependent issues remain Blocked until their own dependency and Scope Gates are satisfied.
This record does not authorize #26 implementation, Review, Merge Gate, or merge. Issue #26 must submit a closed Work Plan from exact
main@a0f3a3e8605812c9f0997059b4a30ea7a736022cbefore implementation begins.pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_26_SCOPE_CHANGES_REQUESTED_CHECKPOINT
Current main remains
a0f3a3e8605812c9f0997059b4a30ea7a736022c; merged-mainquality-gaterun31070657110remains successful.Issue #26 planning has entered its first Scope Gate:
SCOPE_CHANGES_REQUESTED: M2-05: Implement quote collection and deterministic selection #26 (comment)The first plan already closes many important decisions: an explicit 16-path writable set; one public adapter entry; canonical integer-string/BigInt amount handling; byte-stable protocol tie-breaking; per-protocol terminal outcomes; collector-local 8-second timeout and late-settlement drainage; timing exclusion from selection and digest; Quote-not-execution-evidence wording; and independently checked
canonicalize@3.0.0package metadata.Four contract blockers remain before implementation can be authorized:
MAINTAINER_APPROVEDasset-catalog authority; the revised plan must separate untrusted request data from server-owned catalog configuration and freeze catalog identity/version/provenance/failure behavior;NOT_SELECTEDtop-level results are not yet exact discriminated unions, leaving contradictory optional-field combinations and failure precedence open;The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: leave the first plan and review unchanged as history, reconfirm the same main baseline, and submit one complete revised Work Plan restating the full path list, dependencies, API/port change, exact public contracts, catalog trust boundary, timeout semantics, digest/time rules, tests, non-goals, stop conditions, and requested decision.
Lifecycle remains unchanged:
Do not create the #26 branch, worktree, file change, dependency update, commit, push, or PR before a later Maintainer
SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZEDrecord.pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_26_SCOPE_V2_CHANGES_REQUESTED_CHECKPOINT
Current main remains
a0f3a3e8605812c9f0997059b4a30ea7a736022c; merged-mainquality-gaterun31070657110remains successful.Issue #26 Work Plan v2 was submitted and independently reviewed:
Work Plan v2 correctly resolved the prior four blockers:
Two exact blockers remain:
The exported
INELIGIBLEunion still permits contradictory combinations because itsrawfield accepts the entireRawQuoteRetentionV0_1union. The public type therefore permitsUNSNAPSHOTTABLE + ASSET_DIRECTION_MISMATCHandUNSNAPSHOTTABLE + AMOUNT_BASIS_MISMATCH, even though prose says onlyMALFORMED_QUOTEmay be unsnapshottable. The revised type must use correlated branches that make invalid combinations unrepresentable, with compile-time/type-level and runtime evidence.The RFC 8785 vector is internally inconsistent. The displayed canonical text contains the invalid JSON form
\\^O, while the declared bytes and SHA encode the valid lowercase Unicode escape\\u000f. The next plan must use one valid canonical text and independently prove that its UTF-8 bytes, expected hex, canonicalize output, and SHA-256 are identical.The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: keep v1 and v2 unchanged as audit history and submit one complete self-contained Work Plan v3 from the same main baseline, restating the full 16 paths, two dependencies, public contracts, catalog boundary, timeout semantics, exact correlated unions, corrected RFC vector, tests, non-goals, and stop conditions.
Lifecycle remains unchanged:
No #26 branch, worktree, dependency installation, lockfile generation, file change, commit, push, or PR is authorized until a later Maintainer
SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZEDrecord.pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_26_SCOPE_V3_CHANGES_REQUESTED_CHECKPOINT
Current main remains
a0f3a3e8605812c9f0997059b4a30ea7a736022c; merged-mainquality-gaterun31070657110remains successful.Issue #26 Work Plan v3 was submitted, edited to its frozen review object, and reviewed:
2026-08-06T05:58:07ZThe v2 correlated-union blocker is closed at plan level. V3 now has separate malformed, asset-direction-mismatch, and amount-basis-mismatch members, making both
UNSNAPSHOTTABLEmismatch combinations unrepresentable. Its compile-timesatisfies/AssertNever/@ts-expect-errorevidence and runtime correlation matrix are acceptable. Previously accepted catalog, timeout, late-drainage, BigInt, digest, raw-evidence, Quote-not-execution-evidence, exact 16-path, exact two-dependency, and #27 isolation decisions remain intact.One P0 RFC vector blocker remains. In the actual final v3 comment body, both JSON blocks encode the U+000F position as the three ASCII characters backslash-caret-O, hex
5c 5e 4f. That is not a valid JSON escape. The frozen expected byte vector instead uses the required six ASCII characters backslash-lowercase-u-000f, hex5c 75 30 30 30 66. Consequently both displayed JSON blocks failJSON.parse, their actual byte length and SHA differ from the declared 118-byte vector and2d5e01a3...hash.The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: preserve v1-v3 and all reviews as history, then submit one complete self-contained Work Plan v4. Both reference-input and canonical-output JSON blocks must contain the literal six ASCII bytes
5c 75 30 30 30 66, not caret notation and not an actual control byte. Before requesting review, re-fetch the posted GitHub comment and prove both JSON parses succeed, the decoded character is U+000F, canonical text is 118 UTF-8 bytes, hex matches the frozen vector, SHA-256 is2d5e01a318d0f0879ab568c4be289c8b1f64ef8921a53c6277d5e069978baacb, andcanonicalize@3.0.0output equals the canonical text byte-for-byte.Keep all accepted v3 decisions unchanged: the exact correlated unions, compile-time/runtime matrix, 16 paths, two dependencies, catalog boundary, timeout semantics, vectors outside the corrected RFC text, tests, non-goals, and stop conditions.
Lifecycle remains unchanged:
No #26 branch, worktree, dependency installation, lockfile generation, file change, commit, push, or PR is authorized until a later Maintainer
SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZEDrecord.pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_26_SCOPE_V4_AUTHORIZED_CHECKPOINT
Current remote main remains
a0f3a3e8605812c9f0997059b4a30ea7a736022c(feat: add Moss adapter ports (#72)); merged-mainquality-gaterun31070657110remains successful:https://github.com/Moss-Mini-Demo/moss-mini-demo/actions/runs/31070657110
Issue #26 Work Plan v4 has completed publication readback and the Maintainer Scope Gate:
SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZED: M2-05: Implement quote collection and deterministic selection #26 (comment)Frozen v4 authority:
5201269230updated_at:2026-08-06T06:42:10Zf30f88dbe065a257a669d5c68e9f50abb7ae0495bd9232d7a69e5525a7322732origin/main@a0f3a3e8605812c9f0997059b4a30ea7a736022cThe P0 RFC vector blocker is closed. Readback proves both JSON blocks parse, decode the intended U+000F value, produce the exact 118-byte canonical UTF-8 vector, match the frozen full hex, match SHA-256
2d5e01a318d0f0879ab568c4be289c8b1f64ef8921a53c6277d5e069978baacb, and matchcanonicalize@3.0.0byte-for-byte. The correlated outcome unions, compile-time and runtime correlation matrix, exact 16 writable paths, exact two dependencies, catalog boundary, timeout and late-drainage semantics, BigInt comparison, digest contract, raw-evidence separation, Quote-not-execution-evidence boundary, #27 isolation, tests, non-goals, and stop conditions are accepted exactly as frozen in v4.At this checkpoint there is no #26 implementation branch, worktree, commit, push, or pull request. Authorization is not implementation completion.
The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: re-fetch and verify the exact baseline, then create
codex/issue-26-quote-selectionin isolated worktree/Users/qy/Documents/moss-mini-demo-issue-26and implement only the frozen v4 scope. Iforigin/mainhas moved, Builder must stop and request a revised Scope Gate before creating implementation changes.Lifecycle remains:
This checkpoint is not Implementation Report, QA PASS, Review, READY_TO_MERGE, Merge Gate, or merge authorization.
pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_26_SCOPE_AMENDMENT_PATH_17_CHECKPOINT
Maintainer approved one closed Scope Amendment for Issue #26:
#26 (comment)
The authorized writable-path count is now 17. The sole added path is
packages/moss-adapter/test/server-only.test.ts, and its sole authorized semantic change is addingcollectAndSelectQuotesV0_1to the existing exact runtime-export allowlist in default JavaScript sort order.Reason: frozen Work Plan v4 already requires that exact sole new runtime export and requires all existing server-only/full tests to remain green, while current main contains an independent closed export allowlist in this previously omitted test. This is a v4 writable-list correction, not a contract/version change.
All other v4 authority, two-dependency limit, #27 isolation, non-goals, tests, and stop conditions remain unchanged. Any eighteenth path or any second semantic change in the added test remains a stop condition.
Lifecycle remains unchanged:
This checkpoint is not QA PASS, READY_TO_MERGE, Merge Gate, or merge authorization.
pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_26_IMPLEMENTATION_HANDOFF_CHECKPOINT
Issue #26 implementation has reached the independent Pre-PR QA gate.
Frozen review object:
main@a0f3a3e8605812c9f0997059b4a30ea7a736022c97e2806d43caae1881adae9b1c620a2b79d8ce84quality-gate: SUCCESSMaintainer preflight verification confirms:
packages/moss-adapter/test/server-only.test.tschanges by exactly one allowlist insertion forcollectAndSelectQuotesV0_1;@moss-mini-demo/report-schema: workspace:*andcanonicalize: 3.0.0;22.23.1/ pnpm11.16.0, 102 adapter tests, 23 files / 792 full tests, package import, Web bundle, Web production, diff check, and exact path audit passing.The next serialized action belongs to Maintainer Qy: independently review and reproduce the frozen exact head, with particular focus on fail-closed request/catalog boundaries, correlated outcomes, timeout and late-settlement drainage, raw evidence ownership, BigInt/UTF-8 ordering, frozen RFC/catalog/selected digest vectors, exact runtime exports, and #27 isolation.
Builder Qy must keep head
97e2806d43caae1881adae9b1c620a2b79d8ce84frozen during review. Any head change invalidates current-head QA and requires a fresh exact-head CI and handoff.Lifecycle remains unchanged:
This checkpoint is not QA PASS, Review approval, READY_TO_MERGE, Merge Gate, or merge authorization.
pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_26_COMPLETE_ISSUE_27_PLANNING_SLOT_CHECKPOINT
Issue #26 has completed its full lifecycle:
97e2806d43caae1881adae9b1c620a2b79d8ce8465753ada85156716e263b660eeab72c42d293431quality-gate: SUCCESSM2 now records 5 closed items and 9 open items.
Issue #27 dependency gate is cleared and the single active P0 planning slot is assigned to Builder Qy:
origin/main@65753ada85156716e263b660eeab72c42d293431codex/issue-27-capability-integrity/Users/qy/Documents/moss-mini-demo-issue-27The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: produce one closed, exact Work Plan for #27 covering writable paths, public/internal contracts, amount conversion, exact raw Capability identity, independent snapshot/digest, simulator identity handoff, mutation detection, dependencies, tests, non-goals, and stop conditions.
No #27 branch, worktree, code change, commit, push, dependency installation, or PR is authorized until a Maintainer
SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZEDrecord is published.Lifecycle:
This checkpoint is not #27 Scope Confirmation, implementation authorization, QA PASS, Review, READY_TO_MERGE, Merge Gate, or merge authorization.
pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_27_SCOPE_V1_REJECTED_CHECKPOINT
Issue #27 Work Plan v1 was reviewed and is not authorized for implementation.
Scope decision:
#27 (comment)
The 15-path list,
viem@2.55.11, BigInt-only amount boundary, #26 exclusion, and #28 isolation are directionally acceptable. Four P0 trust-boundary gaps must be resolved in a replacement Work Plan:MAINTAINER_APPROVEDaddress metadata is caller-asserted without an authority-backed tracked record or a synthetic-only fail-closed contract.MossPort.actionreturns.Builder must preserve v1 as history and submit a complete self-contained Work Plan v2 resolving all four items. Do not edit v1 in place. Until a new Maintainer
SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZEDrecord exists:Current lifecycle:
This checkpoint is not implementation authorization, QA PASS, Review, READY_TO_MERGE, Merge Gate, or merge authorization.
pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_27_SCOPE_V2_REJECTED_CHECKPOINT
Issue #27 Work Plan v2 was reviewed and is not authorized for implementation.
52060534382026-08-06T14:30:42Zc70046d4df0734e6ea99ee8fbb3b075a385c171d68e626da556c4d8114cde7b165753ada85156716e263b660eeab72c42d293431V2 resolves the prior production-authority, authoritative-snapshot, #26 digest-helper reuse, exact path/dependency and #28 isolation blockers. One P0 descriptor-closure blocker remains.
The planned registered exact-input validator only closes own enumerable data values. The exact object forwarded to the simulator may still expose non-enumerable own data, Symbol keys, sparse arrays, or extra non-index array properties that RFC 8785/JSON evidence can omit or normalize. The simulator could therefore observe state not represented by a reported MATCH digest.
Builder must preserve v1 and v2 as history and publish a complete immutable Work Plan v3 requiring one shared JSON-exact validator for integrity verification and exact-identity simulate delegation. It must use trap-safe
Reflect.ownKeys, enforce closed record descriptors, enforce dense canonical arrays, reject descriptor violations, and add the exact non-enumerable/Symbol/sparse-array/extra-array-property regression matrix. The 15-path and dependency set may remain unchanged if sufficient.Until a new Maintainer
SCOPE_CONFIRMED / IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORIZEDrecord exists:Lifecycle remains #27 Open / Qy assigned / Project In Progress for planning only. This checkpoint is not implementation authorization, QA PASS, Review, READY_TO_MERGE, Merge Gate, or merge authorization.
pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 6, 2026
ISSUE_27_SCOPE_V3_AUTHORIZED_CHECKPOINT
Issue #27 Work Plan v3 has passed the Maintainer Scope Gate.
52063743842026-08-06T14:51:21Zd53b3d458640286079fae2ad4eabf0f39b702a97ab7ff48487feedb6b0d6a766origin/main@65753ada85156716e263b660eeab72c42d293431Issue #27 is now implementation-authorized with exactly 15 writable paths, sole direct dependency
viem@2.55.11, sole new runtime exportconstructCapabilityV0_1, and only the two named type exports.Frozen requirements include synthetic-only policy, reuse of #26's authoritative source-boundary snapshot and
createSelectedQuoteDigest, one shared JSON-exact descriptor validator for integrity and registered simulate input, synchronous exact-identity delegation after validation, the four descriptor regression cases, and strict #28 isolation.The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy:
codex/issue-27-capability-integrity;/Users/qy/Documents/moss-mini-demo-issue-27;viem@2.55.11;Closes #27;No #27 implementation branch, worktree, file change, commit, push, or PR existed at this checkpoint. Authorization is not QA PASS or merge authorization.
Lifecycle remains:
pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 7, 2026
ISSUE_27_PR74_CHANGES_REQUESTED_CHECKPOINT
Issue #27 implementation reached Draft PR and exact-head review:
main@65753ada85156716e263b660eeab72c42d2934311362b60539cd36932d73708d0bf632475e71b966The delivery matches the 15-path, sole
viem@2.55.11, sole runtime-export and #28-isolation boundaries, and all reported/local/CI tests are green. Maintainer review nevertheless found four P1 frozen-contract defects:Date.now(), breaking offline determinism and returningINVALID_INPUT / quoteinstead of the action boundary;The next serialized action belongs to Builder Qy: fix all four defects within the existing authorized 15 paths, add exact regressions, run the complete Node
22.23.1/ pnpm11.16.0matrix, push a new head, wait for new exact-head CI, publish a replacement Implementation Report and QA Handoff, then freeze the new head.No Scope expansion is currently authorized or required. If the repeated-alias requirement cannot be met without weakening/changing the frozen contract, Builder must stop and request a replacement Scope Gate rather than silently changing semantics.
PR #74 remains Draft and is not authorized for READY_TO_MERGE or merge. #28 remains Blocked; #23 remains Ready/unassigned.
pillowtalk-Qy commentedon Aug 8, 2026
BATCH_A / M2 COMPLETE: all 13 child Issues are Closed/Completed and Project Done; non-UI Gate PASS; main
41a32cabd12702fa4786bdf72160db381fa6f542; quality-gate run 31248130228 SUCCESS; zero open PRs.