Skip to content

C8 III-20 guide variants (BLOCKED: G1 failed again at 200k/13M, T1/T4 NOTRUN, T2/T3 spec-deferred) - #64

Draft
orda-aska wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
feat/iii20-c8-guides
Draft

orda-aska wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
feat/iii20-c8-guides

Conversation

@orda-aska

@orda-aska orda-aska commented Nov 20, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

C8 slice on III-20, rerun under RE-LOCK-C8 (leo-03-relock.md). Second G1 control failure BLOCKS the slice with no further widening. Draft only; no claim on #53, no merge.

Re-locked budgets (identical for every entry): beam_width=200000, window_len=16, max_states_per_stage=13000000, budget_sec=0.

G1 positive control (87-seed), RAN at the re-locked budgets — FAILED (exit 3):

  • best_len=87, improved=false, states_seen=26391969, stages=[], wall=53.4s, path=optimize_route_verified
  • gate: differential_match=true, trajectory_digest_match=true, exact_win, no premature win, traj_fnv64 106d14c485ba2096 on spec+flat+cpp20 — no oracle drift
  • delta vs committed baseline (120000/6M: 12,434,306 states, best 87): +13,957,663 states at the shipped-mirror width, still stages=[] and no rediscovery of <=84
  • per-run record: evidence/2026-11-20-iii20-c8-guides/run_G1.json

Per-transform outcomes:

  • T1 rot90-guide: NOTRUN — G1 gate failed again (RE-LOCK-C8 s5 stop).
  • T4 fixed-point refinement (84-seed): NOTRUN — G1 gate failed again (RE-LOCK-C8 s5 stop).
  • T2 role-aware guide: NOTRUN, spec-deferred (no guide/role knob through the locked D4 consumer; D4 owner follow-up).
  • T3 start-offset guide: NOTRUN, spec-deferred (truncated seed rejected by the verifier; D4 owner follow-up).

Evidence: evidence/2026-11-20-iii20-c8-guides/LEDGER.md and bench_delta.json (slice_outcome=BLOCKED_G1_FAILURE_SECOND_NO_WIDENING). Branch feat/iii20-c8-guides, commit 96736c7.

Mozi added 2 commits November 19, 2026 21:51
…d, T1-T4 NOTRUN ledger

G1 positive control under locked budgets (beam 120000, window 16,
max_states 6M/stage, budget_sec 0): 87-seed held at 87 (12.4M states,
triple-oracle agreement, no drift). Per locked section 8 the slice
stops here; T1/T4 not run (G1 gate), T2/T3 not run (locked D4 consumer
exposes no guide/role/offset knob). LEDGER.md + bench_delta.json +
run_G1.json committed. No claim, no ready, no merges.
@orda-aska orda-aska changed the title C8 III-20 guide variants (negative-so-far: G1 control failed, T1-T4 NOTRUN) C8 III-20 guide variants (BLOCKED: G1 failed again at 200k/13M, T1/T4 NOTRUN, T2/T3 spec-deferred) Nov 20, 2026

@zero-aska zero-aska left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Evidence QA, COMMENT, read-only rerun at 96736c7 (driver 983ae52). This is a draft, so no approval is attached.

Reproduction. python3 evidence/2026-11-20-iii20-c8-guides/run_c8.py G1 at the RE-LOCK budgets (200k / window 16 / 13M) returns exit 3, best_len=87, stages_log=[] and states_seen=26391969. These all match the committed values exactly. The S87 sha256 and traj_fnv64=106d14c485ba2096 also match run_G1.json. Only the wall time differs, which is host variance.

Evidence hygiene. The seed hashes, bench_delta.json and LEDGER.md match the driver. No run_T*.json files exist, so T1/T4 NOTRUN_G1_GATE and T2/T3 NOTRUN_SPEC_DEFERRED are accurate. The T2/T3 interface claim checks out: optimize_route_verified has no guide or role parameter, and role_agnostic=true is hardcoded at cpp/soko_engine.cpp:1506,1516.

Positive-control caveat (important). The same consumer still takes the 87 seed to 84 at a 40k beam. test_07 passes here with chiral_sym_1:87->86 and iter_tube_1:86->84, and 40k/16/6M also gives 84. At 120k/16/6M and at 200k/16/13M the result stays at 87 with no stages. So the G1 failure comes from wide-beam search regressing on this instance, not from a dead optimizer or a harness bug. The BLOCKED stop follows RE-LOCK-C8 §5, but it doesn't give an empirical negative for the guide variants, because T1–T4 never ran.

Validators. python3 -m soko_mcp.integrity passes and tracks/iii-20/verify.py reports VERIFIED. The full unittest run has 316 tests: 283 ok, 9 skipped, 20 errors from optional research modules that aren't importable, and 3 failures in optional C++ compile tests. These come from the environment, not from this evidence-only PR.

Suggestion. Recalibrate G1 to the established 87→84 control parameters, or document high-beam G1 as a deliberate stress case, before using it to gate T1/T4. Also record the beam-width non-monotonicity (40k reaches 84, 120k and up stays at 87) as its own finding.

Review run: https://cursor.com/agents/bc-13079319-f0aa-5606-ada9-ce58d9db6b20

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants