Skip to content
Draft
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
91 changes: 91 additions & 0 deletions evidence/2026-11-20-iii20-c8-guides/LEDGER.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,91 @@
# C8 negative-so-far ledger — III-20 structural guide variants (soko-mozi-01-c1, rerun soko-mozi-02)

Rerun under RE-LOCK-C8 (leo-03-relock.md): beam_width=200000, window_len=16,
max_states_per_stage=13000000, budget_sec=0. G1 re-ran at these budgets and
FAILED again (second control failure — slice BLOCKED, no further widening).
Sections below preserve the original-budget history, then record the rerun.

## Rerun G1 positive control at the re-locked budgets (RAN — FAILED, BLOCKED)

Verbatim driver output (`python3 evidence/2026-11-20-iii20-c8-guides/run_c8.py G1`,
exit code 3):

```
S84 sha256=eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6
S87 sha256=536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0
engine=/Users/kethuda/.hermes/profiles/proteus/cache/delegation/mcproof-20261119/soko-mozi-01-clone/cpp/build/soko_engine
[G1] seed_desc=S87 prior record (positive control) seed_len=87 seed_sha256=536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0
[G1] best_len=87 improved=False states_seen=26391969 stages=[] wall=53.4s path=optimize_route_verified
[G1] gate: match=True win=True prem=False len=87 valid_sub84=False
G1 FAILED: 87-seed did not rediscover <=84. STOP per locked section 8.
```

Per-run record: `run_G1.json` (same directory, overwritten by the rerun).
Triple-oracle gate on the returned 87-route: spec + flat + cpp20 all agree
(differential_match=true, trajectory_digest_match=true,
traj_fnv64=106d14c485ba2096 on all three, exact_win, 87 steps, all
must-fail controls rejected) — no oracle drift. Delta vs the committed
baseline (120000/6M: 12,434,306 states, 24.1 s, best 87): +13,957,663 states
burned at the shipped-mirror width with `stages=[]` still — neither window
BFS, the chiral-mirror tube, nor iterative refinement shortened the 87-seed.
Per RE-LOCK-C8 §5 close rule this second G1 failure BLOCKS the slice with no
further widening; T1 and T4 were not run.

## Rerun transform rows (re-locked budgets; §4 field set; unrun stages N/A)

| transform_id | seed_route_sha256 | seed_len | beam_width | window_len | max_states_per_stage | budget_sec | nodes_expanded_window | nodes_expanded_tube | nodes_expanded_refine | nodes_expanded_total | states_seen | edge_consistency_checks | best_len_found | gain_vs_84 | oracle_pair | agreement | outcome | source_sha | run_date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| G1 positive control rerun (87-seed) | 536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0 | 87 | 200000 | 16 | 13000000 | 0 | N/A (engine reports aggregate only) | N/A (engine reports aggregate only) | N/A (engine reports aggregate only) | 26391969 | 26391969 | N/A (not instrumented at this interface) | 87 | N/A (control target was ≤84 rediscovery; held at 87) | spec+flat (+cpp20 third check, agreeing) | true | NO_GAIN — CONTROL FAILED AGAIN, slice BLOCKED per RE-LOCK-C8 §5, no further widening | 983ae52517797e2a3e1d2cc9cb04890d8ec307f1 | 2026-11-20 |
| T1 rot90-guide | eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6 | 84 | 200000 | 16 | 13000000 | 0 | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | spec+flat | N/A | NOTRUN — G1 positive control failed again at the re-locked budgets (87-seed held at 87, exit 3); RE-LOCK-C8 §5 stop condition forbids proceeding | 983ae52517797e2a3e1d2cc9cb04890d8ec307f1 | 2026-11-20 |
| T2 role-aware X-mirror guide | eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6 | 84 | 200000 | 16 | 13000000 | 0 | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | spec+flat | N/A | NOTRUN — spec-deferred per RE-LOCK-C8 §4: locked D4 consumer `optimize_route_verified` (engine_bridge.py:469) takes only a seed, no guide/role knob; C++ `optimize` stdin protocol has no role flag and both `tube_beam_refine` call sites hardcode `role_agnostic=true` (soko_engine.cpp:1506,1516); consumer knob = D4 owner follow-up | 983ae52517797e2a3e1d2cc9cb04890d8ec307f1 | 2026-11-20 |
| T3 start-offset (k=8) X-mirror guide | eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6 | 84 | 200000 | 16 | 13000000 | 0 | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | spec+flat | N/A | NOTRUN — spec-deferred per RE-LOCK-C8 §4: consumer derives its guide internally from the full seed and rejects non-winning seeds (ValueError, engine_bridge.py:480-488), so a truncated k=8 remainder cannot be passed as guide/seed without redesign, forbidden by D4; consumer knob = D4 owner follow-up | 983ae52517797e2a3e1d2cc9cb04890d8ec307f1 | 2026-11-20 |
| T4 fixed-point refinement (84-seed) | eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6 | 84 | 200000 | 16 | 13000000 | 0 | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | spec+flat | N/A | NOTRUN — G1 positive control failed again at the re-locked budgets (87-seed held at 87, exit 3); RE-LOCK-C8 §5 stop condition forbids proceeding | 983ae52517797e2a3e1d2cc9cb04890d8ec307f1 | 2026-11-20 |

## Original-budget history (soko-mozi-01-c1, preserved below unchanged)

Slice stopped at the G1 positive-control gate per locked spec section 8
(G1 failure = STOP, do not proceed). No transform completed; nothing below
was redesigned or retuned. Budgets below are the locked D5 values, identical
for every entry: beam_width=120000, window_len=16, max_states_per_stage=6000000,
budget_sec=0.

## G1 positive control (RAN — FAILED, the stop condition)

Verbatim driver output (`python3 evidence/2026-11-20-iii20-c8-guides/run_c8.py G1`,
exit code 3):

```
S84 sha256=eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6
S87 sha256=536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0
engine=/Users/kethuda/.hermes/profiles/proteus/cache/delegation/mcproof-20261119/soko-mozi-01-clone/cpp/build/soko_engine
[G1] seed_desc=S87 prior record (positive control) seed_len=87 seed_sha256=536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0
[G1] best_len=87 improved=False states_seen=12434306 stages=[] wall=24.1s path=optimize_route_verified
[G1] gate: match=True win=True prem=False len=87 valid_sub84=False
G1 FAILED: 87-seed did not rediscover <=84. STOP per locked section 8.
```

Per-run record: `run_G1.json` (same directory). Triple-oracle gate on the
returned 87-route: spec + flat + cpp20 all agree (differential_match=true,
traj_fnv64=106d14c485ba2096 on all three, exact_win, 87 steps) — no oracle
drift. Engine binary is source-stamped (sha256 stamp matches
cpp/soko_engine.cpp), so no staleness. Diagnosis: the pipeline ran correctly
(12,434,306 states, 24.1 s) but no stage improved — `stages=[]`, i.e. neither
window BFS, the chiral-mirror tube, nor iterative refinement shortened the
87-seed. Leading hypothesis, no action taken: the shipped 87→84 used beam width
200,000 while the locked budget caps at the tool maximum 120,000; widening is
forbidden by the locked spec (sections 7–8), so this stands as the stop.

## Transform rows (§4 field set; unrun stages are N/A, not zero)

| transform_id | seed_route_sha256 | seed_len | beam_width | window_len | max_states_per_stage | budget_sec | nodes_expanded_window | nodes_expanded_tube | nodes_expanded_refine | nodes_expanded_total | states_seen | edge_consistency_checks | best_len_found | gain_vs_84 | oracle_pair | agreement | outcome | source_sha | run_date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| T1 rot90-guide | eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6 | 84 | 120000 | 16 | 6000000 | 0 | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | spec+flat | N/A | NOTRUN — G1 positive control failed (87-seed held at 87, exit 3); locked §8 stop condition forbids proceeding to transforms | 41b6f9ca54cc24954adcd3e88149c2371a4478e6 | 2026-11-20 |
| T2 role-aware X-mirror guide | eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6 | 84 | 120000 | 16 | 6000000 | 0 | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | spec+flat | N/A | NOTRUN — interface: locked D4 consumer `optimize_route_verified` (engine_bridge.py:469) takes only a seed, no guide/role knob; C++ `optimize` stdin protocol has no role flag and both `tube_beam_refine` call sites hardcode `role_agnostic=true` (soko_engine.cpp); exposing it needs search-code changes, forbidden by D4 | 41b6f9ca54cc24954adcd3e88149c2371a4478e6 | 2026-11-20 |
| T3 start-offset (k=8) X-mirror guide | eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6 | 84 | 120000 | 16 | 6000000 | 0 | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | spec+flat | N/A | NOTRUN — interface: consumer derives its guide internally from the full seed and rejects non-winning seeds (ValueError, engine_bridge.py:477-485), so a truncated k=8 remainder cannot be passed as guide/seed without redesign, forbidden by D4 | 41b6f9ca54cc24954adcd3e88149c2371a4478e6 | 2026-11-20 |
| T4 fixed-point refinement (84-seed) | eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6 | 84 | 120000 | 16 | 6000000 | 0 | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | N/A (not run) | spec+flat | N/A | NOTRUN — G1 positive control failed (87-seed held at 87, exit 3); locked §8 stop condition forbids proceeding to transforms | 41b6f9ca54cc24954adcd3e88149c2371a4478e6 | 2026-11-20 |

## G1 control row (same field set, for the record that ran)

| transform_id | seed_route_sha256 | seed_len | beam_width | window_len | max_states_per_stage | budget_sec | nodes_expanded_window | nodes_expanded_tube | nodes_expanded_refine | nodes_expanded_total | states_seen | edge_consistency_checks | best_len_found | gain_vs_84 | oracle_pair | agreement | outcome | source_sha | run_date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| G1 positive control (87-seed) | 536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0 | 87 | 120000 | 16 | 6000000 | 0 | N/A (engine reports aggregate only) | N/A (engine reports aggregate only) | N/A (engine reports aggregate only) | 12434306 | 12434306 | N/A (not instrumented at this interface) | 87 | N/A (control target was ≤84 rediscovery; held at 87) | spec+flat (+cpp20 third check, agreeing) | true | NO_GAIN — CONTROL FAILED, slice stopped per §8 | 41b6f9ca54cc24954adcd3e88149c2371a4478e6 | 2026-11-20 |
159 changes: 159 additions & 0 deletions evidence/2026-11-20-iii20-c8-guides/bench_delta.json
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,159 @@
{
"code_sha": "983ae52517797e2a3e1d2cc9cb04890d8ec307f1",
"floor": 77,
"floor_provenance": "frontier-import PR57 (not repo-proved)",
"oracle_versions": {
"flat": "python_flat_bitmask_oracle@soko_mcp/oracle.py#8145f311051a",
"spec": "python_spec_oracle@soko_mcp/oracle.py#8145f311051a"
},
"positive_control": {
"agreement": true,
"best_len": 87,
"budget_sec": 0,
"engines_executed": [
"python_spec_oracle",
"python_flat_bitmask_oracle",
"cpp20_soko_engine"
],
"exit_code": 3,
"improved": false,
"max_states_per_stage": 13000000,
"beam_width": 200000,
"window_len": 16,
"oracle_disagreement": false,
"outcome": "NO_GAIN_CONTROL_FAILED_AGAIN_BLOCKED",
"per_run_record": "run_G1.json",
"seed_len": 87,
"seed_sha256": "536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0",
"states_seen": 26391969,
"wall_sec": 53.4
},
"reference_best": 84,
"room": "III-20",
"runs": [
{
"best_len": null,
"edge_consistency_checks": null,
"gain_vs_84": null,
"nodes_expanded_total": null,
"outcome": "NOTRUN_G1_GATE",
"reason": "G1 positive control failed again at the re-locked budgets (87-seed held at 87, exit 3); RE-LOCK-C8 s5 stop condition forbids proceeding",
"stages": {
"refine": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
},
"tube": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
},
"window_bfs": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
}
},
"states_seen": null,
"transform_id": "T1"
},
{
"best_len": null,
"edge_consistency_checks": null,
"gain_vs_84": null,
"nodes_expanded_total": null,
"outcome": "NOTRUN_SPEC_DEFERRED",
"reason": "spec-deferred per RE-LOCK-C8 s4: no guide/role knob through the locked D4 consumer; consumer knob = D4 owner follow-up",
"stages": {
"refine": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
},
"tube": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
},
"window_bfs": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
}
},
"states_seen": null,
"transform_id": "T2"
},
{
"best_len": null,
"edge_consistency_checks": null,
"gain_vs_84": null,
"nodes_expanded_total": null,
"outcome": "NOTRUN_SPEC_DEFERRED",
"reason": "spec-deferred per RE-LOCK-C8 s4: no offset knob; truncated seed rejected by the verifier; consumer knob = D4 owner follow-up",
"stages": {
"refine": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
},
"tube": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
},
"window_bfs": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
}
},
"states_seen": null,
"transform_id": "T3"
},
{
"best_len": null,
"edge_consistency_checks": null,
"gain_vs_84": null,
"nodes_expanded_total": null,
"outcome": "NOTRUN_G1_GATE",
"reason": "G1 positive control failed again at the re-locked budgets (87-seed held at 87, exit 3); RE-LOCK-C8 s5 stop condition forbids proceeding",
"stages": {
"refine": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
},
"tube": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
},
"window_bfs": {
"best_len": null,
"nodes_expanded": null
}
},
"states_seen": null,
"transform_id": "T4"
}
],
"seed": {
"len": 84,
"sha256": "eecbea96b09117b108c35cacaa5c3dd39530343d50d7a8b0e48c35ac87a1bca6"
},
"slice_outcome": "BLOCKED_G1_FAILURE_SECOND_NO_WIDENING",
"tool_params": {
"beam_width": 200000,
"budget_sec": 0,
"max_states_per_stage": 13000000,
"window_len": 16
},
"baseline_delta": {
"baseline": {
"budgets": "beam 120000 / window 16 / 6M / 0",
"best_len": 87,
"states_seen": 12434306,
"wall_sec": 24.1
},
"rerun": {
"budgets": "beam 200000 / window 16 / 13M / 0",
"best_len": 87,
"states_seen": 26391969,
"wall_sec": 53.4
},
"states_delta": 13957663,
"best_len_delta": 0,
"note": "Second G1 failure at the shipped-mirror width; stages=[] both runs; no widening per RE-LOCK-C8 s5."
}
}
48 changes: 48 additions & 0 deletions evidence/2026-11-20-iii20-c8-guides/run_G1.json
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
{
"run_id": "G1",
"seed_desc": "S87 prior record (positive control)",
"seed_len": 87,
"seed_sha256": "536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0",
"tool_params": {
"beam_width": 200000,
"window_len": 16,
"max_states_per_stage": 13000000,
"budget_sec": 0
},
"consumer_path": "optimize_route_verified",
"wall_sec": 53.4,
"backend": "cpp20_zero_alloc_engine",
"initial_len": 87,
"best_len": 87,
"keys_saved": 0,
"improved": false,
"stages_log": [],
"states_seen": 26391969,
"best_route_sha256": "536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0",
"best_route": "RAUUURRRADAAADLURAAUAAALULLALAUAAARRDLRDRULURURDDAARAULLRRRRRDDRARRRRALUURDRUURARRDDRDR",
"dual_gate": {
"engines_executed": [
"python_spec_oracle",
"python_flat_bitmask_oracle",
"cpp20_soko_engine"
],
"differential_match": true,
"trajectory_digest_match": true,
"alive": true,
"exact_win": true,
"premature_win": false,
"steps_executed": 87,
"final_ascii_match": true,
"traj_fnv64": "106d14c485ba2096",
"route_len": 87,
"route_sha256": "536fabbaba35e466d91cfad83013783bcc1fe33610cedb34c699bb7963f93bf0",
"epistemic_status": "VERIFIED",
"must_fail_controls": [
"rejected_route_promoted_to_verified",
"truncated_prefix_rejected",
"post_win_extra_key_rejected"
]
},
"valid_sub84": false,
"oracle_disagreement": false
}
Loading
Loading