Skip to content

Qualify the frozen 92-module source514 proof closure with retained native evidence - #534

Closed
d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 6 commits into
mainfrom
cbz/source514-hosted-qualification-20261029
Closed

d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 6 commits into
mainfrom
cbz/source514-hosted-qualification-20261029

Conversation

@d6g8k5htny-coder

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

The shared execution host stopped admitting processes during the preserved partial local build. This narrow carrier checks out Math#514 at immutable 86c00d4c08c6c2af0529ec1744693de3ca6ac6e4, builds exactly 67 registered production modules and 25 consumed support modules, and runs the published self-tested bounded proof-closure program through Lean 4.34.1's empty trust-level-zero kernel replay. Mathematical source is unchanged; the seven unconsumed elder source copies and all application/nonvacuity claims remain outside this admission.

The recorder has 22 finite contract cases and three reason-bound source mutations in each Python mode. Before package admission, the workflow also runs the original replay reader's normal/optimized tests and source mutations, then its actual Lean adverse fixtures and six generated-auditor mutations in both modes. It binds HEAD, exact Git blob bytes, immutable loaded code, dependency/runtime identities, compiled module ownership and object stability; raw streams, observed exits and all failed attempts are retained. No console log is hashed while a tee appends to it.

Initial status: NOT_RUN; no new mathematical or tool qualification is claimed. The canonical integrator will observe the native job and verify artifact hashes before admitting results or registering this tool in federation surfaces. See cbz/source514-hosted/README.md for exact commands and boundaries. This implements the owner's CBZ directive; expired historical human/family approval holds are not operative.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

P1 — source custody and stated module boundary are incomplete at fa42ed0ebe9e21f986ed610f39484eb9cbd1925f. Independent read of the frozen lakefile and all 92 selected files found that the seven inputs/elder modules are registered by [[lean_lib]] name = "SourceElderInputs" with unprefixed roots, and are actually consumed: SourceActualFoldDeath imports ElderClearance, SourceActualFoldTorus imports ReusedCompactFrontier, SourceActualFoldH0 imports ElderBridge, and SourceActualTorusRegularSlab imports ClosedSuperlevel.

The current checked_domain binds only the 67 production and 25 SourceDerivativeInputs sources, so those seven source bytes and their owned declarations are absent from the claimed complete source custody and owned-module census. Transitive dependencies in a replay do not by themselves bind those source bytes or establish the missing module ownership census. The README and workflow's “unconsumed” wording is therefore inaccurate.

Repair by enumerating and binding all seven exact unprefixed SourceElderInputs roots and inputs/elder/*.lean files; build and independently census/replay all 99 modules. Use Lake targets such as +ElderClearance, not the invalid +elder.ElderClearance from the earlier local attempt. Preserve the original 92-module executions and failed attempt unchanged as historical evidence, add adverse controls showing that an omitted imported elder module/source cannot pass, and rerun all source/mutation tests and actual kernel qualification. No earlier execution establishes the corrected 99-module boundary.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

CBZ terminal disposition — Q-MATH-534

  1. id: Q-MATH-534
  2. title: Superseded incomplete source514 92-module qualification carrier; native census failure preserved.
  3. exact location: Math PR Qualify the frozen 92-module source514 proof closure with retained native evidence #534, branch cbz/source514-hosted-20261029; head fa42ed0ebe9e21f986ed610f39484eb9cbd1925f; tree 06c190a77e743dd2916dd083a60c17528e57fd75; parent 787ad73c42805155a50afca5a30b02e48e39726e; original base e877242cf68fb24c605066f16dd07f513ee75a1d; reported tested merge 201d42bc09cd3f43314a6128b7ee94e1e4b3658f. Owned paths are the six PR files: .github/workflows/cbz-source514-hosted.yml, cbz/source514-hosted/{README.md,domain.json}, tests/test_cbz_source514_hosted.py, and tools/{cbz_source514_hosted.py,cbz_source514_mutations.py}.
  4. layer_a_status: QUARANTINED_DORMANT_SUPERSEDED_INCOMPLETE_SOURCE514_92_MODULE_QUALIFIER_NOT_A8_QUALIFIED. A5/A7 require preserving the genuine partial successes and the terminal failure. A8 forbids treating a certifying program as sound when its declared domain omits consumed modules and its independent compiled census exits 1. No source514 theorem is refuted; none is admitted CLOSED by this carrier.
  5. exact proven and unproven boundary: Observed/proven: native run 40948423340/job123709783696 reached the exact head and completed setup/source acquisition, recorder contracts, three recorder source mutants in both Python modes, the original replay reader's tests/source mutations, Lean adverse fixtures and six generated-auditor mutants. It then built all 92 selected modules successfully. Artifact 12931886441 is retained, 1,496,522 bytes, ZIP SHA-256 85690399e350800983796f2b17e1fd3395239f53e9c392ab2b780d7e213877ae, 494 members, integrity clean. Failure/unproven: the independent compiled census exited 1, so the job concluded failure and RESULT.json is NOT_PASS. The exact diagnostic is code-generator metadata unexpectedly has a kernel declaration: _private.SourceFourierSeries.0.I4Source.modeCoefficient.match_1.splitter. Independent review comment 6507661236 also proves the declared 92-module domain is incomplete: seven SourceElderInputs roots are registered and actually consumed, yet their source bytes and owned declarations are absent from the custody/ownership census. Therefore this run does not establish complete source514 proof closure, complete module ownership, A8 tool admission, application/nonvacuity, current-tip integration, or any federation G0–G11 result.
  6. mathematical blocking_reason: this is primarily a certification-domain defect, not a mathematical refutation. The exact source514 proof closure cannot be admitted until every consumed source/module is bound and every genuine kernel declaration is distinguished from code-generator metadata by a sound, adversely tested census. The seven elder modules and private splitter classification prevent truthful complete closure. Mathematical application/nonvacuity claims remain separately outside the replay.
  7. attempted: six commits implemented the bounded qualifier; hosted job built all 92 declared modules; normal/optimized recorder and replay-source mutations passed their stated thresholds; Lean adverse fixtures and generated-auditor mutants ran; raw results and failed census were uploaded; artifact bytes/digest/494-member integrity were freshly reacquired; independent review identified the seven missing consumed modules. The exact repair successor is open Math Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership #539 at head 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198, ten commits ahead and zero behind this head, titled “Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership.”
  8. resumption_cost: do not resume this 92-module boundary. Recover exact head/artifact only for history; otherwise use Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership #539's 99-module successor, rebind all seven elder source bytes and owned declarations, correctly classify private kernel/code-generator entries, rerun every normal/optimized and Lean adverse test, build all 99 modules, obtain a zero-exit independent census and kernel replay, then compose against the then-current Math tip under normal protected integration.
  9. isolation: all six owned paths are absent from current Math default 4cc9ff6de9ed6f7887a24e459607fd1061853509; default is 173 commits ahead while this branch has six unique commits. Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership #539 preserves this head as its exact base and adds the repair. No closed production path depends on Qualify the frozen 92-module source514 proof closure with retained native evidence #534's unique commits. Close unmerged; preserve branch, commits, artifact, failure and successor ancestry.
  10. owner: none
  11. maintenance: zero

Disposition: close #534 unmerged as a precisely isolated failed/superseded qualifier. This removes one dangling delivery while preserving the actual 92 successful module builds, all adverse tests, the terminal census failure, independent P1 finding, exact source history, and authorship. It does not close source514, #539, CBZ-0, or a terminal Partial Baseline.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant