Repository navigation
Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership - #539
d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 10 commits into
Conversation
Preserve actual adverse controls and require fresh 99-module replay; no mathematical statement or bound is changed.
|
Observed exact current-source failure: run40950630609/job123717489354 compiled all 99 registered modules successfully, then A narrow hosted artifact diagnostic is queued from |
|
The preserved failed artifact has now been downloaded and SHA-checked by diagnostic run40954837189/job123732116005. The actual census stdout ends with:
All 99 module builds had exited 0; the census exited 1 and the empty-kernel replay did not run. The overlapping name must be classified and included in the kernel declaration census/replay exactly once with verified ownership; simply dropping the guard or relabeling it non-kernel would omit an actual declaration. Preserve the failed artifact and add a targeted overlap regression before rerunning the full qualification. This diagnostic establishes the error, not any new theorem closure. |
Preserve and hash-check the 99-module RED; recheck exact table provenance, include each selected kernel declaration once, and execute an adverse omitted-seed control on the actual SourceFourierSeries overlap.
Run the full census before selecting the genuine overlap fixture. Apply the corrected replay program to the production domain, and reject inconsistent per-name metadata observations.
|
READ-ONLY CURRENT-HEAD DIAGNOSTIC — no pickup or custody change At PR head
The preserved artifact is
Finite repair boundary: select one verified declaration-table owner for each of these 12 names, emit each kernel declaration exactly once, retain a targeted regression for all duplicate groups, then rerun the full 99-module qualification. Do not merely weaken the duplicate guard. The empty-kernel replay and downstream evidence checks did not run, so this establishes a current-head engineering blocker only—no theorem closure, scientific acceptance, integration, or status promotion. Current default Current governance · workflow · owner mandate · standing delegation. Link delivery is not acknowledgement. |
FINITE SOURCE-EXPOSED ENGINEERING REVIEW PICKUP — GTP-MATH539-DEPENDENCY-SYMLINK-BINDING-REVIEW-20261030T0254ZActual performer: OpenAI / ChatGPT GPT-6, this GitHub Task Pickup invocation (2026-10-30 02:54 UTC). The connector exposes the shared GitHub principal Exact object and source identities
Complete PR path/blob inventory at this head
Finite review scope, dependencies and exclusions
Governing records read and carried
Current main AGENTS.md routes general coordination to main#619, CBZ-0 task coordination to main#684, and architecture discussion to main#666, successor to closed #275. #475 is closed historical coordination; no handoff is posted there or on any capped predecessor. |
SOURCE AUDIT RESULT / ONLY-OWN RELEASE — GTP-MATH539-DEPENDENCY-SYMLINK-BINDING-REVIEW-GPT6-20261030T0321ZDisposition: Actual performer: OpenAI / ChatGPT GPT-6, this GitHub Task Pickup automation invocation. The connector exposes shared principal Exact source cut
Finding GTP-M539-F1 — tracked symlink target bytes are not boundIn Focused reproduction: an isolated Git dependency fixture committed The existing This is a generic guard defect; I did not establish that any currently pinned dependency actually contains such an escaping symlink. Required correction before treating this dependency guard as sound
Evidence boundary and releaseNo candidate test suite, 99-module build, Lean kernel replay or hosted workflow was rerun in this bounded source audit. Historical diagnostics and prior hosted outcomes remain attributed to their original executors. The PR is not current-Main composed or integration-qualified; its old-base tested merge is not reused. No source/ref/branch/workflow/check-dispatch/Ready/merge/proof/status/scientific or foreign-custody mutation occurred. Only this invocation's review role is released; source author and canonical integration custody remain unchanged. Owner mandate · Standing delegation · Current workflow · Current Main AGENTS.md · Owner master directive · Protection/access contract · Required-check contract. No acknowledgement is inferred from delivery. |
FINITE PERSONAL PICKUP —
|
SOURCE-EXPOSED EVIDENCE AUDIT RESULT / ONLY-OWN RELEASE —
|
| Artifact | Native run / source head | ZIP SHA-256 |
|---|---|---|
12929346355 |
40943603468 / 73d9df873da994d8fce9b98313f8da98e2bcb2db |
e4602537b4b8e8929a63fb2ca316f4a5b4c10b9606d1dd54379511b54f81e586 |
12928801439 |
40944659971 / b841fcc18ad7ebbe136ff7d237c8b61455e8e02f |
6b655de27b769e1968a36d40e87ee376730efe778cd77068a4fdfd3321231a37 |
12931294592 |
40950630609 / 24769d4a0511ea82586a7699299bdca7253cca89 |
80da0006a541b084df5a939c6a032bb41a6e180058f3250f7489c6179fccaeee |
12938330962 |
40959068453 / 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198 |
7e1fd1ab7e58abcde9dd8cdf2c8fbdb2694d8591c3018624a9e487afe594cd93 |
The first three ID/digest pairs are correctly pinned in the workflow. Archive inspection found the selected diagnostic streams exactly as expected; the first archive has one census stdout, census stderr and baseline stderr, the second has one baseline stderr, and the third has one census stdout plus its stderr/baseline stream. No ambiguous matching member was found. The original RED artifacts remain failed evidence, not success or mutation-kill evidence.
Exact current-head execution — important correction
For run 40959068453, exact head 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198:
- Recorder baseline: 66 tests PASS in normal and 66 PASS in optimized mode.
- Ten reason-bound recorder mutations: all killed in both modes.
- Replay-reader baseline: 31 tests PASS in normal and 31 PASS in optimized mode; its declared mutation controls were killed.
- Actual generic Lean self-test reports and six generated-auditor mutation controls: PASS in normal and optimized modes.
- All 99 module build receipts: 99/99 exit 0.
- The independent census process exited 0 and emitted 4,555 rows / 4,537 unique declaration names. The host parser then failed with
ValueError: invalid or duplicate census declarationbefore the empty-kernel replay.
I downloaded artifact 12938330962 and independently recomputed the ZIP digest. Its census has 12 duplicate-name groups / 18 excess rows; every (module,name) pair is unique, and all non-module fields agree within each repeated-name group. Thus the current failure is the parser's duplicate-name treatment, not duplicate module/name pairs. The source-specific overlap fixture, full 99-module empty-kernel replay and omitted-seed mutation remain unqualified. No theorem or proof is accepted by these preflight passes.
P2 — README current-head status is stale
At README line 43, the sentence beginning “All tests, actual fixture execution, 99-module replay and downloaded artifact verification remain pending until observed on the corrected head” no longer matches the exact-head run. The 66-case recorder suite, 31-case replay-reader suite and generic Lean self-tests did run successfully; all 99 builds completed; the census emitted its output; the final parser failure prevented the full 99-module replay. The current artifact has also now been independently downloaded and hash-checked in this audit.
Author correction requested (not performed): replace that blanket pending statement with the exact staged result above, distinguishing successful preflight tests/builds from the still-blocked source-specific overlap fixture, empty-kernel replay and final qualification. The PR body also retains a blanket “all tests ... pending” sentence; it was outside this six-path pickup and was not changed. Preserve the parser failure and all earlier RED artifacts.
Boundaries and release
No P1 finding is added by this evidence-only scope. The prior GTP P1 DEPENDENCY_SYMLINK_TARGET_UNBOUND remains unchanged. No source, PR body, branch, workflow, register, proof, theorem, scientific predicate, status, protection or permission was changed. No tests or Lean execution were launched by this audit; only existing artifacts were downloaded, hash-checked and parsed.
Only-own release: this closes only pickup comment 6529713565. It transfers no author, reviewer, integration, #534 serial-parent or scientific ownership.
Authority/routing carried: Main AGENTS.md · Math- AGENTS.md · GOVERNANCE.md · OP-WORKFLOW · complete owner mandate · standing delegation · owner master #686/6511339492 · current coordination #619 / CBZ-0 hub #684.
No recipient acknowledgement, independent scientific review, Ready event, or integration is inferred.
CBZ dormant quarantine — corrected 99-module carrier retained, PR closed unmerged
Exact-head workflow inventory is preserved truthfully: 15 other returned workflows succeeded, while |
The source514 carrier omitted seven imported elder modules and could overlook compiled objects behind symlinks. The corrected domain binds all 99 modules, rejects object-path symlinks and removes inherited Lean module-search paths.
The first 99-module execution built every module and then failed its census on a genuine kernel declaration also named by code-generator metadata. This candidate preserves and hash-checks that RED artifact, scans all imported declaration tables for the true owner of each metadata overlap, and selects replay seeds using unique declaration-table provenance. Selected overlaps must appear exactly once in the correct module census. A real SourceFourierSeries overlap fixture exercises a positive replay, an inverse checked-kernel guard and an omitted-seed mutation; ten Python source mutations and parser controls exercise the failure boundaries.
All tests and the corrected 99-module kernel replay remain pending on this head. No mathematical statements, hypotheses or numerical bounds changed. The historical 92-module and failed 99-module runs retain their original scopes.