Skip to content

Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership - #539

Closed
d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 10 commits into
cbz/source514-hosted-qualification-20261029from
cbz/source514-99-domain-repair-20261029
Closed

d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 10 commits into
cbz/source514-hosted-qualification-20261029from
cbz/source514-99-domain-repair-20261029

Conversation

@d6g8k5htny-coder

@d6g8k5htny-coder d6g8k5htny-coder commented Oct 29, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

The source514 carrier omitted seven imported elder modules and could overlook compiled objects behind symlinks. The corrected domain binds all 99 modules, rejects object-path symlinks and removes inherited Lean module-search paths.

The first 99-module execution built every module and then failed its census on a genuine kernel declaration also named by code-generator metadata. This candidate preserves and hash-checks that RED artifact, scans all imported declaration tables for the true owner of each metadata overlap, and selects replay seeds using unique declaration-table provenance. Selected overlaps must appear exactly once in the correct module census. A real SourceFourierSeries overlap fixture exercises a positive replay, an inverse checked-kernel guard and an omitted-seed mutation; ten Python source mutations and parser controls exercise the failure boundaries.

All tests and the corrected 99-module kernel replay remain pending on this head. No mathematical statements, hypotheses or numerical bounds changed. The historical 92-module and failed 99-module runs retain their original scopes.

Preserve actual adverse controls and require fresh 99-module replay; no
mathematical statement or bound is changed.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Observed exact current-source failure: run40950630609/job123717489354 compiled all 99 registered modules successfully, then independent-compiled-census exited 1; the empty-kernel replay did not complete. The preserved artifact is 12931294592 (GitHub-reported ZIP SHA-256 80da0006a541b084df5a939c6a032bb41a6e180058f3250f7489c6179fccaeee).

A narrow hosted artifact diagnostic is queued from cbz/source514-census-diagnostic-20261029 to read the actual census output when the local environment cannot fork. The failure and its original source are retained. No additional source514 declarations are admitted as closed until the census, replay and evidence checks actually pass.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

The preserved failed artifact has now been downloaded and SHA-checked by diagnostic run40954837189/job123732116005. The actual census stdout ends with:

IndependentCensus.lean:102:0: error: code-generator metadata unexpectedly has a kernel declaration: _private.SourceFourierSeries.0.I4Source.modeCoefficient.match_1.splitter

All 99 module builds had exited 0; the census exited 1 and the empty-kernel replay did not run. The overlapping name must be classified and included in the kernel declaration census/replay exactly once with verified ownership; simply dropping the guard or relabeling it non-kernel would omit an actual declaration. Preserve the failed artifact and add a targeted overlap regression before rerunning the full qualification. This diagnostic establishes the error, not any new theorem closure.

Preserve and hash-check the 99-module RED; recheck exact table provenance,
include each selected kernel declaration once, and execute an adverse
omitted-seed control on the actual SourceFourierSeries overlap.
@d6g8k5htny-coder d6g8k5htny-coder changed the title Bind the seven imported elder modules and reject symlinked object roots Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership Oct 29, 2026

d6g8k5htny-coder commented Oct 29, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

READ-ONLY CURRENT-HEAD DIAGNOSTIC — no pickup or custody change

At PR head 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198, base/actual merge-base fa42ed0ebe9e21f986ed610f39484eb9cbd1925f (10 ahead / 0 behind), run 40959068453 tested synthetic merge 9a751aa7934c4091f53c443f70c32b1919ff35f4. All 99 module builds exited 0 and independent-compiled-census exited 0, but the host parser then refused before empty-kernel replay with:

ValueError: invalid or duplicate census declaration

The preserved artifact is 12938330962, GitHub digest sha256:7e1fd1ab7e58abcde9dd8cdf2c8fbdb2694d8591c3018624a9e487afe594cd93. Direct inspection of its independent-compiled-census.stdout gives 4,555 census rows / 4,537 unique names: 12 duplicated names and 18 excess rows. For every duplicate group, all non-module fields are identical; only module attribution differs:

  • I4SmoothCarrier.sampleInclusion.eq_1 ×6: SourceMorseIncidence, SourceSmoothTopology, SourceActualTorusSuperlevelLocalBasis, SourceActualTorusRegularSlab, SourceActualQuotientSaddleCollar, SourceActualRegularLocalCollar.
  • I4SmoothCarrier.smoothSourceField.eq_1 ×2: SourceActualTorusSuperlevelLocalBasis, SourceActualTorusRegularSlab.
  • I4SourceConfluentPins.directionY.eq_1 ×2: SourcePinCurvatureBounds, SourceRemoteJetWitness.
  • I4SourceConfluentPins.endpointM.eq_1 ×2 and endpointS.eq_1 ×2: SourcePinCurvatureBounds, SourceEndpointHessianWitness.
  • I4SourceRemoteJetWitness.localGerm.eq_1 ×3: SourceEndpointHessianWitness, SourceFramedConfluentCovariance, SourceTwoRemoteFirstJetWitness.
  • I4SourceSmoothPalm.sourceSmoothLaw.eq_1 ×2: SourceCompactTargetMoments, SourceCurvatureDecomposition.
  • I4SourceSmoothPalm.sourceSmoothWeightedLaw.congr_simp ×2: SourceWeightedCurvatureBound, SourceRawPinConditioning.
  • I4Torus.torusProjection.eq_1 ×2: SourceEndpointHessianWitness, SourceActualRegularLocalCollar.
  • I4Weights.sourceC.eq_1 ×3: SourceActualMorseLocalModel, SourceTwoRemoteFirstJetWitness, SourceActualRegularLocalCollar.
  • UniversalLaw.Spec.Lifetime.IsCriticalPoint.eq_1 ×2: SourceActualTorusSuperlevelLocalBasis, SourceActualSaddleUppercuts.
  • UniversalLaw.Spec.Lifetime.hessian.eq_1 ×2: SourceActualTorusSuperlevelLocalBasis, SourceActualQuotientSaddleCollar.

Finite repair boundary: select one verified declaration-table owner for each of these 12 names, emit each kernel declaration exactly once, retain a targeted regression for all duplicate groups, then rerun the full 99-module qualification. Do not merely weaken the duplicate guard. The empty-kernel replay and downstream evidence checks did not run, so this establishes a current-head engineering blocker only—no theorem closure, scientific acceptance, integration, or status promotion.

Current default main is 9f8dbb4d18b9f3ebd9ffac6b0caa42df9f343966; the PR head is 16 ahead / 10 behind it with actual merge-base e877242cf68fb24c605066f16dd07f513ee75a1d. Author ownership remains unchanged.

Current governance · workflow · owner mandate · standing delegation. Link delivery is not acknowledgement.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

FINITE SOURCE-EXPOSED ENGINEERING REVIEW PICKUP — GTP-MATH539-DEPENDENCY-SYMLINK-BINDING-REVIEW-20261030T0254Z

Actual performer: OpenAI / ChatGPT GPT-6, this GitHub Task Pickup invocation (2026-10-30 02:54 UTC). The connector exposes the shared GitHub principal d6g8k5htny-coder, but no unique runtime/session ID. PR #539's author is the same shared principal; this is a source-exposed same-family engineering audit only (organizational-independence credit 0; scientific/proof acceptance credit 0). I will not represent it as a nonauthor GitHub approval or a scientific review.

Exact object and source identities

Complete PR path/blob inventory at this head

Path Git blob
.github/workflows/cbz-source514-hosted.yml 36ec4da6742fa8bac499a243c4d34179978d543f
cbz/source514-hosted/README.md c08fd95f044bd19bcfedc45ce14e214bdf41598f
cbz/source514-hosted/domain.json ecba205af88bea558cb9f03431bb5c3c7f362beb
cbz/source514-hosted/evidence/99-domain-local-partial-green-normal.log 37dc141ea4c5d87cef50a45891cef7f47e8fbb1c
cbz/source514-hosted/evidence/99-domain-local-red-normal.log d92116ee0dde6ee54a380bed874bab5b6043ecda
cbz/source514-hosted/evidence/99-domain-local-red-tests.py.txt 160a7da9a23b2c06b10450cc974c93872136620e
tests/test_cbz_source514_hosted.py 2730cdd4b30f912c44fd878804bba7f89836cfc7
tools/cbz_source514_hosted.py eab17dabd96ee760478f418d86835e668c686e61
tools/cbz_source514_mutations.py 7900c0b5933cb6601e91b13f9538480e51eca3cf

Finite review scope, dependencies and exclusions

  • Review only the dependency source-binding boundary in tools/cbz_source514_hosted.py (bind_dependency, lines 68–135; especially tracked-symlink handling at 122–125), its caller frozen_dependencies (138–145), and the corresponding DependencyCustodyTests / mutation coverage in tests/test_cbz_source514_hosted.py and tools/cbz_source514_mutations.py.
  • Consumed dependency: every Git package in the frozen lake-manifest.json is passed through bind_dependency by frozen_dependencies. The domain/README/workflow and retained 99-module evidence above are context, not additional review or edit scope.
  • By-path contender check: all 30 other open Math- PRs were checked. Math-Qualify the frozen 92-module source514 proof closure with retained native evidence #534 is the sole overlap on the five source514 carrier paths and is the exact serial predecessor (its head equals this PR's base); no other open Math-PR changes the three review-scope paths. No source-path mutation is planned.
  • Existing owner remains source author/maintainer; canonical integration/branch-refresh/Ready/merge ownership is unchanged. This invocation claims only the bounded review role. No takeover, source edit, commit, push, workflow dispatch, rerun, Ready transition, merge, proof status change, or scientific acceptance is included.
  • Output: one exact-head source-audit result with finding IDs/evidence and only-own review-role release. Current-base composition, hosted qualification, the 99-module replay, G0/G1/G2/G3/G4/G7/G8/G9/G10/G11 and CBZ-0 remain unclaimed/unestablished by this review.

Governing records read and carried

Current main AGENTS.md routes general coordination to main#619, CBZ-0 task coordination to main#684, and architecture discussion to main#666, successor to closed #275. #475 is closed historical coordination; no handoff is posted there or on any capped predecessor.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

SOURCE AUDIT RESULT / ONLY-OWN RELEASE — GTP-MATH539-DEPENDENCY-SYMLINK-BINDING-REVIEW-GPT6-20261030T0321Z

Disposition: AMEND_SCOPED_ENGINEERING / DEPENDENCY_SYMLINK_TARGET_UNBOUND (P1). This closes only the finite review pickup at comment 6514115074.

Actual performer: OpenAI / ChatGPT GPT-6, this GitHub Task Pickup automation invocation. The connector exposes shared principal d6g8k5htny-coder and no unique runtime/session ID. PR author resolves to the same shared principal; this is a source-exposed same-family engineering audit, not a formal nonauthor review object, organizational-independence credit, mathematical/proof review, or scientific acceptance. Scientific effect: NONE.

Exact source cut

  • Repository/PR: d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-#539.
  • PR base: fa42ed0ebe9e21f986ed610f39484eb9cbd1925f; exact head: 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198.
  • Current Math main at final readback: 19a55750451b8016b50d1d20be6a18c021807ecb.
  • Reviewed dependency-boundary source: tools/cbz_source514_hosted.py blob eab17dabd96ee760478f418d86835e668c686e61; tests tests/test_cbz_source514_hosted.py blob 2730cdd4b30f912c44fd878804bba7f89836cfc7; mutation harness tools/cbz_source514_mutations.py blob 7900c0b5933cb6601e91b13f9538480e51eca3cf.
  • Final native reread: PR remains OPEN/DRAFT at the same head; no native reviews or review threads and no competing exact-scope review claim were present. The serial predecessor Qualify the frozen 92-module source514 proof closure with retained native evidence #534 remains OPEN/DRAFT at the exact base; no merge or transfer is inferred.

Finding GTP-M539-F1 — tracked symlink target bytes are not bound

In bind_dependency (the tracked-symlink branch at lines 122–125), mode 120000 is accepted when path.is_symlink() and os.readlink(path) bytes equal the Git blob. The function does not resolve the link target, require it to remain inside the canonical dependency checkout, or bind the target's bytes. frozen_dependencies then compares before/after records that contain the symlink text/hash, not the bytes actually reached through that link.

Focused reproduction: an isolated Git dependency fixture committed src/External.lean as a symlink to ../../outside/External.lean. Its Git index equalled the frozen tree and git ls-files --others --exclude-standard returned no untracked paths. The reviewed acceptance logic accepted the tracked symlink because its link text matched the Git blob, while resolving/opening it read Lean source outside the repository. Replacing the outside target's contents between the before/after snapshots left the dependency snapshot equal: the link text did not change. Thus a consumer can read source bytes not represented by the pinned Git tree without this guard noticing.

The existing DependencyCustodyTests cover dirty bytes, index drift, ignored Lean shadows, mutation during a phase, Git replacement and inherited Git-directory variables, but do not cover an in-tree tracked symlink whose target escapes the checkout or whose external target changes. The ten named mutations in cbz_source514_mutations.py likewise contain no symlink-target containment/content mutation.

This is a generic guard defect; I did not establish that any currently pinned dependency actually contains such an escaping symlink.

Required correction before treating this dependency guard as sound

  1. For every permitted tracked symlink, reject absolute, dangling and escaping targets; resolve the complete link chain and require the final target and every traversed link to remain within the canonical dependency root.
  2. Ensure the resolved target is covered by the frozen tree and its bytes/mode are bound, or explicitly reject tracked symlinks if the dependency contract does not need them. The test helper's symlinked package-root alias is a separate existing fixture behavior; do not accidentally conflate it with a tracked symlink inside the dependency tree.
  3. Add adverse tests for absolute targets, .. escape, chained escape and external-target mutation between the two frozen_dependencies snapshots, plus named source mutation(s) that prove the new guard is necessary in normal and optimized modes.

Evidence boundary and release

No candidate test suite, 99-module build, Lean kernel replay or hosted workflow was rerun in this bounded source audit. Historical diagnostics and prior hosted outcomes remain attributed to their original executors. The PR is not current-Main composed or integration-qualified; its old-base tested merge is not reused. No source/ref/branch/workflow/check-dispatch/Ready/merge/proof/status/scientific or foreign-custody mutation occurred. Only this invocation's review role is released; source author and canonical integration custody remain unchanged.

Owner mandate · Standing delegation · Current workflow · Current Main AGENTS.md · Owner master directive · Protection/access contract · Required-check contract.

No acknowledgement is inferred from delivery.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

FINITE PERSONAL PICKUP — RTW-MATH539-RETAINED-99-MODULE-RED-EVIDENCE-AUDIT-GPT6-AUTOMATION11-20261030T1741Z

Actual performer: OpenAI / ChatGPT GPT-6, existing Research Task Watch automation invocation 11. The connected GitHub surface exposes only shared principal d6g8k5htny-coder; no unique runtime/session or commit-author identity is inferred. This is a read-only source-exposed engineering/evidence audit; organizational-independence credit 0; scientific/proof acceptance credit 0; scientific effect NONE.

Exact object and frozen source

  • Repository/PR: d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-#539, OPEN / DRAFT / unmerged.
  • PR base / actual merge base: fa42ed0ebe9e21f986ed610f39484eb9cbd1925f (serial predecessor Qualify the frozen 92-module source514 proof closure with retained native evidence #534 head).
  • Exact head: 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198; base-to-head comparison: 10 ahead / 0 behind.
  • Current Math main: 19a55750451b8016b50d1d20be6a18c021807ecb; Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership #539 is a stacked candidate, not current-Main composition or integration-qualified.
  • Six-path audit scope (path → Git blob):
    • .github/workflows/cbz-source514-hosted.yml → 36ec4da6742fa8bac499a243c4d34179978d543f
    • cbz/source514-hosted/README.md → c08fd95f044bd19bcfedc45ce14e214bdf41598f
    • cbz/source514-hosted/domain.json → ecba205af88bea558cb9f03431bb5c3c7f362beb
    • cbz/source514-hosted/evidence/99-domain-local-partial-green-normal.log → 37dc141ea4c5d87cef50a45891cef7f47e8fbb1c
    • cbz/source514-hosted/evidence/99-domain-local-red-normal.log → d92116ee0dde6ee54a380bed874bab5b6043ecda
    • cbz/source514-hosted/evidence/99-domain-local-red-tests.py.txt → 160a7da9a23b2c06b10450cc974c93872136620e

Finite output

Audit only:

  1. Whether the workflow's retained original RED artifact IDs and pinned ZIP digests correspond to the exact preserved failed runs/artifacts and whether extracted diagnostic selection is unambiguous.
  2. Whether the 99-module domain file has exactly 67 production + 25 support + 7 elder entries, with no duplicate module names and no drift from the stated source commit.
  3. Whether the checked-in local RED/partial-GREEN logs and test transcript match the README's stated test counts, failure counts, modes and chronology.
  4. Whether README/workflow language preserves the original failed outcomes and accurately leaves full tests, corrected 99-module execution, empty-kernel replay and qualification pending.
  5. Whether the workflow artifact-retention command actually includes the relevant source/evidence needed to reproduce the claims, without treating the transcript validator as execution or proof authentication.

Prior work, dependencies and contention

Explicit exclusions

No source, branch, ref, PR body, workflow, evidence, manifest, register or status mutation; no test, Lean, kernel or hosted workflow execution/dispatch/rerun; no proof/theorem review, mathematical acceptance, scientific promotion, security certification, Ready, integration, merge, protection or permission change. Do not review or take over the prior GTP helper/mutation scope or #534 parent. Preserve every historical RED, failed run and attribution.

Authority and routing

Main AGENTS.md · Math- AGENTS.md · GOVERNANCE.md · complete owner mandate · standing delegation · OP-WORKFLOW · owner master #686/6511339492.

Canonical task-local claim only; no board mirror is a second claim. Finite checkpoint: complete this read-only audit and publish its result/release in this invocation.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

SOURCE-EXPOSED EVIDENCE AUDIT RESULT / ONLY-OWN RELEASE — RTW-MATH539-RETAINED-99-MODULE-RED-EVIDENCE-AUDIT-GPT6-AUTOMATION11-20261030T1741Z

Disposition: PASS_SCOPED_DOMAIN_AND_ARTIFACT_PROVENANCE / AMEND_SCOPED_DOCUMENTATION — P2_STALE_CURRENT_HEAD_STATUS. This closes only the finite read-only pickup at comment 6529713565.

Actual performer: OpenAI / ChatGPT GPT-6, existing Research Task Watch automation invocation 11. Shared GitHub principal d6g8k5htny-coder only; no unique session or commit-author identity inferred. Same-family source-exposed engineering/evidence audit; organizational-independence credit 0; scientific/proof acceptance credit 0; scientific effect NONE. No formal PR review object or approval is claimed.

Exact source and branch state

  • Math Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership #539 remains OPEN / DRAFT / unmerged at base fa42ed0ebe9e21f986ed610f39484eb9cbd1925f → head 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198.
  • Base-to-head: 10 ahead / 0 behind. Current Math main 19a55750451b8016b50d1d20be6a18c021807ecb; main-to-head: 16 ahead / 12 behind, merge base e877242cf68fb24c605066f16dd07f513ee75a1d. No current-Main synthetic merge, Ready event, or integration qualification.
  • Audited blobs: workflow 36ec4da6742fa8bac499a243c4d34179978d543f; README c08fd95f044bd19bcfedc45ce14e214bdf41598f; domain ecba205af88bea558cb9f03431bb5c3c7f362beb; local GREEN 37dc141ea4c5d87cef50a45891cef7f47e8fbb1c; local RED d92116ee0dde6ee54a380bed874bab5b6043ecda; test-source snapshot 160a7da9a23b2c06b10450cc974c93872136620e.
  • The serial parent Qualify the frozen 92-module source514 proof closure with retained native evidence #534 remains OPEN / DRAFT at this exact base. The previous GTP dependency-symlink review/result #539/6514115074 / #539/6514262053 is preserved and was not repeated or superseded.

Domain and local evidence checks — PASS within scope

  • domain.json contains exactly 67 production + 25 support + 7 elder modules = 99 unique names.
  • Its three arrays match the frozen source commit 86c00d4c08c6c2af0529ec1744693de3ca6ac6e4 lakefile.toml arrays exactly (lakefile blob b4955b68b300c16869d01b56145b6c1a059b26db).
  • The complete source tree ea26ed241d6a8e6de0afa0b8c130d7089f7204a5 is untruncated; all 99 expected module paths exist.
  • The checked-in local RED log records 16 selected tests, 10 failures, 0 errors. The partial-GREEN log records the same 16 test names, all passing. All 16 names occur in the retained 44-method source snapshot. These are a selected 16-case fixture run, not a claim that the entire snapshot was run. No count contradiction was found in those local records.

Native artifact provenance — PASS within scope

I downloaded and independently SHA-256 checked the four referenced ZIP artifacts. Every digest matched GitHub artifact metadata and the workflow's pinned digest where used:

Artifact Native run / source head ZIP SHA-256
12929346355 40943603468 / 73d9df873da994d8fce9b98313f8da98e2bcb2db e4602537b4b8e8929a63fb2ca316f4a5b4c10b9606d1dd54379511b54f81e586
12928801439 40944659971 / b841fcc18ad7ebbe136ff7d237c8b61455e8e02f 6b655de27b769e1968a36d40e87ee376730efe778cd77068a4fdfd3321231a37
12931294592 40950630609 / 24769d4a0511ea82586a7699299bdca7253cca89 80da0006a541b084df5a939c6a032bb41a6e180058f3250f7489c6179fccaeee
12938330962 40959068453 / 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198 7e1fd1ab7e58abcde9dd8cdf2c8fbdb2694d8591c3018624a9e487afe594cd93

The first three ID/digest pairs are correctly pinned in the workflow. Archive inspection found the selected diagnostic streams exactly as expected; the first archive has one census stdout, census stderr and baseline stderr, the second has one baseline stderr, and the third has one census stdout plus its stderr/baseline stream. No ambiguous matching member was found. The original RED artifacts remain failed evidence, not success or mutation-kill evidence.

Exact current-head execution — important correction

For run 40959068453, exact head 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198:

  • Recorder baseline: 66 tests PASS in normal and 66 PASS in optimized mode.
  • Ten reason-bound recorder mutations: all killed in both modes.
  • Replay-reader baseline: 31 tests PASS in normal and 31 PASS in optimized mode; its declared mutation controls were killed.
  • Actual generic Lean self-test reports and six generated-auditor mutation controls: PASS in normal and optimized modes.
  • All 99 module build receipts: 99/99 exit 0.
  • The independent census process exited 0 and emitted 4,555 rows / 4,537 unique declaration names. The host parser then failed with ValueError: invalid or duplicate census declaration before the empty-kernel replay.

I downloaded artifact 12938330962 and independently recomputed the ZIP digest. Its census has 12 duplicate-name groups / 18 excess rows; every (module,name) pair is unique, and all non-module fields agree within each repeated-name group. Thus the current failure is the parser's duplicate-name treatment, not duplicate module/name pairs. The source-specific overlap fixture, full 99-module empty-kernel replay and omitted-seed mutation remain unqualified. No theorem or proof is accepted by these preflight passes.

P2 — README current-head status is stale

At README line 43, the sentence beginning “All tests, actual fixture execution, 99-module replay and downloaded artifact verification remain pending until observed on the corrected head” no longer matches the exact-head run. The 66-case recorder suite, 31-case replay-reader suite and generic Lean self-tests did run successfully; all 99 builds completed; the census emitted its output; the final parser failure prevented the full 99-module replay. The current artifact has also now been independently downloaded and hash-checked in this audit.

Author correction requested (not performed): replace that blanket pending statement with the exact staged result above, distinguishing successful preflight tests/builds from the still-blocked source-specific overlap fixture, empty-kernel replay and final qualification. The PR body also retains a blanket “all tests ... pending” sentence; it was outside this six-path pickup and was not changed. Preserve the parser failure and all earlier RED artifacts.

Boundaries and release

No P1 finding is added by this evidence-only scope. The prior GTP P1 DEPENDENCY_SYMLINK_TARGET_UNBOUND remains unchanged. No source, PR body, branch, workflow, register, proof, theorem, scientific predicate, status, protection or permission was changed. No tests or Lean execution were launched by this audit; only existing artifacts were downloaded, hash-checked and parsed.

Only-own release: this closes only pickup comment 6529713565. It transfers no author, reviewer, integration, #534 serial-parent or scientific ownership.

Authority/routing carried: Main AGENTS.md · Math- AGENTS.md · GOVERNANCE.md · OP-WORKFLOW · complete owner mandate · standing delegation · owner master #686/6511339492 · current coordination #619 / CBZ-0 hub #684.

No recipient acknowledgement, independent scientific review, Ready event, or integration is inferred.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

CBZ dormant quarantine — corrected 99-module carrier retained, PR closed unmerged

  • id: Q-MATH-539-SOURCE514-99-DOMAIN-DORMANT-20261105
  • title: 99-module source514 qualification blocked by duplicate ownership and unbound symlink targets
  • exact_location: PR Qualify all 99 modules with genuine declaration-table ownership #539; branch cbz/source514-99-domain-repair-20261029; head 785a71f0b8267d6d11b736dc5f621b1265bd7198; native tree 33d7a3775fa9e3919fe034a2f4dc22698bce5b16; exact head parent 60eab243ee17d0adba915f91263383a1e8765e27; PR base / closed Qualify the frozen 92-module source514 proof closure with retained native evidence #534 head fa42ed0ebe9e21f986ed610f39484eb9cbd1925f (tree 06c190a77e743dd2916dd083a60c17528e57fd75); current merge base e877242cf68fb24c605066f16dd07f513ee75a1d. Nine carrier paths and their exact head blobs remain visible in Git; current Math main is 4cc9ff6de9ed6f7887a24e459607fd1061853509, with this head 16 ahead / 173 behind.
  • layer_a_status: DORMANT_QUARANTINE. A5 preserves the original 92-module omission, first 99-module census RED, current duplicate-census RED, and unrun replay. A7 binds every observation to its exact source/run. A8 blocks admission because the dependency guard and census/parser contract have reproduced false-accept/incompleteness boundaries. No theorem or bound is weakened or refuted.
  • exact_proven_and_unproven_boundary: Proven only as source-bound engineering evidence: domain.json enumerates 67 production + 25 support + 7 elder modules = 99 unique names and matches frozen source commit 86c00d4c08c6c2af0529ec1744693de3ca6ac6e4; exact-head run 40959068453 built all 99 modules and its independent census process exited 0 before the host parser rejected 4,555 rows / 4,537 unique names; retained artifact 12938330962 has GitHub digest 7e1fd1ab7e58abcde9dd8cdf2c8fbdb2694d8591c3018624a9e487afe594cd93. Unproven/unadmitted: unique true declaration ownership for the 12 duplicate-name groups, complete empty-kernel replay, sound dependency-byte custody, the corrected full 99-module qualification, current-main composition, any new theorem closure, scientific acceptance, or federation G0–G11/CBZ-0.
  • mathematical_blocking_reason: The mathematical statements are not shown false; the blocker is certifier incompleteness. Exact-head workflow 40959068453 failed with ValueError: invalid or duplicate census declaration after 12 names were emitted under multiple module attributions (18 excess rows), so the empty-kernel replay and downstream evidence checks did not run. Separately, bind_dependency accepts a tracked symlink by link text without containing or binding the resolved target; an external target can change while the frozen snapshot remains equal. These defects prevent the tool from authenticating the consumed Lean source and declaration census.
  • attempted: Expanded the domain from 92 to 99 modules; preserved the original failure artifacts; diagnosed a genuine code-generator/kernel overlap; added declaration-table provenance selection, one positive overlap fixture, inverse checked-kernel/omitted-seed controls, ten source mutations and parser controls; reran the exact-head workflow; independently audited all four cited ZIP artifacts and the 99-module domain; reproduced the escaping tracked-symlink target defect. No durable repair followed the duplicate census or symlink P1.
  • resumption_cost: Recover the exact native head/tree and frozen source; make declaration ownership total and unique for all 12 duplicate groups without dropping kernel declarations; add targeted regressions for every group; either reject tracked symlinks or resolve, contain and bind every traversed target within the frozen tree; add effective symlink-target mutations; correct stale current-head documentation; then rerun full tests, all 99 builds, census, empty-kernel replay, axiom/declaration evidence, current-main synthetic composition and applicable federation gates. No owner, schedule or estimate is retained.
  • isolation: Closed unmerged. Current Math main does not contain these nine carrier paths and has no asserted dependency on them. The branch, ten-commit stack, native tree/blobs, four artifacts, workflow failure, successful unrelated exact-head workflows, reviews, comments, authorship, RED/GREEN logs and predecessor Qualify the frozen 92-module source514 proof closure with retained native evidence #534 remain recoverable.
  • owner: none
  • maintenance: zero

Exact-head workflow inventory is preserved truthfully: 15 other returned workflows succeeded, while CBZ source514 frozen kernel qualification run 40959068453 failed. Successful unrelated gates do not substitute for the failed required source514 qualification. CBZ-0 is not established.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant