Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
5 changes: 5 additions & 0 deletions BOOTSTRAP.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -58,6 +58,11 @@ binds the protected implementation and updater deliveries, exact published
Forge 2.7.25 artifacts, safe schema 38→39 activation, preservation and normal
installed readback. It does not authorize a reset or Mission 3.

The separately authorized Forge 2.7.25 Mission-3 acceptance preflight is
recorded in [Mission 3 on Forge 2.7.25 — blocked before T0](docs/operations/MISSION_3_FORGE_2_7_25_PREFLIGHT_ACCEPTANCE_2026_09_18.md).
It preserves PR #148, performs no reset or Mission allocation, and records the
failed functional-evidence-fit and autonomous installed-ingress conditions.

## Previous pickup checkpoint — 17 September 2026

Implementation PR #128 merged the deterministic aggregate-health timeout-boundary
Expand Down
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,241 @@
AUTONOMY_E2E_ACCEPTANCE = NIET_GEHAALD

# Mission 3 on Forge 2.7.25 — blocked before T0

Read-only acceptance preflight on 18 September 2026. This is a new assessment
of the corrected Forge 2.7.25 installation. It does not reopen or rewrite the
historical Mission-3 rejection in PR #148.

```text
MISSION_SCOPE_EVIDENCE_FIT = FAIL
PREPARATION_ACCEPTANCE = NIET_GEHAALD
CLEAN_CENTRAL_PREFLIGHT = NIET_GEHAALD
MISSION_EXECUTION_STATE = NIET_GESTART
AUTONOMY_LOOP_ACCEPTANCE = NIET_GEHAALD
TELEMETRY_ACCEPTANCE = NIET_GEHAALD
REPORTING_ACCEPTANCE = NIET_GEHAALD
EXPORT_ACCEPTANCE = NIET_GEHAALD
PUBLIC_HANDOFF_DELIVERY = PENDING_PROTECTED_MERGE
SUPPORTED_CRITERION_SOURCE = repository_json
AUTHORITATIVE_HOST_CONTROL_SUPPORT = UNSUPPORTED
E2E_EXECUTION_AND_REVIEW_EVIDENCE = SEPARATE_EP_EVIDENCE_LINE_NOT_EXERCISED
```

## Decisive pre-T0 findings

Two independent start conditions fail before destructive maintenance is
permitted.

First, the available `repository_json` source proves only an approved JSON
property at an exact accepted revision. The read-only scope survey considered
real open Forge work including the installed inner-loop CI seam and governed
progression. Those outcomes require proof of process continuity, execution,
validation, review or decision enforcement. Representing them as JSON fields
would weaken their functional meaning. `host_control` remains
`UNSATISFIED / UNSUPPORTED_AUTHORITATIVE_EVIDENCE_SOURCE`. No toy,
acceptance-only or unused configuration objective was substituted.

Second, the exact installed package contains the documented
`InstalledDynamicMissionRuntime` Python API and `ForgeRuntimeService.serve`,
but the published distribution exposes one console entry point whose supported
commands are storage initialization/status/reset and Execution Host
configuration/preflight. It exposes no Mission-governance, intake, start or
supervised-service command. The public `start` and `resume` methods each drive
one service tick. A new test-session script that repeatedly called those
methods or private composition helpers would be a new controller, not the
existing qualified product route. It therefore could not prove the required
absence of human/external between-Action steering in C07.

The installed Forge-to-EP authenticated read-only preflight did pass after the
normal Keychain-backed credential was resolved. It reported EP 2.3.83,
producer-readback 1.2, terminal-evidence 1.4, matching project/repository scope
and submission authorization. Cryptographic peer identity remains
`NOT_ASSERTED`. This successful read-only check does not cure either start
condition and created no submission.

In accordance with the assignment, the first failed start condition froze the
verdict. No reset, Mission allocation, governance decision, Mission Intake,
planner invocation, provider invocation or EP execution was attempted.

## A. Exact installation manifest

| Product | Active version | Schema | Product release source | Published wheel SHA-256 | Readback |
| --- | --- | ---: | --- | --- | --- |
| Forge | 2.7.25 | 39 | `61e02899277d4ee557696bb24a051916e8c961c2` | `e0ea58bf6ce242d4eca66801ef4c764c7104b90df5503141a8ebf0006c1aa7b8` | normal executable reports 2.7.25; installed isolated interpreter/distribution and schema read back |
| Engineering Platform | 2.3.83 | 68 | `13691e4502c239e03558a9c79538ae9b7387938f` | `006b47b8a864502a4b4596ba17e2724fe6ddba1e932615e183841cfc913e5021` | authenticated declaration through normal Forge peer preflight |

The selected reset coordinator remains
`cross-product-operational-reset-coordinator-v2`, bound by the completion
record to EP source `13691e4502c239e03558a9c79538ae9b7387938f` and artifact SHA-256
`bdfece75b538994a59dc295ab10d4dac6bdfbfcb1a45c36c7e392c4dbcc82acc`.
It was not invoked. Fresh remote observations resolved Forge `main` to
`fd69c443da80c56f11361693fd8ded6e1b20fc3f` and EP `main` to
`13691e4502c239e03558a9c79538ae9b7387938f`.

The Forge completion record in PR #152 and its installed readback remain the
owning qualification evidence. The present preflight independently confirmed
the active version/schema, installed command surface, package entry point and
authenticated peer contract. It performed no rebuild, downgrade, update or
installation.

## B. Evidence fit and functional Mission

No functional Mission was approved or allocated. The read-only candidate
survey deliberately stopped before converting an objective into product state.

| Surveyed real objective | Real consumer meaning | Why the available criterion source is insufficient |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Installed inner-loop CI closure | one installed Mission continuously plans, executes, observes evidence and progresses across real process/EP boundaries | requires execution, restart, timing, validation and review evidence; JSON structure cannot prove those events |
| Governed progression successor fence | Forge blocks/releases successor work from authentic decisions and exact evidence | requires enforcement and replay behavior, not a declarative PASS field |

The only supported criterion source is `repository_json` with exact repository,
safe path, JSON pointer, canonical expected value and an approved validity
policy. It could support a genuinely structural product property, but none of
the surveyed open outcomes could be reduced to that property without dropping
necessary behavior. No `CriterionAssessmentContract`, requirement identity,
predicate or validity binding was therefore approved for a Mission. This is a
failed evidence-fit precondition, not a defect claim about every possible
future Forge objective.

## C. Reset manifest and clean baseline

The installed Forge reset preview was read-only and returned `READY`, schema
39, dataset generation 0, intact integrity checks, no foreign-key finding and
no active maintenance operation. It also reported retained operational history:
3 Mission states, 2 Action derivations, 2 derivation results, 1 planning state,
8 execution-host bindings and their associated audit/history records.

Because evidence fit and autonomous ingress failed first:

- the joint coordinator was not invoked;
- no reset authorization, prepare, backup, revalidate, apply, verify, resume,
finish or service stop/start occurred;
- no EP reset preview was promoted to a joint plan;
- no fresh coordinated backup set was created;
- dataset generations stayed unchanged;
- preserved identities, policy, credentials, security ledgers and allocators
were not mutated;
- no clean-baseline or anti-reingestion claim is made.

Therefore `CLEAN_CENTRAL_PREFLIGHT = NIET_GEHAALD`. Historical reset receipts
and installation backups were not reused as current reset evidence.

## D. Measurement manifest

| Field | Result |
| --- | --- |
| Intended display label | Mission 3 |
| Intended allocator result | `MISSION-0003` |
| Actual Mission ID | none |
| Functional input/criteria | not approved; evidence-fit failed |
| Initial governance decisions | none |
| T0 | not set |
| End time | not applicable; no measured attempt |
| Repository Truth binding | current Forge main observed read-only; not bound to a Mission |
| Test-contract population | C01-C20 retained outside runtime; no Mission population created |

The normal allocator was not called, so no identity was forced or predicted
from repository-document naming.

## E–F. Actions and A-to-B evidence

| Action ID | Contribution | Planner invocation | Predecessor evidence | Baseline | Submission / EP run | Candidate / reviews | Delivery / criteria / reconciliation |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| none | none derived | none | none | none | none | none | none |

There is no A-to-B sequence, partial assessment, remaining-requirement set,
successor planner input/output or second delivery. None is reconstructed from
the source qualification scenarios: those scenarios used external planner,
repository and host fixtures and explicitly did not make a live submission.

## G. Counts

| Item | New-attempt count |
| --- | ---: |
| Missions allocated/admitted | 0 |
| substantive Actions | 0 |
| planner/provider invocations | 0 |
| original submissions / EP runs | 0 / 0 |
| retries / resumes / repairs | 0 / 0 / 0 |
| initial Mission decisions | 0 |
| human interventions after Mission release | not applicable; no release |
| new terminal evidence conflicts | not assessable; no new population |

Zeros are preparation facts only. They are not autonomy, no-retry, telemetry or
quality PASS evidence.

## H. Telemetry, performance and canonical reporting

There is no new Mission population from which to calculate planning usage,
Action usage, token/cache aggregation, invocation timing, external wait,
review/finalization share or Mission duration. Every such value is
`UNAVAILABLE: NO_MEASURED_ATTEMPT`, not zero. EP usage is not substituted for
Forge planning usage.

No new Engineering Report, Action Quality/Security result, finalization receipt,
Forge criterion observation or Mission result exists. Desktop/mobile dashboard
acceptance was not run because there is no selected attempt/chain. This is not
a dashboard-defect finding.

## I. Four telemetry downloads

| Export | Downloaded | Snapshot | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| EX-OV-MD | no | none | not executable without a new Mission population |
| EX-OV-JSON | no | none | not executable without a new Mission population |
| EX-DT-MD | no | none | no selected attempt/chain |
| EX-DT-JSON | no | none | no selected attempt/chain |

No dummy run, old snapshot or administrative report was relabeled as a required
telemetry download. Parse, MIME, filename, parity and completeness are therefore
unproven.

## J. C01–C20

`NIET_GEHAALD` for an unexecuted criterion means not proven; it is not by itself
a separate product-defect classification.

| Criterion | Result | Owning evidence or missing part |
| --- | --- | --- |
| C01 — exactly one fresh Mission | NIET_GEHAALD | no allocation, approval, intake or T0 |
| C02 — real authorized functional work | NIET_GEHAALD | no objective could be approved without weakening required evidence |
| C03 — at least two substantive Actions | NIET_GEHAALD | no Actions |
| C04 — Actions derived by the real planner | NIET_GEHAALD | no planner invocation |
| C05 — new planning after predecessor evidence | NIET_GEHAALD | no predecessor evidence or successor decision |
| C06 — installed Keychain→HTTP→EP execution/readback | NIET_GEHAALD | authenticated read-only preflight passed; Mission execution/readback did not occur |
| C07 — no human between-step steering | NIET_GEHAALD | no delivered autonomous Mission service/controller entry; a new tick-driving script was rejected |
| C08 — zero retries/resumes/repairs | NIET_GEHAALD | no execution; a zero count is not a successful no-retry trial |
| C09 — first-candidate validation and independent Quality/Security | NIET_GEHAALD | no candidate or Action assurance |
| C10 — protected implementation/finalization/terminal evidence | NIET_GEHAALD | no Action delivery |
| C11 — identities/digests/baselines/receipts close | NIET_GEHAALD | installation bindings close; Mission/Action/run chain absent |
| C12 — no unresolved new evidence conflicts | NIET_GEHAALD | no new terminal population to assess |
| C13 — Forge assesses and closes Mission | NIET_GEHAALD | no Mission; evidence-fit failed before approval |
| C14 — safe declared post-execution state | NIET_GEHAALD | read-only safe stop established, but no executed Mission end state exists |
| C15 — exact qualified Forge/EP installation active before T0 | GEHAALD | Forge 2.7.25/schema39 and EP 2.3.83/schema68 bindings plus authenticated compatibility readback |
| C16 — correct live telemetry | NIET_GEHAALD | no new telemetry population |
| C17 — correct desktop/mobile dashboard chain | NIET_GEHAALD | no new attempt/chain |
| C18 — four consistent telemetry exports | NIET_GEHAALD | none downloaded; no valid snapshot |
| C19 — both CENTRAL datasets clean with fresh backups | NIET_GEHAALD | reset/backups intentionally not executed; Forge still contains old operational history |
| C20 — only new-attempt measurement | NIET_GEHAALD | no new measured population or post-reset anti-reingestion proof |

## K. Scoped resource handoff

Lane 1 records the assignment as a read-only pre-T0 preflight with terminal
`BLOCKED_BEFORE_T0`. Lane 2 revision 14 was read back as having no active
assignment or reservation. No maintenance/test window was entered because no
writer stop or product mutation was permitted after the evidence-fit failure.

Effects owned by this assessment are limited to read-only source/installation,
lane and preflight observations plus this sanitized documentation delivery.
There are no Mission/Action/provider/EP subprocesses, submissions, runs,
mutating reset operations, service changes, credentials changes, backups or
runtime reservations to hand off. The documentation branch/PR is administrative
and is not an Engineering Action or evidence repair.

Exact local paths, runtime/instance/consumer identities, Keychain references,
plan/database/backup digests and raw receipts remain outside Git. Public
product versions, source commits, artifact digests and protected PR identities
remain exact.

No repair campaign, production patch, second reset/Mission attempt or next
backlog Mission follows from this result.
Loading