Skip to content

MCA (E): route denominator-root and coordinate-clone exceptions - #1156

Draft
AllenGrahamHart wants to merge 3 commits into
przchojecki:mainfrom
AllenGrahamHart:agent/denominator-root-defect-router
Draft

MCA (E): route denominator-root and coordinate-clone exceptions#1156
AllenGrahamHart wants to merge 3 commits into
przchojecki:mainfrom
AllenGrahamHart:agent/denominator-root-defect-router

Conversation

@AllenGrahamHart

@AllenGrahamHart AllenGrahamHart commented Aug 10, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

What changed

This advances two named branches of the paper's MCA exception-routing
terminal (E).

Denominator-root branch

  • Proves an exhaustive post-cancellation split: a support either remains
    support-wise MCA-nontrivial in the reduced certificate, or has a unique
    simultaneous explaining pair.
  • In the trivialized branch, compiles the original obstruction into a
    same-owner pole-defect record
    u_i + gamma_i v_i = 0 with v_i != 0; the slope is recoverable and
    distinct slopes have distinct explaining pairs.
  • Proves distinct trivialized reduced supports intersect in at most k-1
    coordinates and therefore have disjoint k-shadows.
  • Prints an exact route fence: the resulting shadow-packing upper bound is
    larger than 2^58 throughout both deployed pole-degree ranges, so it does
    not pay either row. Further support-only packing cannot close (E) through
    this bound; the remaining target must use the coupled divided
    scalar-locator identity.

The packet preserves the precise cancellation scope: Q' is nonzero on the
reduced coincidence core, not necessarily on the whole reduced domain.

Coordinate-clone branch

  • Pays every irreducible owner-pencil clone class of size 2 <= c < m by
    N_C(m-c) <= 2(n-c) <= 2c(m-c).
  • Sums all subcritical classes through their disjoint coordinate mass to get
    the literal simultaneous bound 2n = 4,194,304, below both MCA budgets.
  • Uses n < 2m to prove that at most one class of size at least m remains.
  • Keeps identically-zero/fixed-owner coordinates and the unique large clone
    component explicit and unpaid.
  • Records a source-contract no-go for the remaining class: F_x=0 is an
    owner-line incidence, not a selected-support root. The scalar-locator term
    remains, so clone zeros and denominator-root sets cannot be injected into
    actual agreement supports without also proving Lambda(x)=0.

Source-pin repair

The existing pole-tolerant verifier on current main failed because its
grande_finale.tex blob pin predated later paper integrations. This PR
refreshes that pin to the current blob. The pinned scalar-locator definition
is byte-for-byte identical to the formerly pinned definition; no audited
theorem scope is changed.

Validation

All commands pass under both normal Python and python3 -O:

verify_pole_tolerant_scalar_locator_localization.py --check
verify_pole_tolerant_scalar_locator_localization.py --tamper-selftest
verify_denominator_root_puncture_trivialization.py --check
verify_denominator_root_puncture_trivialization.py --tamper-selftest
verify_coordinate_clone_subcritical_payment.py --check
verify_coordinate_clone_subcritical_payment.py --tamper-selftest

The two new checkers run 137,341 and 15,215 deterministic checks respectively;
each rejects 5/5 hostile metadata mutations. They use only the Python
standard library.

Nonclaims

These are local source compilers and route cuts. They do not bound the actual
trivialized-slope cardinality below the row budgets, pay the unique large
clone/fixed-owner branch, absorb every record into (S) or (A), prove
complete (E), close an adjacent row, or move the official score. Independent
review is explicitly requested in both packets.

@AllenGrahamHart AllenGrahamHart changed the title MCA (E): route denominator-root puncture defects MCA (E): route denominator-root and coordinate-clone exceptions Aug 10, 2026
@AllenGrahamHart

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Independent continuation of this PR's unique-large-clone frontier is now banked at 67d17fff8.

For a common irreducible clone component
F_*(gamma,tau)=a+b gamma+c tau+d gamma tau, ad-bc != 0, the Mobius parameterization gives the exact pullback

Qhat=(c+d gamma)Q_0-(a+b gamma)Q_1,
Nhat=(c+d gamma)(A_0+gamma B_0)
     -(a+b gamma)(A_1+gamma B_1),

with slope degrees (1,2) and Nhat=Qhat(r_0+gamma r_1) on every clone coordinate.

Two consequences are proved.

  1. If the two denominator coefficients span one polynomial direction, every clone of size at least m+1 cancels to one fixed coherent rational owner (or the globally affine degeneration), apart from the single denominator-zero projective parameter. At exactly c=m, the only noncancelling remainder is mu Lambda_C.
  2. In denominator rank two, writing Qhat=q_0+gamma q_1 and Nhat=p_0+gamma p_1+gamma^2p_2, the exact Pade remainder
Omega=q_1^2 p_0-q_0 q_1 p_1+q_0^2 p_2

vanishes on the clone and has degree at most m+2d. Hence c>m+2d forces one fixed affine-in-slope owner with reduced denominator degree at most 2d; at equality, Omega is zero or mu Lambda_C. The genuinely moving support bands end at 1,250,992 on KoalaBear and 1,250,920 on Mersenne-31.

This does not complete (E): the finite moving band, the exact locator remainders, and the fixed degree-(d,2d] owner remain unpaid. It does remove the arbitrary rank-one supercritical clone and turns the rank-two branch into those exact leaves. Four independent constant-memory checks pass, together with the local DAG/provenance gates.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant