M5-10: Maintainer release-candidate freeze and tag #59

Activity

1. pillowtalk-Qy

   added this to the M5 - Reliability & Release Candidate milestone on Jul 29, 2026
2. pillowtalk-Qy

   added

   area:architectureArchitecture and module boundariesArchitecture and module boundaries

   priority:P0Critical priorityCritical priority

   type:choreRepository maintenanceRepository maintenance

   status:blockedBlocked by an unresolved dependencyBlocked by an unresolved dependency

   on Jul 29, 2026
3. pillowtalk-Qy

   added a parent issue on Jul 29, 2026

   • M5-00: Reliability and release parent tracker #49
4. pillowtalk-Qy

   marked this as blocked by 2 issues on Jul 29, 2026

   • M5-08: Gate C clean-clone full release acceptance #57
   • M5-09: Final desktop/mobile visual and judge comprehension QA #58
5. pillowtalk-Qy

   marked this as blocking 2 issues on Jul 29, 2026

   • M6-01: Finalize three-minute script, evidence claims and Q&A #61
   • M6-02: Run timed rehearsals and failure-recovery drills #62
6. pillowtalk-Qy

   removed

   status:blockedBlocked by an unresolved dependencyBlocked by an unresolved dependency

   on Aug 9, 2026
7. pillowtalk-Qy commented on Aug 9, 2026

   

   pillowtalk-Qy

   on Aug 9, 2026

   ContributorAuthor

   More actions

   依赖 #57 Gate C PASS 与 #58 P0=0/P1=0 已满足。开始对 main@ce5be8f4934002d8b117ea62a4a980ba6d8951bd 执行只读 RC freeze 审计；Codex 不创建或推送 Maintainer-only tag。
8. pillowtalk-Qy commented on Aug 9, 2026

   

   pillowtalk-Qy

   on Aug 9, 2026

   ContributorAuthor

   More actions

   RC freeze read-only audit - BLOCKED only by Maintainer tag

   Exact candidate: ce5be8f4934002d8b117ea62a4a980ba6d8951bd

   • Required M5 implementation and QA Issues M5-01: Create four deterministic scenario bundles #50-M5-09: Final desktop/mobile visual and judge comprehension QA #58 are closed; remediation P0: remediate production dependency advisories blocking Gate C #102 and P0: Gate C root live-smoke command is missing #107 are closed.
   • PR M5-09: record final visual QA #110 has zero unresolved review threads and no open PR remains.
   • Local main and origin/main are identical (0 0 divergence) and the worktree is clean.
   • Exact-main quality gate 31296474714 is SUCCESS.
   • Gate A, Gate B, and Gate C are linked and PASS.
   • Security, performance, deployment, and visual QA evidence is linked. The security NO-GO condition was fixed by P0: remediate production dependency advisories blocking Gate C #102 and Gate C re-ran the production audit successfully.
   • No open Bug Issue or release-blocking P0/P1 finding remains; M5-09: Final desktop/mobile visual and judge comprehension QA #58 recorded P0=0/P1=0/P2=0. Documented product limitations remain disclosures, not hidden PASS claims.
   • Demo URL, demo/video draft script, visual report, and all four exact-candidate screenshots are publicly accessible (HTTP 200).
   • Feature intake is frozen at this exact candidate: no feature PR will be accepted into the RC.
   • Hotfix policy is posted below.
   • Annotated tag hackathon-rc-2026-08-05 exists on the exact candidate.

   Hotfix policy: after freeze, accept only separately tracked P0/P1 defects. Every hotfix starts from the frozen candidate, adds a focused regression, passes exact-head CI plus affected Gate re-runs, and receives merged-main CI. Never move or overwrite an existing RC tag; publish a new suffixed tag for a replacement candidate. Feature and P2 enhancement work waits until after the release decision.

   Maintainer-only completion commands:

   git fetch origin
   test "$(git rev-parse origin/main)" = "ce5be8f4934002d8b117ea62a4a980ba6d8951bd" &&
     git tag -a hackathon-rc-2026-08-05 ce5be8f4934002d8b117ea62a4a980ba6d8951bd -m 'Hackathon release candidate' &&
     git push origin refs/tags/hackathon-rc-2026-08-05

   Codex did not create or push the tag and did not close the Milestone, as required by this Issue. Once the Maintainer pushes the tag, verify its peeled commit equals the exact candidate before closing #59.
9. pillowtalk-Qy

   added

   status:blockedBlocked by an unresolved dependencyBlocked by an unresolved dependency

   on Aug 9, 2026
10. pillowtalk-Qy commented on Aug 9, 2026

    

    pillowtalk-Qy

    on Aug 9, 2026

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    Updated RC freeze audit: BLOCKED only by Maintainer tag

    Exact candidate: 4ec4e2d8c5e8fbbc08572f544461cbd5e1c24d7d

    • M5 implementation/QA and frontend remediation P0: integrate frontend redesign without evidence-boundary regressions #112 are closed.
    • Open PRs and open bug Issues: 0.
    • Exact merged-main quality gate 31300536251: SUCCESS.
    • Local full check: 52 files / 1264 tests PASS; coverage and production smokes PASS.
    • Production demo points to the new deployment; public smoke 9/9 PASS.
    • Updated four-viewport visual QA: P0=0/P1=0/P2=0.
    • Feature intake is frozen; hotfix policy from the prior audit remains in force.
    • Maintainer-only annotated tag exists on the exact candidate.

    Maintainer-only completion:

    git fetch origin
    test "$(git rev-parse origin/main)" = "4ec4e2d8c5e8fbbc08572f544461cbd5e1c24d7d" &&
      git tag -a hackathon-rc-2026-08-05 4ec4e2d8c5e8fbbc08572f544461cbd5e1c24d7d -m 'Hackathon release candidate' &&
      git push origin refs/tags/hackathon-rc-2026-08-05

    Codex did not create/push the tag and did not close #59 or the M5 Milestone, per the Issue's Maintainer-only rule.
11. pillowtalk-Qy commented on Aug 9, 2026

    

    pillowtalk-Qy

    on Aug 9, 2026

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    UPDATED RC FREEZE AUDIT: BLOCKED ONLY BY MAINTAINER TAG. Exact candidate is now 34f64df after documentation-only Bug #114 / PR #115 synchronized superseded release status. Merged-main quality-gate run 31304149377 is SUCCESS; #114 is Closed and Project Done; open Bug Issues are 0; public health/smoke and all Gate/visual evidence remain unchanged. Draft PR #113 is M6 submission documentation based on this main, has exact-head CI SUCCESS, and is intentionally excluded from the RC until #59 completes. Maintainer-only command: git fetch origin; verify origin/main equals 34f64df; create annotated tag hackathon-rc-2026-08-05 at that exact commit; push only refs/tags/hackathon-rc-2026-08-05. Codex did not create/push the tag or close #59/M5.
12. pillowtalk-Qy commented on Aug 9, 2026

    

    pillowtalk-Qy

    on Aug 9, 2026

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    Maintainer RC action completed: annotated tag hackathon-rc-2026-08-05 is pushed and verified remotely. The tag peeled commit is exactly 34f64df97c510a82a700c7b18bf0c0e0009a00a2. Gate A/B/C, security/performance/deployment/visual evidence, exact main CI, and public smoke are linked above. Codex did not move or overwrite the tag.
13. pillowtalk-Qy

    closed this as completedon Aug 9, 2026
14. pillowtalk-Qy commented on Aug 9, 2026

    

    pillowtalk-Qy

    on Aug 9, 2026

    ContributorAuthor

    More actions

    Correction to the closure comment: the verified peeled commit is exactly 34f64df (the prior comment contained a transcribed SHA typo). Remote refs/tags/hackathon-rc-2026-08-05^{} matches this exact SHA.