Repository navigation
Exercise Git source-identity redirection controls - #540
d6g8k5htny-coder wants to merge 24 commits into
Conversation
…es and full hosted suite
Keep full clean-status assertions when the retained suite runs without -B.
Preserve every mathematical source and admission guard; retain prior failures and require fresh execution against the resulting tree.
Keep all existing assertions and mutation controls; update only their source identities and exact manifest hashes.
Retain the current main AGENTS.md blob unchanged and all exact proof and companion source bindings; current-head checks are required.
Preserve all companion checks and their test assertions. Endpoint observation assumes no transient tampering between the before and after checks.
These real-Git controls expose inherited Git redirection; source checks are unchanged in this first test-only observation.
Retain all existing mutants and make exit-two rejection an observed test.
|
FINITE READ-ONLY BRANCH-RELATIONSHIP PICKUP — Actual worker: OpenAI / ChatGPT GPT-6, GitHub Task Watch automation invocation 11. The connected GitHub surface exposes only shared principal Exact objects and finite scope
Finite output Exclusions Dependencies and stop conditions |
|
READ-ONLY BRANCH-RELATIONSHIP RESULT / ONLY-OWN RELEASE — Disposition: Exact branch relationship
Exact source bindings and carry-over boundary
Current-base and verification limits
I release only pickup Authority and handoff sources: current Main AGENTS.md · current Math AGENTS.md · 15 October owner mandate · standing delegation · workflow · Math required-check contract · 29 October owner master #686/6511339492. Links do not claim acknowledgement. |
|
CORRECTION TO RESULT 6515408635 — add/add and manifest conflict boundary The phrase “path-level additive composition candidate” in the prior result must not be read as a conflict-free or directly mergeable branch composition. A fresh content read at the actual common merge base The directional comparison remains:
The #540 test files are strict textual supersets by the native comparison (no deleted lines): 23 existing source-custody test methods are retained plus 14 added methods; the mutation test retains its one original method plus the added exit-two grader control. Their manifest carries two corresponding different test-source hash entries. This makes an explicit resolution plausible—take the #540 test-file and matching manifest versions while preserving #537's three workflow/decision/governance changes—but does not prove a clean merge, test the resulting tree, or qualify it against current Math main. Corrected disposition: |
|
FINITE PERSONAL SOURCE-EXPOSED ENGINEERING REVIEW PICKUP — Actual performer: OpenAI / ChatGPT GPT-6, Research Task Watch scheduled invocation 11. The connected GitHub surface exposes only shared principal Exact object and serial relationship
Frozen review paths and current #540 head blob identities
Finite output
Dependencies: current Math- Explicit exclusions
Finite checkpoint: one exact-head read-only review and only-own release in this invocation, or a precise blocker. Authority and handoff links: current Main AGENTS, current Math AGENTS, GOVERNANCE, owner master, complete owner mandate, standing delegation, workflow. |
|
RESULT / ONLY-OWN RELEASE — Disposition: Exact source and serial boundary
FindingsP1 — the mutation-grader self-test contradicts the grader. In P1 — Git source-identity operations inherit attacker-controlled Git environment. At this head, P1 — external Lean search paths are not scrubbed. P2 — the LEAN environment restoration assertion is incomplete. The new control checks all three variables are absent inside the mocked execution callback, but after return it verifies restoration only for Mutation-evidence boundary. The declared 13/13 mutation inventory is the existing 13-case set; it adds no named mutation for the new foreign Git environment, alternate-index, replace-ref, or Lean-search-path controls. Do not describe 13/13 as mutation qualification of these new cases. Also, the existing Execution and qualificationNo tests or workflows were run by this reviewer. The native workflow inventory for the frozen #540 head returned five completed failures and one organization-only Math-hypergraph success; that success is not a source/test qualification. No current-base tested merge, Ready, merge, or integration qualification is established. The earlier #537 P1 tracked-symlink-target-chain finding remains separately open at #537/6514436933; this review neither repairs nor transfers it. No source/ref/tree/workflow/PR mutation, test dispatch, author/integrator custody, proof, theorem, kernel, scientific, Layer A, G11, tool-admission, or CBZ-0 status change occurred. The prior branch-relationship result and correction (#540/6515408635 and #540/6515469279) remain intact. Only this review claim is released. Authority: current Main AGENTS, current Math AGENTS, current GOVERNANCE, owner master #686/6511339492, owner mandate, standing delegation, workflow. |
|
CBZ-0 DORMANT QUARANTINE RECORD —
Disposition: precise dormant quarantine, not a test pass, not source repair, not integration, not scientific review, not CBZ-0. |
Current test-only head
213b8848d0a1fad1ddf74b4f4ea4ba3fe14d8508adds four real-filesystem evidence-path controls, including the CLI removal path, a symlinked .lake, a symlinked evidence directory and a symlinked existing evidence member. Tests use disposable sentinels and require refusal before side effects. These four controls await execution; no result is inferred. Endpoint checks do not rule out transient mid-execution substitution.Current test-only head
ccf0a452756aab78ac8c13de4cc521bd4a144894also tests noncanonical dependency names and symlinked.lake,.lake/packages, and package-root paths. These four new controls await actual execution; the producer and mutation grader are unchanged. The earlier actual RED at 40a remains historical at its exact tested merge.Current head
f473155e30d6e74424442f85e5da2808bf77de32adds two additional test-only real-Git controls: a symlinked dependency package root and a symlinked.lake/packagesancestor must be refused even if they resolve to an otherwise clean pinned checkout. These new controls have not yet run. The producer remains unchanged; no result is inferred.This test-first source adds real-Git controls for foreign GIT_DIR/GIT_WORK_TREE, a clean alternate GIT_INDEX_FILE hiding staged source, replacement refs, dependency Git redirection and helper execution under a foreign Git environment. It also checks inherited LEAN_PATH, LEAN_SRC_PATH and LEAN_SYSROOT and the caller's restored environment. The source overlay binds both changed test files; the old producer and grader remain unchanged at this head.
Actual RED on head
40a0196f7a812f2e70b0de7e183adc0b9e9a2369: normal and optimized custody jobs 123722003134 and 123722003680 each ran 29 tests with 4 failures and 2 errors in the six environment controls. Their tested PR merge was61a1cbd8d4668c1e1e8635b43a6688ce35d6fe25; its tree exactly matches this head.Actual grader RED: formal job 123723500168 ran 276 tests with 5 failures and 2 errors. The adversarial grader test failed because the old grader credited all 13 synthetic exit-2 child outcomes as detected mutants. The same run preserved the genuine environment failures. The three D2 workflows refused the changed formal tree on this test-only head; those identity refusals are not mathematical proof failures.
The environment-only successor
27c72abbb134584b7ce232fc7db91ff63a8ec044passed its six focused tests in normal and optimized jobs 123723506167/123723506503. Its helper execution is simulated in those tests and no kernel claim follows. A stricter combined grader candidate exists separately; current-source tests and kernel verification remain pending. No overall custody or CBZ-0 success is claimed here.